What foods are you eating to reduce recurrence?

Options
1101113151640

Comments

  • jessica749
    jessica749 Member Posts: 429
    edited March 2014

    In the past there has been much discussion about dairy and I think if you search the discussion boards you'll find lots of postings and several which refer to different studies of this or that. I feel that food studies are very limited/unreliable and that basically, to wait for 'proof' of things could mean waiting lifetimes, if even ever answerable.  So, I just do what makes sense to me and what I'm comfortable with. 

  • jessica749
    jessica749 Member Posts: 429
    edited March 2014

    OMG Jane Plant!!! THAT was a thread that someone started on these boards a while ago and dairy debate RAGED on it.  Search for it on the boards….I know there is plenty other stuff on dairy too.  I think people on the Plant thread felt that the claims made in her book/s (?) weren't fully backed by science, but I can't recall.

    That said, it doesn't mean that dairy is good for you, or that dairy products which may contain growth hormones (certainly free to use them in the USA without marking the product as containing such)  are something one worrying about cancer should consume…each must make their own decision based on what you are comfortable with.

  • juneping
    juneping Member Posts: 1,594
    edited March 2014

    thank you ladies for your replies. i watched forks over knives and the doctor said even if the dairy were not contaminated he still wouldn't recommend dairy. i think i'll adjust my diet again to cut back dairy. like my integrative doc said, i need to weight the risks over the benefits.

  • juneping
    juneping Member Posts: 1,594
    edited March 2014

    jessica - i found the thread and read it. i already knew farm factory dairy are bad. my main concern was about raw organic dairy...

    it's just funny when ppl advocate plants based diet (reference from far east), the fact that poor chinese ( i am chinese so i can only speak for chinese) did eat meat before but it's like once a year. the more money they had, the more meat they ate. BUT it's not our thing to eat a 3 inch by 3 inch by 3/4 inch steak. we used meat to add flavor not like a main course. and we do eat the whole fish by the whole family/table, not everyone got their own fish in front of them. it's just i felt when ppl (those experts) refer to eastern diet, they just took it so extreme.

    i wanted to add, my parents told me around cultural revolution period, ppl were starving. and when ppl did eat some food, they were never full. because they lacked fat. so having some meat make ppl feel fuller. i think my point is - moderation. i can never understand ppl don't eat meat/fish. they are on the planet for a reason....not that i agree to abuse them like corporate america.

  • Momine
    Momine Member Posts: 7,859
    edited March 2014

    There is a lot of hysteria about dairy lately. 

    1. The main correlation to BC is for high-fat dairy, like cheese and cream. We should avoid those. 

    2. Low-fat dairy, especially fermented kinds like yogurt, kefir etc may be helpful for us.

    3. Raw milk has no advantages over pasteurized milk. Pasteurization is actually a very gentle process of heating the milk briefly to kill bacteria. When I was a kid, they always boiled the milk prior to processing it into cheese or before giving it to us on the farms near our summer house. Boiling is more harsh than pasteurization. You do NOT want a bacterial infection, especially not if you are also fighting cancer.

    4. Hormones. It is actually not that common to give cows extra hormones, because the hormones are expensive and the extra milk doesn't quite make up the cost. However, the other problem is that cows are milked while pregnant, which raises the hormone level in the milk as well. 

    5. Personally I would stick to low-fat dairy and stick to goat milk (less chance of being milked while pregnant, as far as I can tell) products from small farms, as far as possible.

  • juneping
    juneping Member Posts: 1,594
    edited March 2014

    momine

    there are research out there proved the bovine growth hormone that used for cows are related to breast cancer. the hormones use in the US was banned in canada and EU. but here in the US, we are still using it. i don't know the cost so i can't comment. but i know all the regular milk in the supermarket has that carcinogen  growth hormone. i kind of think the US is the only country that is using this hormone. Harvard did a research on this.

