Heart Medicine Alternatives

Options
Hindsfeet
Hindsfeet Member Posts: 2,456
edited June 2014 in Alternative Medicine

My cardio doctor prescribed for me Carvedilol, and Lisinopril twice a day...due to low EF levels (Herceptin side effects). I'm reluctant to take the heart meds after reading the side effects of these drugs. Does anyone here know of alternative ways to rebuild the heart muscle?

«13

Comments

  • itsjustme10
    itsjustme10 Member Posts: 796
    edited July 2012

    Unless someone on here is a board certified cardiologist, you probably want to get advice from your doctors.  CHF is too serious of a condition to mess around with ..  if you're really concerned about possible side effects from medications, speak to your cardiologist, and see if he can send you to cardiac rehab (basically monitored exercise) to improve your heart function, and discuss your concerns about the side effects with them.  Usually exercise helps build muscle, but in your case, it should absolutely be monitored. 

    I don't know how advanced your condition it, or how old your are, but if they gave you 2 medications, it's probably serious enough that you should only make changes your medical team agrees to.  And you'll probably need medical permission to begin any exercise program.

    I understand your concerns, but when it's a vital bodily function, such as heart, lungs, or kidneys, it's usually best to stick with board certified specialists, and not try to self-medicate.

    That doesn't mean that with proper care, and exercise and time that your heart function won't improve and allow you to get off your medications. It just means you probably should listen right now..

  • sweetbean
    sweetbean Member Posts: 1,931
    edited July 2012

    I had a therapist who specialized in guided imagery who had heart problems.  She went on heart meds and began doing a  regular practice on guided imagery, visualization, and meditation.  Her doctors thought she would need the meds for the rest of her life, but gradually, her heart problems were corrected and she was able to go off them.  Her doctors were astounded.  

    I agree with itsjustme10 - heart problems are very serious and you'd want to think very seriously about skipping the meds.  However, perhaps you can find some healing practitioners in your area that do guided imagery or other healing modalities to help you heal your heart faster.  The mind can be a powerful tool.    I have used guided imagery after every surgery and treatment and doctors have always been astonished at how fast I heal and how few side effects I have.

  • luv_gardening
    luv_gardening Member Posts: 1,393
    edited July 2012

    Eve, you do seem to have many adverse reactions to drugs so I don't blame you for being wary.  I was hoping your heart problems weren't that bad, and as the other replies have indicated, it's not something to be taken lightly.  You really need to get as much informed advice as you can from different sources, maybe the her2+ threads will have women in your position who have researched the options. 

    I'm with Sweetbean, use guided imagery, also mindfulness and meditation to help with feelings of peace and calm as an adjunct to the medications and maybe you can reduce the meds after a while. You could imagine the drugs healing your heart each time you take them. This might relieve a lot of fear and stress so your heart has a chance to recover.

    Without medication I believe your heart will be under too much stress and it's a slippery slope from there.  I've nursed many with this condition and my grandfather had it so I know what can happen to those who don't comply with the meds. On the other hand I believe some women do recover from this so keep hope alive.  I'm so sorry I couldn't come up with anything more useful.  I'll keep my eyes open for anything that might be helpful.

    Hugs dear friend.

  • Hindsfeet
    Hindsfeet Member Posts: 2,456
    edited July 2012

    Thanks. I am hoping being off Herceptin for awhile will do the trick. I will only take the meds if it's absolutely necessary. I have another echo on July 30th. My surgery is July 31st. I would have been off Herceptin for a little more than a month. I will know the results mid August. If my Ef drops again for sure I will try the meds. If it is stable, or where it is now then I may give it a few months to see if my heart recovers or my EF improves before taking meds. Meanwhile, it would be nice to know alternative ways to support the heart.

    I'm pretty positive. If at all possible, I advoid conflict. I' layed on our patio the other day basking in the warm sun, imagining that I was somewhere in Hawaii. 

    This morning walking up a slight hill, I could hardly breathe. You would think after being off Herceptin for 3 weeks, my heart would be a little better, not worse.

    Joy, the HER2+ threads is where I now do most of my posting.  I'm one of the few who chose to do Herceptin alone. Plus it's good to know what the side effects are without confusing side effects with chemo.

