Has anyone had micro fat grafting?

Options
1515254565768

Comments

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited January 2012

    faithhopenluv- The armpit incisions were only being done by one PS (Dr. Khouri) when he was removing or replacing implants.  There's a lot of controversy about him doing it this way as it can cause complications (not to mention it's not attractive).  Some of us are prior patients of his who were subjected to this and are not happy.  He is the only PS I have ever heard of, though, who does it this way.

    Eileen- I want to say the only disappointment I've encountered with the fat grafting experience was the armpit incisions.  The fat grafting itself has made a huge difference and feels so much more natural than implants alone.  Not sure who has had a difficult recovery but I don't think that is the norm.  Like I've said, the pain is pretty short lived and the benefits enormous. 

  • mmscullen
    mmscullen Member Posts: 7
    edited January 2012

    Hi Kate,

    Yes, Dr. K said not to wear one, but Cindy said I should wear one.  He said he doesn't think they make that much difference.  Ironically, I struggled into it today just because I don't have to, and find the support somewhat comforting.  He did want to go in through the armpits, but my mx incisions go pretty far out towards my back so he was able to go in that way.  I think it makes it more difficult for him to do the work he needs to do inside "the flap" though.  Can't figure out why I can't raise my arms, though.  I have decided to take the pain meds to help me through this time and that also feels like a relief.  I can't turn the clock back, but feel certain I won't voluntarily subject myself to this again! 

  • mmscullen
    mmscullen Member Posts: 7
    edited January 2012

    geewhiz,

    thanks for this validation.  very helpful.  pretty slow for a month sounds a lot more realistic than what khouri had said before the surgery (i could go back to work the following week - NO WAY!!).  

    to everyone who's had the fat grafting:  did you have red prickly dots over your mid-section after?  what is that?  i should ask khouri, but it is a bit of a drag having to do all this by e-mail and was too out of it at my post op to have the presence of mind to ask everything.  

    to those considering this:  it is too soon for me to see the results and am still in a LOT of pain, but think this would have been easier had i been better prepared for the reality of the post op challenge. 

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited January 2012

    I just read this on liposuction.com which I thought was interesting regarding pain-

    Post-operative HealingPain after tumescent liposuction of the abdomen typically does not require any pain medications stronger than acetaminophen (Tylenol). The quality of the pain is similar to the muscle soreness and burning experienced after having worked-out too much. The intensity of the pain is similar to that of a sunburn; it is most intense when the skin of the area is flexed or touched, such as getting in and out of a car, or rolling-over in bed, or when sitting still in a chair. There is minimal discomfort when walking or sitting.With liposuction totally by local anesthesia, patients do not typically need any pain medication immediately after abdominal liposuction because the tumescent local anesthesia last for up to 18 hours. From 36 to 72 hours after surgery, patients experience the greatest degree of soreness and discomfort, but rarely need anything more than acetaminophen (Tylenol).When general anesthesia has been used for liposuction, there is often somewhat more pain after liposuction. This is because surgeons who use general anesthesia usually use less tumescent local anesthesia, do liposuction of more body areas during on the same day, use larger cannulas, and usually close the incisions with sutures.

    The use of smaller liposuction cannulas (microcannulas) requires a little more time to complete the surgery, but they are associated with less postoperative soreness, and allow smoother results. Because the incisions are smaller, they do not need to be closed by sutures; the open incisions allow more drainage of the blood-tinged tumescent fluid. When incisions are closed with sutures this fluid is trapped under the skin and causes prolonged swelling, and increased pain and soreness. 

  • faithhopenluv
    faithhopenluv Member Posts: 323
    edited January 2012

    Thanks Kate33 - I had a lumpectomy, but found that I'm BRAC 2 positive so I will have a bmx after chemo. I was researching Dr Khouri's procedure that didn't involve implants but grafting with immediate reconstruction and then a second graft if necessary. I haven't met with any PS yet, this is only from Internet research.

