ILC - The Odd One Out?
Comments
-
MsPharaoh, good question about the LCIS. According to my path report (I had neoadjuvant chemo), I did have LCIS in the left breast, along with the ILC and the Paget's of the nipple. Neither the LCIS or Paget's showed up until that point, despite mammo, U/S, two MRIs and a PET/CT, and obviously the chemo didn't get 'em.
I also had the same experience with the BS - she was gung-ho about a double mastectomy, and this was before we knew about the IDC in the right breast. That wasn't found until MRI - neither of my cancers were dx'd via mammogram (that's maybe for another thread). She was out-of-date with her statements about risk of bilaterality of ILC.
In the larger world, researchers are working hard at doing a better job determining who is most likely to benefit from chemo vs. not, and that's encouraging. But again, are they looking at lobular specifically, or are the lenses hormone positive vs. negative, node-positive vs. negative.
Which leads me to another two-parter comment, and as rdrunner mentioned above - the grading for ILC. As I understand it, grading can be fairly subjective in the middle ranges, and especially for ILC. As ILC doesn't form tubules (one of the three components of the overall grade), we automatically get a "3" on that part. Yet, many of us are given a taxane, which is an anti-tubule agent. Why? LOL, that question is for our oncologists and not for my peers. I'll try to remember next time I see my MO. Did any of you have just - just! - AC?
My guess is that there are so many reports of improved outcomes with the addition of taxanes to the regimens - it's been studied thoroughly - synergy with the A and the C. But I do wonder if that's true for lobular. I would have been happy to avoid the neuropathy in my hands and feet, which seems to be permanent as I am almost three years out from my last infusion.
Junipergirl, let's hope the oncotype test results come back without the recommendation for chemo. Please let us know.
RobinLK, another young woman and you have quite the mix - high grade and HER2+. Sheesh. Thinking of you as you start down the chemo road. I had a pap right before I was dx'd that wasn't negative but my MO said BC treatment comes first. So I had to keep that in the back of my mind all the way through, too.
momand2kids, another young and otherwise healthy ILC'er. May we join you in the spring to celebrate your AI tx ending (unless you decide to stay on it)?
holeinone, I don't think any of us were naive. All that awareness that became part of the fabric of our culture 15-20 years ago; we listened and acted accordingly to take care of ourselves. No system is perfect, but where we ILC women are concerned, both the technology AND the radiologists could be doing a lot better by us.
So, for most of us, ILC is slow-growing. I've used the word "lumbering" to refer to it to others. However, the race is not always to the swift and that's frightening to me.
I am not presuming to speak for anyone on this thread - I think threads belong to everyone who participates in them, not just whoever the OP may be - but if there are any Stage IV ILC women reading here who would like to post but are hesitatating, please know that you are most welcome here. -
I was diagnosed 3 weeks before my 50th birthday the first time and my local recurrence happened 4 years later. -
I just got dx'ed a month ago (already!) and I'm 54 and premenopausal. I've only recently begun to get irregular too. I'm 5'3" and 170 lbs and from the looks of it, I'm the resident fattie lol. I don't know if my mother took DES, but fibroids and late menopause run in the family anyway and g-ma told me about 7 years ago that I'd be bleeding until 55 and I was horrified, but the only way I won't be now is if chemo shuts it down. I also started early--age 11. Birth control pills--maybe for a total of 5 years but all of those 5 years were around 30 years ago. My shape is a definite apple--not one whit of juicy pear here and I've always heard that women with fibroids are more likely to be pears. -
I was 49 at diagnosis. 5'5" tall and 117 lbs. My diet was terrible, but I never was overweight, probably due to regular exercise. I smoked when I was in my 20's, but haven't had a cigarette in over 20 years now. I drink in moderation, and have changed my diet to be as healthy as possible, without eating food I don't like.
My mother may have taken DES. BRCA negative. On my 4th year taking Tamoxifen. MO says he will switch me to AI in 2015. So far, so good, but I'm always nervous that I may not be doing all the right things to avoid recurrence. -
I was 65 at dx so part of the older group, never took HRT but had my last period at age 54 a little later than average thus had extra estrogen exposure that way. My post meno weight went up to 172 lbs by age 62 but gradually dropped back to 168 at dx. I like to think that it was declining estrogen due to the weight coming down that kept the cancer progressing further into the nodes. I only had one positive node but it was a big one 15 mm of cancer tumour but rest of the 14 nodes taken all clear. I lost a lot of weight during chemo and kept most of it off and now at age 69 at 148 lbs I weigh less then I did at age 50 all of which is very good news with ER+ ILC cancer IMO. I might even drop the AI early.
