Vitamins, Supplements...oh my!

Options
mcgis
mcgis Member Posts: 291

Good Morning! I'm back on Arimidex (went off when my period just appeared in July after having been told I was in chemical induced menopause). I had a hysterectomy 3 weeks ago so my oncologist said it's time to start the Arimidex again. Boo!

How much calcium and vitamin D should I be taking? I take One A day Women's VitaCraves that has 800 IU of Vitamin D and 100mg of Calcium. I also have additional capsules Vitamin D3 1000 IU and Calcium 1200mg plus 1000 IU Vitamin D3.

So that's 2800 IU of Vitamin D3 and 1300mg Calcium. Is that enough? Too much? What else should I be taking?

Thanks!!!

Comments

  • dlb823
    dlb823 Member Posts: 9,430
    edited November 2014

    mcgis, 1300mg. of calcium is good, since you no doubt also get some from foods. But I think there are much better sources of calcium than the one you're using. Some of the newer formulations have a lot of other minerals that are proven to help build bone. You might want to check at a health food store or natural foods market. I'm using one by Jarrow, but there are several others that contain the right amount of magnesium, boron, zinc and other minerals necessary to maximize calcium absorption and metabolism.

    And I would personally up the D3. Do you know what your D level is? It should be as high as possible -- ideally well above 50. I'd suggest 5,000 minimum. I personally take 10,000, split into multiple doses to ensure absorption. At this time of year, sufficient vitamin D can contribute to overall wellness, including preventing flu and other illnesses. Deanna


  • labelle
    labelle Member Posts: 721
    edited November 2014

    I think you need to have your vitamin D levels checked. It is a simple blood draw and any doctor can order it. Vitamin D has been shown in many studies to be important in preventing and possibly treating breast cancer. You do want your Vitamin D levels to be well above 50. If they are, then the supplements you are taking are enough. If not, you need more, but without testing your levels to begin with supplementation is pretty much a shot in the dark. On the other hand, it is pretty danged hard to get too much Vitamin D, so supplementing isn't going to hurt anything, you mostly want to be sure you are getting enough. I take 5000 IU vitamin D daily. A couple years ago my Vitamin D levels were found to be dangerously low-like 12-lord only knows how long my levels were low prior to this. Did this, lack of vitamin D contribute to me getting breast cancer later? I think so. At that point my gyno had me taking 50,000 IU per week for 12 weeks to get my levels back up. She wasn't the least bit concerned about toxicity even with this pretty high dosage.

  • SpecialK
    SpecialK Member Posts: 16,486
    edited November 2014

    It is important to take your Vitamin D with food that also contains some fat, for the best absorption and effectiveness.

  • Manu14
    Manu14 Member Posts: 153
    edited November 2014

    I agree that getting your vitamin D level checked for a baseline is a good idea. Insurance should cover it once a year and it can be done as a single lab test. The result will give you some idea about what level to supplement with. For me, I was technically in the acceptable range for the average person but not ideal for having breast cancer. Taking 2000 IU Vitamin D3 a day along with a calcium supplement and magnesium pill seems to work for me.

  • JuanitaB
    JuanitaB Member Posts: 31
    edited November 2014

    Hi Ladies, it is my understanding that we can only absorb 500 mg of calcium at one time so it needs to be spread out throughout the day. Smile

  • voraciousreader
    voraciousreader Member Posts: 7,496
    edited November 2014

    Vitamin D supplementaion is very controversial.


    http://www.mlo-online.com/articles/201406/vitamin-...


    I would be discussing what vitamins and supplements that one might need with their team of physicians.



  • voraciousreader
    voraciousreader Member Posts: 7,496
    edited November 2014

    The reason why I reference the above link is because the amount of Vitamin D taken, may not reflect how much is absorbed. Furthermore, once it is absorbed, whether from the sun, eating foods that contain it or through supplementation, the body cannot differentiate where it came from. That said, no one knows precisely how much their body needs to absorb NOR has there there been any evidence of what a "therapeutic" amount should be. We all have read about "dangerously" low numbers of vitamin D. However, it is anyone's guess what a therapeutic amount is. That's why I think it is imperative that specific numbers not be discussed on a thread.

  • voraciousreader
    voraciousreader Member Posts: 7,496
    edited November 2014

    Last point....if one doesn't understand WHY a person is deficient in a vitamin, then giving a Supplement might be a waste. There is usually an underlying cause for a deficiency. Better to examine the cause of the deficiency before taking a supplement. If one doesn't have a classic deficiency, then taking more of a supplement doesn't matter.


    Example...there are people born with genetic mutations that interfere with their body's ability to metabolize carnitine and they become carnitine deficient. Once you supplement Carnitine, they improve. Then you have other people who are missing the enzyme to process carnitine. Since they lack the enzyme to break down carnitine, no matter how much carnitine you give them, their bodies will still suffer because they are deficient in the enzyme that breaks down carnitine.


    So, if you think you NEED a vitamin or supplement, first CONFIRM you have a deficiency. Then try to discover WHY you have the deficiency. And then find a doctor who knows what a therapeutic dose is to correct the problem.


    And also keep in mind...ALL vitamins and supplements along with medications have the potential to create kidney and liver issues.



  • tgtg
    tgtg Member Posts: 266
    edited November 2014

    I second what voraciousreader is saying, and would add that vitamin supplements are, bottom line, like medications and non-medical people, even on this website, should not be prescribing dosages. Ask a doctor of yours to order a blood test for vitamin D levels, and have the results interpreted by that doctor (and others if you feel the need), but not by a layman, however well-meaning. As others have said, overdosing of vitamins can lead to severe damage of your vital organs, TG.

Categories