Are you frank with strangers about your cancer?

Options
illimae
illimae Member Posts: 5,710

I dropped my car off the other day for repairs and I'm still bald any obviously in treatment. The very well meaning receptionist began telling how great, healthy and happy I look. She then said " I know you're going to beat this and live a long and happy life".

Do you get many comments like that and do you politely thank them or do you tell them that you are stage IV and that while you're treatable, you are not curable?

It's weird and sort of uncomfortable but my instinct is to be honest and correct the misconception. But it's quicker and easier to just say thanks

Comments

  • Kandy
    Kandy Member Posts: 1,461
    edited August 2017

    I feel your pain. I have it happen all the time. Even if they know it's stage 4 doesn't seem to matter how long the conversation is. I hate to continuously talk about it. So I answer whatever as short as I can and immediately start talking to who I'm with or intently start looking interested in something at a store. I know it would be educational but I don't think everyone needs to know my business. Best of luck to

  • exbrnxgrl
    exbrnxgrl Member Posts: 12,424
    edited August 2017

    I am very open with those I know, even at work, but not with those I casually encounter. I look as I always did, so trying to explain that I have MBC is too complicated.

  • Freya244117
    Freya244117 Member Posts: 603
    edited August 2017

    I go both ways, mostly I just say thank you and let it go. Sometimes I explain about stage IV, but not very often.

  • JFL
    JFL Member Posts: 1,947
    edited August 2017

    Although I would be tempted to set them straight, I don't bother. I have the same issues closer to home. My immediate family still thinks that I am going to beat this and live a long happy life. My parents recently asked me if I would be the backup executor of their will. I wanted to laugh but just said yes. My parents and siblings (all six of them) don't seem to get that I am going to die. They tell me they can't wait until I don't have to take treatment any more, ask why am I not having more kids right now, etc. I have very directly told them why - "I will be lucky to be on treatment because that means I will be alive" and "I am not having kids because of my short life expectancy" and give them the 5-year survival percentage stats, noting that eventually, everyone with this dies. Nothing seems to sink in. If there is no hope for my family (all very bright, down to earth, practical people), what hope is there for the random person off the street?!

  • illimae
    illimae Member Posts: 5,710
    edited August 2017

    Thank you for the responses. When the lady at the repair shop said I'd be ok, I told her no, I probaby won't, that I appreciate the kind words but people in my situation usually only have a few years left Obviously, she didn't know what to say and was a bit stunned I think (she and I seemed close in age). I guess what I say will depend on my mood that day, it's not really worth the effort but I also want people to understand the seriousness of cancer, even for those of us lucky enough to have the "good cancer", which I hate to hear.

  • vancouverdeb
    vancouverdeb Member Posts: 37
    edited August 2017

    Illimae, you've hit a nerve..... My close friends are good - have adopted my 'live with passion and in the moment' attitude. JFL, I can relate - my mom keeps talking about five, ten, twenty years from now. Mom! - I don't know if I'll ever meet my grandkids! (I don't have any and won't for years). Stop with this talk!! I don't say any of that because I know this is super tough on her. What irks me is being The Tragedy - which happens when running into acquaintances or when hanging out with groups of people. (I'm 49 BTW)

    If explaining I say 'I have terminal cancer' - which everyone gets and I don't have to explain about stages. I don't want to be a downer though. It's as though I've accepted it - but the rest of the world is really struggling with the idea.

    But to answer your question - yeah, in that kind of situation I just go with "thanks".....

  • Freya244117
    Freya244117 Member Posts: 603
    edited August 2017

    "But you look so well!!" I think that and being stage IV since my mid 40's is part of the problem.

    I used to try and explain to people that stage IV means terminal, and that it didn't matter how positive I was, it was eventually going to kill me. I came to the conclusion that most just didn't want to know, and I was wasting my time.

  • bigbhome
    bigbhome Member Posts: 840
    edited August 2017

    I get the " you look so healthy", all the time! A few weeks ago, a friend told me I looked like s#%&t and I thanked her because that was how I felt at the time. People just don't want to know. It makes them uncomfortable.

    Now I just say thanks and go on.