    http://www.notmilk.com/drlarsen.html

    i've read quite a few things about raw milk, there's a book "real food, what to eat and why" by nina planck. she's a farmer's daughter. her parents used to be professors before becoming farmers and she is a well educated woman, not just a farmer as well. and there is a link talks about the benefits of raw milk

    http://www.realmilk.com/health/

    personally if i forgot my milk in the fridge too long, raw milk just turned rancid but pasteurized milk is a lot worse, the smell was very offensive. and raw milk doesn't after that weird after taste and breath 

    there're many documentaries about farm factories, FDA and USDA's attitude towards small farms who could be a potential threat towards the milk industry.

    two documentaries on netflix: Food, inc, Farmageddon

    seriously, 100 or 200 years ago, ppl didn't have fat free or low fat but they're not dying left and right or had high cholesterol or cancer. it's not about the fat, it's something else. it just doesn't make sense. i believe in plants based diet but i also think small portion of meat is also helpful. and most important of all, where the meat come from. those free range grass-fed the way God intended meat are def suitable for human to consume.


  • Fallleaves
    Fallleaves Member Posts: 806
    edited March 2014

    Hi Momine and Juneping,

    There was a recent study linking diet high in animal proteins to higher rates of cancer (in middle aged people, but not elderly people).

     http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/03/1403...

    The interesting thing is this mentions IGF-1 being linked to cancer and a direct correlation between higher levels in the diet and higher rates of cancer. I think dairy naturally contains IGF-1 even without growth hormones being added.

  • juneping
    juneping Member Posts: 1,594
    edited March 2014

    fallleaves - thanks for the link. it reminds me of canceractive's article that protein can promote tumor growth. they suggested rainbow diet and less meat diet, they only recommended chicken and fish.

    i like meat ...but more as to add flavors to my meal. usually i don't eat that much meat and i wish someone could tell me how much is too much. now i only eat meat every 2-3 days and cut back on the portion as well. sometimes i missed the simple days like when i was a child, i only got to eat meat once a year at the new year.

  • bluepearl
    bluepearl Member Posts: 961
    edited March 2014

    The study regarding protein consumption and cancer is somewhat flawed. Regardless, the mediterranean diet is the best for overall health.

  • Momine
    Momine Member Posts: 7,859
    edited March 2014

    June, yes, I am aware that the bovine growth hormone is only used in the US. But when I checked, I found that even in the US, it is a minority of producers who use it.

    I agree that there are many problems with mass-produced meat and dairy. However, in my humble opinion, pasteurization is not one of them. Even if you are using milk from your own eco-cow in the backyard, it would still be prudent to boil the milk before use. Once again, pasteurizing is gentler than actual boiling.

  • Fallleaves
    Fallleaves Member Posts: 806
    edited March 2014

    Sounds like you're on the lower end of the meat eating spectrum, Juneping. Some people I know eat meat three meals a day, and a big hunk of meat is the centerpiece of the meal. Whenever my mother goes to visit my brother in Louisiana she wants a salad as soon as she comes home, lol!

  • Momine
    Momine Member Posts: 7,859
    edited March 2014

    I do eat meat, but limited amounts and not very often. In general, I think we (BC patients) are better off going easy on red meat and things like bacon, salami and other preserved meats should probably not even be in our diet.

    Falls, I can empathize with your mom. Last time I was in the US, I ate my weight in salad as soon as I got home again. We are so spoiled in Greece. Any of my local restaurants will give me steamed veggies as a side dish, and it is usually a mix of broccoli, greens, zucchini and carrot. You can also get a big plate of steamed greens in most places, as well as a large tomato salad etc. In addition, there are many veggie main dishes in the Greek, traditional kitchen.

  • juneping
    juneping Member Posts: 1,594
    edited March 2014

    momine - did you read that from the FDA website?? it's pointless to argue with you about the bovine hormone, you can't find it in your supermarket. but it's all around us here in the US. with BC being so epidermic in the US. not saying drinking milk cause cancer but it's one of the carcinogen elements in our daily lives. the stuff that i've read, they just kept saying those hormones were destroyed in our stomach instead of a minority production thing.

    blueperal - you're right. i digged deeper and found this...

    http://www.westonaprice.org/vegetarianism-and-plan...

    fallleaves - lol...i feel very greasy if i eat too much meat. sometimes if i don't eat meat, i always feel hungry. i do enjoy a hamburger once in a while...