BTW I was just told that I had 'early stage' cancer, no numbers or letters and assumed that with ILC prognosis the TNM staging wasn't all that important. I used the information from pathology reports for my signature but I'm not sure if the tumour measurement of 1.5 cm in the report, which is the central mass of the tumour that was visible to be measured matches the way tumour size is reported elsewhere. Someone above mentioned that their tumour size could not be determined so I guess with ILC threading it can be an iffy thing. My surgery was planned using MRI imaging and the piece removed during lumpectomy measured 8cm x 5cm x 3.5 cm, so the actual size of the tumour looking with microscope would be larger. I still think of my stage as being 2A though when comparing with IDC.
Kathy -
Just adding some missing details. I, too, am of Ashkenazi Jewish descent. Have no close family hx, but have 7 cousins through my maternal grandmother who have had either breast or ovarian ca. We are all BRCA neg but I often wonder if there's some gene that is yet to be discovered. Sadly, we lost most of the family in the holocaust, so there is a limited family hx. Also have mostly male relatives! Mostly uncles, no sisters:) Who knows on this count...
I, also grew up playing in heavily sprayed apple orchards (which have since been condemned.) Wow have I changed our environment around (organic, etc.) but I don't think those years did much good. On the other hand, why did some of us who played in this orchard get ca and others not? That is a key question...
Good weekend, all. Shari -
Okay, here's my background: never overweight, dx at 53, social-smoker (friday nights) during my 20s and early 30s, Friday night social drinker too, which stopped upon dx. 5'8.5", 132 lbs, lost 10 during chemo but seem to have gained it all back (grrr). Regular hard core exerciser/athlete, always have been. Lived in a clean (good air, no environmental problems) town all my life. Vegan/vegetarian, can't remember when I last ate fast food, lost husband in 96 to cancer, dx with fibroids (2x) and had 2 surgeries (myomectomies) to remove them. Dx with a pheochromocytoma (extremely rare, look it up) in 2007 after 7 years of increasingly frightening symptoms that no medical person could figure out; I self-diagnosed and then GP confirmed. This is an adrenal tumor that releases adrenaline (catecholamines) into the system with increasingly ferocious attacks. Catecholamines have been linked to higher incidence of some cancers. Exposed to nuclear fallout from Nevada at age 3 making me a Downwinder, also proven to increase likelihood of some cancers. No history of breast cancer in my family, no gene.
I have a rarer blood type: B positive. Maybe something there?
One more thing: early menstrual period and was still pre-menopause when I began chemo (which of course stopped everything, thank god--I think of all that estrogen flooding my system for so long). Highly ER/PR +.
When I re-read the above, I'm shocked I'm alive. Oh yeah, I had dense breasts too, making it harder to find anything with regular mammograms.
Claire -
this thread is so interesting, I decided to add more info. about myself. Perhaps we can find a connection; this is one smart group of women! Sorry to repeat some things:
Age- 48 at diagnosis, weight 130lbs., height 5'4", very dense breasts since age 14 (36DD- hence a breast reduction surgery that revealed DCIS and LCIS 8 years ago in left breast only) had prophylactic bilateral mastectomy with tram flap reconstruction in 2005; 8 years later ILC only in left breast. Had another bilateral mastectomy to remove reconstruction, as the tumor was growing into the tram muscle. Now I currently have tissue expanders until I have my exchange surgery. I have always suffered from a mild form of anxiety, I get cold sores, and have always had allergy and exercise induced asthma, but it is controlled and I don't take medicine for it unless needed. Never smoked. Drink occasionally, maybe a little excessive at times when I was younger. Not a vegetarian. Liked my sugar, and have cut back a lot. 95% ER positive, 50% PR positive, HERNegative. Live in suburbia(NJ), no family history of breast cancer, dad had bladder cancer 17 years ago, but did not die of cancer. I lost him September 13 of this year, while I was going through chemo. My blood type is A+. Also want to add that I had first child at age 36 and second 18 months later. Was 70 lbs overweight with each pregnancy but lost the weight quickly. Dang, I keep editing this to add stuff. I was also very stressed the past few years. I think stress is a big factor and I forgot to add it in the mix. Chemobrain! -
this is interesting, I agree. Things I should have added to my previous post. I am A+ blood type. Started menstruating age 11. 63.5 inches tall and 142 lbs. Hysterectomy age 35 for adenomyosis. Removed the tubes since they were poly cystic and had caused an adhesion to my bowel that had to be removed 2 years prior. Former smoker 1/4 pack a day. Not much of a drinker, enjoy a nice cocktail or beer every once and awhile. Not sure of DES status. -
ilc diagnosis at age thirtynine. des daughter t shaped uterus when i had tahbso age fifty due to endometrial ca due to tamoxifen use? local recurrence fifteen years after original ilc. early menarche age twelve. no kids by choice but chemopause put an end to that choice at forty.
