I say yes, you say no, OR People are Strange

1171117121714171617171828

Comments

  • kayfh
    kayfh Member Posts: 790
    edited February 2014

    whoaa Blantona.  Why don't you say what you really think?  Don't cloak it in the blanket of another person who you feel was slighted by people who post here because they feel a certain 'sisterhood' with each other.  Sisters aren't always nice to each other, but if they love each other they can at least accept each other. Kay

  • Wabbit
    Wabbit Member Posts: 1,592
    edited February 2014

    Waving hello to everybody!  I've been reading but I'm not sure when I actually posted last.  Mostly I just nod my head in agreement, chuckle, or commiserate.  And then I'm so far behind I don't know where to start.  Sending (((hugs))) and good vibes out to all in need of them.  Love you all!

    Been playing in the snow a lot this year.  Old Man Winter can't pack up and go away quick enough for me.  I'm not entitled to complain too much though.  I'm retired and do not have to go out in it until it's passable and it's not like a little snow shoveling is beyond my capabilities.  It just interferes with my laziness.   

  • pupmom
    pupmom Member Posts: 5,068
    edited February 2014

    Thanks alexandria! This board and thread are so supportive. Politics is definitely NOT my primary reason for coming here.

  • QuinnCat
    QuinnCat Member Posts: 3,456
    edited February 2014

    Wabbit - good point.  By getting insurance, we as customers are getting the negotiated rate between the insurance company and the provider for any given medical procedure.  One can negotiate on their own, but there are some that will never negotiate - I'm thinking anethesiologists :)   It's all a question of supply and demand.

    As far as the $1200 a month, that would be for a family, and presumable two people working or one person working with a good income?  That is $600 a month per adult, and if there are children, less per person.....that is cheaper than my insurance, though my employer pays 2/3rds of my premium.  It seems like a good deal, insurance wise, given the benefits I've seen on Obamacare (I still pay $5000 out of pocket before 100% gets paid, have a deductible, copays, etc..), though it might not be affordable to a family that finds itself in the donut hole.  I get that.

    Anyone know the answer to this?  If one is in a married couple and one of the couple has insurance, but the employer drops the spouse  from that insurance, such as UPS did to it's workers, can the non-insured spouse file for Obamacare as a single person and use their own wages to determine their subsidy?  Maybe they would consider the insured spouse's income, still, in that determination? 

    Addressing what blantona said specifically, I though Obama recently extended those lousy policies for those that would have been cancelled otherwise under the new rules?

  • crazy4carrots
    crazy4carrots Member Posts: 5,324
    edited February 2014

    Besides the wonderful friends I've made through BCO (many of whom I've met in person, from far-flung spots on the planet), my eyes have been widened by the horrendous costs of healthcare in the U.S.  Wabbit's post about the hospital-ONLY cost of her first surgery is a good example.  I discovered, too, that neupogen shots cost 10 TIMES more in the U.S. than in Canada.  Deductibles and co-pays are mind-boggling, and it's no wonder that healthcare costs are the number 1 reason for bankruptcies in the U.S.

    And all of this to preserve some truly bewildering sense of "freedom".....  Healthcare is what is termed an "inelastic" demand (if we're talking in terms of good old supply and demand -- the mantra of capitalism).  You may be able to shop around for a doctor of your choice -- just as we can in Canada -- but when it comes to hospitals and surgeries, you just cannot shop around for the best bargain.  You'll go where your doctor wants you to go, and you'll never know how much your treatments, surgeries and hospital stays will cost until you receive your estimate from your insurance company.  And even then, your doctor will probably spend too much time with the insurer trying to justify the care he/she is certain you need.

    On the other hand, you can shop until you drop to find the best price on a 60" TV, or the refrigerator of your choice, or those pair of shoes you covet.  That's what supply and demand is all about.  The store that supplies the product of your choice for the lowest possible price is meeting your demand.

    So, for those who equate single-payer or universal healthcare with the dreaded "socialism", consider first what your freedom really and truly means when you or your less fortunate neighbour is diagnosed with breast cancer.  And don't ever forget that medicare and social security (ugh, socialist!) had growing pains when first introduced.  Now, just try to take those programmes away!