    Hugs and prayers

    Claudia

  • illimae
    illimae Member Posts: 5,710
    edited August 2017

    Freya, I agree about age. I'm 42 and no one expects I'd have a terminal illness, I think it's assumed I'd have another 40 years.

    People assume a lot with the things they say to those they don't know.

    A cashier at KFC in the drive through felt compelled to tell me about her brother who had cancer and died a few days after getting out of the hospital and that her mom never got over it, she ended the story by telling me he was only 2 years old. I pulled into a parking spot and cried. WTF?! Thanks, that was helpful.

  • Freya244117
    Freya244117 Member Posts: 603
    edited August 2017

    It must be some ancient weird bonding ritual. You have cancer?..........Oh let me tell you about everyone I have ever heard of who died a horrible painful death from cancer. Pregnant women get the same type of thing..........Oh yes, the baby was 25 pounds and they made her have a natural birth, blah blah blah

  • 50sgirl
    50sgirl Member Posts: 2,527
    edited August 2017

    Illimae, What a horrible story for that cashier to tell you! It is hard to imagine what she was thinking.

    I usually don't tell strangers about my disease. I don't look sick and haven't experienced hair loss, so the subject seldom comes up. I have told only a handful of people outside of my family, medical. The friends who know often tell me how good I look, and I just say thank you. I think it makes them feel better. This whole stage IV think just scares some people. I have to say that the exceptions to sharing with strangers are people in my cancer center. I have found that patients in the chemo/infusion rooms often ask questions of each other, and I have not hesitated to talk to them about my disease. Some of there stories and histories are amazing, btw.

    Lynne


  • RosesToeses
    RosesToeses Member Posts: 721
    edited August 2017

    I don't always succeed but I try to look at intentions and odds of repetition and take it from there. Granted right now it's mostly based on Lymphedema sleeves since Xeloda kept my hair but looks like I'll probably need to deal with this a lot more starting in the next few weeks (done with Xeloda, moving to Gemzar and Taxol).

    For someone I won't likely see again or at least not often who tells me I'll beat this or tells me how they (or anyone they've ever heard of) beat "this" I try to take is as sort of generalized warm wishes and say thank you or I hope so.  Inwardly I may laugh at how someone should explain it to them but not me cause I'm stage iv and don't have the time, but I know they mean well.

    For some of the crackpot things my mom says (what is it with our moms?) I'll be more blunt about the facts because my real life is going to happen around her whether she wants it to or not.

    I've never had to deal with someone like the KFC guy, so I don't know how I'd handle that--I hope I'd respond with compassion and focus on how much that person seems to be hurting that they're looking for opening to let it out from *bald women in cars ordering chicken* (sheesh!)--but some days I know it would be an effort to remind myself to think that way and other days when I've just had enough I know that's even less likely to happen.

    At least we have each other to "get it" with us, thank goodness!


  • finallyoverit
    finallyoverit Member Posts: 382
    edited August 2017

    Aside from about 4 immediate family members no one knows I'm stage IV. I never told anyone, including co-workers, the first time I went through this crap.

  • artistatheart
    artistatheart Member Posts: 2,176
    edited August 2017

    I mostly keep it to myself unless someone close to me really has some genuine questions. Then I will be frank to a point. When I start feeling intruded upon I try to think of an easy exit line. Or when someone feels they have to tell me a "gloom and doom" story" I just put up the hand with a fake smile and says thank you for that. If I am not going to see strangers again I just say Thank you. Most people do not want to talk about the gritty details....Things will get more challenging soon as I will be losing my hair although I will probably "wig Out" for awhile until I get used to the new normal..

  • Lumpie
    Lumpie Member Posts: 1,650
    edited August 2017

    I think RosesToses was spot-on. This falls into the the general category of well-wishes. Hard to fault people for that ... even thought we may lack the patience for it on any given day. Many people have never known anyone with stage IV cancer. "Bless their hearts"... they are clueless. Ignorance is bliss. Let them stay that way. Others of us know stage IV'ers who have managed to hang in there for over a decade and still seem to be doing pretty well/have a decent quality of life most of the time. At a certain level of abstraction, we're all dying. Some of us just get advanced notice.

    I'd like to be able to be frank with people if I choose but I worry about issues like employment. So I think I am going to mostly keep my mouth shut.