-
smrlvr and toomuch, two more young women before we flip over to Page Two.
smrlvr, I was still going strong and regular at 50, when I started chemo. My last period was during my first chemo. My MO, once I was done with surgery and rads, wanted to give me Lupron shots when I started Tamox. Well, by then it was 11 months and I pushed him to tell me the odds of it returning. He does not like to talk about stats. He told me, finally, that it was about 4%. I refused the Lupron. For me, that was overkill. And I was right - it never came back. Wishing you well with your treatment and hope you learn you are BRCA negative. I think I've learned a lot in the last few days, just from this thread!
toomuch, I wonder about environmental exposures. I'm sorry to hear about your brother - how is he doing? Isn't 50 young for prostate cancer, too? I am encouraged for you that, despite all the BC in your family, no one passed away from it. Oddly, my remaining breast shows that it is still very dense (per mammo), despite being in menopause for two+ years, and on Tamoxifen. Makes me wonder who's reading the results.
IllinoisNancy, twice and both times under 55. How are you doing now?
pipers_dream, you are NOT the resident fattie! That, probably is me now - +40 lbs. in five months once I started the Tamoxifen. I eat maybe 1300 calories a day. I miss my tiny waist more than my DD breasts (now just a single D). I have a fibroid but it is not big and doesn't cause any for me problems. You are newly diagnosed so this is for later: Should you go on Tamoxifen, please insist on a baseline transvaginal ultrasound before you start. Do you have a treatment plan yet?
vanessa99, another 40s-and-fabulous ILC lady. From what you wrote, you are doing everything that we know to do to keep yourself cancer-free. I always wonder at the posts from women who change their diets in a radical way to "extremely" healthy - do they really like all that kale? Why fear a nice moderately-sized slice of cheesecake? It will only kill us if we choke on it.
kathy044, not just because of the BC risk, but being a little lighter than you were a few years ago might give you a little more energy, which is always good. And congratulations on four+ years. I do wonder if there would be a downside for you to drop the AI early. Have you had difficulties with it?
claireinaz, like you, I didn't have a real grasp of the amount of treatment I had in toto until I wrote my profile here at BCO and saw it on the screen. Yes, sometimes we have to self-diagnose and then tell our docs. That's pretty much a lifelong standard for me.
sgreenarch (shari), seven cousins BRCA- on the same side of the family but with breast or ovarian practically screams that there is more, genetically, going on than we know now. "We" are not the only folks with BRCA associations - I remember reading about founder effects with French Canadians and also Scandinavians, particularly Iceland, IIRC. I wonder if researchers are looking closely at these populations. And, I am so sorry for your family's losses.
Sheesh, ksil, what a year you've had. Don't worry about repeating yourself; we know about chemo brain.
kareenie, not just BC twice, but ILC twice, and so young. And you are known, not speculative, DES daughter. May the fat grafting go well and not be terribly uncomfortable.
I know family history only on the maternal side. One first cousin once removed with Stage I IDC 35 years ago; she turned 80 in May. My grandmother died of cancer at 65, but we don't know if it was liver specifically or if it was liver mets. All five of her siblings and her mother lived into their late 80s and 90s. I am O+.
