Does anyone say no to Tamoxifen

Options
1101113151620

Comments

  • vivre
    vivre Member Posts: 2,167
    edited September 2009

    Great post Fairy! As for the oxyclean guy, didn't I read that he had drugs in  his system. Whether legal or illegal, I tend to feel drugs are bad for our bodies. Vit D is a wonderful preventative and it is great that main stream medicine is finally touting its benefits.

  • AuroraL
    AuroraL Member Posts: 33
    edited September 2009

    My first post!  So, how much green tea do I need to drink to get benefits from it?  I have said no to Tamoxifen, but it's never that easy, is it?  After 3.5 months on the drug with less and less sleep every day, and more and more bleeding, I stopped.  My onc had said I could take it or leave it, having DCIS.  So I had decided to give it a try.  Well, I stopped mid August, and can now sleep.  I had my first mammogram post lumpectomies at the beginning of September, and guess what?  Faint calcifications, and according to the letter from the radiology group, "probably benign" lolz.  Recommended mammogram in 6 months.  I have an appointment with my onc Monday to discuss the Tamoxifen, but sheesh, I can't bear the not sleeping at this stage of my cancer journey. 

  • vivre
    vivre Member Posts: 2,167
    edited September 2009

    Aurora, just taking green tea is not enough. You need to assess all of your health issues and make changes that address them. There is lots of advice on the natural girls and iodine threads. Did you know that iodine helps make our breast tissue healthy? Also, I would consider thermography. It is great for calcifications because it looks at blood flow so can detect things that mammos can't. Plus it is painless and NO more radiation. I would never have a mammo every 6 months. Check out breastcancerchoices.org for more info on both.

    As far as green tea. I drink lots of it all day long. I do not know how much we need, but I feel great drinking it. It helps  with weight control too. Also, if you resteep the green tea, it is naturally decaf, so save the morning teabag and use it in the eve.

  • AuroraL
    AuroraL Member Posts: 33
    edited September 2009

    Of course I know that you have to look at the whole picture, and I am, and I have made some adjustments to my diet/vitamin intake.  Just curious about how much tea, what kind of tea, how can you know that the green tea you buy has the antioxidants or whatever that provides benefits.  I will inquire about thermography, thanks for that tip.

  • Merilee
    Merilee Member Posts: 3,047
    edited September 2009

    4-6 cups of green tea a day is what I have read

  • cejjmom
    cejjmom Member Posts: 31
    edited September 2009

    How does one go about finding a very good GYN?

    I am concerned about other cancers and the ONC said they don't test to make sure everything is clear.  So I think I need to find an exceptional GYN.  How do I go about doing that?

  • Dawnbelle
    Dawnbelle Member Posts: 696
    edited September 2009

    Do you have reason to worry about your uterus or ovaries, cejjmom?

    I have had very heavy periods for years so, my oncologist referred me to an oncologist OB/GYN who did a D&C under general to rule out uterine issues. They were unable to biopsy my uterus under normal conditions because it is upside down. I was never suppose to get pregnant...would you like to meet my 4 kids?

    They did do a trans-vag ultrasound first & then did the D&C to be safe.

    He has agreed to remove my uterus if I get no relief after the D&C, but I will keep my ovaries. Lack of estrogen scares me more than Tamoxifen. He also will not be starting me on Tamoxifen until 8 weeks after I complete my reconstruction.

    Dawn

  • cejjmom
    cejjmom Member Posts: 31
    edited September 2009

    I'm just worried about what could happen. Ovarian cancer doesn't really have any side effects until its to late.  I don't understand not checking at least with ultrasound once in a while to make sure nothing is going on.

  • vivre
    vivre Member Posts: 2,167
    edited September 2009

    Heavy periods are an indication of hormone inbalance. I had the same problem and did nothing. Then I got bc. All I can say is get your hormones balanced and the problems will go away. Read Dr. Lee's book. It explains it all. As for finding a good doctor, just keep shopping. Ask if they understand the whole concept of hormone inbalance, if they know how to read hormone tests and if they have ever heard of Dr. Lee or Brownstien. If they say no, keep looking. Check out Dr. Vliet's website too. She has a great video that talks about this. She is an obgyn. I have not been to her site for a while but maybe she has recommendations. Oh, and Dr. Erika Swartz, and Dr. Christiane Northrup. Great doctors are there who really want to help. You just need to keep looking. But Dr. John Lee started it all.

  • Bermuda77
    Bermuda77 Member Posts: 15
    edited September 2009

    Well said Fairy 49!!

