Good & Bad about Rads?

Options
FloridaLady
FloridaLady Member Posts: 2,155

If you know my history I had tx for 19 mths since being diagnosed.  I have locally aggressive bc (51 Nodes positive from 3 surgeries) no mets other than inflamm bc after completing rads.  I did a trial using a PET probe surgery this month at my third cancer center.  ( top 12 cc in the country) This doc was head of bc surgery.  He had some interesting comments about radiation.  He was not a fan of rads because of cell & blood flow damage.  In case of recurrence they do a good job of containing a small recurrence in a "hair net" but with patients like me who have local disease the rads have damage my chest wall and chemo who travels in the blood can no longer go into this area with strong enough delivery to fight a aggressive disease.

This makes me very mad!  I could see where standard protocol for bc with rads for most people... this would be great.  BUT they new early I had very aggressive bc.  I did ACT chemo before surgery and my cancer triple in size while in chemo also at surgery (1st mast. I had 25 nodes positive and it had spread to inflamm.  These were all signs of aggressive disease.  Why did I have rads knowing I would have a recurrence?  I just had 2nd mast 06/07 again 26/27 positive and they wanted to do rads.  I said no because the first mast. the inflam showed up 3 weeks after completing rads...to me that said rads didn't work for me.  The surgery I just did 09/07 I had more nodes positive taken from right (1st mast) wall and under arm.  He said it my be impossible to control this area now.

I want to know why they do not look at us as individuals and treat us that way?  I have realized with great disappointment after going to top bc centers that no one really is treated as a individual and that if you don't meet standard known tx you get as I have gotten by all three center "We don't know what to do with you".  Believe it or not I'm have doc's asking me what I would like to try next.  (they know I have really educated my self)  I know this is a good problem in some ways...but they know I have cancer and we have stayed ahead of the game.  I still work every day.  If it wasn't for my neuropathy I would be in excellent health after the past two years.  How can I be soooo close NEDS yet so far?

tx history: 7 diff chemos total 24 hits of dose dense

3 surgeries 33 rads one drug trial (bad news)

(And Yes I have been to MD Anderson Houston - the bad trial)

Living in hope

Fla Lady

Comments

  • watergirl
    watergirl Member Posts: 34
    edited September 2007

    Fla Lady,

    You have certainly been through the ringer, I hope you find something that works for you soon.  I think that doctors don't treat us like individuals because of the fear of a lawsuit.  They can hide behind their standard protocol guidelines which works for most, so they don't have alot of motivation to step outside of those and do something novel.  I also don't think many doctors do actual research, I think they implement the receipies developed by others.  You have been to the major breast cancer research centers, but at those, rather than treating your particular disease, I think they try to fit your disease into the research they are interested in and have been funded to pursue.  I wonder if at MD Anderson you had ended up in a different principle investigators office if you wouldn't of ended up with a different treatment.  Unfortunately, as you have found, I think its up to us the patients to figure out what we think will be the best treatment and then go seek that out, rather than a doctor deciding what is the best treatment and sending us there to get it.  Its an easy job for those whose breast cancer is the garden variety, but almost impossible for women whose disease is not.  I have wondered why the doctors aren't interested in discovering what about your makeup is preventing mestatsis.  Perhaps there is a protein or something that is inhibiting the spread to distant organs.  That would seem like an exciting discovery if they could pinpoint it.

  • TenderIsOurMight
    TenderIsOurMight Member Posts: 4,493
    edited March 2008

    Dear FlaLady,



    I have so been thinking of you! Wondering how your surgery went at Moffitt, and now know, reading that your surgeon excised more nodes. I'm glad to see you well enough to post.



    You're right to be mad! You've gone through so very much. I don't really know what to say about the radiation; I can understand you're frustration hearing your surgeon say it limits chemotherapy delivery to cancer cells in the chest wall and axilla. That's the problem isn't it? The retrospectoscope! You do what you can, you go along with the expert's ideas, and in your case, the cancer returned, doggone it! on the other side. And then a doctor tells you, perhaps because he or she is frustrated that this has happened to you also, that a particular treatment can limit you. So go ahead and vent. I've missed you!



    FlaLady, I posted a note to you today on Curcumin (on the Jeffntate thread you wrote on). I seem to remember you said it helped clear your skin some in the past. I wrote that it particularly seems to work in chemotherapy resistant cancer. Perhaps you might talk with your local oncologist about trying it, in a cancer fighting dosage. There are some GI problems with it, and it does cross react with other drugs, but maybe it will help again.