Ladies, we are not a standard statistical patient pool, but it sure looks like we have some patterns here already. I know I feel less isolated than I did three days ago. -
I was also diagnosed right before my 50th birthday, definitely pre-meno at diagnosis. It was large, about 6 cm, no nodes, grade 1. I'm 5'1" tall, but my weight is a state secret!! I am chubby but healthy - I go to the gym 5 or 6 days/week, and always went at least 3X/week. I don't take any prescription medications at all. I tried Tamoxifen for a few weeks, and decided I couldn't live with the SE's, so I stopped. Since I didn't want Lupron shots, I chose to exercise and I'm taking supplements, but no AI. And it is NOT coming back. I don't have the time or patience for that to happen, so nope, done, that's it. -
Oh yes I want to add more too. Never smoked, drink very lightly--maybe one or two a month. Have a raging sweet tooth which is why the weight problems. Breastfed both my babies for 2 years each and I'm convinced that my cancer started at the site of an old injury where my ducts used to block up, though maybe that was from something else that caused this? My girls are 19 and 21 and surely I haven't had cancer that long. I do exercise--not a fitness freak but I love to go folk dancing every week and hike and just do exercise that I enjoy. I'm actually in pretty good shape physically and most people guess me to be younger. -
hi Ladies
Great thread - love a statistical conundrum
Dx 5 days b4 50th birthday ,definitely premenopausal, told 50mm tumour but was actually 20mm and 2 satellites. (Dodged a bullet there). Went into chemo menopause on Tx1
My single affected node was 10mm I am 68inches and <150lbs Breast fed 2 children for 4 months at 32 and 34 years old
Never smoked but drank waaayyyy too much. Sure that's my downfall I Now Stick to my 3 std drinks a week religiously
No family BC history although my dad died of stomach cancer in 2000. Been a stressful 3 years though !!!
Moderate exerciser although now passion about golf ( hello Hin1) and playing twice a week
BC surgeon said other breast unlikely to cause any problems - never had dense breasts and never bigger than a C cup
MmeJ hope you are running a spreadsheet on all this
)))
Concerned re the Tamoxifen comments for ILC ..... -
Nocompromise, if you are in menopause anyway, you should really discuss switching to an AI, in my humble opinion. -
I don't have time to do it now, but I was wondering if people would be willing to fill out a questionnaire with all these questions. I checked out survey monkey, and it would be possible to do it there. It has analytical tools, so it should be possible to collate all the info at the end and search for specific parameters. I could possibly get around to it after the holidays. -
Momine, that is a great idea. There are similarities that I read and think, "wow, I should have mentioned that in my response". So, yes, a questionnaire is brilliant! -
Momine, Great idea.
MsP -
OK, like I said, it will have to wait till after the holidays. One thing that has struck me already is how many of ours were DXed in our late 40s. "Geriatric" my behind!
-
yes, and in the meantime if anyone has any good ideas as to what can be on the survey, I know that although I have never been overweight, I did have high cholesterol in my thirties. It's still on the high side, but I think it's reduced due to exercise and better diet. Never took a statin. Anyway, cholesterol has become suspect as of late...to what degree, I do not know. -
Great thread. I was diagnosed at 54 with stage 1 ILC with some DCIS. I was in menopause but didn't know it. Lots of issues with fibroids and other growths in my uterus and ovaries. Had very dense breasts. Exercised a lot, ate healthy, did not drink. Was a little overweight by 10#. Then had LCIS seven years later.
For the survey, I would ask about extreme stress or depression before diagnosis, hormone use, body mass index, breast density, Ashkenazi background, as well as things others have mentioned. You could include a BMI calculator. I always had issues with my mammograms needing more tests. I have colon, ovarian and breast cancer in my family and also have Ashkenazi background.
I was on Tamoxifen as I couldn't tolerate the AIs. Since my mastectomy my doctor is taking me off it and switching to Evista. Interesting tamoxifen may not work with lobular. -
While the BMI calculators are useful, they are not completely accurate. They do not allow for "in-between" measurements of height. Ex. I am 5' 3.5" at one dr's office they use 5'3" at another they use 5' 4". That makes a huge difference in my overall BMI. I go from overweight at first dr's to well within the healthy weight range at the second. A third dr has my height at 63.1 and I have no idea where they got that from, it should be 63.5.... When I do the actual calculation out with the exact height, I am within a healthy BMI. -
Robin, I lost a lot of weight in treatment, but I happen to like being skinny, so I basically have tried to stay that way. For a while my onc was bitching about it, so I used to tell him I was a CM shorter than I really am
-
Saturday night after the most snowfall in Jerusalem since the 50's. huge excitement. Everyone working together to help those without power. What some snow can do!!!
