ER+ PR+ HER - longterm survival

Options
sharethehope
sharethehope Member Posts: 115

Hi,  Are any of you ER+ PR+ HER -  survivors for 5 yrs or longer?  Have your hormone pos changed what about your HER? Want to narrow down results for my specific cancer to see what has worked or not for others. Thanks April

«1

Comments

  • ABeautifulSunset
    ABeautifulSunset Member Posts: 990
    edited November 2016

    5.5 years here. Started with standard chemo, followed by faslodex and an AI. NED for 3.5 years. Then just a small progression. Switched to Ibrance and an AI. Been stable ever since. and still er and pr + and her-, as far as I know.

  • Chico
    Chico Member Posts: 196
    edited December 2016

    Hi Stefajoy. I would also be very interested to know. I have mets to spine and ribs (next scans January) however I think it would be very uplifting to hear about people who do 5+ years & what there regime involves. Onc's are great however I think the people on the forums live the life and are more willing to share the info. Hope you and everyone is enjoying the run up to the holidays. Chico x

  • Goodie16
    Goodie16 Member Posts: 446
    edited December 2016

    I'm 2 years out with ER/PR + HER2-. I also only had a solitary met to the brain. Scans below the neck show NED. Brain MRIs are currently clear.

    I was started on Tamoxifen but struggled with the SEs. I eventually had a total hyster and switched to Arimidex. So far, so good on it. Chemo was never indicated for me as my oncotype score was only 9 at the time of my original diagnosis. I've had gammaknife radiation to the surgical bed of the brain tumor (after craniotomy to remove the tumor).

    Best wishes to you.

  • Freya244117
    Freya244117 Member Posts: 603
    edited December 2016

    I'm 8 years from dx, 6.5 years with bone mets. My hormone status has not changed from ER/PR+ and HER2-. The tumour was quite large, just under 10cm, ILC/IDC, grade 3, and with 14/22 positive nodes. I am currently getting good results from Faslodex.

  • Groovywilma
    Groovywilma Member Posts: 450
    edited December 2016

    I am approaching my 6th year with bone mets. I did well on the AI's (two years on Arimidex, two years on Faslodex and a couple of others that didn't last as long). I started chemotherapy for the first time in April 2016. We haven't checked if my hormone status has changed, but my doctor suspects that after this much time, the cancer probably has figured out a way around the AI's, which is why we decided it was time for chemo. Wishing you all the best!

  • Chico
    Chico Member Posts: 196
    edited December 2016

    Thanks everyone. Let's keep this going. Chico xx

  • Chico
    Chico Member Posts: 196
    edited December 2016

    Thanks everyone. Let's keep this going. Chico xx

  • pajim
    pajim Member Posts: 2,785
    edited December 2016

    Almost four years with bone mets for me. I'm still on my first treatment, Femara and Faslodex. Worked great for two years. Third year we stalled whilst tumors grew a bit, then added Ibrance earlier this year. Markers sank but I haven't had a scan since February. Get one next month to see how things are going.

    Her2- and probably still so. We have not biopsied any bone mets. When I was diagnosed onc said it was classic presentation or ER+ (and the hormonals worked).

  • lulubee
    lulubee Member Posts: 1,493
    edited December 2016

    Nine and a half years since diagnosis, a little over 6 years since recurrence. When the bone mets first appeared, my skeleton lit up like the Milky Way-- practically every bone. I had a hyst/oophorectomy the next week, which turned up yet another surprise: a sprinkling of mets around my right ovary. The bright side is that those cells gave us something to run through pathology without digging into bone. Sure enough, still ER+PR+Her2-. As you can see in my status section below, I had a fairly good run on AI's. Femara 1.5 years, Faslodex 5 months, Afinitor+Aromasin 1.5 years. Then on to Xelodaville, where I've been for over three years. I have some new bone progression this fall, so I may be moving on to something else soon.

  • sandilee
    sandilee Member Posts: 1,843
    edited December 2016

    Yes, my bone mets were found in June of 2011, so over five years ago. They were probably there for at least a year or two before they were found, as they were so extensive. Faslodex kept everything stable for 3 1/2 years.

    I now have liver mets as well, but bones have been stable. Doxil seems to be reducing the tumors in my liver, fortunately. I feel like I'll be around a few more years, anyway. This is only my second chemo. Tumors reduced on Xeloda, also, but doc took me off of it to try a hormonal for awhile because of the side effects. Hormonals seem to have stopped working.

    So now I'm on Doxil. Only had three treatments, but it seems to be working if my CEA is any indication, and it has been pretty reliable in the past. I am hopeful, as there are quite a few treatments I haven't tried yet, and so far my mets seem to respond to chemo. I don't know if my liver mets are still ER+ as I haven't had a biopsy yet. Still may, but as long as I'm on a treatment that works, I'm ok with it.