  • blantona1
    blantona1 Member Posts: 8
    edited February 2014

    Hmm, maybe my state is different or my providers but I have actually found the opposite to be true. If I have insurance, my ins. may be billed 5k for a procedure that I will be billed 1500 for if paying cash. The ins. co. has negotiated prices with the Dr.'s and will pay say 1200 for the same procedure. So the INS. CO. gets to pay even less while soaking the customers for premiums. So yes I pay more for the procedure than the ins. co. actually pays but still far less than the cost of premiums plus out of pocket and deductibles. As I stated before, that only works if it's a less intensive situation. For someone looking at extensive surgery and treatments, of course it will be expensive, however, even in that case seems the 12k, plus....that is quoted in the post is still below my threshold of premiums and deductibles.

  • blantona1
    blantona1 Member Posts: 8
    edited February 2014

    Actually I was addressing specifically those who are self employed such as myself. As for the situation with UPS etc. I know of someone who tried that and were told that if a spouse's employer offers ins. then they can't. Problem with that was that the employer ins. with the new premiums with pre existing conditions (2012 policy) was priced so high they couldn't begin to afford it. So it's another dead end. Of course that was before all the dust settled so I'm not sure if that's the same with the rule changes. Seems as if employers and ins. co.'s took the route of this is the rule and we're applying it and not changing even if the rules change so it left a lot of people in a lurch. Yes you are correct that is for a family....per the new rules I can't insure just myself (and wouldn't want to) but as someone self employed with a family to support that 1200 +deductibles+copays is beyond anything I can reach. At least before I could simply cover the kids to make sure they were taken care of, now I have no choice and no money to cover it in this economy and I know I'm not alone in this situation. I also find that as you stated we can negotiate bills, have done it several times with my husband, myself and kids. Haven't found anyone (so far) unwilling to negotiate the bill....knock wood.

  • momaton
    momaton Member Posts: 780
    edited February 2014

    Well, well, well, ladies and I use the term loosely for a very select few of you,

    And please don't even try to take offense to that...You have called me a freeloader and sh*t for brains. Really! I have had at least one person from this thread following my posts on the January 2014 surgery thread. Why? you ask? Or did any of you ask or care about the vile things she has been posting about me. These are targeted attacks against me personally. And some of you jump on her personal band wagon without reading for yourselves what I said. The worst part is that you found it all so amusing. How, is or has BREAST CANCER ever been amusing?

    Also

    I've been ridiculed for smoking, but one of the ladies here said she smoked, but had insurance. huh! so smoking is ok for her but not for me. BTW  haven't had a cig in 2 weeks...Bravo for me!

    The posts have been evil and cruel.

    Let me enlighten you wonderful ladies about me, seeing as how this one person has given you a totally bogus impression of who I am and what I have posted.

    Yes, I do NOT have insurance. I could not get insurance. Let me repeat that... I could not get, purchase, beg for insurance. Why? During open enrollment at my DH's company, because Obamacare mandated that employers could use their 2013 plan, which included a pre existing clause I was not eligible for insurance. Because my Dh's company offered insurance I can not get obamacare. K? understand.

    My state did not expand the Medicaid limits, so I am, AGAIN, NOT eligible for that either. 

    Yes, I said I didn't really want either anyway, because I don't want to be on the dole nor do I want to be forced to buy something, anything, by my government. On the other hand I did try to buy obamacare and spent 16 hours+ trying to get anywhere on the website.

    Another point is my BS and PCP don't take obamacare anyway.

    So now to me being a freeloader. I NEVER asked for any reduction in my bills. I was offered the reductions by the hospital and my BS. WHY???? You tell me. I never asked, that was their choice.

    let me state this very, very clearly I AM PAYING CASH for my treatment. 

    I have shared the costs of treatment in my posts, but have never complained of the cost. I am DEEPLY humbled by the generosity of the providers that have reduced my bill.

    You people that think I am a freeloader and have sh*t for brains and anyone else that reads that drivel and laughs and believs it...get this...

    you smug women have insurance. You pay into a risk pool. You HAVE not paid for your treatment in cash...other...OTHER people in the same risk pool are paying for your treatment....GET IT.

    ONE other thing, as far as me stating "I may walk away from chemo" and the comments about that...I said for many reasons besides the money I may walk away from chemo and AI's. There are a huge amount of non monetary reasons I may do that. pre- existing conditions reasons.

    Here is the final deal, I too have effing breast cancer...Some of you attacked me with your very political spin....You insulted me and quite frankly made me cry in devastation with your remarks. I am only 3 weeks out from having my boobs amputated and I hope you will leave me and my posts the eff alone.