  • nolo1098
    nolo1098 Member Posts: 76
    edited January 2012

    Kate,

    Thanks for the link regarding compression garments.  I do plan to wear spanx even though doc said not needed. 

  • november
    november Member Posts: 103
    edited January 2012

    mmsculen " I was not prepared for the pain, having been through bi-lat mx and DIEP, I thought this would be a breeze " I am just curious why you needed fat grafting if you had a DIEP

    I am scheduled for PBMX on 2/1/12 without reconstruction. I am exploring options for reconstruction. I met with PS today and DIEP seems like something I may consider in the future. I would like to know about your experience with DIEP

    I hope your pain subsides soon and that you like your final result

    Thanks

  • dancetrancer
    dancetrancer Member Posts: 4,039
    edited January 2012

    The compression garments DEFINITELY help you feel more comfortable for the first few weeks after lipo.  Like Kate33, if I removed them, I'd feel increased pain or was irritated by the numbness.  The garments made me feel much better when I put them back on. 

  • leeinfl
    leeinfl Member Posts: 317
    edited January 2012

    I've had micro fat grafting 4 times now (yes, I am DONE) Smile - several thoughts and hopefully reassurance on some of the latest posts:

    Compression garment:  Yes, wore one every time - however depending on the extent of lipo, this can be a shorter time period.  One time I only had to wear for 3 weeks.  Definitely makes you feel better to have it on.  Didn't much care for the "hospital grade" (Veronique) garment but once I switched to more comfortable alternatives, it felt good to have them on.

    Pain:  Of course there will be pain but it is very tolerable.  Obviously everyone's pain threshold is different, however, even if someone perceives the pain to be on the upper level, it is short-lived.  First couple of days are the worst, but rapid and distinct improvement every day.  Remember, lipoplasty is the most common and popular plastic surgery - that probably wouldn't be the case if the pain was so horrible.  The part that can be more painful is the amount of repair work that might be necessary on the pocket and/or pectoral muscles with revisions.  However, this also subsides very quickly and that pain would be a part of ANY form of revision surgery.  The actual fat grafting to the breast is not painful.

    Incision placement:  My original mastectomy scars were used - however, case history has shown that a better cosmetic result is possible by using the trans-axillary incision.  If the MX scars are used, it is not possible to graft the fat at the incision line (it would push through) - as the incision heals, the tissue contracts and the scar line develops a dimpled indentation.  On my one side this was very pronounced and it was even visible when I wore a cami top.  I've updated my photos on the picture site with the before/after so everyone can see exactly what I mean. This procedure is still new and it is only normal that it will change and be refined as time goes by and more case histories become available. Other surgeons may still use the MX scar, but as you can see on my photos, there is a trade off.  

    Recuperation time:  That will depend on how much pocket work/repair is necessary.  I took one week off from work after the initial revision surgery.   With the others, I was back to work on Monday, taking just the weekend to recover.  

    Every reconstruction option has pros and cons.  All are painful.  Scars are inevitable.  The true beauty of micro fat grafting is the result, and oh boy are they worth it!  To have warm, soft breasts with feeling sure beats the cold, hard lump of silicone I had before.

    I hope this is helpful and I'd like to remind everyone (again) that www.fatgraftpatients.com is a site dedicated SOLELY to micro fat grafting for reconstruction and augmentation.  There are some fantastic stories (and photos) of ladies who had immediate reconstruction with fat grafting at the time of their MX.  Nothing short of amazing and I'm so very happy for these ladies.  Lots of revision stories as well. 

  • Mina1
    Mina1 Member Posts: 50
    edited January 2012

    Hi Kate

     Thanks for the contact info for beacher who saw Suzanne Summers plastic surgeon.

    Mina

  • EileenKaye1
    EileenKaye1 Member Posts: 469
    edited January 2012

    Kate and Leeinfl--thanks so much for the clarification regarding fatgrafting

  • hopefulhealing
    hopefulhealing Member Posts: 722
    edited January 2012

    dancetrance thanks for your words of encouragment.  I think when you have to keep making decisons about what to do it takes alot out of you. Not knowing the best procedure to fix the NSM mess and feeling overwhelmed.  Before my last appt. I was in a much better place.  I think I will go ahead with the fat grafting and if I don't feel good about what he says he is going to do with the areolas I will wait. 

