AMERICAN IDOL...Season 12 & The Voice...Season 4

mimi1964

Candace was really good.... I told my hubby I don't don't know if she will win as America is too finicky, remember that past female contestants that were heavy were voted off.  It doesn't matter to me... Look at Adele and others, I really like her, but you know we aren't the only ones voting.    I'm a little behind and I actually liked Paul's song... but he may be going bye bye this week especially with the judges giving such tough criticism.  Guess we will have to wait and see.

karen333

Wonderland and sheila, I agree, I thought NM was way off base, when she doesn't like you she is vicious.  I hope to see him back, he has a place in this competition, the ending was spectacular.

Wonderland

Angie is singing like she's in a play. That song needs to be only sung the way Paul sings it.

sheila888

Angie was excellent  A+     

sheila888

Wonderland...I didn't watch just listened to her.....her voice was very sweet

I guess i have to rewind and see her in action

julz4

She always comes across to me that she is in the theater! Tonight she backed off a little.



NM sharpened her nails tonight!!!!

karen333

I like that she restrained her voice in parts, for once Jimmy was right, I think he hampers some of the contestants, like Lazaro, I think he lost all of his confidence last week and this week.  Back to Angie, I still think we are being force fed her, she did do a beautiful job though, the girls own this competition.

Wonderland

Sheila - her voice is sweet but to me, she seemed like she was performing as a character in a play. Her hair looked really good tonight.

Wonderland

Devin was good!

sheila888

You know what i'm really waiting for...

A night that songs are upbeat...where contestants are actually communicating with the audience...

Right now...they all come stand there like a Statue they sing and go.........

karen333

Devin was back tonight, hope Janelle owns the stage and shows all that she is, that would be the best ending to the show, I know I am biased.  Love the way Mariah rolls her eyes at NM's crassness.

julz4

Devin was really good!!!! No snipping NM!!!!!

Wonderland

Janelle was sweet! Looks like a goddess.

sheila888

Janelle.......♥

Such a sweet girl and a beautiful voice.........

My vote goes to her.......

mimi1964

Janelle was excellent tonight!!! and she looked great! what a great twist to a Beatles song... made it her own and it sounded like a country song

my vote goes to her too Sheila... a beautiful swan goddess!!! oh yeah

julz4

Don't get me wrong with this statement ......



Kieth should start singing "Kiss a Girl" & NM should just go on stage & plant one on Jenell!!!! Sheesh NM!!!

julz4

I liked her! Just not like NM does.....hehehehehe!!!!



Good Night Sheila, Mimi, Wonder, & Karen! Any who I missed also!!!

Wonderland

Too funny Julz!

Good night all!

karen333

Janelle should be in the top three this week, so pure, so tender, so natural.  I was thrilled by her performance!

karen333

Goodnight ladies, it is always fun watching with you.  See you tomorrow night.

sheila888

Good night All......

Those who are gonna watch VOICE

Meet us here Monday Night

♥

karen333

Sheila, see you on Monday!

sheila888

Karen.....

mimi1964

good night ladies till we meet again to discuss the one and the only american idol... or the voice LOL

sheila888

Gingerbrew

Did everyone miss that they gave Lazaro a different song to sing LAST NIGHT, Lazaro had to learn a new song in less than 24 hours probably minus run through today. Jimmy's emphasis on you have to practice was a load of crap, like he wouldn't otherwise.

I hope he stays in this week and can get normal practice time on a song suited to him.

He isn't going to the end but lets not stomp all over him while he is here American Idol.

Also I really don't see putting up Beatles tunes and expecting the singers to make them their own! This is Paul McCartney and John Lennon's works we are talking about. Many of us know every nauance of their works, what 20-25 year old is going to in any way improve on them?  

Plus in general the show was bad. 

So that is what I think tonight, p'oed I am!

Ginger 

mimi1964

I missed that Ginger... I didn't hear them say that about Lazaro's song  that is terrible! I can't understand why they would do that.  I guess there must have been many of us that missed them saying that. 

karen333

Ginger. thanks for picking up on that, I surely missed it.  It was a terrible thing to do - especially to Lazzaro.

mimi1964

It's American Idol time NOW

sheila888

Did you hear what Ryan said?

It will be a surprise elimination or something like that.