real food

Options
Iza
Iza Member Posts: 117

I would like to start a thread for those of us who understand "healthful nutrition" as a lifestyle that embraces wholesome foods including meats, eggs and dairy from pastured, humanely raised animals, real butter, traditional foods, and eating the way our great-grandparents did before the politically correct dietocrats came to totally confuse us.

I would like to discuss sources of traditional foods and raw milk, grain soaking, and whatever.

For starts, I am about to try my hand at my first loaf of sourdough bread. Tips or advice, anyone?

«13

Comments

  • lexislove
    lexislove Member Posts: 2,645
    edited May 2009

    I have no tips but I looove Sourdough Bread. I stopped eating it for sometime because someone told me it is higher in carbs than other breads.

    Are you making your own? I look forward to hear how it went. Hopefully you can post your recipe here!

  • Iza
    Iza Member Posts: 117
    edited May 2009
    I am going to adapt the wonderful, famous "no-knead bread" recipe, which I already use often but never before with sourdough.
  • baywatcher
    baywatcher Member Posts: 532
    edited May 2009

    Iza-

    There is nothing healthful about meat, dairy and eggs. Not only are they unhealthy for us but even if they are raised humanely they are not slaughtered humanely. The only way to know that, is to raise the animals yourself and slaughter them yourself. I understand that you don't want to give up meat, eggs and dairy...it is the American diet...but not a healthful one. You can see animal cruelty if you google "meet your meat" and numerous other sites. I suggest as far as health goes, read "the china study" by t. colin campbell. It discusses the role of nutrition and cancer. Also, check out Physicians Council for Responsible Medicine. There is a lot of information that the meat and dairy industry don't want you to know.

    There is no downside to giving up meat, eggs and dairy. It is good for your health, it is kind to animals and it is good for the environment. And you would be amazed how wonderful a whole grain plant based diet is.

  • baywatcher
    baywatcher Member Posts: 532
    edited May 2009

    Iza-

    There is nothing healthful about meat, dairy and eggs. Not only are they unhealthy for us but even if they are raised humanely they are not slaughtered humanely. The only way to know that, is to raise the animals yourself and slaughter them yourself. I understand that you don't want to give up meat, eggs and dairy...it is the American diet...but not a healthful one. You can see animal cruelty if you google "meet your meat" and numerous other sites. I suggest as far as health goes, read "the china study" by t. colin campbell. It discusses the role of nutrition and cancer. Also, check out Physicians Council for Responsible Medicine. There is a lot of information that the meat and dairy industry don't want you to know.

    There is no downside to giving up meat, eggs and dairy. It is good for your health, it is kind to animals and it is good for the environment. And you would be amazed how wonderful a whole grain plant based diet is.

  • Iza
    Iza Member Posts: 117
    edited May 2009
  • fairy49
    fairy49 Member Posts: 1,245
    edited May 2009

    Baywatcher, I don't think you can use a blanket statement that meat, dairy and eggs are unhealthy, moderation is key with anything and I think Iza wanted to start and thread for people on the same page as her, if you don't agree why say anything? there are plenty of other threads that address your lifestyle, let Iza have hers! I am sure there are plenty of people who are interested and I think its awesome! I think getting back to how our great grandparents ate is a good idea, I believe they had a lower incidence of BC than now.

    Peace Out!

  • idaho
    idaho Member Posts: 1,187
    edited May 2009

    Iza- I think your thread got hi-jacked!  Oh-well, I am trying the "what my grandma ate" thing, and am feeling well.  I get my eggs from the guy down the road and I know what the chickens eat, We get a steer every year from the rancher a couple miles a way, (grass fed only), and I am trying my hand at making homemade whole grain bread, (not as easy as you'd think!).  We also use real butter.  It all started for me when I talked to the local mortician and he told me that the stuff they use in margarine is in the stuff they use to embalm you.  I decided I didn't want to be embalmed before I was dead, hence I started down this road.  Good luck to you,   Tami

  • idaho
    idaho Member Posts: 1,187
    edited May 2009

    Iza - one more thing,  I have a raiki/naturalist in town also and she explained that animals are put here for our use, and they are happy to give their lives for our nutrition, IF we remember to be thankful to them for that.  I thought it sounded weird at first, but the more I think about it, the more it makes sense.....Tami

  • Annaswe
    Annaswe Member Posts: 55
    edited May 2009

    I think you can eat meat, eggs and dairy but the animals must eat grass and not so much grain or corn (sorry, I don´t know the right word) It has to be a balance between omega 3 and omega 6.

