Which treatment is better? Port or IV?

blinds23
blinds23 Member Posts: 6

Hello Everyone :)

I just turned 23 and I have stage 3 breast cancer. I'm suppose to start chemotherapy treatments soon. Which is better? The port or the IV? I tried to research and couldn't find much. I have concerns for both because with the IV i'm worried about the markings and consistently having to get the IV. My concern with the Port is I usually only wear tanks and I may become self conscious knowing it's there. Any advice is greatly helpful!

Comments

  • annika12
    annika12 Member Posts: 433
    edited March 2014

    You are so young and need your veins for a long long life so get a med port !! You can still wear a tank top , you can even wear a bikini :) my bikini days are over but my port is placed in a way you can't see it !! I hated it at first but we are great friends now !!

  • clarrn
    clarrn Member Posts: 557
    edited March 2014

    I am going to get a PICC line.   Recent TEs with fills ongoing and I was worried about the interference.  A Port or PICC is smart at our age, especially if like me you are down an available arm due to mastectomy.  You can't get a PICC site wet though so a port is more convenient.

  • Cowgirl13
    Cowgirl13 Member Posts: 1,936
    edited March 2014

    Blinds, as Anika said you want your veins to stay healthy, especially given your age. I had a port because of being HER2+ which meant that I would have a year of Herceptin.  I'm so glad I did.

  • Oncearunneralwaysarunner
    Oncearunneralwaysarunner Member Posts: 252
    edited March 2014

    hi blinds23,

    I'm triple positive and as Cowgirl13 mentioned, I also get Herceptin every three weeks for a year. I'm 31 and I have a three year old at home, she was 2 and a half when I started chemo. She would have grabbed at a PICC line. The nice thing with the port is that it's pretty much part of me and I can do what ever I want. Shower, swim, you name it. I don't have to worry about getting it caught on something or getting it wet (once it's healed). Having it accessed is easier than IV, there is no need to look for and find a vein. Once the needle is in, you don't feel it like you do with a IV needle.

    I wear tank tops all the time in the summer, and mostly scoop or v-neck shirts in the winter and my port shows. I can understand why you might be self conscious about it, I was a little when I first got it but It got to the point where it was too hot last summer and decided I was going to wear what was comfortable for me. All you see once the incision is healed is a small bump on my upper chest. I've never had anyone make comments about it, nor have it had anyone stare at it. I really don't notice it anymore, it's just there.

    Hope my experience helps provide some insight for when you make your decision. All the best with the upcoming treatments.

    Edited to add: chunky necklaces or scarfs are a great way to camouflage the port while still wearing tank tops :)

  • exbrnxgrl
    exbrnxgrl Member Posts: 12,424
    edited March 2014

    I love my port and as others have said you need to save your veins. My port is placed in the little hollow between my shoulder and upper chest. Unless my tank has spaghetti straps, it's not visible. It is very small and is a "petite" Bard power port. Also, the port or IV are not the treatment at all, but simply methods to deliver treatment.

  • ruthbru
    ruthbru Member Posts: 57,235
    edited March 2014

    Definitely get a port. As others have said, you will want to protect your veins; if you blow them out with an IV, you will have trouble the rest of your life. I would definitely do a port over a PICCA line. DH had one after a surgery, and they are very 'touchy' to care for. With a port, it is just there & you can go about your life. (I ended up getting more V-neck tees when I had one, because mine did show in scoop tops, and I was self-conscious about it).

  • encyclias
    encyclias Member Posts: 302
    edited March 2014

    I loved my port.  Had it in for a year and a half.  Got it taken out about a half hour ago; just got home from the hospital.  It served me very well.  I could not have gotten through the chemo infusions, surgery, and all the blood draws without it.  As for tank tops, pick out those whose shoulder straps are a bit wider; I did put the very narrow-strapped and string tied ones away until now. 

    Summer's coming!  Yeah!

    Carol

  • leggo
    leggo Member Posts: 3,293
    edited March 2014

    It's a completely personal decision. Some will insist it's medically necessary. I have been through six chemos and four years of herceptin and have never had a port or any trouble with my veins. The only difficulty I had was the dye for a CT scan, which went interstital and caused me a lot of grief and from what I've been told ports can't be used for that anyway. It was later determined that it was due to the tech's incompetence. I chose not to get a port because I really didn't want to look like, or be constantly reminded of the fact that I'm a cancer patient. It's probably best to get ALL your options from your medical team. Neither way is without it's risk of complications.....and it certainly has a lot to do with how competent your IV administrator is. Good luck to you, whatever you decide.

  • MellowYellow
    MellowYellow Member Posts: 2
    edited August 2014

    I was only doing six treatments, one every three weeks, so I chose IV. I have had more problems with finding veins for the blood work. And I am 51. It's a personal choice but the number of treatments and frequency will likely help you make the choice.  

Categories