Considerations: Lumpectomy w/Rads vs. UMX vs. BMX
Comments
-
I have a question re:
From page 3, bottom right column
"Currently, it is unclear why breast-conserving therapy with radiation would demonstrate an overall survival benefit. One of the theories proposed is that improved systemic therapy options are resulting in improved control of micrometastatic disease leading to decreased distant recurrence of breast cancer. Currently, it is unclear why breast-conserving therapy with radiation would demonstrate an overall survival benefit. One of the theories proposed is that "improved systemic therapy options are resulting in improved control of micrometastatic disease leading to decreased distant recurrence of breast cancer. Therefore, improved locoregional control provided by radiation therapy with tangential axillary exposure may contribute to a survival benefit by preventing secondary dissemination of the disease".9,10 Unfortunately, because the NCDB does not gather information on recurrence, this is only theoretical as it pertains to the current study.9,10 Unfortunately, because the NCDB does not gather information on recurrence, this is only theoretical as it pertains to the current study"
"Improved systemic therapy options". My question: To my understanding radiation is not systemic. Wouldn't chemo and/or the anti-hormonal meds be the only systemic therapy options? Many thanks for any clarification.
-
What the article is saying is basically that while it is not clear exactly why BCT offers slightly better OS than a MX, it might be because of the extra local control that radiation provides.
In other words: Cancer cells left behind after any surgery (lumpectomy or mastectomy) could still disseminate and cause metastatic disease later. We know that systemic treatment (chemo and/or hormone therapy) help to eliminate undetectable microscopic metastatic disease, but these drugs are certainly not 100% effective. That is why radiation might offer an additional layer of local control beyond surgery alone, possibly accounting for the greater effectiveness of BCT over an MX. At least that is the possible explanation.
I think this is really important information for early stage patients making a surgery decision. I hope BCO will consider including this new information on their pages soon also.
-
I didn’t see that in the article, but it is exactly what I was thinking. And per my more detailed thoughts above, the problem is that lumpectomy patients are getting radiation to the nodes and mastectomy patients are not. This makes no sense to me. Looks like the study is node negative. But of course there could always be a few cells lingering. Even node positive doesn’t always get radiation which is beyond ridiculous. Nccn recommends it be “considered”. I think that needs to change. It is not consistent.
-
buttonsmachine and JRNJ, if you look at the other studies that I reference in my opening post, there are earlier studies that have reached the same conclusion. For example:
Survival Comparisons for Breast Conserving Surgery and Mastectomy Revisited: Community Experience and the Role of Radiation Therapy (June 2015) "We found no difference in overall survival by breast cancer surgery type when the effects of adjuvant radiation therapy and other covariates were eliminated using statistical methods. However, comparison of BCS plus radiation to mastectomy alone revealed a significant survival benefit with breast conserving therapy, suggesting that the prognostic differences reported here and by others may be related to use of adjuvant radiation therapy after BCS rather than to the extent of surgery itself. Given the limitations inherent in this type of study design, prospective confirmation of this finding is necessary."
-
Beesie, the sentence structure in your first point of consideration in the main post confused me. You said
However you should be aware that there is no guarantee that radiation may not be necessary even if you have a mastectomy,
Perhaps change it to
However, you should be aware that even if you have a mastectomy, radiation may be necessary...
Also, this question comes up in new posts so often, I've saved it as a favorite to make it easier to provide for them. Thanks.
-
Buttons, thank you for clarifying it for me.
-
Thank you Beesie
-
MountainMia, you mean you don't like my convoluted language? I specialize in it!
Change made, thank you!
-
Looks good!
-
I thought I would add this link to one of my favourite websites on the topic of breast cancer surgery choice:
Lumpectomy vs Mastectomy: How to Choose http://www.melbournebreastcancersurgery.com.au/lum...Here are a couple of helpful graphics from the site, but for anyone struggling with this decision, I would suggest going to site itself - there is a lot of excellent information there to help with the surgery decision.
Categories
- All Categories
- 679 Advocacy and Fund-Raising
- 289 Advocacy
- 68 I've Donated to Breastcancer.org in honor of....
