My sister invited me to "Survivor" Day - why am I so irritated?

Options
clariceak
clariceak Member Posts: 752

My younger sister had an earlier stage of BC before me and has passed the magical 5 year mark.  She is all about pink ribbons, walks and apparently Survivor day when a bunch of women get together in California and celebrate their victory over breast cancer.

I just can't relate.  My tumor markers showed a rise last time I was tested.  I just made an appointment to have them tested again after sticking my head firmly in the sand for the holidays.  One of my bc friends, Ann Silberman (we were dxed the same day) is Stage IV and is feeling weaker after non stop treatment.

I almost find the whole idea of celebrating survivorship offensive and I'm sure there are many people who would disagree and find it reaffirming to join with others.  I don't know. Maybe it's the crappy weather, but I need to find a way to be more diplomatic.

«13

Comments

  • caaclark
    caaclark Member Posts: 936
    edited January 2013

    I think I understand what you mean.  For me, it feels premature to celebrate survivorship-and I'm 7 years out.  I think some of us with more advanced bc are just a little more on edge regarding long term survival.  Because of this, it may be difficult to seem all "survivory" and waving around pink ribbons. 

    There are times when I feel like a survivor but I can't say I would be happy to be celebrating suviving bc with others who have never had chemo or had very, very early stage bc.  I don't think I can relate to them as much as I can relate to someone who is stage II or III.

  • thefuzzylemon
    thefuzzylemon Member Posts: 2,630
    edited January 2013

    I'm with you....100%. First, I can not stand a general "label" or "box"...but more than that...

    Im not a fighter with this disease....its not a fair fight, I didn't instigate anything and I can't even tell when I'm suppose to Bob & weave...

    I'm not a warrior either...this war is billions against one. No thanks.

    And Finally....a "Survivor"....I can't say that I have survived for a lot of reasons. Or, I could say I survived a million things...its just a cheap expression that doesn't feel good to me.

    Mine is advanced as well...I know I'm sensitive but we have gone through the frigging ringer...I feel so connected to my sisters and very disconnected from others. Is that "surviving"?

  • exbrnxgrl
    exbrnxgrl Member Posts: 12,424
    edited January 2013

    Last year, I walked the survivor lap in an ACS Relay for Life event. I looked at it this way, I had survived up to that point.

    Caryn

  • wintersocks
    wintersocks Member Posts: 922
    edited January 2013

    Ladies,

    This is  a really interesting thread. I am glad others object to the term 'survivor'. I am less then 12 months dx, and the label is as alien to me as calling myself a super-model it just doesn't fit on so many levels.

    i am just keeping my head above water, and trying to dodge the bullets at the same time.

    I too am not early bc and am well aware that I could fall into the abyss at any time.  Survival to me is having come through a terrible ordeal of some kind knowing you are now safe and never have to go back to that particular horror again. It implies relief, an ending, a celebration. an act of courage, longevity.

    I'm still whimpering in the corner.    

  • Rachel1
    Rachel1 Member Posts: 363
    edited January 2013

    I find that my anger and irritation from this disease comes out at the strangest times and when I least expect it. My therapist keeps asking me to ask myself if I'm angry at the person, the freakin disease or is anger a response to my fear of the disease.  Can it be all three?? I suspect with what is happening with your friend and your concern about yourself, it's very hard to be happy and celebrate survivor day -- we've seen too much, we know too much.  Big hugs to you. We all have to do what feels right to us. Stay strong and don't let anyone make you feel badly for feeling the way that you do.

    Rachel

  • clariceak
    clariceak Member Posts: 752
    edited January 2013

    Perhaps it is the media coverage of such events.  There seems to be the iconic shot of smiling women dressed in pink hugging, without a care in the world, or so it seems to me.  Maybe I would feel that way if I was an earlier stage and the odds were in my favor.  I certainly believed that before I got breast cancer.  I thought of it as the good cancer, the one that you could survive and maybe I will. 

    But I don't think I'll ever have the confidence that see in those women's faces.  The true belief that they have "beaten" cancer.  I am grateful to be alive and for every year I'm here to help my girls  (11) & (14) grow up.

    I told my sister flat out that I have a bad attitude when it comes to such events, so hopefully she won't bring it up with me again

  • Moiralf
    Moiralf Member Posts: 1,056
    edited January 2013

    I agree totally with just about everything above.

    The term "survivor" is ridiculous and has no meaning in any real sense. If I am fighting this I would like to at lest be able to see what I am fighting. I can't,as far as I can see I'm just along for the ride and I can't "fight". I can live with it and not let it dominate every waking thought and not let the fear steal any of my precious time but that's about it.

