Need your opinion

Options
finallyoverit
finallyoverit Member Posts: 382

How much do you tell friends who disclose their own diagnosis to you? This friend knows about my original diagnosis but not progression. She’s DCIS, so I’m afraid that I’ll scare her.. but keeping it out of the discussion makes me feel that I’m not being truthful.

I do not speak about my original dx or progression with friends so usually not an issue. I don’t think I will disclose unless she asks specifically, but curious what everyone else has done.. especially those who aren’t public with your dx.

Comments

  • Sadiesservant
    Sadiesservant Member Posts: 1,995
    edited August 2020

    Hi. I'm completely open about my diagnosis as I feel it avoids having to either explain/or cover up the inevitable hair loss as treatments evolve. I'm one of those who hates wigs - they always have far more hair than I have ever had so I feel weird, their hot and itchy... yuch - so go natural if hair loss is part of the treatment. Having said that, my social circle is relatively small so those that know me have known for some time.

  • illimae
    illimae Member Posts: 5,710
    edited August 2020

    I’m an open book but I tell friends that there are some things I wish I had known and I they want to hear it, I’ll share but if don’t, I’ll just listen. I hate scaring people too but if I feel the info is relevant and important enough then I say it anyway, as delicately as I can.

  • moth
    moth Member Posts: 4,800
    edited August 2020

    I tell everyone. I cannot imagine discussing cancer with a friend and not mentioning it. If I found out way later that someone had chosen to keep their own dx, including progression, from me I'd definitely rethink the whole friendship. I think this is a recipe for hurting and losing friends.
  • exbrnxgrl
    exbrnxgrl Member Posts: 12,424
    edited August 2020

    I’m an open book as well. My friends are all adults so even those with cancer handle the truth well. Being an open book has allowed me to set the tone for how I wish to be treated. No gossip, no rumors since everyone knows that if they just ask me I will tell them the truth. I also hope I’ve educated a few people too

  • ShetlandPony
    ShetlandPony Member Posts: 4,924
    edited August 2020

    A lot of people knew of my early stage diagnosis, but I am not an open book about the mbc diagnosis. I did not even tell close friends until I determined my kid was ready to know, because people can't keep secrets. It was my judgement knowing my kid, not someone else's choice. And then the few friends I chose to tell, who are also mothers, understood. My kid did not need to hear the whole saga, just what was relevant now. That's what worked for us; other families will find their own way.

    I have valuable information for a newbie, and I would offer what would be helpful to them where they are. I would not bring up stage iv to a newly diagnosed person, because at that point it is about them and what they are currently going through. Deer in the headlights. Trying to get through diagnosis and treatment. If they wanted to talk about what if stage iv and what that might mean, then I might open up and try to encourage them that we can live with it longer and better than they might think.

  • exbrnxgrl
    exbrnxgrl Member Posts: 12,424
    edited August 2020

    Shetland,

    I absolutely agree that having younger children adds another consideration to “openness “. My children were adults already when I was dx’ed but if they were young I might well have looked at the situation differently.

  • finallyoverit
    finallyoverit Member Posts: 382
    edited August 2020

    Thank you, everyone for the responses. Me opening up to everyone is just not going to happen. I will be honest with my friend and not give her more info than she needs right now. If it doesn’t come up, I’m not going to mention because I think all that will do is scare her more. She’s already scared enough

  • ShetlandPony
    ShetlandPony Member Posts: 4,924
    edited August 2020

    That seems wise and caring, finallyoverit.

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited August 2020

    Finallyoverit - I was an open book back in 2008 when I was first dx. I started a new career in 2011 and love it ! I was shocked in 2019 with my stage 4 dx . I decided to keep it quiet unless I had to have treatment where I lost hair or felt terrible and needed to quit. Close friends know but most don’t live in my community. So far I feel fine - I have no shame in my dx but didn’t like the “how’s your health “ questions I got with stage 1 from random people . In general, people don’t understand stage 4 - at all. It’s too much and i found myself having to console people when I shared my stage 1 dx which I don’t need to take on. I feel good, still work full time and am taking it scan by scan and still trying to really get my balance with this. If / when I progress, I may change my mind.

  • DivineMrsM
    DivineMrsM Member Posts: 9,620
    edited August 2020

    finally, in 2011 when I was diagnosed from the start with mbc, most people knew I was diagnosed with bc but I only told close family about the metastatic part and asked them to keep it private. I’m glad I did it that way. It made me feel like I had a small amount of control at a time I needed to feel that way. It gave me space to sort out the massive amounts of emotions I felt without outside interference.

    About five or six years later, I was more open about mbc. Many people really didn’t comprehend it. I live in a town of about 5,000, and gossip travels fast. Some people thought the cancer “came back”. Some people seemed shocked that I looked as normal as I did when they found out. Some were skeptical that a pill a day could keep the cancer at bay. Some thought I was on death’s door. In fact, I had a bit of a blow-out with two siblings who always knew of the mbc and were cool with it for years until I had progression and they started making it the focus of every conversation. Not what I wanted. I had to set new boundaries.

    So take it slow. You don’t have to reveal too much. Take care of yourself first, physically and emotionally. You have a right to remain private about your health details and what you reveal.


Categories