Momine, great idea. This thread is already so interesting. Think we should add family hx of any cancer. My dad has leukemia 2x and prostate ca. Died of second leukemia last year. Mom survived lung ca. Grandfather died of stomach ca. Also always had dense breasts. Type A+ blood. -
Dx'd two weeks before my 52nd birthday, peri-meno at the time. ER/PR+, HER2- Pleomorphic ILC Had it not been found then, most likely would have become multi-focal and multi-type since same breast had other areas of ALH along with ADH.
Ironically, the BC side was NOT the problem child breast. Right side always had more Fibrocystic issues and a prior biopsy. Thankfully, Mother did not take DES. -
Momine, love the idea of a survey. I should add that I had dense breasts and so does my mother. She went through menopause very early in her 40s and had so many cysts that her doctor put her on evista. She now believes this is why she never developed BC.
Many of the risk factors we are discussing here are same for any type of BC. For lobular, it is common for women to be diagnosed between the ages of 45-55. But since many of us suspect the cancer was around for years before, maybe those numbers should really look like 40-55? So does it have something to do with proximity to menopause?
I was listening to a radio show where a breast surgeon was discussing the rise in breast cancer among younger women. She was saying that breasts are not completely mature until a woman gives birth. Since women are not giving birth until later, the breasts are more susceptible to toxins from food and alcohol. Guilty as charged for me in my twenties!
I did breast feed both babies, but obviously did not help for me. -
I had that fateful mammo on my 57th birthday - 4 years of HRT after many years on the pill. One of the very special Triple positive girls. Also suspect I may be a DES daughter but my mother is too old to be sure of what she was given.
-
i was 44 at dx, big 6cm tumor. never overweight, competitive runner, never on pill. first child at 27 and second when 31. breast feed both. although i drank when younger not a lot, now very rarely. Sister and grandmother and aunt but braca negative. low cholestrol, no insulin issues. extremely dense breast, which i read recently is an independant risk factor -
Adding more. As stated above, I was 49 at diagnosis. I have never been a healthy BMI. Not a big drinker as of late, but did drink in my teens (bad girl). Apparently, I had density issues, but no one ever told me until I read it after the diagnosis. Every year I flew through the mammo, never any extra pics, never a call back, never a recommendation for 6 month screenings. 8 months later, I was diagnosed. I also ran behind what we called the "mosquito man" in my youth. Fibroids were picked up on my CT scan at diagnosis.
Two interesting things, at least to me. Any birth control I ever used took away my periods, even low estrogen progesterone birth control pills. The time would come for a period, and it would not come. The doctors told me that was okay. I then went on Mirena the last 10 years before diagnosis, which is a progesterone infused IUD. I wanted a tubal ligation, but was refused that and told this would be "easier". Again, no periods. I rarely had a period from the time my son was born in 1991 until diagnosis--only if I was in between birth control methods.
The other thing is that I definitely have had that combo of things called metabolic syndrome--high blood pressure, overweight, every now and then a bad cholesterol, always had high triglycerides. I had blood sugar problems, but with low blood sugar. I also had a 9'5" baby which is indicative of future diabetic problems down the road. I think I've probably had excess insulin for quite awhile. There seems to be a role for insulin in this whole mess. I breastfed my son for 2 months. I was 29 when I had him. -
Momine - Love the idea of an informal Survey!
Categories
- All Categories
- 679 Advocacy and Fund-Raising
- 289 Advocacy
- 68 I've Donated to Breastcancer.org in honor of....