    I have lost family members to cancer and give money to help research and to provide services for cancer patients but I will never go to a rally and I will never march in any sort of "survivor" walk. I refuse point blank to be labeled like that and I fail to see any benefit to it. Like I want others to gawk at me while I stride along waving to the sidelines. 

    Now I'm getting cross so I think I will go and have a nice cup of tea and finish mumbling to myself.

    Moira

  • pupfoster1
    pupfoster1 Member Posts: 1,484
    edited January 2013

    Boy am I with you 110% Clarice. I can't find ANYTHING worth celebrating about this disease!  I'm going through a scare right now and have an appt with my onc later today.  Being stage III I think we feel like we've dodged a bullet, and not to minimize anyones journey at a lower stage, but they just didn't experience what we did.  I've said it before, it's like true PTSD. We were hit with the big guns and now I freak out at the thought of having to go through tx again, or worse.  I think it's just that we are apples and they are oranges.  We are just different, and everyone has their own way of dealing with things.  I guess we (and they) have to learn to be polite and respect how personal this is and that we all deal with it differently.

    But for me I find NOTHING to celebrate about having to be here!!! (other than meeting all of you lovely ladies :))

    Take care,

    Sharon

  • hopefour
    hopefour Member Posts: 459
    edited January 2013

    I don't refer to myself as a breast cancer survivor....I don't know if I have survived, if the battle is over, whether there is a second battle coming.....I don't feel victorious which is what I would want to feel if I was a survivor!! I am a fighter. But, am happy for others who feel they are survivors and may well be. I grieve my children have to see pink everywhere in their day to day lives....reminds them of their fear of their mom dying! But, realize the pink comforts and brings joy to others! BC is really such a personal journey for each!

  • kathleen1966
    kathleen1966 Member Posts: 793
    edited January 2013

    I want to be a "forgetter" instead.  I want to forget all about the cancer and I want the cancer to forget all about me. And I am lucky to still be in a position to have this attitude, and I know it. I went on a breast cancer walk the first year (what walk is not important).  Never again.  I know that there are women who really feel empowered by these types of groups/walks/pink/ta ta and if that is what helps them than they should continue to meet and celebrate their survivor-ship. And I think you either ARE one of these types of women or you're not.  You are not. I am not. There is absolutely nothing wrong with thanking your sister for the invite and then just saying that these types of things do not help you and that, for you, it is more helpful to NOT attend. When I walked in a breast cancer walk, I went all out with pink-ness.  Pink boas, pink hats, pink for my friends (I am cringing even writing it now). When I got there and I saw 40,000 people and I marched in an enormous parade of survivors and ate doughnuts and pink yogurt in a tent (that was already being taken down when I finished the walk with giant pink tumbleweeds blowing everywhere that spoke and said "we don't really care about you in particular" ) and then I saw the news story, all happy, all power, all poo poo (insert pink tumbleweed comment here as well), I felt deeply, deeply devastated...and then highly, highly pissed off. So I went from one type of woman to the other type of woman in one day. My eyes "opened". It is perfectly ok for you to not want to be a part of this. 

  • Celtic_Spirit
    Celtic_Spirit Member Posts: 748
    edited January 2013

    I'm with Kathleen, I'm a breast cancer "forgetter," too. I like looking in my rear-view mirror and seeing that sucker laying by the side of the road. Each year, it gets more distant. And I hope it stays that way!

    Some people are joiners. Some aren't. Some find the whole pink thing empowering. Some, like me, just find it annoying. To each her own, but no one should feel pressured into "pink pride" when it makes her feel uncomfortable.

  • Elizabeth1959
    Elizabeth1959 Member Posts: 346
    edited January 2013

    I agree with everything said on this thread. I am annoyed by the term survivor. I actually can identify with the idea of being a victim before being a survivor. I like the color pink, but I refuse to wear it in conjunction with breast cancer. Cancer is ugly, scary and outside of my control. I attend a support group and that's it

  • jennyboog
    jennyboog Member Posts: 1,322
    edited January 2013

    I agree...victim not survivor.  I'm just not into all the "happy, happy, bubblegum pink survivor" stuff.  It seems to much like a party or celebration to me and BC was anything but that.  I deal with and live with what BC has done to me and to my life everyday, it's nothing to celebrate.  We all deal with survivorship in our own way but it's just not for me, I get why a stage I-er would though.