    I do not HATE Obama, and do not hate obamacare.

    peace and healing,

    Eve

  • Wabbit
    Wabbit Member Posts: 1,592
    edited February 2014

    I have never been able to get a firm price quote for any medical procedure from any provider.  Not even when hubby tried to get one for a simple sleep apnea test.  It all 'depends' they tell you.  "They just won't know until it's all over with."  That is my problem with us being told we should be smarter consumers and comparison shop.  It only works for simple things like an office visit or a flu shot. 

    ETA ... pip is right.  This thread is for other stuff.    

  • gardengumby
    gardengumby Member Posts: 7,305
    edited February 2014

    I was under the impression that UPS only dropped spouses who were able to get coverage from their own employer, but did not drop those who were either unemployed or unable to receive coverage.

    In regard to the amount for insurance.  When I retired, neither hubby or I were yet eligible for Medicare - therefore we opted for Cobra coverage at a cost of $1335 per month.  We did not go the Obamacare route, even though it would have been less expensive - not massively less, but less, because we are not yet sure that the Republicans will not be able to get rid of it.  Since we both have pre-existing conditions, it seemed to be too big of a chance to take.  Also, if we would have gone any other route, when we are eligible for medicare next year, we would not have been eligible for my company's Medicare add-on - and it appears to be a pretty good option.  I REALLY wish that single payer would have been an option with Obamacare.

    In regard to the cost of healthcare if uninusered.  Most doctors here in Washington will also offer a reduced rate to someone who is paying CASH.  If, however, cash is not an option, then neither is the reduced rate.

    Edited to add...  Momaton - I do not know you, have never posted about you, have never even read about you, to the best of my knowledge.  I hope you are well.

  • pip57
    pip57 Member Posts: 12,401
    edited February 2014

    blantona, welcome to our little bit of BCO.  You will find a lot of good info and support here.  We are all united sisters in this fight against bc.  However, you will find that some of us have made very different choices regarding our tx and lifestyles.  Those things are better addressed on the threads meant for such discussions. This is just a place where we can continue our friendships that started on this site but have grown beyond our medical situations.  Many of us have met in person as well.  And, sadly, we have lost many friends from here.  The only thing we all agree on is that bc sucks!

  • bluedahlia
    bluedahlia Member Posts: 6,944
    edited February 2014

    Well troubles abound!  The comments made did not refer to anyone specifically, or pointed anyone to your posts.  I had no idea who was being discussed until you came here and revealed it yourself.  I guess one of our "friends" directed you here.  

  • QuinnCat
    QuinnCat Member Posts: 3,456
    edited February 2014

    OMG - I caught the tail end of some Fox News show hosted by Carol Alt - yes, Carol Alt the model, not Carol Alt the newswoman.  Is this Fox New's attempt to get legitimacy with women?  God help us.  Anyway, I was intrigued as they were actually talking about some bad chemical Chick-fil-A was putting in their food - was I really hearing this?  I'll give them some credit for bad advertising for that homophobic restaurant (though they wanted to say how Chick-fil-A did remove these chemicals voluntarily after social media pressures), but at the end of the segment Carol Alt says to her female guest, who explained all of these horrible chemicals "Oh and by the way Bonnie, I can't believe you can remember all those heavy words."  Well, you had to be there to get the full impact, short dresses and heavy heavy makeup.  I felt like I was transported back into the 1950's.

  • River_Rat
    River_Rat Member Posts: 1,724
    edited February 2014

    Momaton, I post in this thread with this lovely group of ladies from time to time but have been busy with real life so not sure exactly what all has been going on and really don't want to know. But in your last post you mentioned that your husband's company insured him but not you due to your pre-existing conditions and you said that you can't get Obamacare because he has this insurance. You are eligible for Obamacare. It is difficult if your state government is not cooperating with the ACA but please look for an insurance broker. Or try the website again, it is working better now - and you don't have to do it all online. There's a phone number that which you can call and handle things that way. Good luck. I hope you get the coverage you need.

    Hey everybody else. Chickadee, Enjoyful and Glenna you're in my thoughts. Yorkie, sorry to hear about your fur baby.

  • momaton
    momaton Member Posts: 780
    edited February 2014

    manipulated????

    kam called me a freeloader and illlady said I had shit for brains.

  • pupmom
    pupmom Member Posts: 5,068
    edited February 2014

    Well, bye then.

  • bluedahlia
    bluedahlia Member Posts: 6,944
    edited February 2014

    Where's Wald errrrrrrrr Wendel?

    image

  • YramAL
    YramAL Member Posts: 1,651
    edited February 2014
  • bluedahlia
    bluedahlia Member Posts: 6,944
    edited February 2014

    Yup, manipulated by whoever directed you here.  Good Luck!  We all need it.