    I had a BM with TE on 9/14 and still have my 4 drains.  I've met with my breast surgeon and oncologist today to confirm the final pathology results.  I am free of breast cancer and my sentinel node is clean.  The type of cancer they found was cribriform carcinoma.  It is very unique but the kind that has good prognosis.  Not a lot of study about it.  Stage 1, 1.5 cm on the right breast but I elected to do a phophylactic mast on the left breast too.  I don't need rads or chemo.  The oncologist told me I don't need further test.  I didn't even get an oncotype score.  It didn't seem important to the oncologist.  However, he was prescribing that I take Tamoxipen for 5 years and for me to think about it.  I asked him to write a presciption and I picked up a bottle but I don't really want to take it.  I'm not comfortable with the idea because I don't see the value outweighs the risk of taking it everyday for 5 years.  I am more inclined to continuing my healthy habits consisting of regular exercise and this time really observe "clean eating" (although I've already been eating healthy but his time avoid processed food).  I want to hear your opinion.  Anybody have tips on natural, healthier and "cleaner" approach for prevention?

  • Dawnbelle
    Dawnbelle Member Posts: 696
    edited September 2009

    vivre,

    During my first visit to the OB/GYN to actually complain about the periods, they actually checked my thyroid, to see if something was wrong. I am always hyper and buzzed up...she felt it was my thyroid, tests came back fine.....this is all falling in place for me.

    I am actively searching for a doctor in my area willing to even check my hormone levels...I am aware as we age we lose progesterone.....making us moody....this is like a jigsaw puzzle....piece by piece by piece it is becoming clearer...

    I also looked at cancer in chimps....very rare......their bodies do a better job of killing the cancer cells than ours do, it is a whole cell death thing...but I find it important.

    Another thing my search keeps coming back to is vitamin D!!! And it is FREE!!

    My first oncologist, at UAB, gave my a Rx for Tamoxifen on my first visit...I never started....my new oncologist says we won't even try it until after I am done reconstruction....

    The ladies who have come before me, who questioned just doing whatever the doctors say....you have all paved a path that will make my journey easier...I don't have to follow you, but I can learn so much & it is just priceless....

    I am actually thinking out-loud....sorry ;)

  • vivre
    vivre Member Posts: 2,167
    edited September 2009

    Bermuda-head on over to the  natural girls thread. We have so many ideas, your head will spin. Just think of it like reading a book because that is how long it will take! We are a bit chatty and get off on all kinds of tangents. But I learn something new every day!

    Dawnn-Keep looking for the answers. When it feels right, you will know that your decision is the right one. And thinking out loud is great too!

  • Merilee
    Merilee Member Posts: 3,047
    edited October 2009

    interesting read on Tamoxifen

    http://www.drugs.com/pro/tamoxifen.html

    This drug may have caused a permanant hearing loss with a tiny clot in my ear.

     The FDA are  admitting that there is an  increased risk of clot and stoke from this drug in addition to cancer and liver damage

  • Member_of_the_Club
    Member_of_the_Club Member Posts: 3,646
    edited October 2009

    "admitting?"  The possibility of clots has never been a secret.  For many of us the benefit far outweighs the risks, but I don't think anyone has ever claimed there are no risks.

  • Merilee
    Merilee Member Posts: 3,047
    edited October 2009

    Did you read the article? There were details in there that I had not seen before. Such as warning signs and when to disconinue it.

     I had these signs and shared them with my ONC and she wanted me to continue using it telling me I would "adjust" to it.

    God only knows what could have happend to me.

  • Britt
    Britt Member Posts: 731
    edited October 2009

    Merilee, I agree with you.  The article you shared with us is spot-on.

    I started Tamox in the beginning of July - 20 mgs daily.  Developed nearly every s/e listed - including the debilitating depression. suicidal ideations, and weepies and in my case, agoraphoia.  I met with my med onco and she suggested cutting the dosage in half to take that daily.  So I did so.  Side effects were actually worse this time.  So now, with my med onc's blessing, I am off the Tamox.  She ordered a "menopause test" for Monday to see if I can now perhaps take Evista.  But I told her in no uncertain terms that I will not continue to take Tamox.

    And for those of you who are happy with taking your Tamox with no debiliating s/es, then that is wonderful and we are all pleased for you.  But you do not belong on this thread.  Please stop interfering with those of us who have decided not to take Tamox, or to stop taking Tamox, for our own personal reasons.  Each individual has a different reaction to this drug.  Although some of you may mean well, and that is appreciated, there are some of you who seem to be rather militant  towards us about starting or continuing to take the Tamox.  In that case, please remain on your Tamox thread.  Please leave us alone.  Our decisions  to not to take this drug or to discontinue it were prompted by a great deal of research. We are not on your thread trying to convince you to stop taking Tamox . . . so please accord us the same respect for our decisions.

    You all know who you are.  And in the spirit of tolerance and respect for each other's decisions, I am submitting this post.

    Maria

  • vivre
    vivre Member Posts: 2,167
    edited October 2009
  • Britt
    Britt Member Posts: 731
    edited October 2009

    Thank you, Vivre.  I did not mean to offend anyone, but I just wanted to point this out.

