How many biopsies, surgeries and years?

Options
2»

Comments

  • MsVeryDenseBreasts
    MsVeryDenseBreasts Member Posts: 100
    edited October 2015

    Res112, I also opted for PBMX. I'm recovering from surgery now. I was on the frequent flyer close surveillance program for 7.5 yrs and after 5 core biopsies and 2 excisions with LCIS findings every time + extremely dense breast tissue. I thought I was managing the anxiety quite well until my last mammo. At that appt they nearly let me out the door and sent me on my way for another 6 mos, but at the last minute they pulled me back in for more images and then did an abrupt turnabout concluding that I needed 2-3 areas biopsied. That really gave me pause and concern about what could potentially be missed and the fact that at least in my case, none of the diagnostic methods are especially infallible. The dense breast tissue adds a special level of extra concern for me. I have had ultrasound, mammo and an MRI just this calendar year. For many reasons the SERM and AI drugs were not a good choice for me. I began to feel like I was living with a loaded gun and sure did not want to run the risk of waiting just one 6 mos checkup interval too long only too discover I had something invasive. Another thing that factored into my reasoning leading to PBMX is that I had felt okay for years biding time to see what new studies would turn up re: LCIS...but there really isn't any big new news. The new study that came out in Sept is a decent sample size and length of time and it seemed to confirm that your risk with LCIS never plateaus with age and that in fact it may be 2%/yr vs. 1%/yr higher than the average woman. The Univ of Pittsburgh study that came out in June hypothesized about 4 possible areas for investigation to determine what might trigger LCIS to become invasive but they were merely suggestions/theories and who knows how and when that will get picked up for serious research.

    I would echo what the other posters said. Do your due diligence. Investigate all you need to and consult with whomever you need to on all possible choices, summarize the pros and cons and let your head digest the info you organize. Stew on it for a bit. Once you feel like you have done all the rational legwork, as a poster said, your gut will tell you ultimately what is right for you. Having the utmost confidence in your surgical team will go a long way towards helping you get to an answer.

    FYI, I was able to have nipple sparing, skin sparing PBMX and am dealing with the reconstruction process now. I feel like I have wrested some control over these circumstances by making the choice before it got made for me. My pathology came back with more LCIS + atypia in the supposed "good" breast. I feel I made the right choice. Nothing invasive found and no need for long term drugs. I no longer have to live my life in 6 mos increments along with the anxiety of waiting for test results. It probably took me a year+ to wrap my head around the prospect of a PBMX. If you had asked me about it 2 years ago I would have been horrified. By the time I went for surgery, I was strangely calm.

  • marketingmama
    marketingmama Member Posts: 161
    edited October 2015

    I had a very similar situation as msverydense. LCIS, highly dense breasts. Major difference is I made the decision for a PBMX within 6 months of diagnosis. I knew I wouldn't be able to manage through the testing every 6 months and just felt better removing my risk. DH felt very strongly about the decision as well. Following PBMX, LCIS was found in abundance in my "good" breast, which I guess wasn't really a surprise since this condition is so often bilateral. My surgeon said we did the right thing when he saw the pathology. He seemed to correlate the amount of LCIS found by pathology (on both sides) with my overall risk. I suspect that was more his gut than the data talking but when I consider his distinguished career, I am fine with his gut.

    I'm also in the middle of reconstruction and had a complication (infection) that required me to have an implant removed. I'll have to start over with tissue expansion and exchange surgery in a few months. So two more surgeries. It's not what I'd like but I still don't regret the decision. That being said, none of this has been easy. I miss my real breasts, and some of the emotion has been very much like grieving. It's easy to question the decision when you are recovering from surgery or wishing you still had nipple sensation when making love or accepting new (fake) breasts that might not be as perfect as Angelina Jolie's.

    The challenge of LCIS is really around all the unknowns. However, there are some "knowns" around active breast cancer and when I think about those women who are literally fighting for their lives (one of whom is a good friend), I feel sincerely grateful that I will not have this same battle in my future.

    Your decision is deeply personal and I wish you peace of mind as you weigh your options.


  • 614
    614 Member Posts: 851
    edited October 2015

    This discussion board is so helpful.  Good luck to all of you with your decisions.  Go with your gut instincts which are always right.  I am sending hugs and positive wishes.

  • boobymcferrin
    boobymcferrin Member Posts: 11
    edited October 2015

    Just to clarify, Msverydense, I think the study says a 2% absolute risk per year, not 2% higher than the average woman.