  • Chickadee
    Chickadee Member Posts: 4,467
    edited February 2014

    Ain't  no morons here.  I also don't go looking for aggravation anymore, got too much on my plate and want the sunnier side where I can find it. 

    Please grumpy, irritable, confrontational people find a thread for yourselves and settle in with a nice beverage and a cookie 

  • QuinnCat
    QuinnCat Member Posts: 3,456
    edited February 2014

    In the strict definition of the word, "freeloader" is reserved for "libs"  or  "lib" leaning folk only, like me....you know, the ones that will "regret loving their guy in months to come."   As far as I know, aren't 47% of Americans "freeloaders" per Mitt Romney?  I never personally took offense at that comment, despite knowing Mitt would probably put me in that category - one time in my life getting 2 months of unemployment and now having a government pension, because I think poor Mitt just doesn't understand that he's a freeloader too.  He just does it in different ways that don't have the same stigma that has been created around getting food stamps, welfare, medicaid, etc..   I just feel bad when Mitt, and people like Mitt, don't understand the paradox (or is that hypocrisy) of labeling someone that.

  • IllinoisLady
    IllinoisLady Member Posts: 29,082
    edited February 2014

    Well, I'm here late and have little to add.  So many of you have said it so well already.  I have made a HUGE habit of not addressing anyone personally as such.  I guess I'm the "odd" person out as I feel in order to actually score on someone, you really should KNOW them.    I may have a lot to say over many, many things, but it is in general. 

    Wabbit...great to see you.  Can't recall how many times lately I've wondered what you were up too.  If you can get your winter to go away, maybe mine will too.  I see we are not that far away from each other.  Too much bragging on my part....about this little pocket of territory where we live.  This part of the country is referred to as Little Egypt because we usually have it much milder than anything going on around us.  This winter has been a bummer.  Got up to 30 degrees today but I'm told we will go back to the deep-freeze later tonight or tomorrow...oh joy.  We still have five or 6 inches of the white stuff here.  Not so bad out in the country...it stays pristine for the most part, but it is getting tiresome. 

    Many a year it has been warm enough in February to open the windows for a bit and fill the house with fresh and un-stale air.  I'm sure it is not going to happen very soon and not this February either.

    Done with work this week-end.  Nice paycheck though.  Kept me off of here and the other areas where I post. 

    I think you got it right Blue.

    Jackie

    ETA:  Well bye from me as well. 


  • rosemary-b
    rosemary-b Member Posts: 2,006
    edited February 2014

    I am happy with the Affordable Care Act. My 29 year old son got an affordable policy on the exchange that has a yearly out of pocket maximum that is less than the deductible on his old policy, at rates he could afford. There have been very few changes to our insurance, no more than any other year. I am sorry that everyone has not had a positive experience. 

  • alexandria58
    alexandria58 Member Posts: 1,588
    edited February 2014

    Oy.

    Momaton

    I have not read any posts except those here.   The term "freeloader" seemed to be being used ironically, but that is just my take.  I do not think anyone intended to insult any one who is unable to obtain health insurance.

    AS someone who has voted and argued my entire lie for universal single payer health care, along with many of the other other women here, I would never denigrate someone who does not have health insurance.  However, the fact that you consider expanded Medicaid as being on the dole does seem to indicate a political world view that differs from mine.  I would never think that a person who works but doesn't earn enough to live and pay for insurance as being on the dole because he or she is able to get expanded Medicaid.  I consider that MacDonald's and Walmart are on the dole because they refuse to pay their employees living wages and the rest of us are in fact subsidizing multi-million dollar companies, which are therefore able to pay poverty wages.

    That's neither here nor there.

    I am under the impression that insurance companies cannot turn you down for pre-existing conditions.  You might want to call a health consultant or even an attorney in your state who specializes in health care law.  You should be able to be covered on your husband's plan.

    The problem with American healthcare is indeed that it is inelastic - and that the prices set have no relation to cost or in fact to anything in particular.  There have been numerous articles on the fact that th exact same hip replacement will cost $14,000 in Belgium and $75,000 in the United States.  There is something very wrong here, and I don't think that the astronomical costs here in the US can be justified as having superior outcomes.  This is perhaps where the laissez faire attitude towards profit - and the idea that health care is just another free market commodity - has created a monster.