  • Momine
    Momine Member Posts: 7,859
    edited March 2014

    June, I am not arguing, since I agree that bovine growth hormone is bad news. I am just saying that it is not actually used as widely as I thought it was. It is still fairly easy to avoid, even in the US. Lots of stores carry hormone-free milk.

    I did not see any link to the FDA.

  • juneping
    juneping Member Posts: 1,594
    edited March 2014

    momine - i read about the hormone free milk but never seen one, at least not at the supermarket next to my building. i got my milk from a local farm so i didn't really browse at the milk section when i grocery shop (i shop at wholefood market...want to eat clean food). i'll take a look...

    but i've read enough to know grass-fed milk is a lot better than those corn-fed milk. i would like to know what's the ph value of the grass-fed milk vs corn-fed milk. i actually don't drink cow milk, i drink goat milk. i asked the farmer who i bought the milk from, what do the baby goats drink if the milk was bottled for human, he said they drink something else. i actually felt pretty bad...

  • Momine
    Momine Member Posts: 7,859
    edited March 2014
  • exbrnxgrl
    exbrnxgrl Member Posts: 12,424
    edited March 2014

    june ping,

    Not arguing either, but every grocery store and supermarket where I live (Northern CA) carries hormone free milk, even the store brands. I spent most of last summer with my father in NJ and noticed the same thing there as well. Whole Foods would most certainly carry it as does Trader Joe's (trying to think of national retailers).

  • smrlvr
    smrlvr Member Posts: 422
    edited March 2014

    I switched to almond milk, and it suits me fine.  I was never a milk drinker anyway.  I do enjoy Greek yogurt, and I would love to find hormone free.  I have read about yogurt made from goats milk.  Have any of you tried it and do you know where to get it?

  • juneping
    juneping Member Posts: 1,594
    edited March 2014

    momine - thanks for the link. i just wanted to add that their 365 brand milk is UHT pasteurized which is bad. in case other ppl is reading.

    http://www.foodrenegade.com/just-say-no-to-uht-mil...

    exb - actually my neighborhood is considered a very poor neighborhood, i doubt they have it. it's the only place i shop that i see ppl using food stamp which i've never seen that before...but i'll check just for my own sake.

  • juneping
    juneping Member Posts: 1,594
    edited March 2014

    smrlvr - i thought i've read there's something they put in those almond milk...can't recall which thread exactly. its better you make your own almond milk with raw unpasteurized organic almonds. and add raw honey for better flavor. they taste quite different from the ones on the market.

    i bought mine from a local farm...i haven't tried goat yogurt but planning to try sheep yogurt. it's raw so not sure if you want to risk it. i've seen wholefood had some goat yogurt plain.

  • leggo
    leggo Member Posts: 3,293
    edited March 2014

    Re: the commercially produced almond milk....It's carrageenan. At least that's the one I find most concerning.

  • sgreenarch
    sgreenarch Member Posts: 528
    edited March 2014

    Hi, jumping in in the middle here as this topic interests me a great deal. Post dx I felt like one of the only things I could control (cancer out of the blue, w no family hx, made me feel like I had totally lost control, as if I had been struck by lightning,) was my diet. I didn't need to read much to decide that I didn't need to inject additional hormones into my body. (Had had a hysterectomy at 47 due to enormous estrogen driven fibroids, and now very ER + BC.) I immediately switched to organic dairy products for our family. Most of the organic dairy that comes from a cow here in Israel is 3% fat, they don't make lower fat organic milk. Truthfully, I don't drink milk ever (but the kids and DH do) as I use organic rice or almond milk in coffee. I buy goats milk plain yoghurt (organic) and try to have some every other day, but not too much since it's also 3%. I do buy a little bit of nonorganic cheese and butter, but we all eat very little of this. One of my new projects is to go to a cheese making course as I would love to make my own cheese from this milk. They do sell organic cheese here but it's very expensive. When I visit in the US I am amazed at the amount of great dairy products that are BGH free or organic. I know it's more expensive, but I feel that this is one area that is very important to those of us who've had BC (and our families, actually, probably...everybody.) 