  • DivineMrsM
    DivineMrsM Member Posts: 9,620
    edited December 2016

    Six years today and stable. I posted about it here if you'd like to read it:

    Medicine, Miracles and MyThoughts-Six Years: https://community.breastcancer.org/forum/8/topics/...


  • sharethehope
    sharethehope Member Posts: 115
    edited February 2017

    thank you for your hope infused replys.

  • barbe1958
    barbe1958 Member Posts: 19,757
    edited December 2016

    share! You made a chemo pun!

    I'm 8 years from original diagnosis and one year from stage iv. Not NED a this time as we're watching a single node of one cm that appeared in my lung in less than 6 months (from CT to CT). I can't get an MRI due to a pacemaker so I have to wait until my next scan in Feb to see if there are more of if it's gone.

  • Chico
    Chico Member Posts: 196
    edited December 2016

    Hope we can keep this thread going and gather more people. BTW I was 12 years from original dx however as I have oestoarthritis and lots of back pain the bone mets in my spine and ribs may have been around for a while. I am on 3rd cycle of a trial in the UK using Ibrance and Letrozole with Denosumab thrown into the mix. My first scan is due in January. On a trial I am not allowed to do many things such as take herbs or have acupuncture etc however I would really like to gain knowledge from people who have managed to outdo the odds and are willing to share that information. So many of the threads are great and Bestbird and Zarovka etc share great information but it is difficult to go back through all the threads to find info so I thought perhaps keeping this thread going may just concentrate on the MBC Long-timers and give us newbies hope and ideas. Merry Christmas everyone and wishing you all a Happy 2017. Chico xx

  • Heidihill
    Heidihill Member Posts: 5,476
    edited December 2016

    I'd like to share here as this is my 10th Christmas since diagnosis of stage 4 de novo. I've stayed NED for almost nine years and that is I suppose the circular secret to my longevity. I do think NED is in many ways just a form of stable, but not visible to scanning. Maybe there are folks whose cancers are in a deeper sleep than others or unable to multiply for some reason or unable to develop resistance to treatment. I could be in any one of those groups. I believe bone, gut and liver health are important for us in addition to estrogen deprivation for ER+ disease to prevent recurrence/progression.

    On the latter, I've had Femara, Arimidex and Tamoxifen (after chemo, radiation and surgery), switching due to side effects. At the time, Afinitor and Ibrance were not yet available. For my bones and initial bone mets, I had 5 years of Zometa. I also started exercising daily, including lifting weights, to supplement the Zometa. I was worried that Zometa prevents bone breakdown but does not by itself build new bone, unlike exercise, and important for immune health. Exercise also regulates estrogen levels, as in women athletes who stop having periods. Some more recent evidence of that here: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/05/130507061143.htm.

    Also as a way of regulating estrogen I started eating 7-10 portions of fruits and vegetables daily.

    https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/09/140911135316.htm

    Which helped me lose some weight, another risk factor which I forgot to mention. Didn't have much room for sweets and refined carbs with all that bulk.

    At some point I tried intermittent fasting for a whole year except for vacations. I starved myself from 7 pm to 12 pm. I did improve my metabolic health, lowering my blood glucose levels as a result. I hoped to starve cancer cells and maybe some did get hit as this study suggests:

    https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/12/161221111246.htm

    Tumor suppressors seem to accumulate in mouse liver as a result of food withdrawal.

    Together with a having a good diet, I also try to get 7-8 hours sleep and limit alcohol intake. From the NY Times:

    short-term changes in either sleep or diet can affect the liver’s ability to contribute to fat digestion. Chronic disturbances... may lead to fat accumulation in the liver, which can cause “many different problems: fatty liver disease, diabetes, obesity, heart disease and even cancer.” ( http://www.nytimes.com/2016/12/22/health/your-liver-doesnt-know-its-the-holidays.html )

    I'm not very good during the holidays but I do try to reset my circadian clock by going for long walks in the morning.


  • Linda11111111
    Linda11111111 Member Posts: 49
    edited December 2016

    I'm 16 years original Stage 2 diagnosis and 6 years since Stage 4. Aside from lots of doctor appointments and more aches and pains, my life has pretty much stayed the same. Very thankful I can still do pretty much whatever I want. Wish you all a very Merry Christmas.

  • DivineMrsM
    DivineMrsM Member Posts: 9,620
    edited December 2016

    I would like to say that a thread like this always inspires me. Heidi, knowing you have been NEd for over nine years is especially nice to hear. Early this year I had to see a doctor as I was applying for disability payments through a state employee system. This oncologist, a real oddball, told me no way i had stage iv bc, it was probably stage 2 and arthritis because there had been no progression. He said stage iv have a life span of five years or less. A real gem of a doctor, right? He said if I had been stage iv and am still living I an outlier. He said it like it was too incredible and looked at me like I wasn't special enough or deserving enough to have an exceptional response to treatment. So I was turned down for disability payments even tho Social Security had determined I was disabled. I got a lawyer and am in the appeals process.