  • Merilee
    Merilee Member Posts: 3,047
    edited October 2009

    Britt...you are awesome, well said

  • eliz46
    eliz46 Member Posts: 71
    edited October 2009

    Hi everyone i have decided to join this group i have read some post . i also have just finished chemo .my onco wants me to take tomoxafen. how is everyone doing taking this....i have read some things lately that seem scary ......

  • Merilee
    Merilee Member Posts: 3,047
    edited October 2009

    Hi eliz46

    Welcome

    I think that most of us on this thread have opted out of it. You may want to look at a few past posts and read an article I posted a link to yesterday.

  • fairy49
    fairy49 Member Posts: 1,245
    edited October 2009

    awesome Britt!!!!

    L

    ox

  • Britt
    Britt Member Posts: 731
    edited October 2009

    Thanks, Merilee and Lorraine! 

  • Mandy1313
    Mandy1313 Member Posts: 1,692
    edited October 2009

    For some of us the risk of tamoxifen or an AI override the benefits.  I am one of those people and while it does give me concern not to have one or the other, it is not a safe option for me (and I was told this by an oncologist at a major medical center with whom I consulted).  So these dangerous side effects can be truly dangerous for some of us.  I would hope that those, who can take these drugs, would not denigrate the dangers and problems for those of us who cannot. 

  • debintn749
    debintn749 Member Posts: 99
    edited October 2009

    Mandy I agree. I had extensive dcis and had a right mx. Node clear. I asked several nurses about the tamox and they said they wouldnt take it if it were them. I think diligent monitoring can do the same as taking a drug that invades your whole body and changes the natural happenings in the body. For a few percentage points, this is very dangerous. None of us want it back, but why risk it going other places... I am encouraged to hear an onc told you that it was an insafe option. Did he say why?? Brainwashing is a common occurance in our society. Think about tall the vioxx users, the phen phen users etc.

  • Britt
    Britt Member Posts: 731
    edited October 2009

    Thank you, Mandy. Your post stated it all, quite lucidly and beautifully.

  • Mandy1313
    Mandy1313 Member Posts: 1,692
    edited October 2009

    Debintn, to answer your question, in my case tamox was not safe because I had blood clots many years ago from the birth control pill.  The onc said that if I'd had the clots in my early 20s, when it was unusual to get them, that now I was at an age where I might get clots anyway and that to add tamoxifen to that would simply not be safe.  He said that my chances of having a significant problem from the blood clots (probably over 30 per cent, he was not sure how much more) were much greater than a cancer recurrence because I was not on tamox (I had chemo and rads for my cancer).  And I had a similar problem with heart disease factors that would make an AI problematic.  Interestingly this was a consult. My treating onc, who had ruled out an AI, refused to consider the issue of blood clots with tamox because she did not have another option for me.   So I got a consultation with a highly respected onc because I did not want to substitute one problem for another.   Recently I went to an integrative doctor who worked out a low estrogen diet for me (basically vegan with fish and whol grains) and I am doing my best.  Hopefully I have kicked cancer's butt with the chemo, rads, and surgery!  But in my case it is not a choice but a necessity to say no to tamoxifen and the AIs.

  • Britt
    Britt Member Posts: 731
    edited October 2009

    Mandy - your low-estrogen diet sounds very interesting - I am going to discuss that with my onc soon - I am having a biopsy of my left (non-BC) breast on Thursday due to a "questionable" mammo that I had on Monday - my first follow-up one - they saw a lot of calcifications - so of course I will be seeing my onc afterwards for the results.  She is a firm believer in alternative treatments and proper nutrition.  Thank you so much for your information and your explanation re Tamox and AIs -

    Maria

  • Member_of_the_Club
    Member_of_the_Club Member Posts: 3,646
    edited October 2009

    I guess I'm the interloper you are referring to but I do think if women are considering whether or not to take tamoxifen and read this thread, that it provides balance to see that some of us have done just fine with it.

  • vivre
    vivre Member Posts: 2,167
    edited October 2009

    Member-there are plenty of threads where people can go to to talk about the wonders of tamox and arimidex and all the other drugs. This one is titled "Does anyone say NO". So we are just saying that we would like to be able to discuss this topic without having to argue with those who want to follow the standard. Some of us just cannot or do not want to be on drugs. I for one fear the side effects of taking a drug more than I fear the return of breast cancer. Actually, I do not even fear the return of breast cancer, because I have learned there is a lot I can do to prevent it that I did not do before. I am happier and healthier than before and I believe this is the best prevention for me. For those of us in this mindset, we would like to be able to learn from each other and share our experiences beyond the standard. We respect the fact that doctors have to prescribe drugs like tamox. They do not have much of a choice. If they do not follow standard protocols, they can be sued. We, however, do have a choice. There are other ways that are proven to be just as effective, but do not have millions of $$$ in studies behind them, so they are not adopted as "standard of care", yet. Someday, I believe they will be, as more and more of us have good outcomes going this route. I respect your right to choose the drugs and I am happy it is working out for you. Please respect our right to explore other avenues.

Categories