    We eat to much omega 6 now. Wild animals and grass-feeded are better. My husband hunts so we eat meat from wild animals and birds but not so often. Butter is better, it tastes better too! We only eat organic sourdough bread, we have a local bakery where you can buy them. Iza, I´ve tried to make them myselves but sorry I can´t give you any advice ! I wish you good luck with the sourdough,

    Anna

  • apple
    apple Member Posts: 7,799
    edited May 2009

    i am a big fan of ingesting nutrients and vitamins provided by what i eat...

    simply cooking with whole grains is a great start.  i personally eat alot of nuts, fresh spinach and other vegetable, tons of fruit  and eat/take codliver oil and molasses daily.

    i eat eggs, meat and cheese in as natural a state as possible  - they are loaded with nutrients and protein which we need.  i guess i'm an omnivore.  i'm not the best gardener but i try.  We have  herbs, peppers, tomatoes, onions and greens.

    it's a little late for planting unless you start with potted plants ,and/or  live far north. but arugular is the most delish unusual salad green.. it's just spectacularly flavorful. 


    Dx 5/10/2008, IDC, 5cm, Stage IIIc, Grade 3, 4/9 nodes, ER+

  • Merilee
    Merilee Member Posts: 3,047
    edited May 2009

    I have eaten meat for years but stopped when I learned of the hormones that are in the feed. I do think that meat can be healthy, I just choose not to eat it.  I am very interested in this thread inspite of that.  I love wholesome down home food. I eat eggs milk and other dairy but I am picky and get the organic. If anyne has not tried orgnic milk you should.  I was shocked at the imporved taste over regular milk.

    Bread, yes I would like to find a good whole grain one that does not have soy flour in it.  Any suggestions?

    By the way, I love the name of this thread LOL

  • StaceyR
    StaceyR Member Posts: 136
    edited May 2009

    Recently I read the book Anti-cancer (mentioned a lot on these threads) by David Servan-Schreiber, MD, PhD, who discussed a study done examining the health of people eating eggs and meat.  The people in the study ate the same food, but the diets of the animals differed.  They were fed either primarily grass or primarily corn.  The result was a huge difference in the health of the people consuming the animal products.  I forget just now what they were using as an indicator, though.

    It's a big reason why "free-range, grass-fed" animals are the trend lately - the products are better for you.

  • Iza
    Iza Member Posts: 117
    edited May 2009

    That is exactly my point! All eggs / milk / meat are not created equal. They can be as healthful or unhealthful as the animals that produce them. Since I started eating animal products again, I stick only to food I can trace back to the farm, and to farms I trust. Not that I travel to those farms all the time (although I sometimes do), but farmers' markets have lots of stands where one can talk to the farmers and find out exactly how their animals live, what they eat, etc.

    The other big change I made was to limit processed food to close to zero. I make a lot of things from scratch: yoghurt, tomato sauce, bone broth, all kinds of soups, bread (not always), even sometimes mozzarella (and that one sure is fun). I even experimented grinding my own sprouted grains, but I do not own a grain mill and the results from using my food processor were just not usable for bread.

    Butter is an excellent example of a real food that beats the fakes from all points of view: from taste to nutritional value. If I find the time I will try to send more info on this.

    As to the name of the thread, the truth is I borrowed it from the title of Nina Planck's book, the one that first opened my eyes.

  • Idun
    Idun Member Posts: 127
    edited May 2009

    I welcome your new thread :)

    Have you planned on making the sourdough from scratch or use yeast for the process?  I made one from scratch few years back, it was a heavy duty work and you have to take care of it as your own baby.  It was mainly an experimental move, but it worked and the bread was nice, real San Fransisco style, great taste, great crust.  At that time I had access to the book Nancy Silverton's Breads from the La Brea Bakery, it was full of great ideas, I recommend it.

  • FloridaLady
    FloridaLady Member Posts: 2,155
    edited May 2009

    The key to eating like our grand parents is not just diet that had zero preservatives, dyes and hormones, very little prepackaged foods, but they also did lot more exercises to do many daily task and a whole lot LESS stress in their lives compared too most people now days have in there lifes..  We all need to research their entire approach of life style not just one part. Also remember the condition of the air they breathed, the water they drank and many other issues we do not have control over.  Another thing to remember we are treating a body that has been or is sick.  Breast cancer was one in twenty than.. not one in five now. Something bigger happened along the way....