  • vespersparrow
    vespersparrow Member Posts: 62
    edited July 2012

    Eve, here are some supplements to consider for CHF.

     http://www.doctoryourself.com/congestive.html

    Personally I'd take the CoQ-10 and definitely the taurine.   The taurine seems especially promising, "2-6 g/day in 2 or 3 divided doses".

     http://www.webmd.com/vitamins-supplements/ingredientmono-1024-TAURINE.aspx?activeIngredientId=1024&activeIngredientName=TAURINE

    it's even science-based... Wink

  • itsjustme10
    itsjustme10 Member Posts: 796
    edited July 2012

    Well, you're an adult, and you're going to do what you think is best.  I've been going back and forth over whether I would feel guilty if I didnt' try again to explain to you how serious congestive heart failure is, but based on re-reading your post, and how you're glossing over your shortness of breath, I guess nothing I can say will convince you, so.  Good luck - I hope your test comes out good enough so it's safe for you to have your surgery.

  • autism_mom
    autism_mom Member Posts: 184
    edited July 2012

    evebarry

    may I ask what your EF is now. rather what it was at your ladt echo

  • Chickadee
    Chickadee Member Posts: 4,467
    edited July 2012

    Perhaps it's important to learn as much about EF and the benefits of your potential treatment as it is to be frightened of side effects. This site seems very helpful.



    http://www.chfpatients.com/faq/ef.htm

  • luv_gardening
    luv_gardening Member Posts: 1,393
    edited July 2012

    Eve, This is my understanding from memory and what I've read, please check with any Dr who is honest and you feel you can trust.  Most people have CHF for chronic underlying conditions that aren't going to get better so it's not recoverable for them. 

    If it's caused by Herceptin and that's withdrawn then there is a chance it will get better, some people do, and some don't as you doubtlessly know from the Her2+ threads.  If it does go away of it's own accord then you may have been wise not to risk further SE's from the heart drugs, but if it gets worse then it can quickly gain momentum without the drugs.  So monitoring and taking the drugs at any sign of worsening would be critical if my understanding is correct.  Don't take my word for it as I'm not qualified and this is too important to leave to anyone's uninformed opinion.

    You are doing the right thing by resting up and staying away from stress.  I hope you have lots of inspiring music and people to surround yourself with in the next few weeks and your heart is able to recover.

    Sending love,

    Joy

  • Hindsfeet
    Hindsfeet Member Posts: 2,456
    edited July 2012

     In a week, I'll have another echo. My doctors are concerned because of the continued decline. I have physically worsen since my last echo. I am fortunate that my heart issues are caught early. Because it's caught early, hopefully I'm more likely to recover. I am not comfortable taking drugs before giving my body a chance to heal itself.

    Late today, I got a call from the cardio nurse, who said my doctor wants me to do the stress test before surgery. If the test come out normal then I will go ahead with the surgery on the 31st of this month. If the stress test comes out abnormal the surgery will be cancelled. The chemical stress test as well as the echo next week will give us a better picture of what is going on with my heart.Today, my cardio doctor also said not to take the heart meds before surgery. It would probably lower my blood pressure too much.

    I know the heart is not a muscle to ignore. I have had so many reactions to medicine that' right now I'm pretty gun shy. I was told Herceptin was pretty B9, and I'm the one to have the more serious side effects. Fosamax did a real trip on me. The anti-viral pill negatively effected me. I' read askapatient.com on the heart meds, and I'm fearful of taking them, but will if it's absolutely necessary. I think I'm being cautious for good reason.

    So thanks for your concern itsjustme. I also appreciate the links.

    My cardio doctor said a few days, my EF rounded out is 44 (so it was probably 43-45). Before starting Herceptin it was 65. I may have more going on than the heart due to tighteness in the chest. I know lungs can be affected by the Herceptin. Who knows? The hope, like said before is our hearts can recover on its own.

  • autism_mom
    autism_mom Member Posts: 184
    edited July 2012

    Evebarry.

    At 44% you are really ok to wait. That is just mildly reduced lv function. If it was 10-15% it would be a far differnt story. At this point folow your cards advice but let him know you want alternative methods. Normal is pretty much 55-60, some even go with 50 as a normal. 65 is high normal. 75 as some have posted is not a normal resting ef. Its hyperdynamic and not good for your heart. That would be a good exercise ef. Keep jn mind muga scans tend to estimate higher than echos and your resting ef is the one to pay attention to. God luck with your testing.

