Drug Creates Inhospitable Environment for bc Progression

Options

I thought this was very interesting...

http://www.cancernetwork.com/asco-2015-breast-canc...

Not sure how or if this finding translates to eliminating other potential sources of copper from our lives, such as copper in our diets (which would include kale, mushrooms, and avocados... hmmmm....) or wearing copper bracelets, but definitely something to think about.

«134

Comments

  • leggo
    leggo Member Posts: 3,293
    edited June 2015

    That's a little scary to me. I can't move without copper. I'll have to keep an eye out to see if it makes a measurable difference in triple positives.

  • 2timer
    2timer Member Posts: 590
    edited June 2015

    This sounds really promising.

  • floaton
    floaton Member Posts: 181
    edited June 2015

    Thanks for posting this. I've been dragging my feet on a copper iud ever since I saw there was a clinical trial for this. I'm not triple negative, but why provide what may be extra "food" for tumorangiogenesis until more is known?

  • dlb823
    dlb823 Member Posts: 9,430
    edited June 2015

    floaton, I agree with you. And it's also the cumulative effect -- a copper IUD, lots of kale, avocados, cashews and other high copper foods we assume are healthy and helpful, maybe a copper bracelet for the aches and pains from an A/I... and suddenly without realizing it, we're on copper overload for our particular situations.

    I've read other research that points to the host environment being perhaps more important than the existence of cancer cells themselves in either developing cancer or its progression, which is why this research really interests me.

    leggo, what do you mean, you can't move without copper? Are you taking it as a supplement?


  • leggo
    leggo Member Posts: 3,293
    edited June 2015

    No, not supplemental, but I have a whole bunch of compression wear with copper in it to help my aching bones. I really need it on my feet in particular, or I really can't stand on them without crying. I must be absorbing enough to make a difference which scares me now that I read that article. Maybe I'lI just wear the socks and ditch the rest and see how it goes. Ugh, which is worse? Pills or copper? I despise making these decisions.

  • mike3121
    mike3121 Member Posts: 410
    edited June 2015

    I will reply for my wife since she adores forums of any kind (had a few bad experiences with them).

    My wife, (now age 68) back in Dec of 2012 was diagnosed with Stage 4 ER+ breast cancer. One node and a small spot on the spine. After 3 infusions of AC she was clean except for the 6 cm tumor in her breast. The oncologist said since the cancer was responding well to estrogen blocker (aromasin) it was best to leave it be.

    A little over a year later, Nov 2014 the cancer morphed and went crazy. She had a radical mastectomy and breast removal. A biopsy showed it to be ER+ and the oncologist prescribed tamoxifen. 19 lymph nodes were removed and 9 of the 19 had triple negative Metaplastic keratinized squamous carcinoma. A PET scan done after the surgery showed some cancer still in her armpit, probably spill over from the nodes. She's completed 4 doses of A-C and used up her lifetime amount.The last PET scan showed an SUV of 2.2 down from 5.9 and 1.0 is normal baseline. She's now having radiation to get rid of the last vestiges of the cancer.

    She has two cancers, one ER+ PR+ HER2- and another triple negative.

    I brought up copper depletion with her oncologist. He gave me one of those knowing looks and implied that Kaiser they would treat cancer with proven science. I guess this isn't main stream treatment yet?

    Mike W.

  • dlb823
    dlb823 Member Posts: 9,430
    edited June 2015

    I'm so sorry to learn about your wife's situation, Mike, but it sounds like she's responding very well to the tx she's on. And that's really interesting that she had both ER+ and TNBC bc going on at the same time.

    As far as her onc's reaction to your question about copper depletion, it sounds pretty typical. OTOH, the above research, which is out of Weill Cornell and was just presented at the recent ASCO meeting, may open the door and his mind to its potential -- especially for the TNBC element of your wife's dx.

    And leggo, I am also taking this research seriously for now. In fact, I consciously decided against eating either avocado or lentils for lunch. (I know, sometimes I tend to overreact!)

  • labelle
    labelle Member Posts: 721
    edited June 2015

    Since starting this whole BC thing, I've read several (100s) of books about cancer, BC and diet, nutrients. Several have suggested if we (those diagnosed w BC) are taking a multi-vitamin we should be sure it does NOT contain copper-ditto for iron. Some have recommended we not cook with copper or cast iron pans either. So avoiding excess copper is not a new idea but this drug does sound promising anyway.

