surgery for stage one breast cancer

Options
Nawarhusna94
Nawarhusna94 Member Posts: 5

Hi and good day everyone. Im Nadia. Well i have a question, is it advisable for my mom who is a 65 year old woman to get a surgery as she was diagnosed with stage one breast cancer. I have read some and it said that need not a surgery and instead consume a B17 vitamin. Thank you=)

Comments

  • Lula73
    Lula73 Member Posts: 1,824
    edited August 2017

    Nadia- there was a recent thread on here about alternative therapy and higher risk of death compared to traditional treatments for curable cancers. I've posted the link below. I guess the question is is your mom willing to risk her life ending sooner going with a non-proven alternative treatment vs going the traditional route with proven survival rates.

    https://community.breastcancer.org/forum/121/topic...


  • ruthbru
    ruthbru Member Posts: 57,235
    edited August 2017

    She needs to have surgery.

  • GreenEyes81
    GreenEyes81 Member Posts: 389
    edited August 2017

    I am stage 1, this is how my doc explained it. Cancer is like a yard full of dandilions. A lumpectomy or mesectomy is just pulling the flowered weeds. There is no way of knowing how many seeds are deep in the grass that may or may not grow. As hard as it was, the more they looked after a mammagram (MRI), the more dandilions were found. I had a full masectomy and at a very minimum will take a pill for the next 5 years because ther is no way of knowing how many seeds there are or are not left.

    I have a family member that has been super pushy on a more natural path. For me, I am stage 1----I have a better survival rate now pulling the weeks now. Than if I try some natural method and find out 6 months from now I am now stage 2 or worse. Now I have I have an even bigger fight ahead of me.

    We all have to make the best desision for us, do it and move forward. Never look back, don't focus on the what ifs. Cancer is a one day at a time battle that can change course at any moment.

    Wish you and your mom the best, what ever she chooses, support her 100%.

  • Nawarhusna94
    Nawarhusna94 Member Posts: 5
    edited August 2017

    Thank you for your reply i will read it thoroughly. much love <3

  • Nawarhusna94
    Nawarhusna94 Member Posts: 5
    edited August 2017

    Right i think that so as a daughter. I mean by right if the surgery went well, chemotherapy might not be needed right??

  • Nawarhusna94
    Nawarhusna94 Member Posts: 5
    edited August 2017

    Thank you for your reply and wishes. I will acknowledge myself with every ways that is best for my mom. =)

  • Nawarhusna94
    Nawarhusna94 Member Posts: 5
    edited August 2017

    really? ok thats quite a reliever. Thank you =')

  • Kicks
    Kicks Member Posts: 4,131
    edited August 2017

    'You' can find all sorts of 'gobbled goop' on line that has no basis in FACT. Anyone can write whatever they want and because it's their personal agenda they can post it. Did you ever hear of the Laetrile hyp that was foisted off as the 'Cure for All Cancers' back in the '60's. And how many gullible people fell for it, went to Mexico where it did have at least some approval for use. And how many died because of it not 'curing' a thing, only allowed the cancer to progress until it was too late for tested medical TX to do anything.

    I was 63 when DXd. Without a mastectomy, after neoadjuvant Chemo to get it to where surgery was even an option if I wanted to live. Live I did and am enjoying, loving, living every day I have been blessed with to the utmost 8 yrs after DX. I do everything again (if I need to) in a heart beat.

    Suggest to your Mom to write all her question down when she thinks of them - make a second copy to ha d to her Dr so that all her questions can get an answer from her Dr(s). Another good idea is to use smart phone to record what the Dr actually says so it can be reviewed later in his/her exact words, not just what she thought the Dr said and wrote down at the time. If what is said is not understood, then keep asking til the answer is put in words that are understood.

    You didn't mention what type of BC or her ER/PR status or HER2 status. These come into play with the TX plan. Also her overall health going into whatever TX, can be a concern with the TX options. For me there were no health issues to be concerned about as my only 'isssues' were osteo arthritis in upper back (been there for yrs before DX) and osteopenia (again years and a huge family HX of it) so I was healthy going in. (Still am.)

    Unless she has issues with mental ability and is a legal Ward of the Court or an individual, her decisions are hers to make no matter what they are without undo pressure to do the wishes of another. It is hard to do but put aside your personal choices (what you THINK you would do now IF in the same position because you aren't) and truly LISTEN to what she says - not 'hear' what you want to or push your opinions her.

    Bottom line - it is HER life for HER to make HER own decisions on what TX (or even no TX) to do with information from her Drs. I was fortunate as our 31 y/o at the time Son and Hubby ( of 34 years at the time) never tried to influence me but whole heartedly supported my decisions to fight with everything that was offered. They did get together and come up with how they were going to take over all that I did so all I had to do was fight the Monster but if I wanted to do something they were handling on a daily basis, I did/could if I wanted/felt like doing but if I didn't - everything (house, meals, dogs, bunny, horses) was taken care of by them.

  • Kicks
    Kicks Member Posts: 4,131
    edited August 2017

    GreenEyes81

    I haven't heard the dandelion analogy before but it is so 'spot on'.

    Life "is a one day at a time battle that can change course at any moment. . There are no guarantees for the future in any way. So I live each day to the most that I can for that given day and the dawn will bring a new day to also live to the utmost. The past is gone and cannot be changed so put it where it belongs - in the past, not to dwell in darkness if it was not the best day. The new day is to be lived/enjoyed for 'it' will be if allowed.

    The first time I saw my Rads Dr, he kept me there for quite awile talking about 'life' which I thought was a bit 'unusual' but - -. The last time I saw him, he told me that I had taught him a lot - say what! He had thought I was in denial of being IBC and called my PA for her to get me into see a Psychiatrist ASAP because I was in 'denial'. He said that she laughed at him (the first time he had been laughed at by a PC) and told him that he was wrong - I was not in denial. She'd been my PA for a lot of years and knows me well. Like I said it was the last time I saw him that he told me about his call to my PA. There were a couple of times during rads that we did talk (other than rad issues) but I always felt that it wasn't quite the same as the first time - more like 'picking my brain' for insight. Don't know.

Categories