AMERICAN IDOL...Season 12 & The Voice...Season 4

Let me just add that I really hope that a girl wins this year... We honestly need a girl to win again it's been a while

That Nicki Minaj was worn me down. I changed the channel. Her nasally voice & mocking of the contestants irritate me. She asking them to model to dance. She ask about clothes & give the dumb nicknames. I'm like "can u let them sing??"" I thought Randy & Mariah made a valid pt with the girl last night. She had a country voice & the advice pretty much was know ur strength. Not to count country out cuz she had sound. Some pple with pretty voices choose wrong songs or genres and lose!!



I am a singer & I have heard pple sound average singing 1 style but is amazing singing another. Nicki isn't a singer & therefore she didn't get it. She raps...It's Y Randy kept saying I'm giving her some real advice. Like the black rock singer. Her first song choice was blasé but then she sang Alanis Morrisette & sounded very good. I'd rather hear comments on singing than omg I love ur eye make up. Or omg r u single. Ohhh can u dance. **eyes roll just like Mariah***

I feel that the judges aren't having fun.

I miss the original judges too. 

NM doesn't really bother me but MC doesn't appear at all engaged in the process. Why would MC thinkl it was acceptable to roll her eyes. I was taught that was rude and disrespectful.   I suspect the NM requests to ask this or that are request from a producer that can't really be refused.      

See you next week. 

NM, wrong lip color!   1st singer .

What did you ladies think of Savannah O.  I liked her "At Last" she has an amazing voice. 

Judges seem to be getting along!

I rather liked the Peaches fellow. I am not even sure why but I do. 

Ginger

Yes it is!    I watched both seasons of that show. 

That bad?

Some human interest is good but they are pushing the formula way too far. I don't want to watch a show for entertainment with guilt as a component. 

I actually recorded the last 30 Rock instaed of AI.