seromas and LE study

Options
2»

Comments

  • Nordy
    Nordy Member Posts: 2,106
    edited January 2011

    If your body is not able to take up the excess fluid and a seroma forms, it is usually best to get it drained. The issue with a chronic seroma is that it impedes healing and there is the propensity for the body to form a pseudo bursa there. The area is able to heal much quicker (and better) when there is not a fluid filled cavity.

  • barbe1958
    barbe1958 Member Posts: 19,757
    edited January 2011

    Nordy, that's the best explanation I've heard! Keeps with my thinking, but I really, really had to push the walk-in clinic doctor to drain mine. My surgeon wouldn't.

  • Binney4
    Binney4 Member Posts: 8,609
    edited January 2011

    Here's the StepUp-SpeakOut page about kinesio taping for LE, with some additions by LindaLou:

    http://www.stepup-speakout.org/kinsiotaping_for_lymphedema.htm

    Not sure how it applies to seromas, but all interesting, yes?

    Be well,
    Binney

  • kira66715
    kira66715 Member Posts: 4,681
    edited January 2011

    Nordy, pseudo bursa makes so much sense--mine persisted for 5 months in my axilla, and it sure felt encapsulated. Finally it was drained--big syringe of clear, yellow fluid, and it did re-collect a little, but I massaged it, and it FINALLY went away.

    I did send this information to my (former) breast surgeon--now she has no excuse to say "Oh my goodness, you have a seroma! What should we do about it!?" to anyone else...

    She thanked me "for the update". (Nah, I'm not still mad.....)

    Kira

  • Nordy
    Nordy Member Posts: 2,106
    edited January 2011

    LOL... I am the expert on seromas since I had to have the donor site for my reconstruction drained... ummm... I can't even count how many times! And then had to have 2 smaller drains put back in. On the NOLA site we call it an ass*piration!

  • Marple
    Marple Member Posts: 19,143
    edited January 2011

    Lets hope our surgeons are keeping as up to date on information about seromas as we are.  Mine said, "well, we can drain it or wait for your body to absorb the fluid".  Since it was uncomfortable I asked him to drain it.  Sigh, I still got LE though.

  • Erica3681
    Erica3681 Member Posts: 1,916
    edited January 2011

    It's interesting to speculate about whether draining seromas contributes to LE or helps prevent it. I do not thus far have lymphedema but I had a small seroma on one side for THREE years after BMX (I also had axillary web syndrome three years before my mastectomy, after a lumpectomy and SNB).

    After my BMX, when the drains were removed, I initially had a small seroma on each side. On my left side, the area spontaneously re-absorbed after about a month. The right side lingered and lingered. It wasn't painful, so my breast surgeon said I should let in re-absorb on its own. After six months, most of the fluid was gone, but a small pocket lingered. After almost three years, my PT (at my request) tried to break up scar tissue in the area, in the hope that the fluid would drain away. Instead, the seroma got bigger. I was distressed and finally decided to ask my breast surgeon to aspirate. But about that time, I started doing the Lebed exercises. Amazingly, after about a week of doing those exercises, the seroma began to disappear and, within a month, it was gone!

    It had felt very encapsulated, like what's been described here as a pseudo bursa, yet it did ultimately disappear on its own.

    Not that I'm encouraging anyone else to wait three years for fluid to dissipate (and I realize that large, painful seromas do need to be aspirated). But I now wonder whether not aspirating it might have been a good decision in my case after all.

    Given that I had axillary web syndrome and a seroma (and frozen shoulder) on my right side, I'm still very careful of my arms (especially the right side). I still do the Lebed exercises, especially if I feel I've stressed my arms in any way. As I've written here before, I find them to be great at stretching me out and making me feel more limber.

    Barbara

    p.s. On a different note, I've been wondering whether tai chi, the ancient Chinese slow martial art form, is healthful because the movements help to keep lymph channels open. The Lebed method aims to do that. If I could find a tai chi teacher where I live, I'd give it a try. Just a thought...

