To sleeve or not to sleeve, that is the question

Options
Anonymous
Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
edited June 2014 in Lymphedema

Hi ladies,

I am finishing 33 tx of rads, whole breast/supra clavicle.  I had a lumpectomy with 11 nodes removed. I am thin, very fit, active, and have had absolutely no evidence of LE so far.   However, because of the rads and nodes, I consulted with a local LE specialist who gave me some confusing advice about flying and backpacking.

Flying: I am flying to NYC next month for 5 days. She fitted me with a sleeve, then told me to wear it while flying. When I mentioned to her that my RO said I shouldn't need to use it flying since I live at 7,000 feet and the cabin's pressurized to 10,000 feet, she then said instead, okay--don't wear it but take it along in case you do feel any change. I regularly change elevation from 7000 to 9500 to 1800 feet and so far so good.  What should I do? Wear it? Or not?  Will a sleeve cause lymphedema? 

Second, she told me that I couldn't backpack because the straps would cut into my shoulders and chest area where the nodes were removed and remaining  ones tx'ed.  I'm not a big backpacker so it doesn't bother me, but she said anything over 10 lbs! I do a lot of day hiking and would like to carry a pack more than 10 lbs at times.

Any advice you've received from your specialists would be helpful about these issues. She confused me more than anything.

Claire in AZ

Comments

  • kira66715
    kira66715 Member Posts: 4,681
    edited May 2012

    Claire, the issue of compression for flying is not resolved for people at risk. What is clear though, is if you chose to wear a sleeve, and you're "just" at risk--you should wear hand protection so as not to push fluid into the hand

    Here's a link to Andrea Cheville discussion the need to compress the hand if you wear a sleeve:

    http://lymphedivas.com/lymphedema/gauntletandsleeve/

    The NLN just put out a new position paper on risk reduction and now say they can't recommend either for or against compression when you fly: I was just at a Vodder recertification course ( a lymphadema therapist training school) and we discussed it at length, and I talked to Renee Romano who runs BandagesPlus, who is great and a trained therapist, and she recommends--as do other LE therapists--to put light compression on the arm: 15-20mm (only made by Jobst) and class 1, which is 20-30mm on the hand, if you chose to wear prophylactic compresssion for flying. The length of the flight seems to matter, and there's an arbitrary cut off of over 2 hours. The arguement for the lighter compression is that it won't trap fluid, less likely to push it into the hand, and women who don't routinely wear compression often just hate the feeling of the higher compression.

    Also, on the plane, there are other factors: using your arm to heft luggage, lack of movement in flight, dehydration--so the advice is to move around, drink like crazy, and periodically raise your arms over your head and pump your fists to engage your muscles and move the fluid out of the arm.

    Re: backpacking. My LE therapist saw a case of LE caused by a backpacking accident and the straps go right over the supraclavicular area.

    However, the current advice for exercise is to DO IT--just slow and steady. I'm not a back packer, but other women on this forum are, and perhaps you can work on a frame that puts almost all the weight on your hips.

    The 10 lb rule is outdated. A gallon of milk is 8 lb. The newest advice is to exercise, but very slow at first, and advance slowly while paying careful attention to how your arm/chest/breast feel and if they swell.

    Some of the women here use hiking poles to keep their arms up.

    All too many LE therapists practice in isolation and their quality and knowledge of new advances vary.

    Here's a link to checking out a qualified LE therapist

    http://www.stepup-speakout.org/Finding_a_Qualified_Lymphedema_Therapist.htm

    If you pm Binney4, she knows many good LE therapists in Arizona.

    Hope you never, ever join the swell sorority, but it sure is hard to figure out how to prevent that, isn't it.

    Kira

    Love your quote: as a habitual worrier, my sister always admonishes me "Worry is not preparation"

  • Nitocris
    Nitocris Member Posts: 187
    edited May 2012

    Hi,

    Some models of backpacks only have one wide strap.  They are called either cross body sling bags or sling backpacks. They are usually smaller than the regular ones but the good thing is that you will not carry so much weight. 

  • Moderators
    Moderators Member Posts: 25,912
    edited May 2012

    Hi Claire,

    In addition to the wonderful help the folks here have provided, you may be interested in checking out the main Breastcancer.org's new Lymphedema section, especially the Reducing Risk of Lymphedema and Lymphedema Flare-Ups, including things to avoid.

    Hope this helps!

    --The Mods

  • lisa-e
    lisa-e Member Posts: 819
    edited May 2012

    I don't backpack, but I use a day pack without any problem.  My hands tend to swell when I am hiking.  But they swelled before my BC diagnosis; it is called dependent edema.  I use hiking poles, as mentioned above, and have minimal problems.

    I suggest going for some short hikes, trying out your equipment and see what works and what doesn't.  I have several different packs; the one I prefer centers the weight on my hips.   

  • coraleliz
    coraleliz Member Posts: 1,523
    edited May 2012

    I'm an occasional backpacker but haven't been since my diagnosis. Lymph nodes removed on both sides plus RADs on both sides. At risk but no visible signs of LE. I went to a screening with a LE therapist because of a achey arm. She called me "stage 0" but also said she's not sure my symptom is due to my surgery & treatment. I haven't come to terms with not backpacking yet. I'm hoping that the further out I get, my arm will feel better & I might want to give it a try. I have been on several day hikes before my arm got achey. Between 8-14miles. I tote a pack with my camera & a couple of lens, water & lunch. I'm sure it weighs more than 10 lbs. I carry it on both shoulders for awhile, then switch from on shoulder to the other. Not ideal, but that's what I figured out because I just wasn't ready to give up my long hikes & my photography. Still not. As my arm becomes less achey, I'm hoping to resume hiking. Not sure if this helps, but you're not alone....

  • kira66715
    kira66715 Member Posts: 4,681
    edited May 2012

    So, I'm studying for a CLT course, and just reviewed the anatomy of the lymph system (or learned it for the first time, really) and with the axillary nodes, the alternate pathway is the supraclavicular nodes, and the advice was not to put pressure in that area with either tight garments or packs.

    Ironically, it was obeying this tenet, that I had my laptop bag on my good arm, and fell in Oct 2010, and broke my LE hand, as it was the free hand that I put out to break my fall...

    I'm thinking, that we need to look at alternative ways of carrying packs so they don't press on that supraclavicular pathway.

    Kira

  • carol57
    carol57 Member Posts: 3,567
    edited May 2012

    Do we know of any pack makers who might listen, and devise a pack that is ergo friendly to our needs? If I had an appropriate light backpack, I would use it instead of pulling a rolling briefcase when I travel.

Categories