    Flalady

  • Joytotheworld
    Joytotheworld Member Posts: 42
    edited May 2009

    Since completely changing my eating habits around, I found a wonderful cookbook that deals with exactly the sort of foods that this thread is about.  It's extremely comprehensive and the author gives lots of back-up evidence for all of her theories about "good old-fashioned" cooking and nutrition.  The book is called "Nourishing Traditions" - the cookbook that challenges politically correct nutrition and the diet dictocrats by Sally Fallon.  I heartily recommend this book - I've found it to be a fount of practical ideas and recipes.

    Joy

  • flannelette
    flannelette Member Posts: 984
    edited May 2009

    Interesting thread - thanks for starting it! I can't say much about sourdough, but for anyone making small amounts of whole grain bread, I've found the answer for me is a breadmaking machine, just to make the dough with no fuss, and then I always bake it in the oven in a wonderful old breadpan my mother had, that I never wash. I've never found a bread recipe baked in the machine that has a decent crust. bread machines seem to have gone out of favour lately but I believe with this economy are making a comeback. yes, it is expensive, energy-wise, to bake one loaf, but if you, like me, live far away from a good bakery, it's the only way to get great bread.

    For anyone trying to make whole grain bread that comes out TOO heavy - try adding some gluten flour.

  • althea
    althea Member Posts: 1,595
    edited May 2009

    Nourishing Traditions is a book I also really enjoyed last year.  I spent the summer trying a number of vegan recipes.  I couldn't fathom baking without butter or eggs and was very pleased to find suitable substitutes for both.  I never went 'wholehog vegan' lol, but at least now I would know how to put food on my table if I decided I really need to go that route. 

    I went without butter and eggs all summer last year.  I tried to be vegan once a week.  I had been steadily feeling better and better from march to july.  Then practically overnight I backslid.  It was on the anniversary of my surgery, so a big dose of ptsd was involved, but the effects have lingered, so I'm not sure what happened. 

    Then in the fall I read Nourishing Traditions plus two other books in the same month that all stated vegan diets cannot provide adequate levels of B12.   I very much like the ideology of being vegan.  And even though there are B12 shots or sublingual B12 available to us, I just can't get past the notion that if we were meant to be vegan, we wouldn't have been created in such a way that we need animal products to assimilate B12 from our diets.  

    So my quest for the 'best' diet continues and I hope lots of good information appears on this thread.  My favorite book right now is Raw Food Detox Diet by Natalia Rose.   It's not all raw food, and she allows some meat and dairy, but the emphasis is on proper food combining. 

  • Iza
    Iza Member Posts: 117
    edited May 2009

    Yes, as I said I, too, struggled for a long time with the ethics of eating animal products, until I made peace with the idea--with all the caveats I already mentioned (humanely raised, pastured). One part of what made me question the vegetarian / vegan diet is precisely my 18-year-old daughter, who has been a vegan for about two years. For the past year and a half she has also been fighting depression. I can't help but think that at least one component of her depression has to do with her diet. It breaks my heart to see her skip my bone broths and pastured eggs, because I have this hunch that if she ate just that (broth and eggs) she would feel a lot better.

    I still cannot report on my sourdough bread because it is now rising (I hope!). I plan on putting it in the oven tonight. I prepared my own sourdough (just whole wheat flour and water, "feeding" it more flour and water every day for four days) for the first time, so I still don't know if it is going to work.

    I, too, have read "Nourishing Traditions" and consider it something to tend to, but I am far from a close follower. For example, I just don't like fermented foods, which are big in Nourishing Traditions. I tried kombucha, but it is just not for me. And I have never liked pickles or sauerkraut. Too bad, because they do seem to be very good for one's health. I might give them another try.

    Flalady, I totally agree that there is more to the whole picture than just diet.

    Stacey, I am going to look for that book.

    Best,

  • EWB
    EWB Member Posts: 2,927
    edited May 2009

    what a great topic! I think this is so important. So much of this is really looking at how much fast food, pre-done meals @ food store, preservatives. artifical crap that we have been eating because it was fast, easy and convenient. Food tastes so much better when we make it ourselves, we can even make our own "frozen" meals, and pre-done meals.

