AMERICAN IDOL...Season 12 & The Voice...Season 4

sheila888

Elimar...i believe once the voting starts then everyone gets a fair chance......

I'm not new to the show but sometimes i can't figure out how the show goes

Like AI at the beginning they only show the good singers in full length

I think I confused you more by getting confused myself

You have a Good night Ladies

I need my tea....starving as usual......

elimar86861

Yeah, Idol blurs by some of the contestants stories sometimes, while others get a whole feature on their backstory.  Still, it seems like they do get about the same airtime for their song preps and the singing itself.  The Voice format is new to me.  I agree with Karen...couldn't even tell which ones I liked from the three battles that they rushed thru' tonight.  Will have to check out the tote board and see how all that turned out.

sheila888

http://www.tvovermind.com/american-idol/american-idol-spoilers-save-to-be-used-plus-tonights-song-spoilers-208293

This link contains the songs for tonight

but I'm not sure what they are talking about judges and us choosing the top 3

Can someone Please explain it me   

elimar86861

Well, I don't get that bit in the article that was supposed to be a "spoiler" for the May 1st show.  How can "Four Finalists Compete?"  If they do use the save tonight, won't they let two of them go next week?  That still adds up to three on May 1st.  Math was not my strong suit, so maybe I'm not adding it up right.

Not bowled over by the song choices listed for tonight. 

karen333

It sounds like they are going to take it down to the top 3 rather than 2 as in previous year's, then the voters would decide the first, second and third artist.  It is pretty confusing, that's just my guess.  I hope they are totally wrong on Janelle's performance on the songs that she chose.

mimi1964

Hey ladies I didn't chime in while ya'll were watching the Voice as I had to record them (I watch Dancing with the Stars and dvr the voice) and I have finally caught up last night.  I was really glad Blake stole the little red haired girl and sad he let the girl that sang with the accent (from the coffee shop.. darn she's really pretty and Adam stole her) go and be stolen.  I think he made a mistake on her.  I really like the Swann brothers (is that right?) they are amazeballs!!

mimi1964

http://youtu.be/9w9W3oQvIPw  ( janelle's 1st song "Dumb Blonde")

http://youtu.be/uwmGWCJOxnw (jeanelle's 2nd song "When I call your Name") 

I like both these songs especially the one by Vince Gill, but if she doesn't spin these right...

sheila888

Renee...I like them too.....

sheila888

Thank You elimar and Karen.....

I'm good in math but my question was that the Judges will have a saying until top 3 .........?????????

Don't Like.......

karen333

Loved Janelle, so sweet, so natural, so pure.

julz4

Hi idol Girlz! I'm sleepy but watching. It's good but no excitement!

sheila888

Hi Julz...I agree

julz4

Darling girl judges put the Nails away! NM upstaging again! I didn't expect that song!



This whole season the songs feel sleepy. Nothing too upbeat, getting me on my feet toe tapping, dance worthy! As much as I have watched.

sheila888

I'm waiting to jump up and down......

Still Waiting...................

Maybe I'll be waiting forever.........

julz4

Angie pulled the heart strings! This time I really saw emotion! Not some smiley trying to be emotion! She is really good but the smile that is plastered on her face through a lot of her songs gets to me at times. I think she did good tonight!

sheila888

Amber...

julz4

NM giving PRAISE to Mariah!!!!! OMG! I think I fainted!!!!!

karen333

julz, I think Mariah was ready to faint!  Amber, nope.

sheila888

JULZ

mimi1964

so Sheila did you like Amber or NOt?  me not so much! I really thought the song was too high for her and that she strained to reach the high notes and when they listen back they will find that it wasn't that good! The key was really off... Candice was not good tonight either (well I didn't like her first song) and as for Kree I liked her song, but honestly at this point I would give Angie, Janelle, Kree, Candice then Amber.  But I know they have one more song to go... thoughts?

julz4

OPPS on the "alert" blip out of Keiths mouth! He was going with "his" feeling at the moment & didn't have his brain engaged!

sheila888

Renee....NO AMBER 

So far only Angie sang it good....

mimi1964

I didn't catch what he said... darn I missed it!

sheila888

I loved Candice......♥

Second time NM called MC a Diva.......

Julz are you watching?

julz4

I agree Mimi! Only one other singer can hit Mariah caliber with singing that song. "Charice"!!! YouTube her.



That was really good! They going all over the Judges podium!!!!

karen333

Ok - I am officially cranky, picky tonight, I didn't think she was as good as that last song she sang last week, when all the red flowers or hearts were drifting down around her. That was definitely worth a SO. 

julz4

Yes but miss things as I am typing!

sheila888

Karen....That song was one of Candice's Best performance......

I post the link for you......

Janelle sang happily....not sleepy.....It was OK......

karen333

Now I want NM to go home tomorrow for saying that to Janelle, it wasn't the best song choice but she sure did have fun with it, I'd just like her to stay one more week and do a song just sitting on the stairs, the way she did once a few weeks back, it really showed her emotions and connection to the song, and her beautiful voice.

julz4

I agree with you....a little up tempo! Some blondes out in the world may take offense to the song. But herself she was I think making a statement with it!



Ok idol Girlz gotta run through my personal car wash & get shined up for work! I have about 30 minutes till I have to depart mi casa!!! Nite. Night & enjoy the end of show!!!!