    What did they do for the nipple that was removed? 

    I keep thinking ok it is ok to be down and cry about all of this.  But as my husband said it is normal to feel this way and be patient with yourself.  Have a good weekend.

  • dancetrancer
    dancetrancer Member Posts: 4,039
    edited January 2012

    Hopefulhealing, boy do I understand the keeping having to make decisions issue!  Ugggh!!!  Can someone just give me all the right answers, please?  LOL   I guess there's no "EASY" cancer button.  Ha!   

    I ended up with a straight line across my breast maybe about 3" across - like your typical mastectomy scar.  It was a tough adjustment, just had to work through it.  I am going to use a nipple prosthesis from naturallyimpressive.com.  I have too much on my plate to worry about any more recon surgeries right now.

     And yes, it IS ok to be down and to cry.  IMO, it's the only way to work through it and get to the other side, reaching acceptance.  It also helps so much to hear from others feeling the same pain.  You aren't alone.  This all sucks!

    Sorry for the thread derail, but this stuff is important, too, gang (which I know you all know)!  Back to your regularly scheduled fat grafting convo, LOL. Smile 

  • mormor1
    mormor1 Member Posts: 136
    edited January 2012

    Ladies.... please don't give up on fat grafting for fear of pain!!  I had natural childbirth five times, but then had a tubal and couldn't believe how painful it was!  (maybe because I was expecting "band aid" surgery.  I did have a several inch incision.).  Some people think a MX is hardly any pain, some think it's the worst pain ever.  I like DT's point that lipo is a very common procedure.  This isn't anything that mysterious, surgery wise.  It shouldn't be a reason to rule out fat grafting.  I want to join Lee in encouraging anyone who does it though to participate in fatgraftpatients.com.  THere is a wealth of information and wonderful support to get you through each step of the way.  Lee expresses the outcome well.  To have sensate, natural breasts is a wonderful thing.  I almost forget they aren't my "originals"...and actually they are better than my originals and so is the rest of my body!

    Dancetrancer - didn't really see that as a thread derail...sometimes it's hard to remember which thread we are all on, but all seems pertinent here. :D

    Hopefulhealing - can feel your pain...your DH is so right. This just isn't an easy journey...there are many losses, uncertainties about future and decisions to make, times of waiting for test results; emotional, physical, spiritual pain; body image changes...and there are some silver linings. Love the new friends I've made even though I haven't met most of them...people who will stand by you through thick and thin, to laugh and cry with...such a treasure!!  For me, the big turning point was when I found out about fat grafting and met Dr. Khouri.  It seemed like even though there was a lot to go through with the Domes and seven surgeries...it all seemed positive somehow.  Glad for everyone bringing in their points of views and different MD's to consider who do various approaches.

    mmscullen:  about the red dots all over your abdomen...are they needle pricks or a rash?  I know my body liooked pretty much like a pin cushion in many places, esp. on the breast though.  Is it resolving for you?

    whoever asked about recovery time (sorry, can't scan back for name):  my experience was similar to Lee's.  I traveled, so took 3 days off each time, but would say many women would want at least a week or maybe two.  Much of it depends if you need to do heavy lifting on your job.  Again, it varies.  You know yourself and your job best on whether to error on the longer side and come back early if you can, or hope for shorter recovery and get extra days off, if needed.

  • nolo1098
    nolo1098 Member Posts: 76
    edited January 2012

    Hi,

    I think someone on this thread may have mentioned insurance problems with fat grafting.  Well, I am scheduled for surgery next Thursday and I just heard from the insurance company that they need additional medical information in order to make a final determination of the benefit.  I called the PS office and they said that they have been getting a lot of "push back" from insurance companies regarding fat grafting and revision of reconstructed breast even though it is required to be covered.  She said that she will do everything she can, including having the surgeon speak to the medical director at the insurance company because they are making everyone jump through hoops just to get approval.  More to follow.........  