    Just because we eat some meat or eggs, doesn't mean we eat ALL meat and eggs, there are so many great food out there. Moderation, and variety are important. Someone earlier mentioned how much more continiuos/ongoing stress we are dealing with, how much less activity we have today than our grandparents, how much more we are eating and drinking....How true that is!

  • cp418
    cp418 Member Posts: 7,079
    edited May 2009

    Flalady - I definitely agree with your observations. My parents are in their mid to late 80's as well as numerous relatives in mid to late 70's. Yet I am the first female in all my relatives to be diagnosed with breast cancer.  I see elderly people who are still getting around and some still driving and wonder where did I get it. In the past, the breast cancer ratio was something like 1:30 back in the 60-70's I read somewhere. 

    My soap box is that children of our generation (born 1950-60's) were adolescents when the 'Chemical Age' took off with pesticides. I hope not to offend anyone but the three largest chemical factories during WWII were in Germany - you know the history. You can do the research but at some point they were broken up and are the large world pharma companies of today who have their origins in these chemical companies.

    So our generation got the exposure to the pesicides, fertilizers and then introduction to growth hormones in food. Studies show the direct link of DDT exposure to young girls during the 1960's who later developed premenopause hormone positive breast cancer. It appears the impact of early exposure during youth to these carcinogens increases our risks later in life to develop cancer. So IMO this is why some of us have elderly family members who ate healthy (more or less what they could afford during the Depression) and are still alive today. Some in fairly decent health if they continued to take care of themselves.

    As usual I've rambled off topic but our parents and grandparents ate dairy, meat, eggs - - however, their foods were organic and NOT tampered with chemicals and hormones!!  Okay - I guess I finally got to my point!  So for me, I eat in moderation and try to eat as much organic as possible with healthy diet and exercise as top priorities.  Sorry about the hi-jack.....Great topic!

  • crazy4carrots
    crazy4carrots Member Posts: 5,324
    edited May 2009

    Yes, great topic!  Thanks for starting it, Iza.  Seems to me that when we go grocery shopping, we should be sticking to the outside and organic product aisles and never venture into the other ones except for laundry and cleaning items.

    My grandparents lived to their late 80's and 90's.  My mom, the first in her family to develop cancer, hated milk and dairy products, and had none of the risk factors for bc.  But of her four daughters, one died of leukemia, two are ovarian cancer survivors, and then there's me.  But we were exposed to pesticides, and although my sister had the BRCA test (negative) I also believe we inherited some as-yet-unidentified genetic component from our mom.  Our brother, on the other hand, is an extremely healthy 69!

    Michael Pollan's book "In Defense of Food" talks about certain populations with eating habits vastly different from ours.  Consider the Inuvut in the far north, who existed very well on fish and whale blubber (no fresh veggies up there).  Then there are certain tribes in Africa who are totally plant eaters and are thriving, while others eat nothing but meat.  Our culture and environment play an enormous part in illnesses such as cancer, diabetes and heart disease.  Perhaps we have far too much choice??

    Second piece of advice:  Stay out of fast food restaurants!!!  I cheered when I noted that a big MacDonald's restaurant in my city had closed......

    Linda

  • cp418
    cp418 Member Posts: 7,079
    edited May 2009

    Linda - Great point about the Fast Food restaurants.  I remember when some those chains opened in our area and while in college eating fast foods because it was so cheap for us students!  Then on to the job rat race and commuting and not having enough time to eat properly. Years ago when I was a Med Tech working evening shifts at the local community hospital you would not believe all the hospital personnel who were chain smokers!!  No time to eat but to take a quick smoke and cup of coffe in the side lunge room.  This is life style and what our generation grew up on.

  • havehope
    havehope Member Posts: 503
    edited May 2009

    I am recommending "Real Food - What to Eat and Why" by Nina Planck. It is not a book specific for BC diet,  but it is explaining why we need to eat all the foods and why humans should not become vegetarians:we are omnivores.

  • CrunchyPoodleMama
    CrunchyPoodleMama Member Posts: 1,220
    edited March 2010

    I am bumping this old thread because this idea of REAL FOOD has been very much on my mind lately.

    I went through a phase in the past where I tried raw veganism (only uncooked vegetables, fruits, nuts, seeds). Needless to say, eating those foods is definitely great for your health. The problem with raw veganism, though, is that the human body needs nutrients that it can only obtain from animal products (B12 for instance). Because of this, humans crave "meaty" foods with substance and texture that you just can't get from eating a raw carrot.