  • ohio4me
    ohio4me Member Posts: 491
    edited January 2013

    Last year, before I finished radiation, the receptionist asked me to attend a chili cook-off that was raising money for Relay for Life. AND - if I wore the shirt I could get in free! WooHoo! I'm being facetious - I rebelled against being called a survivor - I was still bald from chemo, my chest had open wounds from radiation, I couldn't stay awake past 6 PM and I was a survivor?!

    Well - I did go because my healthcare team is so wonderful. Got in free - ate my chili and left. I know many people that survived more in life than I have. A friend has struggled with cerebral palsy her entire life - she is in a wheelchair - has never walked and smiles all the time. She has outlived the odds - she is a survivor.

    I don't think I'll ever put myself in a 'survivor' category. I had cancer. I did everything I could to fight it. Today there is NED. It's confusing. I was to support my family/friends but don't want to be the 'token' BC survivor.

    Well, I could go on, but.... don't like to be classified as a survivor but I will go be the BC survivor because it means something to my family/friends. I'll do it with a smile and then come home and say 'never again'.....until next time.

  • DCMom
    DCMom Member Posts: 624
    edited January 2013

    I walked in the local High Schools all night cancer walk when I was a year out of chemo.  I registered with a group and planned not to "out" myself as this is a personal journey and I didn't want to flag my status as a, for lack of a better term, "survivor".  One of my team members decided to take it upon herself to "out" me so I was forced to march around the high school auditorium for the "survivor lap" and introduce myself and how long I had been cancer free.  I wanted to crawl under a table as this was so out of my comfort zone to share my personal story.  I come to these boards because we are all in the same boat and you all get it.  I hate the sympathy looks and the curiosity/poor taste questions.  Hmmm...I supose similar to the questions forcing the reliving of a rape.  Yes cancer raped me of my security, it attacked me from the shadows, it mutilated my body, it stole my youth (ok maybe just my middle ageWink), and it has left me scared to death that it will happen again.  

    Victim, yes...Survivor, somedays...wishing to forget, always.

    As much as I disliked the initial survivor walk the night was an equally distasteful experience.  Who in their right mind would think "let's line the walk with the "survivors" that lost their battle with cancer.  How empowering to see all of the people who have GONE before me.  (Yes now I am just getting cheeky).  Anyone care to put up a screen full of statistics based on staging to really depress me ALL NIGHT LONG!

    I now tell people about this experience when they bring up a walk.  I still love to participate in events for other medical needs, but cancer walks are way too PTSD for me.  I agree with Kathleen on prefering to be a "forgetter" (and not just because of chemo brain Laughing)  To those of you who feel empowered...Thank you for representing for me and for bringing awareness, but as for me I would prefer to stick my head in the sand, stick my rear high in the air, and let cancer kiss my A## (derriereYell).  

  • ohio4me
    ohio4me Member Posts: 491
    edited January 2013

    DCMom - laughing out loud, here. You have a way with wordsSmile

  • Moiralf
    Moiralf Member Posts: 1,056
    edited January 2013

    Oh yes, Dcmom,

    I totally agree with what you say. I would be horrified to be put in that position. And pictures of those who have died around the walls?

    Your imagery is wonderful.

    Ohio4me, Yes I know people who have "suffered" and have a wonderful outlook on life. I'm pretty sure none of them or us want pity and attention drawn to us that way.

    Moira

  • Outfield
    Outfield Member Posts: 1,109
    edited January 2013

    Oh, DC Mom, I would have been mortified.  I hate the word "survivor" and I hate the words "cancer free."  Maybe it would be different if my cancer had been "caught early" (hate those words too), but I know I have a high risk of recurrence.  I know there are probably slumbering tumor cells all over my body listening to the lullaby of my Arimidex.  If I felt like I could be sure the hell of my cancer experience were over, then maybe I could embrace those terms, but realistically I can't.  My challenge is learning to live fully, yet wisely, with that uncertainty.  

    I also don't like the words "warrior" and "battle."  Yes, I feel like I "fought," but it was a like a playground fight with a kid three years older.  I am messed up by my treatment.  I've got a number of things permanently wrong with me as a result of the treatment, not as a result of the cancer itself.  I sure do feel more like a victim.

    "Survivor" is almost a taunt, because it just reminds me I don't believe it.  The "me" that was diagnosed is gone, and I have no guarantee the bully won't kick me again.  I do a better job of forgetting and living my life fully without that kind of euphemistic hype.

  • fredntan
    fredntan Member Posts: 1,821
    edited January 2013

    I want no part of these walks. We have been through toonmuch. I remember crying in the bathroom last winter.