  • Hindsfeet
    Hindsfeet Member Posts: 2,456
    edited July 2012

    Thanks Joy, you are so right. If my heart doesn't recover and worsens after being off Herceptin for a few months, yes absolutely, take the drugs. Again, I do not want to take the drugs unless I absolutely have to. The reason, I may have worsen this week is due to last week demanding schedule. I got up early in the mornings to milk goats, had camp all day, guest at night, and two weddings over the weekend. I'm taking a little time off this week before workshops next week. I wish I could afford to do nothing for awhile. At least I enjoy my job, and the great community of people I work with.

    I do like my doctors a lot. I am fortunate to have doctors that listen, care and I can trust.

    My echo's are while resting.

  • luv_gardening
    luv_gardening Member Posts: 1,393
    edited July 2012

    I've been looking at weedgirl's first link and I'd be wary of the advice given about selenium on that web page.  He's saying to take selenium supps then further down the page he says to eat Brazil nuts for Potassium and Methionine (see Taurine). 

    If you took both the Brazil nuts and Selenium supps that could be a toxic overdose.  From Wikipedia...

    Brazil nuts are perhaps the richest dietary source of selenium; one ounce can contain as much as 10 times the adult USRDA (U.S. Recommended Dietary Allowances), more even than the Tolerable Upper Intake Level (UL), although the amount of selenium within batches of nuts varies greatly...    Although selenium is an essential trace element, it is toxic if taken in excess. Exceeding the Tolerable Upper Intake Level of 400 micrograms per day can lead to selenosis...

    I've known about selenium toxicity since studying nutrition decades ago so that makes me question the validity of the whole site, shouldn't the author check for such errors before publishing to the web?  So I suggest you follow up the recommendations from reliable web sites before utilising any of them.

    ETA, I do appreciate the web site which gives a good starting point for supps to investigate but not to take the author's word.

  • Hindsfeet
    Hindsfeet Member Posts: 2,456
    edited July 2012

    Thanks Joy...about the heads up on Selenium. I haven't taken it in awhile. Right now, I'm timid about eating nuts. I discovered a month ago, I have an allergy to Almond seeds. I've been snacking on them for a few years because I heard they are anti-cancer. One day, while eating a almond, I notice my mouth itching, and a mouth sore forming. I've been plagued with mouth sores for about 2 years. Since I've stopped eating all almond products and of course almonds, I haven't had a mouth sore. Amazing. I also get mouth sores after surgery due to antibiotics, but mostly I believe due to almonds. I' also have little bit of allergy to other nuts. So, now, I'm shy of nuts. Hate it, because they are a good snacking food, and tasty.

    Weedgirl...thanks. I appreciate your support too :)

    I haven't said much to my friends about my heart. As far as they know, I'm ok. I' don't want to be defined by health problem. I'm glad I can come here and share my health concerns.

    (((hugs)))

  • Hindsfeet
    Hindsfeet Member Posts: 2,456
    edited July 2012

     Someone e-mailed me a few links and info for the heart. http://www.thecholesteroltruth.com/discover-the-powerful-natural-alternative-to
    THE ABOVE NATURAL ALTERNATIVES TO STATINS AND TESTIMONINES TO PEOPLE WHO LEFT THEM

    The researchers found that as little as two ounces of tomato paste, or a pint of tomato juice a day, could be an ‘effective alternative' to statins.
     Lead researcher, Dr Karin Ried from the University of Adelaide, said that eating just one tomato a day would not be enough, but recommends looking at tomato paste, which is very rich in lycopene. Writing in the journal Maturitas, Dr Ried added that taking more than 25 milligrams of lycopene daily, can reduce "bad" cholesterol by up to 10 per cent and help protect against heart disease.

    Curcumin (turmeric root): Scientists believe that curcumin attaches to cholesterol and prevents its ability to pass from the bowel to the rest of your body, where it can do harm.
    Curcumin also helps control your cholesterol levels assisting your liver to eliminate any excess cholesterol. Not only does curcumin have an overall beneficial effect on cholesterol, it is also able to specifically increase HDL levels and reduce LDL.

    On top of that, curcumin also helps keep your blood thin, which prevents blood clots from forming in your arteries and lowers your risk of having a heart attack.

    The recommended dosage for curcumin is 900mg taken once or twice a day.

  • luv_gardening
    luv_gardening Member Posts: 1,393
    edited July 2012

    Eve, Lowering your cholesterol naturally would be good, but the two drugs you were prescribed weren't statins so that wouldn't replace them.  They are a beta blocker and an ace inhibitor which work directly on the heart and blood pressure.