    Sorry to hijack the thread. I am very happy to hear of others who have been around awhile and wish you many, many more years of stability. Merry Christmas to all who celebrate it, and happy everything else toeveryone else.

  • SusanR
    SusanR Member Posts: 598
    edited December 2016

    14 years since original diagnosis, 8 years since Stage IV with bone mets in hip.  Femara and Zometa kept me stable for 3 years and then more bone mets progression in 2011.  5 years stable on Fasolodex before progression in bones in November.  I am now on Zometa, Femara and Ibrance and just finished my 1st cylce. 

    When originally diagnosed I was ER+ PR+ HER-.  Bone mets biopsy on hip mets in 2008 showed change to ER+ PR- HER- 

  • Chico
    Chico Member Posts: 196
    edited December 2016

    Thank you Ladies for posting your replies and sharing tips, advice and research. Just knowing you are exceeding expectations is so very uplifting and helpful. Please keep giving advice. I am a sugarholic and know from this forum that I need to cut this back however as a very long term lacto vegetarian I dread also cutting chocolate and cheese from my diet. On the other hand I have a wonderful life that I wish to continue enjoying for as long as possible so 2017 will see me cutting back and joining the fitness girls. Happy 2017 to you all. Chico xx

  • zarovka
    zarovka Member Posts: 3,607
    edited December 2016

    Chico The Stage IV Fitness Girls are taking a bit of a break but we look forward to having you join us in 2017.

    And life without chocolate is not worth living. I prefer to add things (like a salad for one meal every day) rather than restrict.

    >Z<

  • Jill45
    Jill45 Member Posts: 71
    edited December 2016

    7.5 years since original Stage IV diagnosis with mets to bones and liver. Was on Tamoxifen for 6 months then switched to Femera which I have been on for last 7 years. Cancer has been stable since I have been on Femera and Tumor markers are all normal. Have not had any tests to confirm whether the cancer make up has changed since original diagnosis.

    Was also on Xygeva up until Jan 2016 when I fell on some ice and fractured my Femur they feel that the Xygeva could have been a reason that the bone fractured so easily. I stay very active and exercise on a regular basis.



  • ShetlandPony
    ShetlandPony Member Posts: 4,924
    edited December 2016

    Jill, may I ask if you had both liver and bone mets with the original stage iv diagnosis in 2009?

  • Ronnie3001
    Ronnie3001 Member Posts: 169
    edited January 2017
    Thank you everyone for the post I was diagnosed 8/16 with Bone METS and thought life was ending. These posts are encouraging and I truly appreciate the information...
  • Cure-ious
    Cure-ious Member Posts: 2,626
    edited January 2018

    <Bump!>

    How are all our long-term survivors doing?

    Someone suggested all long-term survivors tend to be Her2+ ? Any ER+ out there?

  • tinyturtle
    tinyturtle Member Posts: 34
    edited January 2018

    Cure -ious -- I think you have it reversed. From what I understood HER2 is more aggressive and has less treatment options then hormone receptor positive. But I am very, very new to all this and may be wrong.

    p.s. I'm planning on being a long term survivor -- but I'm only 6 months in :)

  • Partyoffive
    Partyoffive Member Posts: 188
    edited February 2018

    cure-ious: I’m almost five years out from my stage 4 diagnosis-still on my first treatment(tamoxifen) and er+pr+her2-. Best of luck!


  • Cure-ious
    Cure-ious Member Posts: 2,626
    edited February 2018

    Whoop! Tamoxifen for five years!! Congratulations Party, and just keep trundling on tiny turtle, you can win this race! :- )

  • ABeautifulSunset
    ABeautifulSunset Member Posts: 990
    edited February 2018

    some of the promising new treatments seem to only be beneficial for HER +, but they really need it because it used to not have many treatments and it can be aggressive (well, they all can). Hormone positive HER- still have lots and lots of options.

    I’m ER and PR positive, and HER2 negative. I’m at 6.5 years and still going.

  • Heidihill
    Heidihill Member Posts: 5,476
    edited February 2018

    Cure-ious, I'm doing well except have managed to gain several kilos since Thanksgiving, when I visited relatives in the US.  Then more eating celebrating my 10th Christmas since MBC diagnosis.

    I did cross off another item on my bucket list, which was to ski in the Matterhorn area.

    I am ER+

  • lulubee
    lulubee Member Posts: 1,493
    edited February 2018

    Still here! This coming summer will mark 11 years since diagnosis, and 8 years at Stage IV. Been on weekly Taxol for a year now, in a clinical trial. I'm in the Taxol-only arm of the trial. I'm always tired but hey, I'm still here. Quarterly scans for the trial next week.

Categories