  • kira66715
    kira66715 Member Posts: 4,681
    edited January 2011

    Erica, I was doing Tai Chi weekly until a few months ago--the deep breathing and the slow movements are definitely helpful. And the balance work is good as well. I just got tired of the class, took a break for the summer, and then broke my hand. I found a great instructor, and will likely re-join them soon.

    I just figured out yesterday, while doing Pilates on the reformer, with a PT, that I have a touch of frozen shoulder after the cast--and while I borrowed my husband's exercises and will be in touch with the PT, I plan to do Lebed to stretch it. It's only "internal rotation, abduction"--the movement to touch your back--like to undo a bra. All other movements are great--but my deltoid had been really hurting while I was in the cast and splint.

    If it's not one thing, it's another.

    I think the seroma article shows that seroma can perpetuate inflammation and the pseudo-bursa, as Nordy described--can delay healing. Since the axillary lymphatics are delicate and have a limited time to re-join each other, I think it's the early seromas that we need to consider treating aggressively, and to limit axillary stretch so we minimze seromas and webbing--in the first 10-14 days post op.

    Yes, I have a touch of frozen shoulder--but I was in a cast for 6 weeks and a splint for 4 weeks, not moving your shoulder for 10 days is not a huge issue. Ironically, I dug out my shoulder range of motion exercises that I'd gotten from PT in anticipation of surgery and did vigourously post-op, and Jodi Winicour says she sees that all the time: women who overdo the shoulder stretches post op,early, and come in with tons of webs and whopping axillary seromas--that was me, and I did it because I was told to--I sent Jodi's slides and this abstract to my breast surgeon, in the hopes she'll read them and understand the need to treat the axilla gently.

    So, time to reconsider Tai Chi--I had done it weekly for almost 2 years and just needed a break, but we did Qi gong and stretching and the form. Good stuff.

    Kira

  • barbe1958
    barbe1958 Member Posts: 19,757
    edited January 2011

    What is Lebed?

    I didn't get exercises to do after my surgery so I didn't do any. I think that kept me from the web syndrome stuff, but the LE is surely from the seroma. Or the drain at the back as that's where it was first found....Undecided

  • BMac
    BMac Member Posts: 650
    edited January 2011

    My drains were taken out waaaay too early by the f***ing homecare nurse; day three!  That led to seromas on both sides which were drained twice.  I also had cording.  Did chemo first, 3 FEC and 3 Taxotere & Herceptin followed by surgery, then rads.

    I developed LE six months after surgery, mainly a puffy hand.  Went to the lymph clinic, learned MLD which I do daily and have always worn the sleeve and glove for exercise and flying only.  Recently flew and had to take glove off because my fingers were numb (Dec 6).  Since then I have had various degrees of swelling in the left arm and hand.  Wearing both sleeve and glove seem to make it worse!  I'm at the end of my rope and really pissed that an incompetent nurse caused this.

  • kira66715
    kira66715 Member Posts: 4,681
    edited January 2011

    Barbara,

    it's so hard not to stay mad--I wake up, two blocks away from my former breast surgeon, wrapped, and wonder if she realizes how much LE impacts me.

    No one is perfect, and she didn't intend to cause LE, but she was really into "cosmesis" so she pulled down all my axillary breast tissue to minimize the "defect" and she didn't deal with the seroma--so the concept--which was brought up at the NLN conference, of treating the tissue gently, wasn't in her plan.

    At the first office visit, she greeted me with 1)"We've never met before"--we worked together for years and had recently spoken at a conference, and 2) "Well, it is cancer--but you sure didn't give me much to work with here."--she wanted to do a mastectomy with reconstruction for cosmesis. I should have listened to the "red flags" but my daughter was getting married in 3 weeks, she was/is highly reguarded, and I felt I needed to act swiftly.

    Did she cause my LE--I'll never know, but she sure didn't treat my tissue gently and she made me decided how to deal with the seroma, and refused to help me when I developed LE.

