Do you want to know your prognosis?

Options

Just wondering how others handle this. What would be reasons to know or to avoid knowing.

Comments

  • HelenaJ
    HelenaJ Member Posts: 1,133
    edited July 2009

    Well I wanted to know everything about my breast cancer, stats, grades etc. so I researched and researched, doing all the tests and ask questions all the time.  I worry too much so for me knowledge is power, it calms the demons in my brain.

    My sister on the other hand did all the treatments suggested without question and has the attitude that she has done all she can so just doesn't even look at the statistics and possible prognosis for her.

    I would imagine everyone is different on this Ailenroc, be interesting to see what comes up.

  • MarieKelly
    MarieKelly Member Posts: 591
    edited July 2009

    I'm wondering why someone with tumor stats like yours would even be asking such a question?? It appears you've got an excellent prognosis from what you've listed in your bio line. Don't you realize this??  I can understand someone not wanting to know their prognosis if it's likely to be distressing news because sometimes ignorance really is bliss - but small size, grade 1, stage 1 node negative and hormone receptor positive is about as good as it gets with invasive breast cancer.  It appears that my BC was very similar to yours except I only had a single node removed during my surgery. To share some words of optimism told to me by an oncologist shortly after my diagnosis "this kind of breast cancer isn't going to kill you." 

    Some people see the glass as half full - others as half empty and when the line is drawn midway, it's understandable that the views can fall either way. But then again, there are sometimes those who see it as half empty even when the glass is nearly topped off and virtually anyone else viewing that same glass would call it full or near full.  It's all a matter of personal perspective (and sometimes personal choice).  As someone with an equally good prognosis as yours appears to be, I have to say that I certainly would and DO want to know that my prognosis is good because not knowing this very important fact might lead me to live a life unnecessarily consumed by fear. 

  • Debonthelake
    Debonthelake Member Posts: 244
    edited July 2009

    I wanted to know my prognosis because I feel that knowledge is power.  I also have a stage I BC.  But, mine was Triple negative which is a much more aggressive form of cancer.  So my treatment included chemo in addition to the lumpectomy and radiation.  My prognosis is good though perhaps not as good as yours.  I have the power to make my prognosis as good as yours by exercising vigorously on a regular basis and eating a healthy mostly vegetarian and low fat diet and keeping my weight down.  My kind of cancer responds very well to these measures and since I don't have any pills to take for follow up I view these measures as my medicine.  Like I say the research and information I have received have empowered me.  Knowledge is power.

  • donsuzbee
    donsuzbee Member Posts: 129
    edited July 2009

    Deb, like you I wanted to know everything. But at no point was I given a prognosis other than the onc said I had a 95% chance of no recur when originally diagnosed 1993. Did have RECUR 2001. I am always puzzled when persons with any kind of cancer say the doctor tells them they have xxxx amount of time to live. I don't truly believe anyone can say how long someone will live. Live each day to the fullest, take care of yourself. And you are right knowledge is power and give you extra encouragement to keep on keepin' on.

    God bless!

    Susan

  • ailenroc
    ailenroc Member Posts: 308
    edited July 2009

    Thanks to all for your feedback thus far. I am interested in hearing more.

    I've been really puzzled in the year since D-Day how women deal so differently with their cancer. Some tackling it head on, doing lots of research ... others going into denial - no value judgement there just trying to understand the different motivations. And yes, I know ... individual differences, etcetera, etcetera ...  but my question is "why the individual differences" ... what do we get out of knowing or not knowing.

    Forgive me, I'm thinking about cancer quite a bit since I got it ... and like to make sense of the experience ...  

    MarieKelly: I know my prognosis and understand it just fine. My onc has even gone so far as to say that I have a "Mickey Mouse cancer" ... after a bilateral mx that didn't feel right though ... ... besides even he admits that the prognostic stats are not as clear cut as one would like to think ... it's all large group data. However, there are no large groups with long term data that necessarily have all the particulars of my cancer or anybody's cancer ... we are just talking about likelihoods in regards to a limited number of prognostic factors, not all the factors that pertain to us ... e.g., there are no large groups that have my cancer characteristics in the combination of multifocal and true concurrent bilateral; that's pretty rare, especially in the absence of any known risk factors ... so there goes the validity of the large group data ... .prognostic data represents averages, just averages that map onto some of the common characteristics, not all ....

