NYTimes Magazine Cover: Our Feel-Good War on Breast Cancer

LtotheK

By the inimitable Peggy Orenstein, who recently struggled with a recurrence.  http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/28/magazine/our-feel-good-war-on-breast-cancer.html?src=dayp&_r=0

wallycat

WOW, what an amazing author!  She put into words exactly how I feel....without beating it to death.

She did neglect one thing though...she said that the rise of bx mastectomies vs. lumpectomy has risen due to two things but she neglected to mention cosmetic...those of us who were large breasted (myself) did not want to deal with schleping a fake thing as big as the real one, regardless how improved they are. THAT coupled with fear helped me play the hand I was dealt.

gpawelski

Gary Schwitzer at HealthNewsReview brought this up in his blog.

Peggy Orenstein who begins:

“I used to believe that a mammogram saved my life. I even wrote that in the pages of this magazine. It was 1996, and I had just turned 35 when my doctor sent me for an initial screening — a relatively common practice at the time — that would serve as a base line when I began annual mammograms at 40. I had no family history of breast cancer, no particular risk factors for the disease.

So when the radiologist found an odd, bicycle-spoke-like pattern on the film — not even a lump — and sent me for a biopsy, I wasn’t worried. After all, who got breast cancer at 35?

It turns out I did.”

But a few paragraphs later, she updates readers:

“Sixteen years later, my thinking has changed. As study after study revealed the limits of screening — and the dangers of overtreatment — a thought niggled at my consciousness. How much had my mammogram really mattered? Would the outcome have been the same had I bumped into the cancer on my own years later? It’s hard to argue with a good result. After all, I am alive and grateful to be here. But I’ve watched friends whose breast cancers were detected “early” die anyway. I’ve sweated out what blessedly turned out to be false alarms with many others.”

And she concludes the long piece:

“It has been four decades since the former first lady Betty Ford went public with her breast-cancer diagnosis, shattering the stigma of the disease. It has been three decades since the founding of Komen. Two decades since the introduction of the pink ribbon. Yet all that well-meaning awareness has ultimately made women less conscious of the facts: obscuring the limits of screening, conflating risk with disease, compromising our decisions about health care, celebrating “cancer survivors” who may have never required treating. And ultimately, it has come at the expense of those whose lives are most at risk.”