    I sent her an article:"Shame and Humiliation in the Medical Encounter"--that my students read, and she asked me never to email her again.

    I did voice my concerns to the head of her department, and we had a 7 am meeting with him, the head med onc and her--sweating bullets--and the next time I saw her, she did something else thoughtless that upset me terribly, so I never have seen her again--but she has her office call to try and set up appointments.

    At the time, I went with the best information I had. So did you.

    Now, we have new information that should help other women in the future.

    Barbara: if the sleeve and glove together make it worse--the sleeve may be pushing fluid up into the hand--it sounds like it's time to see your LE therapist again and get re-measured, come up with a new plan and re-evaluation.

    I hate that I hang onto this anger--but I live with the consequences, and I tried hard to advocate for myself, but she really didn't listen. And, I should have gotten a second opinion, but I didn't, so it's remorse as well.

    Kira

    Barbe: Lebed is an exercise DVD developed by Sherry Lebed Davis, who is a bc survivor with LE, here's her site:

    http://www.lebedmethod.com/sherry/

  • BMac
    BMac Member Posts: 650
    edited January 2011

    Thanks Kira.  You're right about everything, especially the anger.  I was at the massage therapist the other day and she measured me for another sleeve and wrapped my hand; maybe I should try wrapping my hand.

    I have an appointment at the Lymph Clinic on Feb 8th; I'll call them Monday to see if I can get in earlier if they have a cancellation.  It's all so confusing not knowing what to do.  I think the sleeve is pushing fluid into the hand (I was wearing an older sleeve yesterday).

  • Erica3681
    Erica3681 Member Posts: 1,916
    edited January 2011

    Barbe,

    As you can see, Kira gave you the link to Lebed, above. I first heard about the exercises here, from Binney.

    I wish Sherry Lebed would come out with a new tape. I think the exercises are great, but a little variety would be terrific. There are some live classes, but none in my area.

  • kira66715
    kira66715 Member Posts: 4,681
    edited January 2011

    Erica, she did--she came out with an inexpensive DVD--I haven't seen it. I've looked at her YouTube videos, but they're too short and poorly produced for me--I did write her and ask why she doesn't wear garments on YouTube (her DVD was sponsored by Juzo) and she said it's because they're so short.

    Here's the link to it--she calls it a private class and it's $12. 

    https://www.lebedmethod.com/store/?productID=60

    Maybe you could preview it for us?

    Kira

  • Marple
    Marple Member Posts: 19,143
    edited January 2011

    Too short?  OMG, is she not aware of custom fittings?  I really need to haul out my Lebed DVD.......sigh.

    (Edit to add~due to my pea brain I misunderstood 'short' but gave myself a good chuckle this morning.)

  • barbe1958
    barbe1958 Member Posts: 19,757
    edited January 2011
    Didn't she mean the VIDEOS were too short? Undecided
  • kira66715
    kira66715 Member Posts: 4,681
    edited January 2011

    Barbe--she said she didn't need to wear her garments, because the videos were only about 5 minutes long--but she has 45 of them on YouTube and if you watched them back to back, you could do a fair amount of exercise.

    Just goes to show: here's a woman who made a DVD--based on research, sponsored by Juzo, designed to be safe and effective for women with LE, who doesn't wear her garments when she makes her own videos....

    I thought it was a bad example, that's why I wrote to her, and she was really sweet in her reply, but still doesn't wear garments in her YouTube videos....

    That said, I did the Lebed DVD today, and it really loosened up my shoulder, and felt good. The one where she's wearing her sleeve and glove.

    Kira

  • BoobsinaBox
    BoobsinaBox Member Posts: 550
    edited January 2011

    Kira,

    Thanks for including the URL to order the new Lebed DVD. I have been trying to convince myself to get one for a couple of years, and this finally did the trick for me.  I have placed my order, and I am looking forward to getting it some time next week!  Perhaps between that and my rebounder, which I don't use enough, I will get myself in better shape for doing other things.  I'm still looking for a good Tai Chi class.  That's next on my agenda.