    Friends didnt call. Even that friend that started raising money for a komen walk before i fou d my bc, even she fell off face of earth. Hippocrite. She only walked to make herself feelbetter

    My work did a video for some pink thing. They tried to make bc cute. Made me sick

  • Momine
    Momine Member Posts: 7,859
    edited January 2013

    DCmom, you gave me several chuckles (being robbed of middle age, and I can relate, lol), but lining the walk with the "fallen"? I am truly speechless.

  • 1Athena1
    1Athena1 Member Posts: 6,696
    edited January 2013

    No matter which way I look at it, the term survivor seems so inapppropriate.

    First, it's disingenuous because it assumes that nobody dies of BC. If you are an early stager, it assumes that you won't recur.

    Secondly, NO ONE dies of stage IIB cancer - why call me a survivor for something that, at the given stage, was never a threat to my life? Medically my life could be much more at risk from a bad flu.

    Thirdly, a real "survivor" is someone who comes out alive despite an experience that should have/could have killed them, such as a massive heart attack or a plane crash. To compare my stage IIB experience with those is an insult to the plane crash and heart attack victims.

    No one survives stage IV. You LIVE with it, but you don't out-live it, which is what surviving means.

    So when I hear people talking about "bc survivors" I wonder, who in the hell are they referring to?

    And don't get me started on the "fighter" and "warrior" labels....my reaction is like thefuzzylemon's.

  • blondiex46
    blondiex46 Member Posts: 5,712
    edited January 2013

    FINALLY, PEOPLE THAT UNDERSTAND, just had this conversation with someone....hate the word survivor am I one, but not for this, I survived raising 5 kids as a single parent.....I am stage 4 and it is a recurrence after 14 years, so maybe I survived through the 14 years but really....I do do the Susan G. Koman Race for the Cure, but will say that I didn't go to the first one until 1999, 3 years after the diagnosed and I finished chemo is April of 1997, had to do it when I was ready....can't stand pink, October is annoying, the whole month....don't have to get mammograms anymore so that is something...sorry if I offended anyone, got chemo today, steroids, it is 430am have been up since 1130pm after a nap.....

    Sandy

  • RosesToeses
    RosesToeses Member Posts: 721
    edited January 2013

    Somehow feels great to hear so many of you feel like this too, even though it's kind of a cruddy way to feel. People keep telling me about other people they know who had BC however many years ago and are doing great--at first it was nice to hear but now it just bugs me because as I've been living this beast and learning more, I question in my mind the stage these people were and assume it was probably not stage III or IV. It doesn't feel like comfort, it just feels like they have no idea what this is really all about with me. Like they're confusing what we have with some other disease.



    And that's what survivor celebrations feel like to me, like it has nothing to do with the disease we have, that all these happy pink princesses survived something else (and I know that may not be true, and I know other stages are also hard and deadly and everything, but it's just how I feel). It just seems so misleading in so many ways.



    So, yeah, Clarice, I don't think it's strange or wrong to want nothing to do with that celebration. I'd feel the same way.

  • misswim
    misswim Member Posts: 931
    edited January 2013

    Clarice, hope I am not butting in here. I was diagnosed stage iia in 2011. I am an early stager yes, but I had an oncotype score of 42- a 25 % percent recurrence risk with tamoxifen. I had far more chemo than most people at my stage because of that fact. I have almost 2 years with no issue, but I am constantly waiting for the other shoe to drop. I particpated in the Avon walk last year and I flip flopped. I walk 39.3 miles in two days because I think I was trying to prove to myself that I am a survivor. And I did well, until less than a mile before the finish a volunteer stopped me and threw a giant pink ribbon around my neck, in memory of a woman who died- and they do this every seven minutes to someone during the whole weekend. I lost it. Cried my way to the finish, cried through the survivor parade and the closing ceremonies and for days after. 

    I aloow myself to live my life, and I try to live in the present moment. But I do not prescribe to the fact that I won't have to deal with again. I don't think I am a survivor. I think I live with breast cancer, be it active or not. Do I hope that I will "survive"? Of course I do. But I don't need nor want the pressure of a label to have to live up to. 

    I totally understand why you said no. I can't even think of going to a Relay for Life. They are overwhelming and the survivor lap feels like a display. 

  • DCMom
    DCMom Member Posts: 624
    edited January 2013

    Oh my gosh.  So good to be able to vent to those who won't think, "but geez we are just trying to do a good thing for a good cause".  Oh come on...