    I definitely don't take any supplements w copper in them, but I'm not ready to give up cashews or avocados-especially not avocados-they have lots of really healthy things in them too and I love them! Kale? Maybe, I'm not too keen on it anyway, LOL.

  • Stephmoen
    Stephmoen Member Posts: 563
    edited June 2015

    eek I have a copper iud I had no idea it had any correlation with breast cancer should have it taken out

  • dlb823
    dlb823 Member Posts: 9,430
    edited June 2015

    Hmmm... Have IUDs always been made of copper? I had one for years, but have no idea what it was made of.

  • Stephmoen
    Stephmoen Member Posts: 563
    edited June 2015

    tgere are 2 kinds the newer one merina I think it's called releases hormones my dr said if I had that type to get it out due to my bc being hormone positive I have the older iud because it's the only one my insurance covers it doesn't release hormones but is made of copper because copper is a spermicide

  • geewhiz
    geewhiz Member Posts: 1,439
    edited June 2015

    This is fascinating and timely. My naturopathic oncologist just tested me and the results of my copper test are REALLY high...and he says that he is seeing i in most of his breast cancer patients. I have never used an IUD, nor cooked in copper. I meet with him again on Monday to discuss what to do now.

    He also gave me a Dtectrx Breast test..and since i haven't had my coffee yet, I can't remember why I did that one....recurrence indicators I think, but its new technology as well that sounded good.

  • leggo
    leggo Member Posts: 3,293
    edited June 2015

    HOLY COW! I can't believe I haven't heard anything about this copper thing until you posted this Deanna. A quick google search on "copper and cancer" brings up a mind-boggling amount of literature, some of it so contradictory. I don't even know where to begin. I'm overwhelmed and the scary part is that it seems to be the one thing that makes a huge difference in so many cancers. So much cancer, so many copper pipes!!!!!! That was my first thought. I'm kinda freaked out. I can't make any sense about what level is the "right" level. Not enough seems just as dangerous. This copper thing is quite something to think about. Normally, I'm pretty comfortable blowing stuff off and moving on. The more I read, the more I realize how important this is.

  • dlb823
    dlb823 Member Posts: 9,430
    edited June 2015

    Leggo, please share any pertinent links you find!

  • geewhiz
    geewhiz Member Posts: 1,439
    edited June 2015

    http://informahealthcare.com/doi/pdf/10.3109/02841...

    Not sure if I linked that correctly...but here is an older study that echos what I was being told.Here's another good one...more recent

    http://annonc.oxfordjournals.org/content/24/6/1491


    Serum copper reference ranges are 72-166 ug/dl. Cerloplasmin is 16-45 mg/dl.

    You can use Copper levels and more importantly ceruloplasmin levels as recurrence markers as I understand it (and the link above discusses is standardly done in the Turkish hospital). Ceruloplasmin is the one involved in angiogenesis. So I have high copper levels, but the enzyme the liver uses to convert for angionesis is a normal level in me. So hopefully, I can do some sort of chelation as mentioned in Deanna's study to address and lower that copper level.


  • MusicLover
    MusicLover Member Posts: 4,225
    edited June 2015

    Deanna, Thank you for this.

    Leggo, That is scary, for years people would say it's the water  - so maybe it's the copper pipes that we are using?

  • Meow13
    Meow13 Member Posts: 4,859
    edited June 2015

    Four ladies in my cul-de-sac have breast cancer. Sometimes you do wonder about our environments.

  • dlb823
    dlb823 Member Posts: 9,430
    edited June 2015

    Meow, that sounds like what they call a cancer cluster. Has anyone looked into possible environmental factors in your neighborhood?

    http://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-preventi...

  • leggo
    leggo Member Posts: 3,293
    edited June 2015

    I do not like what I've been reading about copper and cancer. And to top it all off, whenever I've read something about copper, zinc was included as well. As it so happens, I do take a zinc supplement. Shit. I'm seeing my doc on Thursday so I'll run it by him. 

    Still stunned. Frickin' copper pipes? Sure would explain a lot.

  • MusicLover
    MusicLover Member Posts: 4,225
    edited June 2015

    Leggo, If your suspicions are correct about the copper pipes that might explain why there are cancer clusters in cul-de-sac's and neighborhoods that dead end.  The water may lay there in the pipes longer.  Just an idea.