    I wish hubby would eat cooked tomato or tomato paste as he's on heart meds and won't eat healthy or try to slim down.  He's a man... sigh.

  • vespersparrow
    vespersparrow Member Posts: 62
    edited July 2012

    I take selenium for bc, but I'm careful with the brazil nuts too because there's no good way to know how much you're getting.  If I eat brazils I sometimes even skip my supp.  If you're going to use selenium as medicine I think it's better to just take a Se-methylselenocysteine supp up to 400mcg.  Just my opinion... I agree it's best to research any new supps (or meds for that matter).

    But here's another good one for heart problems... cayenne!

    Interesting inteview with Dr. Richard Schulze (seems like he put cayenne in lots of his formulas): http://dietgest.blogspot.com/2007/09/unknown-facts-about-cayenne-pepper-and.html

  • luv_gardening
    luv_gardening Member Posts: 1,393
    edited July 2012

    Thanks Weedgirl, good find! Cayenne heart benefits are repeated all over the internet, this is for a heart attack.

    Capsaicin for Heart Attack
    Capsaicin Could Stop a Heart Attack in Progress

    Research from the University of Cincinnati shows that a common, over-the-counter pain salve rubbed on the skin during a heart attack could serve as a cardiac-protectant, preventing or reducing damage to the heart while interventions are administered.

    These findings are published in the the journal Circulation.

     --------------------------------

    This article mentions foods that can help lower or maintain blood pressure which need to be researched for accuracy. Study references are given for each food. Both drugs you were prescribed lower blood pressure.  It might be worth trying each food while monitoring your blood pressure, after all, it's only food, and the effects will be specific to you.

    Study Discovers How Capsaicin Helps Blood Pressure Health

    While soy foods (5), fiber (6), fish oil (7), Pycnogenol® (8), beta -glucan (9) and pea protein (10) have all been found to help maintain blood pressure health, research has also found capsaicin, found in peppers, to also be beneficial (11). Now a new study (12) has found out how capsaicin may be able to elicit its blood pressure health properties. 

    "Limited studies show that these capsinoids produce effects similar to capsaicin," Zhu says. "I believe that some people can adopt this sweet pepper."

  • Hindsfeet
    Hindsfeet Member Posts: 2,456
    edited July 2012

    Joy, beta blockers and ace inhibitors are all new to me. I don't know much about them or statins. My daughter assumed they were statins and didn't want me on them. I'm not sure why. I just read the side effects from askpatients.com on the side effects, which is what made me nervous. It brought up a few people who had low EF.

    I love spicy foods. My daughter read to that cheyenne pepper can stop a heart attack. We have cheyenne supplements. They are also supposely anti-cancer.

  • luv_gardening
    luv_gardening Member Posts: 1,393
    edited July 2012

    Here's more, a good one... Another job of your prescribed medications is to improve blood flow, and again the recent research points to capsaicin.

    Hot Pepper Compound Could Help Hearts
    ScienceDaily (Mar. 27, 2012)
     

    Capsaicinoids also blocked the activity of a gene that produces cyclooxygenase-2, a substance that makes the muscles around blood vessels constrict. By blocking it, muscles can relax and widen, allowing more blood to flow.

  • luv_gardening
    luv_gardening Member Posts: 1,393
    edited July 2012
  • Hindsfeet
    Hindsfeet Member Posts: 2,456
    edited July 2012

    Joy...it seems that these medicines do the same thing. Why do I have to take both. I hate the idea of it effecting my eyes. Already Herceptin has done a number on my eyes and I don't know if I can handle the fatigue it could cause. I am not sure other than helping blood flood how it helps. It says that it doesn't correct the heart just helps with blood flow.

  • AlaskaAngel
    AlaskaAngel Member Posts: 1,836
    edited July 2012

    Hi Joy. My guy thought man could live on meat alone until age 65 when he ended up with severe CHF, and he is on the cardiac drugs too. He is also having to take on the chore of minimizing carbs in addition, due to possible early diabetes. I have thus far avoided the temptation to say "I TOLD YOU SO..."

    A.A.