  • cheryl58
    cheryl58 Member Posts: 182
    edited July 2009

    Hi Ailenroc

    In the beginning, I wanted to know everything about my cancer.  I couldn't get enough information.  I researched until I couldn't read anymore because my eyes were blurry and burning.  I, too, had Stage 1, Grade 1, ILC, 0/4 nodes, ER+/PR++, HER2-.  So, again, a good prognosis.  I am now 3 years out and just turned 51 a week ago.  I had a bilateral mastectomy with no recon (fear of more surgeries), 4 AC treatments, and am now on tamoxifen for another 2-1/2 years.

    Now, at this stage, I don't want to know anything.  I have osteoporosis (onset since chemo) but barely drag myself in for my bone density tests.  I had back pain and only went for the MRI because my husband went with me.  I barely make it to the oncologist's office for my 6-month checkups.  I am scared to death of finding out any more information about my health.  I truly think my coping skills are just burned right out.  I had a lot of trauma/drama throughout my life, and I think the breast cancer, loss of my boobs, and a profound aging of my mind, body, and soul were the last straw for me.  My GYN doctor always wants to do uterine biopsies because of the tamoxifen and I have literally not gone for them.  I am sick of being sliced and diced and poked and prodded.

    So, I have a great prognosis but that is just what it is, a prognosis.....a guess at the outcome of my diagnosis.  There is no rhyme or reason to who recurs and who doesn't.  Yes, we have a "better" prognosis but we did have invasive cancer too.

  • mmm5
    mmm5 Member Posts: 1,470
    edited July 2009
    Great thread I am like Cheryl, really in control in the beginning as I just wanted my hands on everything. Got 3 opinions even had a consult with UCLA and Christina Applegates Doc. I wanted someone to tell me I would be ok. Sadly no one can tell you for sure so I just started being fearful, I had severe back pain for 3 months back in Jan and could not bring myself for scans. I tried everything and just could not get rid of it, my Onc had me believing it was lumbar mets. I finally agreed to an xray and cried through the whole thing. I think the constant waiting for test results in the beginning made me traumatized. The diagnoses, then the lymph node biopsy, then the pathology, then the scans....way too much waiting and wondering.
    In  addition I have met so many women that have had false positives that they have to wait and watch for 6 months to a year.
    I just don't want to sit around and wonder, I have convinced myself that I am going to be fine, yet I am scared to death. I really don't want to know anymore, yet I torture myself with curiousity both on this site and questions to all with all types of cancer.
  • bettysgirl
    bettysgirl Member Posts: 938
    edited July 2009

    i did alot of reading after i was dx'd and searched the net for all kinds of prognosis info....then when i asked my onco about it he gave my husband and i the answer 50-50...well hell i knew that before i ever walked in the door!!!! He went on to explain the treatment plan, doing all we could do to fight it effectivly..and giving it our best shot. He is an encourager and cutting edge...BUT you can read between the lines because he wants my port to stay in for at least two years...I knew why..hubby asked and got a sheepish look. I turned to him an told him..because it's a high chance of recurrance...we need to make two yrs.

    You just have to come to terms with your dx and know that noone knows what causes it to come back. I have a friend who had a very poor prognisis with over 20+ nodes and so far she is a over 12+ yr survivor. Another only had two pos nodes and hers came back quickly in the nodes in her neck. The bold truth is while we may want to look at the figures, they are just that, figures and doctors, scientists and research CANNOT predict our outcomes. We just have to live our lives and take things as they come.

  • HelenaJ
    HelenaJ Member Posts: 1,133
    edited July 2009

    Bettysgirl (((hugs))) - I have a triple neg friend who has to make the 2 years.

    I have been thinking a lot about this postl  This is the disease that just keeps on giving.  I am the Northern Rivers New South Wales, Australia poster girl for breast cancer.  Caught it early, bilateral mast with immed recon - no problems, no infections, Oncotype (only 14 done in Australia so far) and a score of 6.  No chemo, no radiation and my exchange surgery 2 weeks ago has been fantastic.  My new foobs look amazing.  Been on tamoxifen for just over 4 months and no side effects now other than a bit of anxiety (no hot flashes, no joint pain etc.) and had the CYPD26 test done and I am an Extensive Metaboliser - of course.  I am the text book case.  Is my future secure.  No. 