    I just wanted to know I have been thinking of you. It's good that you posted today.

    Tender

  • Lauralynne
    Lauralynne Member Posts: 123
    edited September 2007

    Hi Ladies-

    I had a "breakout" of skin mets in June while taking Abraxane/Avastin.  There were only a few spots at first, but then in a matter of weeks, they progressed to the opposite side of my chest (left side had original tumor plus inflammatory breast cancer last year) all over the right side of my chest.  I had bilateral mastectomy last September.  Because these skin mets are creeping all over my chest and I have noticed a rash also, I have been recommended to have radiation to the right side to try to control the skin mets.  I am willing to try it because they are growing and spreading  rapidly.  I hate that I have to have radiation AGAIN but I honestly do not know what to do at this point.  I will also be starting a trial of Alimta and hopefully that will treat me systemically.  

    I agree with you FloridaLady that since you had a recurrence so soon after completing radiation, it did not "work" for you.  I had a recurrence after 5 months.   The doctors just don't have a protocol set up to treat skin mets.  I will try radiation again because I cannot stand to see this spreading on my chest and hopefully the chemo Alimta will help the cancer on the inside.  

    Ugh!  This is all so frustrating.  FloridaLady--are your skin mets stable or growing?  

    ~Hugs

    Laura 

  • FloridaLady
    FloridaLady Member Posts: 2,155
    edited September 2007

    Hi Laura,

    My skin mets have not returned in 13 months.  See "Tenders note one up on curcumin.  I believe this help with my skin a lot. It's and herb that fights inflammtory.  See Ageless Cures.com and go under research.  I had Avastan, Carbo & Gemzar to treat disease. Took about three months to go away. I don't think this chemo was working until added the herb.  I don't blame you for trying rads again...But they are not giving you chemo?  Skin met means nodes involvement.  That means chemo usually.  Have you looked under the inflamm. part of this site.  It is a different disease than mets but it may give you some ideals.  Hope they get it right...I found rads more tiring than chemo.

    Living in Hope

    Fla

  • Lauralynne
    Lauralynne Member Posts: 123
    edited September 2007

    Hi Florida Lady-

    I will definitely look for curcumin and give it a try.  My skin mets are out of control (on my stomach and creeping toward my back).  My radiation oncologist who has 25 years experience with breast cancer said today that I am one of his biggest challenges.  Ugh.  He is going to keep radiation going to my right side twice a day but is not sure what to do with left side since it had its limit of radiation last year.  Radiation did help me get my cancer under control last summer, but I guess it did not irradicate ALL the cancer since it came back.

    I had my first chemo yesterday of Alimta (not an approved breast cancer drug) and according to a skin biopsy of the mets and a molecular profile this chemo should target them.  I will have to wait a few weeks and see if there is any change for the better.  I feel like the skin mets are spreading like wildfire...so I will try curcumin.   I was diagnosed with inflammatory breast cancer last June so I know the cancer is in my nodes and now traveling aound via lymphatic system.  So far it is only in my skin and nodes in neck, no other organs involved. (Something to be thankful for.)

    I have had Adria/Cytoxen, Taxotere, Xeloda with radiation, Avastin, Abraxane, Taxol, Sutent and now trying Alimta.  I am triple negative.  I think I may need to try Gemzar or one of the platin drugs.  I just hope I still have time to try out some other chemos before this friggen disease kills me!  

    So tiring to be fighting this for 20 months straight with no break in action.  I agree with your first post above that we as patients have to make the decisions on what we think works for us.  Leaving it up to one doctor to decide is too much like a shot in the dark.  I stay active in my treatment, we all have too.  Its just hard to make such important decisions when we are already under so much stress with the side effects of the treatment and the shock of the diagnosis.

    Thanks for listening.

    Laura 

  • FloridaLady
    FloridaLady Member Posts: 2,155
    edited September 2007

    Lauralynne,

    You sound like me... been through sooo much.  You must have soft tissue cancer like me also. That's cancer who  seem to stay locally aggressive.  Let me know how your new treatment works.  I was told again thus week that I do not have "enough" cancer to treat.  I would have to wait for three months and scan again.  I'm not cancer free and have never been since starting this trip.  Wait three months??? Scarey but I need a break but three month is a long time...

    I have found a Homopthaic doc near me who is college educated in this style of treatment.  I started a detox diet and alot of other supplements next week.  I'm hoping to repair the damage from chemo and fight some cancer cells.

    Living in hope.