    So, raw vegans have developed these elaborate recipes for fake foods... fake cheese, fake bacon and eggs, even fake pizza and hamburgers... made of large quantities of ground nuts and other raw vegan foods.

    At one point one day during this raw-vegan phase, it occurred to me: If a system of eating relies heavily on fake foods, or on one type of food (i.e. nuts), something is just innately WRONG. (I've thought the same about "cooked veganism"... all the fake sausage, fake lunch meat, fake cheese, made primarily of soy product.)

    Anyway, it dawned on me that I don't want to eat FAKE foods, period. Not fake processed chemical-laden "food product" from the likes of Monsanto, and not fake foods that are supposed to look like meat or cheese.

    If your body is craving meat or cheese, wouldn't it be better to eat a small amount of the REAL THING (organic/pasture-fed/etc. of course) than to concoct some unnatural recipe to try to imitate it?

    I was shocked at myself when I first had this thought. It seems sacrilegious to think that any amount of animal products would be "okay." But after reading books like Anti-cancer, Nourishing Traditions, and The Maker's Diet, I'm amazed that I ever felt pressured to confine myself to a limiting and unhealthy diet.

    It's freeing to realize that yes, there are nutritional benefits to consuming a certain amount of organic animal products. It's not "cheating"... it's the way we were born to eat. It's wonderful that if I am craving eggs one day, I can cook up a couple of free-range eggs in a bit of pastured butterand have all the omega 3's and other nutrients in a real egg, instead of having to concoct yet another pureed nut mixture to make a fake egg. (Most raw vegans eat a LOT, and I mean a LOT, of nuts... nuts are great for you, but are that many really that good??)

    It's funny, raw vegans are all about "living foods," claiming that only fruits/vegetables/nuts/seeds are "living." But what is more alive than fermented foods... raw yogurt... cultured butter... wild sourdough... all of which have nutritional benefits that just can't be replicated in a strictly raw vegan diet??

  • RobinWendy
    RobinWendy Member Posts: 1,983
    edited March 2010

    I do like this thread... thanks for bumping it up, Crunchy.  I just wanted to clarify why sourdough bread is in keeping with healthy eating.  Whatever yeast or product that goes into the sourdough, causes the bread to be metabolized slowly in the body, which is what whole grains have to offer in general.  So, even though it looks like "white bread", it doesn't metabolize like refined grains used in the "bad" breads.  It keeps insulin from being flooded into the body at unnaturally high amounts (insulin is both necessary for survival and dangerous as a growth hormone if released into the body quickly).

    Robin 

  • Suzanne3131
    Suzanne3131 Member Posts: 3,953
    edited March 2010

    Also, there was no such thing as plastic when our grandparents were growing up.  They stored their leftovers in glass.

  • CrunchyPoodleMama
    CrunchyPoodleMama Member Posts: 1,220
    edited March 2010

    Thanks for that clarification about sourdough, Robin. I still don't eat any commercial bread products, but I do want to try my hand at baking some sourdough (I ordered cultures for sourdough, Greek yogurt and cottage cheese -- so I can make my own raw organic for my Budwig flax seed breakfast, and kombucha -- 'cuz I just plain love it!). I also want to try sprouting grains to grind into sprouted-grain flour for the bread. I will probably never eat a lot of bread, but a moderate amount of truly healthy organic, whole-grain bread (especially sourdough and/or with sprouted grains) has good healthy cancer-fighting nutrients!

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited March 2010

    Robin, that is a frequently circulated old wive's tale about different breads, sour dough or whole wheat having a better insulin response than plain white bread.

    Dr. Richard Bernstein, the famed diabetologist, has actually tested this. White breads and sour dough wheats raise glucose exactly the same.

    Thought you would want to know. This myth has been circulated for at least 30 years. Until someone actually tested it. My son is a diabetic so I follow the information--and the misinformation carefully.

  • RobinWendy
    RobinWendy Member Posts: 1,983
    edited March 2010

    Thanks Lucy.  But one question... Are you saying that whole grain breads are no better for you than breads baked with white enriched flour?  It's so widely stated all over that whole grain breads do not cause insulin to be released as fast as white breads.  Can you clarify?

    Robin 

Categories