- Test
- 322 Walks, Runs and Fundraising Events for Breastcancer.org
- 5.6K Community Connections
- 282 Middle Age 40-60(ish) Years Old With Breast Cancer
- 53 Australians and New Zealanders Affected by Breast Cancer
- 208 Black Women or Men With Breast Cancer
- 684 Canadians Affected by Breast Cancer
- 1.5K Caring for Someone with Breast cancer
- 455 Caring for Someone with Stage IV or Mets
- 260 High Risk of Recurrence or Second Breast Cancer
- 22 International, Non-English Speakers With Breast Cancer
- 16 Latinas/Hispanics With Breast Cancer
- 189 LGBTQA+ With Breast Cancer
- 152 May Their Memory Live On
- 85 Member Matchup & Virtual Support Meetups
- 375 Members by Location
- 291 Older Than 60 Years Old With Breast Cancer
- 177 Singles With Breast Cancer
- 869 Young With Breast Cancer
- 50.4K Connecting With Others Who Have a Similar Diagnosis
- 204 Breast Cancer with Another Diagnosis or Comorbidity
- 4K DCIS (Ductal Carcinoma In Situ)
- 79 DCIS plus HER2-positive Microinvasion
- 529 Genetic Testing
- 2.2K HER2+ (Positive) Breast Cancer
- 1.5K IBC (Inflammatory Breast Cancer)
- 3.4K IDC (Invasive Ductal Carcinoma)
- 1.5K ILC (Invasive Lobular Carcinoma)
- 999 Just Diagnosed With a Recurrence or Metastasis
- 652 LCIS (Lobular Carcinoma In Situ)
- 193 Less Common Types of Breast Cancer
- 252 Male Breast Cancer
- 86 Mixed Type Breast Cancer
- 3.1K Not Diagnosed With a Recurrence or Metastases but Concerned
- 189 Palliative Therapy/Hospice Care
- 488 Second or Third Breast Cancer
- 1.2K Stage I Breast Cancer
- 313 Stage II Breast Cancer
- 3.8K Stage III Breast Cancer
- 2.5K Triple-Negative Breast Cancer
- 13.1K Day-to-Day Matters
- 132 All things COVID-19 or coronavirus
- 87 BCO Free-Cycle: Give or Trade Items Related to Breast Cancer
- 5.9K Clinical Trials, Research News, Podcasts, and Study Results
- 86 Coping with Holidays, Special Days and Anniversaries
- 828 Employment, Insurance, and Other Financial Issues
- 101 Family and Family Planning Matters
- Family Issues for Those Who Have Breast Cancer
- 26 Furry friends
- 1.8K Humor and Games
- 1.6K Mental Health: Because Cancer Doesn't Just Affect Your Breasts
- 706 Recipe Swap for Healthy Living
- 704 Recommend Your Resources
- 171 Sex & Relationship Matters
- 9 The Political Corner
- 874 Working on Your Fitness
- 4.5K Moving On & Finding Inspiration After Breast Cancer
- 394 Bonded by Breast Cancer
- 3.1K Life After Breast Cancer
- 806 Prayers and Spiritual Support
- 285 Who or What Inspires You?
- 28.7K Not Diagnosed But Concerned
- 1K Benign Breast Conditions
- 2.3K High Risk for Breast Cancer
- 18K Not Diagnosed But Worried
- 7.4K Waiting for Test Results
- 603 Site News and Announcements
- 560 Comments, Suggestions, Feature Requests
- 39 Mod Announcements, Breastcancer.org News, Blog Entries, Podcasts
- 4 Survey, Interview and Participant Requests: Need your Help!
- 61.9K Tests, Treatments & Side Effects
- 586 Alternative Medicine
- 255 Bone Health and Bone Loss
- 11.4K Breast Reconstruction
- 7.9K Chemotherapy - Before, During, and After
- 2.7K Complementary and Holistic Medicine and Treatment
- 775 Diagnosed and Waiting for Test Results
- 7.8K Hormonal Therapy - Before, During, and After
- 50 Immunotherapy - Before, During, and After
- 7.4K Just Diagnosed
- 1.4K Living Without Reconstruction After a Mastectomy
- 5.2K Lymphedema
- 3.6K Managing Side Effects of Breast Cancer and Its Treatment
- 591 Pain
- 3.9K Radiation Therapy - Before, During, and After
- 8.4K Surgery - Before, During, and After
- 109 Welcome to Breastcancer.org
- 98 Acknowledging and honoring our Community
- 11 Info & Resources for New Patients & Members From the Team