  • MiniMacsMom
    MiniMacsMom Member Posts: 595
    edited January 2012

    So I have been following this thread off and on and I am way pre recon (still doing chemo, then I have too wait a year after Rads)  but I like getting all the info early ;)  Anyway.  I was reading another website that was reviewed by a series of doctors on fat grafting.  Some of them, were concerned as it hasn't been around a long time, and they don't know how it will affect breast cancer reoccurance. Have any of  you had these concerns?  What has the PS said in response to these concerns?  THe info you guys have shared has been amazing so far, and my hubby and I are really excited for this as a possiblity.  Also for those of you who have used Dr Ahn, how much does somthing like this cost?  She isn't in-network as I have found for my insurance :(

  • hopefulhealing
    hopefulhealing Member Posts: 722
    edited January 2012

    Just a quick question.  When you have the fat injected they just use a small syringe right?

    Also is it an incision at the point where they do the liposuction?

    Thanks having some done in Feb.

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited February 2012

    hope- Not sure the answer to your first question but I would assume it is as I didn't have any sores afterwards, just some bruising.  As far as incisions- technically it is one but is very small (usually less than 1/8") and is not stitched up afterwards but left open to drain.  It takes about a week or two to close up completely and about 4 weeks to heal completely though the lipo site may be visible for up to 2 years.  (It looks like a tiny freckle afterwards.)  Most of mine are completely gone but I do have a few that can still be seen.  Not sure anyone would notice except me, though.

  • mmscullen
    mmscullen Member Posts: 7
    edited February 2012

    Hi

    Thought I had replied, but didn't see the post up, so will try again.  I am happy to discuss the DIEP procedure with you, and imagine there are postings elsewhere on this site.  It is a big decision and has its own pro's and cons.  If you'd like to discuss this "offline" my e-mail is:  mmscullen@aol.com.

    best with all this - - sooooo challenging! 

  • slinky
    slinky Member Posts: 397
    edited February 2012

    I am five months out from my second revision which included fat grafting.  I think I have capsular contracture on one side - there is a dip and it is painful.

    I am so tempted to get the Dr. Khouri technique done.  Isn't there a doctor in Palo Alto that does this? Anyone go to her and have any feedback?

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited February 2012

    slinky- The PS you are thinking about is Dr. Lauren Greenberg and I believe she was trained by Dr. Khouri.  Not sure how many of them she has done but she seems really excited about the procedure on her website.  It's at laurengreenbergmd.com-

    http://www.laurengreenbergmd.com/breast/fat-grafting-for-augmentation-or-reconstruction/ 

  • janny99
    janny99 Member Posts: 119
    edited February 2012

    I am so glad to have found this thread!  In April 2010, I had a lumpectomy with a lift/reduction procedure bilaterally as originally the diagnosis was DCIS...turned out to be a larger area of invasive malignancy, so they had to take more breast tissue than planned.  Because of this, I was left with smaller breasts than anticipated, although I can't complain as I was pretty symmetrical and still had my nipples.  After the chemo, and then radiation, I had quite a change/shrinking of the breast with the cancer.  I opted to try the fat grafting, which I had this past December.  The stem cells of the fat were spun down/separated and returned to the fat to be reimplanted to my breasts.  I have to say, that after the inflammation went down, I didn't really see much change in the size of my breasts, and my tummy is lumpy and bumpy.  I know I'm to have this done at least 1 or 2 more times to get the desired result, but now I'm scared and wondering if it's worth it.  I was not able to have implants because of the radiation, now that I'm into this, I feel I need to see it through.  The co-pays are turning out to be more of a cost than I had realized.  I'm not unhappy with this, just wondering if I should just 'stop' and say enough is enough....Is it normal to have to have this done 3 or 4 times?  I would appreciate any insight or advice.  I'm trying to move on to a life 'past cancer' and wonder if this may be holding me back from just accepting myself the way I am, albeit imperfect.  I'm just feeling uncertain.  The surgeon is very well known and has been highly praised for his work; so I'm just wondering if my expectations are too high for what fat grafting can do.