    Cheryl, mmm5 - no rhyme or reason but I love this forum - I don't want to know stats anymore although I am scared to death deep down but I want to sit and read and write to all these wonderful women.  Enough for me.

    big hugs

    Helena

  • susan_CNY
    susan_CNY Member Posts: 276
    edited July 2009

    I worried about prognosis when first diagnosed and researched endlessly, but after reading here at this site I have found that so many prove the stats wrong it is better to just use them as a tool like tumor markers, and other tests like my oncologist does. we will always worry, is our nature

  • smithlme
    smithlme Member Posts: 1,322
    edited July 2009

    I never asked my Onc for stats or my prognosis. When people have asked me, I tell them that I am alive today, and today is the only day I can live in. With my first diagnosis I had a mastectomy and DD chemo. With my second diagnosis, I chose to have another mastectomy. My first cancer was triple negative and after my second time I found out I am BRCA 2+. I'm so glad I did all that I did. I have also had a hysterectomy/oophorectomy to hopefully avoid ovarian cancer.

    Knowing I've had triple negative breast cancer and that I carry the BRCA 2 gene I have changed my lifestyle. I am in the gym 5 days a week, take Yoga classes twice a week and walk whenever I can. I have chosen to live a long healthy life by adjusting my attitude and lifestyle. For me, this is all I can control, so I'm doing all I can to stay alive. And, yes, some days I get wrapped up in the reality of cancer, but I deal with those days when they come up, not dwell on them. I have always been a "fluke" when it comes to cancer so I keep moving forward and planning my future...

    Linda

    Edited to add that I participate in The Two Sister Study, one through Kaiser and one through Dr. Susan Love. I will do whatever I can to end this friggin' disease!

  • leaf
    leaf Member Posts: 8,188
    edited April 2011

    Sure, I want to know my prognosis.  For me, numbers help me determine what choices to make. 

    I have LCIS (with about a 1:10,000 incidence for my age group), and a type of systemic scleroderma (lcSSc) , which one paper says has a 5-20:1 million incidence (I think this includes both systemic types).  So there isn't a whole lot of information because they are unusual conditions.

    I was told at a major NCI institution my risk for bc is somewhere 'between 10-60%, but a lot closer to 10%'.  I think that's a rather large range. 'They'd have to look at journals to find a more accurate number' (which of course I had done. A major reason why I got the consult. Oh well.)   The latest paper I could find on systemic scleroderma gave a mean survival of about 11 years after diagnosis for my type.  

    One paper opined that the famous modified Gail model for bc gave a prediction for an individual (no previous history of bc) as better than a coin toss - but not by much.   http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17148763

    I have a PTSD-like syndrome too, from many traumas.  That predisposes you to have increased anxiety and feelings of decreased lifespan.  

    If I had a better idea about my bc cancer risk, and my risk for lymphedema with lcSSc and BPMs, it would help me make a decision about whether or not to get BPMs (assuming I could find a surgeon to do them and my insurance would cover.)  I cannot have rads (if I got DCIS/invasive) due to the lcSSc.

    So, sure I'd like to have a better idea of my prognosis, but I don't think its going to happen.

  • baywatcher
    baywatcher Member Posts: 532
    edited July 2009

    I don't want scans or tests. I don't want to go looking for it. Been there, done that. I want to live my life in the most healthy way possible and if that doesn't work atleast I know that I have tried my best.

  • ailenroc
    ailenroc Member Posts: 308
    edited July 2009

    baywatcher: is that because you feel that the tests don't accomplish much and you are wasting your time? Or is there another reason?

    cheryl, mmm5, bettysgirl ... : It sounds like we are fatigued from all the testing, probing and prodding ... I sure feel like that at times. Have a hard time to keep up with my 3 month follow up appointments; they feel like a waste of time. But that's different than not wanting to know our prognosis or not wanting to do something about our cancer ... isn't it?

  • baywatcher
    baywatcher Member Posts: 532
    edited July 2009

    Ailenroc-

    I know that I just can't live my life with the emotional drama of finding something wrong. If I get a scan that shows something questionable, then there will be more tests. And more fear. I just decided that I don't want to live my life that way. My surgeon wanted me to have blood tests and a chest xray at a one year check up. I am not doing it. I guess I just don't want to know. Maybe I'm real weird, but I have thought about it a lot and this is my decision.

  • Roya
    Roya Member Posts: 346
    edited July 2009

    At first, when I was first told of my BC, and was very very afraid........I wanted to know everything. .............especially my prognosis.  Perhaps this was because I have a family and wanted to make certain that my affairs were in order .......just in case.  If you havent done so there's nothing worse than dying without havng made a will and provisions for ones family. 