    Dawn 

  • Erica3681
    Erica3681 Member Posts: 1,916
    edited January 2011

    Kira,

    Thanks for letting me know about the new DVD. I check the Lebed website from time to time, but haven't checked for a while, so hadn't seen this. I may give it a try. If so, I'll definitely report back! 

  • sunflowerE152
    sunflowerE152 Member Posts: 83
    edited January 2011

    I had my first drain for 3 wks.  When I finally got it out and went back 3 days later, fluid was building up, and my BS aspirated it a couple of times.  When the radiologist put my port in, fluid went all over the place, and he thought he might have cut an implant at first.

    To make a long story short, I went back to the intervention radiologist and had another drain put in and it finally worked.  My surgery was 10/12, and I got the drain out 12/20 for Christmas.

    Reading this thread makes me really glad that my BS did not let the seroma just stay there - though I was getting really tired on the drain and wanted answers.  She did not restrict my movement in any way after surgery, and the seroma did not go away until I took it really easy for a week b/c I had another surgery to get a mass on my neck taken out.

    I don't think it is a very common problem.  My BS has been practicing 20 years, and my case stumped her.  Thanks for all the info on this thread!

  • barbe1958
    barbe1958 Member Posts: 19,757
    edited January 2011

    It's a very common problem that they fail to diagnose! My surgeon didn't "believe" in LE and a lot of doctors don't know what they're looking at. Two doctors were prepared to do even MORE surgery on me to remove excess skin when in reality it was LE. How much worse would it have gotten??? Yell

    I've read various stats that up to 30% of bc patients get it. That's high.

  • kira66715
    kira66715 Member Posts: 4,681
    edited January 2011

    Dawn, I have both the original VHS tape and the DVD she put out: I really like the DVD and you can do specific chapters of it--I orignally took it out from our library to make sure I liked it. I believe I ordered it on Amazon--not reduced in price, but free shipping (if you need something else--to make it over 25$)...

    http://www.amazon.com/Healing-Through-Therapeutic-Exercise-Movement/dp/B000HWY60G/ref=pd_rhf_p_t_1

    On healthy steps it's the same price, ? shipping

    https://www.lebedmethod.com/store/?productID=3

    The new "private class" was done to be less expensive, and none of us have seen it, and I don't know if it's broken into chapters like the other DVD. Personally, I do the first chapter--lymphatic openning and then focus on arms and torso and skip the leg stuff.

    Marcia: although seromas are common, it sounds like yours was lncredibly persistent and very unusual, I hope you're feeling better now.

    Kira

  • kira66715
    kira66715 Member Posts: 4,681
    edited January 2012
  • carol57
    carol57 Member Posts: 3,567
    edited January 2012

    I'm late in reading this topic, but I want to return to the question of arm raising in the first week or so after surgery. I know the thread concerns seroma, but there was commentary on the first page about exercises for range of motion also being part of the LE risk.

    Here's a study (I'm excerpting here; this was sent to me as a Word doc, and I do not know that the link embeded in the title works, as I think a subscription is required):

    A randomised controlled trial of two programmes of shoulder exercise following axillary node dissection for invasive breast cancer  Original Research Article
    Physiotherapy, Volume 94, Issue 4, December 2008, Pages 265-273
    Jacquelyne Todd, Andy Scally, David Dodwell, Kieran Horgan, Annie Topping

    Here was the study objective;

    To compare the incidence of treatment-related complications, including lymphoedema, after two programmes of shoulder mobilisation in women with invasive breast cancer when surgical treatment included axillary lymph node dissection.

    Here's what was compared in the study and control groups:

    Arm exercises and shoulder movement restricted to below shoulder level for the first 7 days after surgery. Controls commenced an exercise programme that incorporated exercises above shoulder level within 48 hours.

