AMERICAN IDOL....Season 11

cmbear

I hate saying that Hollie is doing well tonight. She also has the only song that is newer than 35 years old. That will appeal to the younger voters.

SeasideMemories

Ok... I'm going to say this with the caveat thst I have missed many of tonight's performances but, I thought Hollie's performance was really good....

Joan811

OK - round 1 - I missed Skylar and P.P.
What did they sing?  Anyone pleez?

cmbear

Skylar sang CCR Fortunate Son and pp sang the letter by the Boxtops

Wonderland

Skylar: Fortunate Son by Creedence

PP: The Letter  

karen333

Hollie is really doing a great job tonight, top one of this evening.  Joshua sang well but it was like he was  one of the original singers, didn't add his own touch to it. 

cmbear

Who's you're daddy?

Joan811

thanks, bear and wonder!
but what' going on with P.P. now??? 

Wonderland

PP - uh oh

What was that? 

SeasideMemories

Joan, I think we are in the same boat tonight... Missed a bit of the beginning so may not be able to compare all of the performances to each other but, can say if I liked a performance stand- alone....

cmbear

PP just not his night.

karen333

He sang it well, but had to really strecth on some of the notes, not his best night.  He certainly is the charmer though.

SeasideMemories

cmbear,



Agreed! And DH, who looks like he's watching but really only half listens as he's doing stuff on his computer, even said... What's up with PP tonight? He's really off...lol....

SeasideMemories

Hi Karen....

cmbear

Jessica looks so uncomfortable.

sheila888

It's a weird night......I only like Hollie's second song........

Hi Seaside......

Joan811

P.P. certainly charms - judges were kind...they want him around.
But he was not so totally comfortable with that song...not his best.

Seaside, yup, not easy to get the whole picture when missing stuff.

Wonderland

Seaside: LOL, dh does the same thing! Acts like he doesn't care but then comments on the songs. After PP sang, dh said, "He's going home."

SeasideMemories

Lol, Wonderland! They do try to keep up their appearance of not following long... but we're onto that game!



Hi back at ya, Sheila.... Our faithful leader!!!

sheila888

I loved Skylar mellower side......

rosasmommy

Good song choice for Skylar --- I prefer the subdued version of her.

Wonderland

Skylar was really good! I didn't like the ending, though.

cmbear

I don't know why, but I'm not sold on Skylar. I appreciate her talent but she is missing something for me.

sheila888

I listened to Jessica from another room.....her voice is good.......

Wonderland

I bet Jessica's parents are crying right now. That was beautiful. But then again, the song is beautiful.

rosasmommy

Jessica was good.  Still not a fan though.

cmbear

Didn't like the arrangement but darn Jessica can sing.

sheila888

You're right Wonderland....

cmbear

Remember when Jordin Sparks was a chunky 17 year old? She has certainly grown up!

sheila888

I voted for her every week...what a sweetheart and a big voice..........

They must be showing the same commercials cmbear