    Knowing ahead of time gives an advantage over not knowing.  You get to prepare.  You get to do your best for the ones you love, you have time to realize that if you haven't already.........you had better get out and start finding meaning in and enjoying life.  

    Knowing your prognosis and if it is not good...........means you have time to decide whether to pull out or make your  'bucket list.' 

    Being taken by surprise, especially death by surprise, is not a pleasant surprise at all......not for anyone.   Knowing ahead of time gives the same advantages for friends and family as it does for you.  Sometimes they need time to prepare as well. 

    I also agree with Debonthelake in that knowledge is power.  Knowledge will help one to advocate for oneself.  Knowledge makes one a co partner in ones own care! 

  • lisa-e
    lisa-e Member Posts: 819
    edited July 2009

    I am another one who feels that knowledge is power.  I don't think I could make rational decisions about how to treat my breast cancer without knowing my prognosis and how a particular treatment will change it.  I decided agaist chemo due to the risk of permanent side effects and becuase it did not improve my prognosis by a significant amount. 

  • cheryl58
    cheryl58 Member Posts: 182
    edited July 2009

    Yes, the recent development of my wanting to hide my head in the sand is different from wanting to know my prognosis in the beginning.  I think my problem is that I do not truly believe my prognosis.  Mentally, I am preparing myself (if that is even possible) for it to come back...I tell myself it is not "if" it comes back but "when".  Maybe this is the pessimist in me (which more than one person has told me I am) or maybe it is my way or preparing for the worst and deep down hoping for the best.....I don't know.  So, even though I wanted to hear that I had a good prognosis, I do not believe it.  And, this way of thinking is probably based on all the experiences I have had in my life.  I always used to be happy-go-lucky, optimistic (when I was much younger), and a dreamer.  Now, I am quite the opposite.  Life has a way of beating you down, I think.

    So, in a nutshell, yes, I wanted to hear my prognosis but only because I found my cancer early and had hopes that it was a good prognosis.  What I have done with that information is probably quite the opposite of what I should be doing though.  My prognosis is based on the fact that I did everything my onc told me to do....bilateral mast, chemo, tamoxifen.  Supposedly, each of these steps made my prognosis better.  Now, I am still being told to do things, but as I tell my onc, I have become a very bad patient.

    Edited to say:  Baywatcher, I totally agree with you.  I am the exact same way.  I just don't want to know anything.  It only brings it all back when you have to have tests or walk into the doc's office.  I don't think you are weird.  I just think there are different ways of dealing and this is the way we have chosen.

  • ailenroc
    ailenroc Member Posts: 308
    edited July 2009

    Great feedback ladies. Thank you. I'm getting the impression that we have cancer burnout ... after too many doctor's visits, tests, and treatments ... filling out the same questionnaires that no one seems to read and the same forms over and over ... oh my.

    Not wanting to know the prognosis doesn't seem to be anyone's issue here ... come to think of it, the people who went completely into denial after diagnosis are probably not on this website. 

    But reflecting on your responses, I'm starting to wonder if most / all of us eventually get to the cancer / doctor / treatment / etc burnout. It occured to me that it may not even be the cancer issue per se that gets to us ... but the exhaustion of having to deal with the workload:  scheduling, visits, pricking and prodding (I can't remember the huge number of people who "checked" me in the last year ... well over 100 people fumbling around on my body; I should have counted. That is definitely a drawback of research hospitals where you don't just get your doctor but the umpteen green residents who check you out and impart their wisdom only to have it overidden by their chief. I actually have determined that I am not going to have another resident or student touch me anymore. Enough already.

    And there are all the other issues: waiting for the test, researching what it means, trying to come to a decision of what to do next based on the results, going back and forth on it, reading some more, still struggling, ...

    Another big issue may be that some of us loose our confidence in the tests, doctors, wisdom of the research. As a professional researcher I know firsthand that all research has considerable limitations. I have yet to see the first piece of research that is not to some extent contradicted by another study ... which means one has to review more studies in order to find some consistency in the outcomes ... which means more work.

    I certainly had my confidence in the usefulness of tests shaken: first there was the pathology report that was substantively revised by a second opinion pathologist ... diagnosis changed from DCIS to IDC and multifocal. Then there were the 8 tests on my left breast: mammos, biopsies, PET scan, MRI, ultrasound ... that showed a very healthy breast only to have that judgment overturned by the path report after a prophylactic mx that showed cancer.

    So my confidence in the value of all these procedures is shaken and given the feeling that time is more precious than before, I just don't want to waste my time on unproductive doctor's visits, etc.