    As for the rest of our diet, we try to eat along the lines of the Meditteranean diet. Like Momine, this is the native diet, so getting lots of good, fresh produce is relatively easy. My other pet concern is pesticides as I grew up in an area of northeastern Pa that had a real cancer cluster and I often wonder if it wasn't from all of the spraying of the agriculture in our midst. This is another thing that I am sure will be revealed as a cause of the surging cancer rates. Again, I don't have time to delve into deep science on this, (just superficial science:) but I am willing to take the more costly chance and buy organic produce. I even try to grow some. We definitely pay more for food, but we don't go out much, so I hope it balances out, sort of. We don't eat much red meat, poultry about once a week, and we try to have fish once or twice a week. My new thing is eating more nuts. I am battling high cholesterol (thank you Femara) and I am hoping that this infusion of nuts, seeds and legumes (more fiber and omega 3's) will help bring it down naturally. I also find that adding these helps digestion enormously. Sorry to run on. Thanks for starting.

  • sophie786
    sophie786 Member Posts: 83
    edited March 2014

    My gosh - there are debates raging everywhere on what is causing the breast cancer epidemic.  The rates are definitely on the rise and I think many of us would agree that evironmental factors along with diet are big culprits.  I am sad with the food that is available.  As someone recently said the me recently we have a food crisis in the world right now.  Most of us buy our food and we pretty clueless on how it is handled.  The vast majority of us don't grow our veggies or raise our own livestock.  We are at the mercy of others whose main motivation is PROFIT.  Honestly everybody wants to make a buck these days including most of us.  You can pretty much find studies to backup every theory under the sun.  Is Dairy good?  Is it harmful?  Is pasteurized milk better than raw milk?  Are vitamins good?  Is Juicing harmful?  Can Juicing cure Cancer?  

    Basically you have to use your common sense when it comes it your health.  One thing for sure is TOO MUCH OF ANYTHING OR ANY FOOD CAN BE HARMFUL.  Since my dx I try to incorporate as much of variety as I possibly can.  One thing I have discovered is that vegetables are very good for your health.  Moms and grandmom were right when they said to EAT YOUR VEGGIES.  Stay as close to nature as possible.  Fresh is always better.  I always bought juices from the grocery store.  I had no desire to make my own.  Until a friend who went thru treatment a year before me said to drink fresh juice.  I definitely feel good when I drink fresh juice.  I will juice as much of variety as I can of organic veggies.  I try to incorporate beets, carrots, celery and apples because it takes great.  I will add ginger too.  My body feels energized when I drink these concotion.  So skins glows 15 minutes after I drink it.  That being said I don't that just drinking juice without fiber is good for you on a long term basis.  Its good to put the veggies in a smoothie as well and of course eat it in salad form.  A whole plant -based diet is the best option.  I have replaced store bought juices with fresh juicing.

    FADS COME AND GO.  The Atkins diet so popular a few years back.  Celebrities and people lost alot of weight doing it.  Do you think this type of diet is good for your digestive system?  I certainly don't think so.  Yes, its good for quick weight loss but it is not a sustainable diet just like the juice diet is not completely sustainable.  Seems to me that everybody has an agenda and wants to sell you something.

    Case in point is coconut oil.  It is a hot commodity along with KALE.  There are facebook pages touting the numerous benefits of coconut oil and someone has a 100 ways to use coconut oil.  thats fantastic but coconut is VERY EXPENSIVE. Surely somebody who has stocks in coconut oil came up with this list.  I love coconut and have been using to OIL PULL for the past several months as part of my morning routine.  However, I will not use it to shave my legs with bc it is astronomically expensive.  So my basic argument is MODERATION IS KEY!