    FrednTan-  You should feel blessed those komen walking, fundraising friends didn't continue to keep contact.  I had a friend whose Mother-In-Law was a "did that breast cancer thing" .  Her MIL had even written a book that was so empowering to me.  I certainly thought my friend would get it.  She had been a fundraising fiend because of her MIL, but when my diagnosing came she mysteriously disappeared.  Her kids had all but lived at my house (happily keeping hers all tidy), but when this occurred she did not even offer to help out with mine once.  She actually lived next door (please imagine me shaking my head in dispair).  This "do good for the cause" friend did however take evey chance encounter to inform me of every stage 4 she heard about and felt I was interested in hearing how poorly they were doing, how she was helping to raise money for them, how I certainly would like to contribute since I was just like them, and then to finally finish it off pointing out how there was no hope. Thank you very much.  I'll add her to my list of things to forget.   Calgon (or chemo brain) take me away.

    Outfield- Loved the Arimidex Lullabye. Are there lyrics or is it just hummed.  I assume something like:

    Rock-a-bye maybe,

    In the dark spot,

    Where the pill goes

    The cancer will stop.

    (sad at this point I had to you tube the song because I couldn't remember the second part.)

    When the nights over

    La di di da

    I'll have forgotten

    The words to this songLaughing

    I, however, am currently hoping for a Tamoxifen Ether for my baby brats.

  • DCMom
    DCMom Member Posts: 624
    edited January 2013

    Oh and msswim the giant pink ribbons?

  • Lily55
    Lily55 Member Posts: 3,534
    edited January 2013

    Wow I don´t feel so alone and crabby now - I am spitting mad that an ugly cruel disfiguring disease like BC hi-jacked the lovely colour pink and prettified it, it is so NOT a pretty disease.....I hate all the happy clappy stuff around BC - it makes people blase about it, they say cruddy things like "I know loads of people who had breast cancer, they had great recons and are looking better than ever, just stay positive"...........

    I allowed myself to be talked out of getting an oncotype as I had decided to refuse chemo anyway but now I wish I knew - I read that only 10% of breast cancers respond to chemo fully but that seems too low to be true - I still think I would make the same decision again given MY wider personal health status and idiosyncrasies, but as stage 3A do feel hunted by cancer.........and get PTSD at the drop of a hat - a song called "Lean on me" the other day had me going again as I don´t want to lean on cancer charities, I don´t want cancer and recurrence scares the life out of me and as for dying of BC well don´t go there.......and I hate all this partying around BC.....I am not a survivor or a hero just a reluctant struggling angry person who got cancer and hates how its left her...

    One big question - it seems a lot of you have also not announced your cancer to the world?  I made that decision also as I wanted some areas of life to be the same and not be constantly asked how I am.......

  • NancyD
    NancyD Member Posts: 3,562
    edited January 2013

    Eight months before I was diagnosed with BC, I did a half-marathon through Leukemia & Lymphoma Association's Team In Training. A close friend was very active with them and got me involved with the local chapter.



    After my breast cancer diagnosis, I told her I would not be participating any more, that I would be focusing my time on breast cancer. Obviously, it was a personal choice for me to pick the cancer that had almost taken my life. I think she was slightly hurt that I would drop them. Tough.



    My support does not extend to any more marathons or relays. I'm just not into them, and I do not like putting myself "out there" as a cancer survivor for all the reasons mentioned in other posts.



    I will talk about my treatment to another person going through it. I feel reaching out and giving emotional and informational aid is far more useful than any "survivor's lap".

  • BirdyRobin
    BirdyRobin Member Posts: 105
    edited January 2013

    I am stage IIIB I had to do a biopsy on Monday I find out the result tomorrow. I am still living day to day with this disease. Fighting? Ya I suppose I am fighting to survive because I refuse to lay down and be whipped by it. Somethings about all the hype annoy me. Celebrities, somehow annoy me, I am not even sure why, they just do. Pink dosnt bother me anymore than red for heart disease doesnt (my brother died from heart disease). Sometimes I have wanted to take a vacation from all this and get away, yet I cant get away from it because it is always right there with me. I want to burry my head and forget but as I said its always right there with me. Glad we all have a place to say it like it is, though.

    Robin

  • blondiex46
    blondiex46 Member Posts: 5,712
    edited January 2013

    yep we do Robyn....and you can't live your life as around cancer, it is so not healthy, I try not to think about it and talk about it, I will say...I don't feel like talking about it now, or enough or I am done not talking about it anymore...take a vacation from it..

    Sandy

Categories