    Results:  Of 109 women who completed the study 22 developed LE in their first postoperative year.  Sixteen were in the early-exercise group and 6 in the delayed exercise group. There were no statistically significant differences in shoulder movement, grip strength, or self-evaluated outcome between the two groups at one year.

    My PS needed me to keep arms low after diep, to protect the flap's blood supply. I had zero instructions from my BS on the matter (bmx with immediate recon).  So PS's instructions along the way saved me from any inappropriate arm lifting.  Got LE anyway, so clearly there are no guarantees here. My LE is mild, so certainly it's possible that not arm lifting prevented worse. That's just a guess, of course.

    Carol

  • BeckySharp
    BeckySharp Member Posts: 935
    edited January 2012

    I have two DVDs of Lebed.  I don't like one of them very much.  She is with someone else who sits in a chair the whole time.  It is later as her hair is different and what it is now on her website.  She does a dance at the end in which you have to fill two bottles with rice to shake.  It does give variety but I like the original better so I can choose which segment(s) to do.  Becky

  • toomuch
    toomuch Member Posts: 901
    edited January 2012

    I don't know how I missed this thread last year but I'm glad it was bumped. My surgeon instructed me to stretch my arms above my head to prevent frozen shoulder immediately after my AND and lumpectomy. That time is a blur. I do remember that my drain wasn't pulled until postop day #8. I definitely did overhead stretches after that. I developed cording 1 week post op and started PT with a poorly trained LE therapist 2 1/2 weels post op. I often wonder if some of the repetitive motion exercises with weights that she had me do contributed to my LE. Sigh. It wasn't until I found information on this site that I realized she/I could be making things worse.

    I didn't have a axillary seroma but I did have donor site seromas after my S-Gap, One developed inspite of keeping the drain in for 8 1/2 weeks. I guess some of us are genetically predisposed to LE. It would be nice if our surgeons could give us advice to minimize the risks though!

    Kira - "Shame and Humiliation in the Medical Enconter" I'd love to read that!

  • kira66715
    kira66715 Member Posts: 4,681
    edited January 2012

    Toomuch: Lazare was a psychiatrist at U Mass. He published it in 1987

    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3632171

    Arch Intern Med. 1987 Sep;147(9):1653-8.

    Shame and humiliation in the medical encounter.

    Abstract

    Patients are at high risk for experiencing shame and humiliation in any medical encounter. This is because they commonly perceive diseases as defects, inadequacies, or shortcomings; while the visit to the hospital and the doctor's office requires physical and psychological exposure. Patients respond to the suffering of shame and humiliation by avoiding the physician, withholding information, complaining, and suing. Physicians may also experience shame and humiliation in medical encounters resulting in their counterhumiliation of patients and dissatisfaction with medical practice. A heightened awareness of these issues can help physicians diminish the shame experience in their patients and in themselves. Twelve clinical strategies for the management of shame and humiliation in patients are discussed.

    Somehow, I don't think it's that dated.....

    Kira

    Who got NO post op instructions, and had a sheet of shouder exercises (borrowed from a PT) and was aggressively overhead stretching within a day, and got a whopper seroma and tons of AWS. Jodi Winicour said I was textbook of what she saw for bad AWS. And, when I saw the surgeon at the post op visit, seriously, she said "OMG! You have a huge seroma? What should we do about it??" And I was so tired, I'd waited hours in the room, I just asked to go home. Wrong call.

  • cider8
    cider8 Member Posts: 832
    edited January 2012

    Thanks for bumping this Kira.  I am hoping with all the info you and everyone else has shared that I can make the best decisions that allow me to avoid LE.  I will have much to talk about with my radiologist who aspirates me, my LE therapist and my PT.

    I wasn't sure about aspirating (the PS's nurse seems to leave it up to me) but this is info is leaning me toward aspirating vs leaving it be.  It is distressing but the info helps me face it instead of avoid dealing with it.  

Categories