    Vitamins and health foods are a billion dollar business.  There are arguments on both sides.  I think that common sense would dictate that the best place to acquire vitamins is from foods.  A varied diet rich in variety is the probably the best way to achieve optimum health.  Again I feel that there are so many people trying to sell you something.  Case in point is Dr. Mercola.  I like his videos and signed up and I get an email everyday telling me to buy some product or the other that will give me optimum health.  So do you think this person or all the other fb pages devoted some product or other are unbiased?  I think not.  Before you change your complete lifestyle USE COMMON SENSE  and live your life in moderation.

    btw: I think oil pulling (an ayuverdic technique) may have had some positive effects on my health.  It reduced the amount of hot flashes I got after rediation.  My period stopped after 1 dose of chemo a year ago.  I got some spotting a couple of weeks ago but I think the period is pretty much gone.

  • leggo
    leggo Member Posts: 3,293
    edited March 2014

    This one always makes me laugh....organic garlic, from China....yeah right. The organic honey too. Do they put little leashes on the bees so they can't fly into the neighbouring pesticide-laden field? It's very hard for me to accept that organic food is actually that. There's no way I'm going to believe that some farmer, amidst an infestation crisis, is going to risk losing his crop, certified organic or not. He's going to do what he has to do to get product to market....we just won't know about it. Regulations, shmegulations.

     http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/pesticide-residue-found-on-nearly-half-of-organic-produce-1.2487712


  • juneping
    juneping Member Posts: 1,594
    edited March 2014

    leggo - the link is about organic food in canada...didn't say anything about organic garlic from china.

    but i watched a documentary of bee disappearing (colony collapse)...and some bee keepers fed bees suger...geeze...couldn't help to roll my eyes. and apparently there're organic honey. the lady said it means not feeding the bees sugar and they need to move their bee stations to somewhere safe without those systematic pesticides bc bee could lose orientation and die from it.

  • flaviarose
    flaviarose Member Posts: 442
    edited March 2014

    Re: Raw milk.  I'm an advocate of raw milk vs. pasteurized.   I've read a lot on the subject, and feel very safe drinking the raw milk that comes from the farm down the road from me.  there are many health benefits to raw milk vs. pasteurized milk - one of the main ones being that the enzymes that help you digest it are destroyed during pasteurization.  My favorite phrase that I came across when researching the controversy between raw and pasteurized mile was that pasteurized milk is a "dead white liquid."  that said - I still am reducing my diary consumption due to the growth factors present, even in raw milk.

    http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2009/11/12/choosing-between-raw-milk-and-a-dead-white-liquid.aspx

  • juneping
    juneping Member Posts: 1,594
    edited March 2014

    flav - totally agreed with you. i found this link, it's written by a doctor who advocate raw milk. she said there is CLA in raw milk that fights cancer. the article is from 2010

    http://drcate.com/raw-milk-why-mess-with-udder-per...

  • leggo
    leggo Member Posts: 3,293
    edited March 2014

    I know the link didn't say anything about garlic. I was just commenting on my experience with buying it. It always makes me chuckle when I see these bags of garlic, marked "organic", but also with a China import sticker. The link I provided was just to make people aware that they are getting what they pay for. 






  • flaviarose
    flaviarose Member Posts: 442
    edited March 2014

    All I know is that when I drink pasteurized milk I get a stomach ache, and when I drink raw milk I don't.

  • sophie786
    sophie786 Member Posts: 83
    edited March 2014

    flaviarose:  it makes me sick when I see ginger from china in my local Walmart -Superstore.  Surely we can grow ginger closer to home.  To increase shelf life our food has to be laced with some sort of chemicals or preservatives.  Unfortunately city and urban living forces us to be dependent on supermarkets.  Most of us have no idea about our food sources.  We are slaves to MARKETING and the processed foodlike substances that line up the grocery shelves.  Mass production and cheaper methods have wreaked havoc.  It reminds me of the book I read more than 25 years ago in High School about Meat Packing plants and industrialization in the early 1900's - don't recall the name.  It was for english class of course.

    My grocery bill has skyrocketed bc I try to buy organic.  But I have been thinking I have no way of knowing if something is truly organic or not.  I am truly how many of us can trace of the source.  However at the same time I am paying 3 to 4 time the amount for organic food.  I hope to God that industry is not preying on desparate people.  the only way you can be sure is to grow your own food.  I wish I could but I have always been dependent on outside sources.  May God have Mercy on all of us.

Categories