  • leggo
    leggo Member Posts: 3,293
    edited June 2015

    That makes so much sense MusicLover.

  • floaton
    floaton Member Posts: 181
    edited June 2015

    http://www.e-spenjournal.org/article/S1751-4991(11)00056-4/abstract

    This is also interesting re: the ocp / breast cancer link in that ocps elevate copper and ceruloplasmin.

    https://www.mskcc.org/cancer-care/integrative-medicine/herbs/zinc

    I'll have to start looking at some of the links they've provided, but I thought this was a good overview of the role of zinc. My takeaway is that balance is key - too much or too little leads to inflammation and oxidation. I'm taking a zinc supplement right now too (I jut started a ca/mg/zn/D combo for my osteopenia) and am interested where my levels are. May be time to find myself a naturopath after all, as I have a feeling my regular onc won't be willing to test me.

    Also, since they balance each other, I wonder what the zinc levels of women being copper chelated are?

    This is all very complicated, but I'm really glad someone is thinking outside of the just kill the cancer cells box and looking at their supporters.

  • leggo
    leggo Member Posts: 3,293
    edited June 2015

    I realize it's probably a lot more complicated, or maybe it's not because I'm pretty sure they complicate things on purpose, but if us lowly lay people can identify this as a pretty big environmental factor, copper depletion isn't a treatment 'cos.......why?

  • Srh242
    Srh242 Member Posts: 328
    edited June 2015

    in the clinic Euromed in Arizona they measure the level of ceruloplasmin and if copper is high they give you a product to lower it, to decrease chance of relapse

  • leggo
    leggo Member Posts: 3,293
    edited June 2015

    I should have said in conventional medicine. I realize alternative clinics are doing it.

  • Srh242
    Srh242 Member Posts: 328
    edited June 2015

    yes they are Leggo, alternative medicine is ahead

  • leggo
    leggo Member Posts: 3,293
    edited June 2015

    Agreed. I'm a tad annoyed that my naturopath never mentioned this. Actually, in hindsight he checked my eyes for a quick sec and mentioned something about copper but never explained. Didn't see a problem, or maybe decided in the grand scheme of things it wasn't important. We have to talk.

  • sandilee
    sandilee Member Posts: 1,843
    edited June 2015

    I had heard about this study awhile ago, but it's so hard to cut back on high copper foods. Salmon and mushrooms? That's tough. Here's a link to low copper foods, intended for another disease, but still informative.

    http://www.arizonadigestivehealth.com/low-copper-d...

    One thing I wonder about is how low a level is necessary to reach any kind of therapeutic level to stop tumor angiogenesis. It sounds like one needs a very low level-- low enough to affect your red blood cell counts. Can you even do this by restricting foods? And would it throw other things off-kilter?

    Awareness is good, though, but I'm not sure the benefits of leaving out so many healthful foods will give us the desired result. I do take a zinc supplement which I hope balances things somewhat.

    I have copper plumbing- have had since we moved into this house 20 years ago. Been using a lot of bottled spring water for the last few years. Think I'll keep it up.


  • dlb823
    dlb823 Member Posts: 9,430
    edited June 2015

    floaton, thank you for the links! For anyone who hasn't read them, the first one concludes about oral conceptives...

    "OC use influenced zinc, iron and copper homeostasis. Zinc supplementation further altered copper utilization in OC users, possibly favoring oxidative stress."

    This 2013 article suggests that copper doesn't cause cancer, but that copper in drinking water does influence cancer proliferation, and that minimizing it may be beneficial. Mike, this might be a good one to show your wife's onc, if you haven't already. http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/11/13111...


  • dlb823
    dlb823 Member Posts: 9,430
    edited June 2015

    Wow, Sandilee ~ You can't make much of a meal out of those foods that are low in copper. And I think some of them, like beef, are probably relatively high in iron, which promotes angiogenisis. The other thing is, so many high-copper foods are healthy foods, so I think it would be very easy to eat a cumulatively high amount of copper simply by eating kale, spinach, sweet potatoes, avocados, lentils, tofu, mushrooms and such on a daily basis, which many health conscious eaters do. Arrrgh!!! This is incredibly frustrating!!! I haven't had an avocado since I started this thread, and I'm not about to start eating cold cuts or refined flour!

Categories