    Flalady

  • TenderIsOurMight
    TenderIsOurMight Member Posts: 4,493
    edited March 2008



    Hello Lauralynne, Flalady and Watergirl and all,



    I saw FlaLady so had to read her update; sounds good to my ears, FlaLady! I know though how frustrating to not be able to just take one medication to rid it all. The homeopath sounds very interesting: just verify before you try anything too new.



    I wanted to write about the Curcumin. Lauralynne, I hope you might ask your radiation oncologist to research the new papers out on it. Curcumin has been found to be effective in undoing the effects of a protein we get after a lot of chemotherapy (much more common with multiple, different chemotherapy, not as common with initial breast cancer treatment with chemotherapy, please don't confuse this), called multi-drug resistant protein, of MDRP. This MDRP is a small molecule, and very common and unfortunately, unless it is reversed, chemotherapy has trouble working.



    I am not big on natural agents, being more a believer in medicinal agents. I stumbled upon Curcumin when I was reading generally about chemotherapy failure and resistance to it (again, not common with initial treatment regimens). Now even I knew that Turmeric contains Curcumin, and that it has been used in the middle east for years as a natural medicine. So, I looked a bit deeper and found that it has been so effective, now clinical trials are starting utilizing it.



    Curcumin has side effects: primarily GI, upset stomach, trouble if you have biliary problems. There is an encapsulated form to help bypass the stomach.



    It appears Curcumin is particularly effective in BC patients with skin mets, while they are taking a (new) chemotherapy.



    So, I just wanted to let you know about this. You have to make your own decision. Maybe you could research it a little, or , if you are too sick, I can try to help you.



    I will keep you all in my thoughts,

    Tender

    Edit addendum: Well, looking at a paper on oral absorption of Curcumin suggests it takes a lot (6 to 8 grams of 66% pure curcumin), and doesn't go far behind the gut wall: just low levels of serum curcumin were found, if much at all. So, obviously while animal studies show a benefit, they're going to have to refine their knowledge on how to get it into the bloodstream before we see any of the benefits listed above. What a shame. I'll post more if necessary after I review a paper by M.D. Anderson Hospital.T.
  • FloridaLady
    FloridaLady Member Posts: 2,155
    edited September 2007

    Hi Tender,

    You are such a good researcher.  I wanted thank you for the help you extend to all of us.  I hope you don't mind but I told Jin Jin to contact you about her sister and liver mets.  She is having trouble with research.

    I also wanted to tell you about my last doc visit to my oncologist.   My doc was so mad that I had surgery.  I never saw him so upset.  He said the surgery did not help me.  That now did not have disease to tx.  Excuse me but that why I did it.  I told him they (the doc's) left me know choice.  Moffitt also told me they put me to their tumor board and no one could think of anything new to do.  Strike three! (MDA, Moffitt, Local)  He still did not know if he could get Gleevec approved.  Also said he talked to a top BC doc about me and they said they would use Carbo or Taxotere with Gleevec but he said he could not give me those chemo because of my neuropathy.  Things don't look good...  Any way he said now I would have to wait three months to see if more would grow. While I'm waiting I'm hitting the natural way hard.  I started an all veggie fruit only diet and feel great.  I'm having my hands and feet massaged and she uses electric probe and they feel better.  Now only if I could DRIVE things would be good.   (for a while anyway)

    Living in Hope

    Fla

  • jin
    jin Member Posts: 17
    edited September 2007

    Hi, Floridalady: Thanks so much for your informaiton. My sister is knocked down by the news - mets to liver. We will wait for pet scan next week and get more detail for the situation. You have mentioned "hair net" and radiation damages cells and blood flow, would you tell me more about it? Thanks.

    How was your day? Are you still working? Take easy!!!

    Jin

  • FloridaLady
    FloridaLady Member Posts: 2,155
    edited September 2007

    Sure jin.  From what I've been told by the head of surgery here at Moffitt in Tampa.  Is if he opens back up a chest wall that has had rads and there still is cancer the cancer is in a web of damaged tissue.  The "net" slows the growth of cells because they are confused by all the damage and no good blood supply. On the other side if you need chemo to say... treat skin mets in the chest wall where it has been radiated this same damage slows blood flow that needs to be delivered at high doses to this area and it can't because of cell damaged and blood flow is reduced.

    I have been working ever since a week after my last surgery.  I have never stop working due to neuropathy.  I just had someone drive me to work and someone did my work while I explained what to do.  Now my hands and feet are doing better and I can work alone but very slow.  I found massage and using a electric stick help big time.  I also started an all veggie & fruit diet...Can't believe I have had tons of energy.

    Hope this helps.

    FlaLady

Categories