AMERICAN IDOL...Season 12 & The Voice...Season 4

I'm still awake but did everyone else fall asleep on me? I would more than understand a little do unto others! ; )

Ut Ohhhhhh! Which group is which????? If Angies group is the top oh my! Kree will have made it another week!

That's the surprise!!!!!!

YEAH for julz too, she stayed awake!!   Goodnight ladies, a pleasure as always, see you for The Voice, on for three days, HOORAY.

Sheila yeah I wonder Who was the lowest!



Karen yes they kept Kree!!! I think she felt safer when she walked out to Angies group. Relief! I know Candace was worried about not being in that group!

Nite Sheila! We will have to see I don't know but I'm thinking you might be right!

Sheila hahaha they don't give trouble about the show but my books I read THAT is a whole nother story!

sheila, I think you are right, it'll come down to Kree and Angie, I wonder if Angie will do both songs on the piano.  Kree knew she was safe when she stood next to Angie, and since I am doing a clothe's critique tonight, I think Amber had a wedgie, talk about short and tight - wow.

Cookiegal, the only ranking was Amber and Candice  as the bottom two and Kree and Angie as the top two, then Ryan announced no one was going home, that since the judges didn't use their save, thus eliminating one week from the schedule, no one was leaving this week.

I like all of the top 4, glad they didn't have to send anyone home this week. but Angie is  still my top favorite to win. she was fantastic in both her songs.

anne

So, last week was their last chance to use the save then.  Because last night wasn't really a save, no one sang for the judges.  They just had an extra week and said, "Everybody's safe!" which was really anticlimactic.

So the real thing is they basically slapped Janelle in the face last week and said, "No, we're not using our save on you even though this is the last possible week."  They still would have ended up with the same number of girls today, and Janelle might have been able to sing her way back into the competition - she would have had another chance.

Like you said, Elimar, this way Candice and Amber are starting in the hole - this does an injustice to them, too.

Are the producers on AI thinking, how can we possibly alienate our fan base even more?

That's why I was so mad when my DVR cut off last week.  How on earth did they justify not using the save when it was the last week?  Did Ryan question them about it?

Amen Sheila!! you said it well  the judges and producers have doomed this show this year by messing with something that wasn't broke and by adding the likes of NM and MC and the other big mistake... "Listening to the press say that NM was the savior for the show" I mean really? Do these people not look at ratings, do they not read blogs, do the not look at twitter and facebook? Hello!!! It's out there... people in the age that should be watching this show and liking this show, voting and enjoying this show have LEFT the Building!!!! they have all said it's boring, terrible judging this year and most have said that they sent home many singers that should have made the top 10 and picked mediocre singers.  There were a few that they got right, but there were a few they just plain got wrong.  Another big mistake they made was not letting the audience vote on who made it through to the top 10... it's always been this way and it shouldn't have changed this year.  JMO and millions of others of course.  The producers should have realized that they couldn't turn AI into a show closely resembling the Voice.  That is a seperate entitiy unto itself. I don't want another voice... I want the old Idol