- Test
- 322 Walks, Runs and Fundraising Events for Breastcancer.org
- 5.6K Community Connections
- 282 Middle Age 40-60(ish) Years Old With Breast Cancer
- 53 Australians and New Zealanders Affected by Breast Cancer
- 208 Black Women or Men With Breast Cancer
- 684 Canadians Affected by Breast Cancer
- 1.5K Caring for Someone with Breast cancer
- 455 Caring for Someone with Stage IV or Mets
- 260 High Risk of Recurrence or Second Breast Cancer
- 22 International, Non-English Speakers With Breast Cancer
- 16 Latinas/Hispanics With Breast Cancer
- 189 LGBTQA+ With Breast Cancer
- 152 May Their Memory Live On
- 85 Member Matchup & Virtual Support Meetups
- 375 Members by Location
- 291 Older Than 60 Years Old With Breast Cancer
- 177 Singles With Breast Cancer
- 869 Young With Breast Cancer
- 50.4K Connecting With Others Who Have a Similar Diagnosis
- 204 Breast Cancer with Another Diagnosis or Comorbidity
- 4K DCIS (Ductal Carcinoma In Situ)
- 79 DCIS plus HER2-positive Microinvasion
- 529 Genetic Testing
- 2.2K HER2+ (Positive) Breast Cancer
- 1.5K IBC (Inflammatory Breast Cancer)
- 3.4K IDC (Invasive Ductal Carcinoma)
- 1.5K ILC (Invasive Lobular Carcinoma)
- 999 Just Diagnosed With a Recurrence or Metastasis
- 652 LCIS (Lobular Carcinoma In Situ)
- 193 Less Common Types of Breast Cancer
- 252 Male Breast Cancer
- 86 Mixed Type Breast Cancer
- 3.1K Not Diagnosed With a Recurrence or Metastases but Concerned
- 189 Palliative Therapy/Hospice Care
- 488 Second or Third Breast Cancer
- 1.2K Stage I Breast Cancer
- 313 Stage II Breast Cancer
- 3.8K Stage III Breast Cancer
- 2.5K Triple-Negative Breast Cancer
- 13.1K Day-to-Day Matters
- 132 All things COVID-19 or coronavirus
- 87 BCO Free-Cycle: Give or Trade Items Related to Breast Cancer
- 5.9K Clinical Trials, Research News, Podcasts, and Study Results
- 86 Coping with Holidays, Special Days and Anniversaries
- 828 Employment, Insurance, and Other Financial Issues
- 101 Family and Family Planning Matters
- Family Issues for Those Who Have Breast Cancer
- 26 Furry friends
- 1.8K Humor and Games
- 1.6K Mental Health: Because Cancer Doesn't Just Affect Your Breasts
- 706 Recipe Swap for Healthy Living
- 704 Recommend Your Resources
- 171 Sex & Relationship Matters
- 9 The Political Corner
- 874 Working on Your Fitness
- 4.5K Moving On & Finding Inspiration After Breast Cancer
- 394 Bonded by Breast Cancer
- 3.1K Life After Breast Cancer
- 806 Prayers and Spiritual Support
- 285 Who or What Inspires You?
- 28.7K Not Diagnosed But Concerned
- 1K Benign Breast Conditions
- 2.3K High Risk for Breast Cancer
- 18K Not Diagnosed But Worried
- 7.4K Waiting for Test Results
- 603 Site News and Announcements
- 560 Comments, Suggestions, Feature Requests
- 39 Mod Announcements, Breastcancer.org News, Blog Entries, Podcasts
- 4 Survey, Interview and Participant Requests: Need your Help!
- 61.9K Tests, Treatments & Side Effects
- 586 Alternative Medicine
- 255 Bone Health and Bone Loss
- 11.4K Breast Reconstruction
- 7.9K Chemotherapy - Before, During, and After
- 2.7K Complementary and Holistic Medicine and Treatment
- 775 Diagnosed and Waiting for Test Results
- 7.8K Hormonal Therapy - Before, During, and After
- 50 Immunotherapy - Before, During, and After
- 7.4K Just Diagnosed
- 1.4K Living Without Reconstruction After a Mastectomy
- 5.2K Lymphedema
- 3.6K Managing Side Effects of Breast Cancer and Its Treatment
- 591 Pain
- 3.9K Radiation Therapy - Before, During, and After
- 8.4K Surgery - Before, During, and After
- 109 Welcome to Breastcancer.org
- 98 Acknowledging and honoring our Community
- 11 Info & Resources for New Patients & Members From the Team