  • Sadiesservant
    Sadiesservant Member Posts: 1,995
    edited August 2017

    In my case, it depends. I have been very open with friends, neighbors and colleagues but then it's hard to hide. I lost my hair with my first treatment after diagnosis and hate wigs so it's pretty obvious. With strangers I often nod politely unless they really annoy me.

    I had a situation with the new manager at Weight Watchers (that's another question, why I continue to weigh in religiously as a lifetime member when I've already lost more than ten pounds in the last six months). She clearly had also gone through treatment for early stage BC and kept going on and on comparing our situations, how she didn't like wigs, what she wore when it was hot, etc. She was relentless and when she finally started in with the whole bit about the fact that I just need to take care of myself and get better I kind of snapped. I stopped as I was going out the door and said "You do know that getting better is not an option for me?" She looked like I had kicked her and I know I should have had more empathy but I also felt that as a manager of a business with a largely female clientele she needed some sense knocked into her. Not my finest moment but I'm not sure I totally regret it

  • illimae
    illimae Member Posts: 5,710
    edited August 2017

    I love the replies, everyone's take on this is so genuine but different too. I was torn but I guess it'll just depend on the situation. I've always been a good, glass half full girl but at the same time, I'm the one that told other kids that there was no Santa Claus. I'm lucky that I have a gov job and wonderful supervisors and I just didn't like wearing a wig, so I never did, in a building with 500 people, everyone knew. I guess I wanted people to see the effects of treatment and that it's doable but part of me wants to remind themthat not everyone is "done" and comes out the other side cured.

  • DivineMrsM
    DivineMrsM Member Posts: 9,620
    edited August 2017

    It all depends on how you want to spend your energy. If you feel led to explain mbc, then do it. Other times, it is not worth the effort to go into details.

    I feel I have outlived statistics, so I am not going to go on to others about being terminal. Many people look at terminal as less than three years or a year to live.

    For the random people who say things like, you will beat this, I would give a half smile and simply say "Thank you for your kind words." Then I would change the subject: "What is the amount of the bill for repairs?" "Do you do oil changes?" "What does a tune up cost?" It lets people know you don't want the cancer conversation to go further.

    It is not easy for other people to comprehend the fear and anxiety that began at diagnosis in 2011 not knowing how I would respond to treatment. They are just seeing it from the six years looking back. Few or no people grasp how a stage iv diagnosis changes your perception of life, your approach to life, how it puts you on a completely different trajectory than people around you, a different trajectory than what you envisioned for your life just the day before diagnosis. I had no way to know I would have this many years with mbc. It is one of those things you cannot understand unless you have lived it.

    At this point, I take the cancer stories others tell me in stride. However, the first year I was dx, when working with a young woman who'd been diagnosed with bc a year before me, a co-worker started telling us two about a relative's hard luck cancer story. The young woman said, "Look, she (meaning me) and I, we don't want to hear these stories. They do not help us." The co-worker meant well, but the young woman didn't let her off the hook, and I admired her for it.

  • Tigwin
    Tigwin Member Posts: 275
    edited August 2017

    Hi

    I very openly with kindness, tell anyone and everyone. I have always been very open about having cancer. This is the third time for me. I find so many do not understand that there is not a cure. I just explain I will be on treatment for the rest of my life. Treatment will change as one fails me, I will have to try another it hopes it will work better and longer. We all have an expiration date, yet none of us truly know that date. I am hopeful I will have many years. Every day I wake up is a gift so I try to find some beauty in that day. On the tough days, I have my joy givers in my life that no matter how down I might get, one minute with them and I am up and forget I have cancer. These joy givers are the nieces and nephews in my life. They young ones do not even know I have cancer as there is no need for them to worry. I just fill my heart up wit her thire joy and keep moving. Findyour joy givers! They really help

  • stagefree
    stagefree Member Posts: 2,780
    edited August 2017

    depends on my mood really.. only ones with MBC can understand no matter how much detail we tell people, thanks to the wrong ads.

    The ill one does not die, the one, whose time is die

    This is a popular saying here and after saying I'm stage4, I complete the sentence with it.. a slap on many's faces.

    2 of my friends expected me to die died already, before me.

    My main issue these days is that My pregnant looking belly confuses people's minds. They ask when the baby is due.. ugh!