  • hopefulhealing
    hopefulhealing Member Posts: 722
    edited February 2012

    robo sorry I didn't respond.  I am not having total fat grafting.  But just on the tops and the medial aspect I think to try to take care of some rippling. I am seeing Dr. Mustoe.  Every heard anything about him?  My original PS does not do any fat grafting for breasts at all and he recommended him.

    He did not say anything about a compression garment but I think I will get something. 

    I had many complications so I am hoping this will go well and I will be pleased.  It will be nice if something goes as expected for once :)

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited February 2012

    janny- It's pretty normal to do multiple procedures when you're trying to create an entire breast after MX.  I think it is less so when using the fat grafting for lumpectomy divots, to cover implants and to help repair radiated skin.  When you say your PS is highly praised for his work are you talking specifically about his fat grafting or recon in general?  There are different techniqes for injecting the fat into the breast and some have a higher retention rate than others.  I had fat grafting over my implants last spring and have retained just about all of it and am still happy with the results.  My PS claims a retention rate about 85%, the average is about 50% but it sounds like you may have had lower than that.  Have you spoken to your PS about your concerns?  It's difficult to go through this if you're not seeing a pay off at the end.

  • lalisa
    lalisa Member Posts: 114
    edited February 2012

    I saw Dr Aronowitz ("Suzanne Sommers Doctor"- whatever...) last week in LA where I live. I consulted him about stem cell enhanced fg. He says that since the amount of fat I have for the donation is small, and since I want very small breasts the stem cell enhancement is not necessary. He also says I don't need to use the Brava. Interesting. He works at Cedars-Sinai and asked if I would be interested in going on their TV show as a kind of case study.

    Like a lot of PS in LA, he does not take insurance. So that means I pay up front and then his office helps with the paperwork to see what my insurance will cover. I know the insurance will not cover much. My insurance WILL cover the operating room fee and the anesthesia though.

    My impression from Dr A is that it is a simple procedure, and it will be easy to get the result I want, just some padding and a small mound. I liked him a lot as a person, easy to talk to, easy to relate to.

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited February 2012

    lalisa- Glad you had a great consult with Dr. Aronowitz.  Sounds like beacher did, too.  It's just too bad he's not willing to take insurance since any recon patient he will be taking is going to go through their insurance company.  

    I just heard on another thread that Blue Cross/Blue Shield is no longer covering fat grafting.  Has anyone encountered this?  I don't have them but I hope it's not a trend that is developing.  I wonder what the cost difference is between fat grafting and TE/implants or flap surgeries.  It seems it would be cheaper than doing some of the flaps.  I just hope this isn't one more thing that women are going to have to fight for. 

  • EileenKaye1
    EileenKaye1 Member Posts: 469
    edited February 2012

    Hi Kate--I have Blue Cross/Blue Shield and am hoping to be covered for fatgrafting. 

    From what location did you find out this information?  It is new to me--as I was told I will be covered for all aspects of reconstructive surgery.  Would appreciate this information source.

    Thanks, Eileen

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited February 2012

    Eileen- For some reason I didn't put the thread in my favorites so had to hunt it down.  The title of the thread is "BC/BS Officially Denied Fat Grafting" and it was posted by nolo1098 on 3/3.  She said she got a letter in the mail denying her upcoming surgery saying the fat grafting was "experimental/investigational".  Another member (chrissilini) said hers was denied, too, and she has Cigna.  I really hope this is just a coding error and not a trend that is developing.  One member said how is fat grafting any different than the DIEP that is covered which is a good point.  I will try to post a link to that thread-

    http://community.breastcancer.org/forum/44/topic/782131?page=1#idx_24 

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited February 2012

    Eileen- nolo just posted one minute ago that BC/BS is now saying they will cover the fat grafting for divots and such but not for total breast reconstruction using just fat as they still consider that experimental.

Categories