  • luv_gardening
    luv_gardening Member Posts: 1,393
    edited July 2012

    Eve, maybe someone with more knowledge than me can answer that one which I wondered myself.  Their action is in taking the load off the heart so it's not working so hard, I believe one of them slows the heart down so that is a direct action on the heart.  The only way I know to achieve that without the drugs is a temporary fix with meditation, relaxation etc.  The other way is long term aerobic exercise which I imagine is not helpful, dangerous even, for CHF patients.  What I don't understand is why they give two drugs with similar actions.  Perhaps the one which slows the heart (Beta blocker) is not strong enough to bring the BP down enough so that's why the ace inhibitor is needed in addition.  That's my guess and I hope someone will correct me if I'm wrong.

    A.A.  I have a close relative who has spent her adult life yo-yo dieting with low carb high meat diets.  She has many illnesses and it's hard to know if they are caused by her weight, or diet, or if she would have got them anyway.  I have to accept she has many demons that I can only imagine that drive her to eat that way, and accept that she's a wonderful caring woman who has the right to choose her own course in life, no matter how painful it is for me to watch.  Husbands on the other hand are more easy to temp me into nagging mode so I have to avoid the subject. Fortunately we take most things light heartedly. Life's too short to fight.

  • autism_mom
    autism_mom Member Posts: 184
    edited July 2012

    Joy

    I dont know how how to explain it cause its too complicated for my wee little mind but look up preload and afterload. That is what those meds are for. Very basically the more your left ventricle can relax between each contraction the harder it can sqeeze which gives you the ejection fraction. If your hr is slower the lv has more time to relax and if your arteries are more relaxed the less work the lv has to do to get that sqeeze. Im betting youll be able to explain far better than I.

  • luv_gardening
    luv_gardening Member Posts: 1,393
    edited July 2012

    Ooooohh thanks autistic mom, I'll look that up when I get back from my trip which will be AM in the US.  I'm a sponge for medical facts.

    PS.  I think I'm on the spectrum, a bit below asperger's. All about facts and struggling with social rules which make no sense to me. I'm face blind too which makes life interesting. All part of the colourful fabric of life.

  • autism_mom
    autism_mom Member Posts: 184
    edited July 2012

    lol joy. i kind of had you pegged for spectrum after reading several of your posts. you remind me a lot of my husband who is definately spectrum without a dx. the apple does not fall far from the tree in our house. and i mean this as the highest compliment to you. enjoy your trip.

  • Hindsfeet
    Hindsfeet Member Posts: 2,456
    edited July 2012

    Joy, what is a CHF patient? As far as diet, most of the time, I'm off breads, white flour, and sweet drinks...except for juice at times. I treat myself to fun foods at weddings and special events...sometimes at home :) Since Herceptin, inspite of the little I eat, I have a tummy...not bad, but one that I didn't have before. I heard that tummy fat causes our cholesterol to rise. I wonder what my bad cholesterol is right now? The only good thing about having a little fat around my middle right now is for the upcoming liposuction for fatgrafting for my new reconstructed breast. My husband is always telling me to eat something. He brings me lunch at work fearing I'll skip eating, which I tend to do.

    Before Herceptin, I was told that I had the heart of an athelete. I also had very low blood pressure. Just a few months ago, my blood pressure was 100/50 ... now 100/130. Maybe I have it backwards. I'm just beginning to gather info on the heart. And before I take the meds, I'm going to ask my cardio doctor why I'm given two meds that basically do the same thing. I fear taking them, it will suddenly drop my blood pressure too low. Do most people on heart meds monitor their heart? I already feel like dizzy, and a lot of times like I could pass out.

    btw..joy, where are you going on vacation?

  • autism_mom
    autism_mom Member Posts: 184
    edited July 2012

    chf is congestive heart failure.

    130/100 is a little high...specifically the 100 which is your diastolic pressure. that alone could be a reason for either one of those meds. it needs to come down soon so it doesnt cause damage to your heart and arteries. maybe you could start with the meds then work on some alternative ways to decrease your bp and strengthen your heart. and you should really monitor that bp yourself. if that bottom number gets to 110 call your dr right away.

  • luv_gardening
    luv_gardening Member Posts: 1,393
    edited July 2012

    I don't have a Dx.  I don't think they can do it without interviewing the parents and what would be the point?  No help even for those adults with the most difficulties. My youngest could claim some employment and income help for his situation but they make people jump through hoops that are beyond their capabilities for a small benefit.

    Sorry to hijack the thread but all these things impact on our ability to get help, converse with professionals and have our decisions accepted. Fortunately my MO is understanding of my quirks and fierce independence and I'm honoured to have her as my specialist.

Categories