AMERICAN IDOL....Season 11

rosasmommy

I LOVE Tina Turner.  I think if I just listened Hollie with my eyes closed, I would like her a lot more.  She just needs to gain some maturity on the stage.

sheila888

It makes a big difference...Sometimes I listen with my eyes closed....lol

karen333

NICE JOB Hollie, hoping Jessica doesn't shine tonight.

cmbear

I love her dress!--- I close my eyes too!

Wonderland

Thought Hollie was really good. (Plus, I love that song!)

I love PP but really didn't care for his rendition of The Letter. 

karen333

Oh that PP, he always does it his way and is so unique and what a voice.

rosasmommy

Skylar's another one I need to listen to with my eyes closed.  A little tired of the foot stomp, fist pump, and bouncing squat.

Wonderland

Good song choice for Skylar. 

sheila888

PP is eye candy

Skylar is an entertainer and i love her but she needs to slow down a little bit.

karen333

Skylar just takes over the whole stage, she makes it a party with her voice and her dancing.  You have fun because it is so obvious she is.

rosasmommy

Digging Johsua and Phillip!  And thinking about watching Top Gun again. 

SeasideMemories

Well shoot.... DS and his girlfriend were here and, apparently, feeling chatty.... They obviously have no respect for the scared 'Idol Hour'....lol... They have finally left!



PP and Joshua... Gonna agree in that it started a bit like a train wreck but gained steam and, overall, was a decent performance!

marilyn113

I thought the duet was awful.  Proved to me that Phillip has no range.

karen333

Two such different voices but did they sound good together, funny how Joshua wouldn't let Phillip touch him, really gave PP a chance to use his impish ways.  Didn't think they"d be able to pull it off but it was good.

Wonderland

Seaside: I agree about the duet. But it ended well. What was up with Josh? I'd let PP put his arm around me anytime. 

sheila888

Jessica.....No Comments 

Wonderland

Too big of a song for her.

rosasmommy

Agree with Randy -- I LOVE the version of Proud Mary done by Tina Turner.  Can you tell I'm a big Tina Turner fan?

karen333

Totally agree with Wonderland, it is so identifiable with Tina Turner, Jessica looked like a 12 yr. old prancing around.  Bad song choice.

Joan811

Seaside, I'm with you...I was all settled in with some work spread out in front of me when DH arrives at 8 PM....gotta go pick up my car from inspection station -- and he won't wait until 10 because he's going to bed early.  So I missed at least 30 min...saw Hollie, saw the awkward moment with Joshua and PP, and Jessica. What did Skylar sing?
Ahhh the sacred Idol hour.....there is an hour left, right??

rosasmommy

Great song choice for Joshua.  And he can actually perform!!  Makes up for his akward interactions with PP during their duet.

cmbear

So who won round one?

rosasmommy

I say Joshua won round one.

sheila888

Everyone except PP

Anonymous

I loved the duet with Joshua and Philip, I thought they complimented each other really well.

My front runners are Joshua, Holly an Skylar for the top 3--in that order.

Anne 

Wonderland

I vote for Hollie (and just last week I was wishing she was voted off!)

sheila888

I don't know yet.........

sheila888

Hollie has my vote so far.....she was good. 

rosasmommy

Great song for Hollie!!!!

Hindsfeet

I hope the last two are Skylar and Philip. Josh screaming is painful to my ears.