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited February 2014

    THANK YOU TO THE MODERATORS FOR POSTING THIS:

    "This thread you have chosen is a very old thread with much history, and
    certainly not for everybody's liking. It is also therefore not on the
    active topics list. We have a very large number of incredibly supportive
    members on here though, and it has been quite harmonious."

    MODERATORS: When a "new member" of BCO immediately posts on a thread, AND ONLY ON THAT THREAD, which is not on the Active List, prompting a Moderator to "intervene" - would it be possible for the tech team to determine if that poster is in fact, new, or posts under a different name.

    A special note to anyone who reads this thread, even tho it is not on the Active Thread, and must mark it as a Favorites ( really?) or go to the Friendship Section of the Forum Listings, why bother?  It is so much easier to follow that wonderful advice from the Moderators:

    DON'T LIKE, DON'T READ.

    Sending snowy greetings to Beautiful Blue, have you been to the acupuncturist again yet?  Yet again?  Pats to Wendell's silk tummy....

  • QuinnCat
    QuinnCat Member Posts: 3,456
    edited February 2014

    Rosemary - my gf got Obamacare for $45 a month and is now scheduled for hip replacement surgery on March 18th.  She will have to dig into her little bit of savings while not working during her recovery period and now because she can't really function at work full time - she can barely walk, but she had no hope of any replacement surgery without Obamacare.  She also told me last night, she wanted to feel like she was paying her way and though she knows she is being subsidized, and will still have out-of-pocket expenses, she feels like she is contributing to the cost of this operation while not having to lose her home to have the operation.

  • Chickadee
    Chickadee Member Posts: 4,467
    edited February 2014

    I just finished Roosevelt & Taft. The  Golden Age of Journalism.    

    Most interesting to me was that at the turn of the century we were in the same situation. The Rockefellers, etc who were amassing incredible amounts of wealth refused to even acknowledge they were doing on the backs of essentially child labor, immigrant labor or any free way they could do it. 

    They raised tariffs on every essential the average person needed till it was simply unaffordable.  

    The journalism part comes in with an amazing team of writers working for. SS McClure and his magazine who went essentially deep throat and humiliated the bastards publicly which allowed Roosevelt to go after them legislatively because even the bought and paid for congress were losing seats when people knew the TRUTH!

    We are missing truth in the media.  They like their celebrity status too much to tell it. I told my husband years ago when George Will starting lunching with Nancy Reagan that something stunk to high heaven......and the flood gates opened.  There are no big time investigative journalists anymore like jack Anderson. The corporations started buying the TV programming the newspapers and magazines. Too many sheep in this country again. 

  • IllinoisLady
    IllinoisLady Member Posts: 29,082
    edited February 2014

    Sunny...my title here is why didn't I think of that !!!!!  But was going to post that I'm likely a freeloader as well.  When I lost my Ins. and realized something BAD was wrong and had no idea where to turn, I checked into the V.A. and they took me on and have taken most excellent care of me.   I might add as well that I brought home after every chemo infusion 7 shots of Neupogin to give myself.....costing roughly $7,500 for the week and I did this for 8 infusions.   I am grateful every day that I had them to turn too.  I do now have Medicare so am not required to solicit ACA insurance, but would in a heartbeat otherwise. 

    I too am truly sorry for anyone that CANNOT get Insurance.  I know what the terror is like of not having it, but un-like some, I had no money either.  So....technically, I am a freeloader.  I'd cry in my beer but I don't drink it.  I'd cry in my Coke, but I don't drink that either -- very rarely I'll have  Sierra Mist because it has real sugar in it rather than corn syrup....guess I could cry in that.  Well, heck.....most of the time I'm not the crying type....so I'll just be grateful and let it go. 

    Jackie 

  • pupmom
    pupmom Member Posts: 5,068
    edited February 2014

    I think anyone who has attended public schools, driven down state and federal highways, and checked out books at the public library is technically freeloading. Yes, we pay taxes for those things, but many pay no taxes. Am I mad that I am subsidizing those who make so little they are not contributing to these services? NO. 

  • bluedahlia
    bluedahlia Member Posts: 6,944
    edited February 2014

    civilization

    ˌsivələˈzāSHən/

    noun

    noun: civilization; noun: civilisation

    1.

    the stage of human social development and organization that is considered most advanced.

    "they equated the railroad with progress and civilization"

    synonyms:human development, advancement, progress, enlightenment, culture, refinement, sophisticationMore

    "a higher stage of civilization"

Categories