    I really don't think it's just the cancer topic that got to me but the workload of questionable value. I happen to have a few other minor health issues to deal with, and I realize that I have become just as resistant to see my dentist or my dermatologist as my oncologist or breast surgeon or plastic surgeon. It's just all too much given the brevity of life. It's kind of hard actually to keep myself on track with necessary appointments. I keep 'forgetting' to make them.

    Anyone else burnt out?

  • swimangel72
    swimangel72 Member Posts: 1,989
    edited July 2009

    I'm getting there - almost burnt-out - but I have no choice right now but to go to my follow-up visits with my plastic surgeon after my surgery on July 10th to repair the hernia; hopefully he'll remove my drains. At this point in my life, my mind has detached emotionally from my body - I make doctor appointments like I'm just a secretary - I've become much more organized. In the past I used to "forget" to make appointments (including my yearly mammo, which I "forgot" for 3 years in a row - all because I felt healthy, wealthy and wise back then, lol! Nowadays I can't afford to be "forgetful" - at least not until my body is repaired. The benefit to being better organized and emotionally detached is that I'm more organized in helping the rest of my family make their doctor appointments - not an easy feat considering my two daughters are 5 hours away in college and my DH hates to go to the doctor. So..........in a nutshell.........even though I emotionally feel burnt out, my brain won't allow me to nuture that feeling. I don't have the luxury of good health right now to ignore my doctor appointments - and I for one am grateful that I have good enough health insurance and live in a metropolitan area where there are outstanding doctors who can help me - and that includes my oncologist who is always optimistic about my prognosis - which helps me to stay optimistic (even though I get scanxiety - and continue to find scary medical articles online about how BC can spread to mediastinal lymph nodes, etc, etc) - I try to keep things in perspective and do what I can within my own power to stay healthy - with knowledge comes power - oftentimes, I feel like putting my head in the sand, abandoning BC.org and just "move-on" but I can't.

  • bettysgirl
    bettysgirl Member Posts: 938
    edited July 2009

    i have also found it frustrating to me that people seem to think that tamoxifen is a cake walk and once you get there you are home free....(NOT)

    It is also hard to move on when eveyone i see asks how i am...where are you in your treatment...your hair i really coming back in now....you look like you feel good..when are they going to do your scans.....not hello, they dare not ask how are you? It isn't that i bring up the BC it seems that's all they have to ask me about right now....

    I know from all the literature that i am high risk recurrance...I also have little faith in research and tests...Research can be tainted by the ones who pay for it and tests are not always accurate. Most if the info I have read lately is that more oncos are relying on bloodwork to flag a problem and scans come is the bloodwork is not quite right and you are having symptoms. I don't know I tend to think more about when that if also..

    We just have to try to make the best of things and do the best we can to cope.

  • carolinachick
    carolinachick Member Posts: 387
    edited July 2009

    I just finished radiation, after having a lumpectomy and chemo earlier this year.  It felt good to look at my calendar and actually have four weeks before my next doctor appointments!  Right now I seem to be completely obsessed with my prognosis.  Since I have an aggressive form of bc (triple negative), I'm almost expecting a recurrence.  Also, I'm waiting for my BRACAnalysis to see if it's genetic.  I made it through treatment with a very positive attitude, but now it's hard not to be negative sometimes.  I'm hoping that this anxious feeling will fade with time and that I can go on with the rest of my life without the feeling that the other shoe is about to drop.

  • TammyLou
    TammyLou Member Posts: 740
    edited August 2009

    I had to laugh (or was that a derisive snort?) when I read the lady's comment...her doctor said she had "Mickey Mouse" cancer.

    I don't think that there is any cancer that I don't take seriously.

    Tammy Lou

  • TammyLou
    TammyLou Member Posts: 740
    edited August 2009

    "Do I want to know my prognosis?"

    Well...I do know my prognosis.

    And, I (eventually) learned that whatever it's going to be...it ain't today.

    tl

  • TammyLou
    TammyLou Member Posts: 740
    edited August 2009

    I think that trying to accept this "negative" information (prognosis = it ain't good) is a way for me to try to protect my future self.

    I was really traumatized by diagnosis...it's never good when the doctor does the deer in the headlights thing.  "We've never seen anything like this.  I've called around the country, talking to doctors, trying to get some advice about how to treat you."

    On the rational level, I know that there is not a way to mentally prepare myself for more breast cancer, but I seem to be determined to try.

    tl

Categories