AMERICAN IDOL....Season 11

sheila888

Good Night Karen

sheila888

Tate wasn't that good...maybe it was the song........

karen333

Tate and Carly Rose are going to battle for the top spot for the rest of the competition I think, I am switching between the X Factor and 12 12 12, trying not to miss an X Factor contestant.  12 12 12 is bringing back some old, old memories.

karen333

Fifth Harmony did a really nice job, they may take third place.  Is this a single elimination or double this week?  Sheila.  Still cannot believe Nicholas got picked, it's a strange, strange world out there.

sheila888

Karen....Yes it's a single elimination.....

The phone rang so I'm way beyond the show.....

Can't watch 12-12-12 because Survivor and Criminal Minds are DVRed......

Please about Nicholas...I realized he is not holding his heart...maybe it's some type of religious think...he is weird....totally weird.....He scares me.......

karen333

He's a scary fellow indeed.  Caught Tate's second song, a song to his wife, it was a lot better than his first song.  ON 12 12 12, Bon Jovi did a whole set - he was awesome!!  Going to catch Carly Rose is doing Imagine and playing the piano.

mimi1964

I'm telling you all I love Tate but OMG I loved Emblem 3's Hey Jude it was AWESOME!!!!!!   they are in it to win it and I did not love Carly Roses' first performance and her second one was ok.  She is just so predictable as Demi would say.  She has not sang one upbeat song the entire time.  What kind of music album would she sell??? hmmm.... don't get me wrong she is amazing for 13 and what will she be like in 5 more yrs? Incredible I will guess.  So, if I had to make a choice between her and Tate, I'm going with Tate.  But get real... my guess is that all 4 of these in the semi-finals will be signed by someone to a contract.  I'm guessing if Emblem 3 doesn't win Simon will sign them and possibly 5th Harmony as well, because he made the comment a few weeks ago that girl groups were lacking.  Carly, well geesh! anyone would want her! they can mold her into some kind of superstar like a Christina or Brittany. 

O.k. that's my take on tonight's show. 

karen333

Carly Rose did not do as well on Imagine, she was trying to do too many things at the same time.  L.A. compared Emblem 3 to the Beatles, I think not!  Tate takes first place.  

mimi1964

I think 5th Harmony just kicked that song out of the ball park.  I really lovred it... don't care if they have done it before.

sheila888

Carly Rose with a beautiful voice...but she is not ready yet........

I'm not a big fan of group music so for me...

TATE all the way......♥♥♥♥♥♥

His family values makes him a star even if he couldn't sing.......

I just listened to Carly's song......too slow and depressing..........

sheila888

OMG Hey Jude I love that song.......

karen333

Tate as number 1!!!!  The tweenies may vote Emblem 3 to third, I would rather see Fifth Harmony in that place, stronger voices.  I agree Sheila, that song showed Carly Rose is not ready yet.  Simon said it, Tate is not going back to his old job!  Good night ladies, see you tomorrow.

sheila888

Ok I just finished listening 5th Harmony...i loved it.....they really did a good job......

good Night Karen and Renee

sheila888

I voted  

I'm watching 12-12-12 now

I love Alicia Keys....

sheila888

♥

karen333

I love her too Sheila, she has such a distinctive voice, I asked for a CD of her or Blake Shelton for Christmas, we sure do have eclectic tastes in music, I think it's grand!!

sheila888

karen333

I'm here, tons of errands today, time to veg, bet one of the group goes.

sheila888

sheila888

Everything is possible even Carly going home tonight.......

karen333

Simon looked amazed, Brittany looked ill, I am surprised, thought the tweenies would vote the boys through.  I hope that this isn't the X Factor's Nicholas moment of bizarre things happening.  I will be sooo disappointed if Tate doesn't get through.

sheila888

We boycott the X Factor if Tate goes home tonight or any other night......

I really want him to win.......

sheila888

TATE is #1   

karen333

I'm smiling with you - he so deserves to win.  Brittany will not tolerate Carly Rose not going on.

sheila888

Gut feeling Carly going home and 5th Harmony winning the competition

Britney and Carly fainting........

And on the Voice Nicholas winning.....

OMG...I shouldn't be this judgemental 

We still have our AI coming next month

karen333

ROFLOL, we will need anti- anxiety medication by the time AI even begins!!  Always a good time watching with you Sheila, see you next week.  Karen

sheila888

Good Night Karen

Next week will be the end....

♥

sheila888

X Factor......

http://entertainment.gather.com/viewArticle.action?articleId=281474981813574

sheila888

WOW...What a beautiful dedication Voice did for the Sandy Brook little angels........

karen333

It was truely beautiful, so touching.  Sheila - Nicholas cannot win, he sure can sweat at least he didn't look like he would faint.  Cassedee was stunning in dress and singing, it was so Blake to relate it to America's heart being broken and music as healing.  Now onto Terry and Blake, WOW!!