  • leaf
    leaf Member Posts: 8,188
    edited October 2015

    Hi Res112: The number of LCIS or ALH/LCIS women who accepted tamoxifen varies with the study you look at.

    In this study, 20 of 200 pure LCIS patients (1990-2008) took antihormonal therapy (15 of these took tamoxifen.) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25944033

    In this study, Overall, 26% of the 219 women in the current study received tamoxifen for chemoprevention, a figure that is substantially higher than the 4.7% rate reported by Port et al.,14 and very similar to the 32% acceptance rate of women with atypia who were offered enrollment in the Breast Cancer Prevention Trial.15 ....

    A comparison of the 38 women with LCIS or AH who accepted tamoxifen and the 30 with these diagnoses who refused the drug demonstrated no significant differences with regard to mean age, family history of breast carcinoma, menopausal status, or history of hysterectomy.

    Overall, a family history of breast carcinoma, a history of prior breast biopsy, menopausal status, and having undergone a hysterectomy were not found to be predictive of the acceptance of tamoxifen. Four of the 57 women (7%) who accepted tamoxifen stopped the drug during the study period: 2 because of mood changes and 1 because of night sweats, and 1 patient opted to undergo bilateral prophylactic mastectomy for greater risk reduction.http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/cncr.20...

    While its interesting to see how many people with X diagnosis or Y characteristics accepted tamoxifen, that doesn't mean you should or shouldn't take tamoxifen. Its so very individual. I had almost no problems with tamoxifen (besides multiple benign uterine polyps), while others just could not tolerate it.


  • MsVeryDenseBreasts
    MsVeryDenseBreasts Member Posts: 100
    edited October 2015

    Thanks for the correction boobymcferrin. My bad on the phrasing.

  • Res112
    Res112 Member Posts: 4
    edited October 2015

    Wow, lots of food for thought coming from these postings. So very helpful for me to hear about the different experiences and decisions you've all had and made. I have an appointment to meet with my doctor to go over some details and schedule my surgery. I feel very right about my decision to go ahead with the PBMX. I'm getting loads of support from my husband and children which have made this easier to handle too.I wish I would have discovered this discussion board sooner.

  • MrsGreenJeans
    MrsGreenJeans Member Posts: 95
    edited October 2015

    Hi Res, I am in the same boat as you. Had my appointment with the BS, waiting to hear back while they coordinate with the PS for a surgery date. I have been pretty certain about PBMX since my diagnosis, and am ready to get it done.

    I am glad for you that you have made a decision and are comfortable with it. Maybe I will see you in the November Surgery thread!!!

  • Res112
    Res112 Member Posts: 4
    edited October 2015

    Hi MrsGreenJeans, wishing you the best for your surgery and recovery! We'll have to compare notes afterwards ; )

  • commander
    commander Member Posts: 10
    edited October 2015

    In 2006-07 I underwent three stereotactic core needle biopsies and one excisional biopsy all showing ALH or LCIS, all on the left side. I took the careful watch and wait approach. Now, after seven years of stable screenings, a recent mammogram, followed by ultrasound guided biopsy, is showing ALH again on the left side. My sister, age 64, is currently undergoing treatment for invasive lobular cancer. I'm 54 and just post-menopause, my breast tissue remains very dense and breasts very "busy." I have an appointment with a surgeon next week to discuss choices. The initial recommendation is another excisional biopsy. I don't know how many more biopsies, surgical or needle, I have left in me. Tamoxifen does not appear to be a choice for me due to family history of blood clots. I need to do some reading on AIs. For the first time, almost ten years after my initial problems, I'm considering PBMX. Will discuss further with surgeon and oncologist (who specializes in prevention) but this seems more and more to be a rational decision for me. But wow, it's a really hard one! Thanks everyone for posting your experiences. I'm going to go back and carefully re-read everything here before my appointment.

  • Moderators
    Moderators Member Posts: 25,912
    edited October 2015

    Hi Commander and welcome to Breastcancer.org!

    You're sure to receive incredible support and advice here from other members shortly. In the meantime, you may want to check out the main Breastcancer.org site's pages on Aromatase Inhibitors, and also the Prophylactic Mastectomy pages.

    We hope this helps! Please continue to check back in and let us know what you decide, or if you need more help!

    --The Mods

Categories