    I say a month generally, not to explain the MBC crap each time, weirdly most believe it! And yes, it's a boy.

    Hugs

    Ebr

  • Micmel
    Micmel Member Posts: 9,450
    edited August 2017

    Hi Mae~I am frank with people. I have realized that I break out in massive obvious heat flashes, I always have a towel in my hand, if I don't it drips down my forehead. If I explain why, usually it ends up in an extra discount , or a free rental car Day, or a community fund raiser at the local Dairy Queen. Sometimes it does work to our benefit! Love your thread! ~M~

  • Micmel
    Micmel Member Posts: 9,450
    edited October 2017

    bump!!!! Let's support Mae and tell her, are we frank or not ?? God knows I am. After what happened to me in Boston market!!! People are so stupid sometimes. They called me my DH's mother!!!! I am five years younger than him. I am 47 and he is 51 almost 52! I am just. Growing my hair back in. Jerks!! My DH went back and gave them a talking too!!! People can be so mean. My self esteem took an even harder hit from that. So annoying,so yesssssss we all should be frank So other won't feel the way I felt this weekend!

    Hugs to you Mae~ my sweet friend ~M~

  • DorothyFromKansas
    DorothyFromKansas Member Posts: 34
    edited October 2017

    For family and friends, I've told only my youngest adult DS. He visits from out of town regularly and I couldn't hide all the initial doctor/lab/scan appointments as I was one who never went to the doctor unless I thought I was dying. I swore him to secrecy and he has kept his word.

    I had to tell dental office since I was going there against MO advice. Got hit with the "think positive" crap there and was unprepared. After reading here, I am now prepared. "Peaceful acceptance not pointless positivity." Thanks to all the writers here for the lifeline. I will have no problem being frank.

  • Micmel
    Micmel Member Posts: 9,450
    edited October 2017

    i agree frank is best. That woman from now on will think twice about opening her big ole mouth. Sometimes you never understand anything unless you have walked the walk!! ~M~

    Waving hi to Mae

  • Nkb
    Nkb Member Posts: 1,436
    edited October 2017

    I've mostly kept it a secret- but, took out the garbage one night and just had a hat on (no wig) and my next door neighbor said "are you on chemo?" I didn't want to tell her, although I like her a lot- I said yes and she proceeded to tell me a horrendous story about her friend with ovarian cancer! I did not need that.

    Another time when I went in for one of my daily radiation treatments the receptionist said" here's a pink bracelet for promoting early detection" I blew up briefly- Look I've had an annual mammogram longer than you have been alive-early detection did nothing for me! Then, I regrouped and said-sorry, no thank you to the pink bracelet.

    And to the few people who know I'm almost always fine. (which is true in that moment in time) We all do what we hope works for us. People on this forum are who I discuss breast cancer with.

  • Micmel
    Micmel Member Posts: 9,450
    edited January 2018

    I went into Boston market with my DH one night while I was growing my hair back in. It was in its awkward stages of course and I didn't want to dye it so soon! A woman cashier said. “Oh isn't that nice, your mom taking you out to dinner"? I was crushed and after that no longer hungry! My DH, leaned over and said thanks Mom. And gave me a big sloppy wet kiss on my lips. Then looked at the lady and said nothing. He waited until the store was closing and went back and had a talking to the entire staff about kindness and treating customers with respect and to remember everyone has their struggles! I was humiliated, then the next day, I called my hairdresser, and got my hair done within the very next few days. I don't want that to happen again, if I can help it. People are either wAyyy. Stupid. Or just cruel. If you're not sure don't say anything ! Is the key! Biatch! ~M~ Two weeks later in the mail we got a huge sorry letter with $50 of free meals. I know that didn't. Changewhat happened, at all. But maybe it won't hapoen to someone else again! ~M~

  • wleeky1952
    wleeky1952 Member Posts: 64
    edited January 2018

    I have to chime in here with a somewhat funny story. Waiting in line at the grocery store the lady in front of me noticed my hair was growing back and then started telling me stories of people and family who also had cancer. Some survived some didn't. I am answering yes no finally she stops talking and looks at me and said at least you are not stage 5 like my Aunt Betty, it took her so quick! really people! Stage 5? I just got my groceries and left.

    Wanda

Categories