Lymphedema Treatment 101 - Questions from a Newbie

Options
guitarhero25
guitarhero25 Member Posts: 3
edited January 2016 in Lymphedema

Hi everybody,

I'm new to treating lymphedema, and I have some questions I hope you guys can help with.

Background: I was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2007, but it only presented in the lymph nodes in my left armpit (occult breast cancer). I had 25 lymph nodes removed during surgery. For four years, I have had no problems with lymphedema. But in the last year, I've noticed lymphedema in my left arm. The swelling is still relatively minimal, but I want to understand my options for treatment now before it gets worse. I have been to see a lymphedema therapist twice. I'm 44, thin, physically fit and active, and eat healthy.

 The therapist recommended manual lymph drainage and a Tubigrip sleeve. Here are my questions:

 - Once you start experiencing lymphedema, can you expect to always have some degree of lymphedema (even after taking all precautionary measures, exercising, and wearing a tubigrip or compression sleeve)? Or is it possible to eliminate lymphedema entirely from the limb (and if lymphedema persists, you're not doing enough)?

- I've seen references to wrapping throughout this forum. My therapist did not talk to me about wrapping. Is wrapping general recommended for people are experiencing more advanced lymphedema?

- I've noticed that my hand is pretty swollen in the morning, which makes sense since I'm wearing a sleeve that doesn't completely cover the hand. Is there a complete sleeve that includes a glove? Or do you have to get a separate glove to accompany the sleeve (for example, I've seen a reference to Isotoner Full Finger Therapeutic gloves)?

- Can you recommend an alternative to Tubigrip? Tubigrip gets grubby pretty quickly.

Love this website and forum! Thanks for in advance for any tips and responses!

 Michelle 

Comments

  • o2bhealthy
    o2bhealthy Member Posts: 2,101
    edited June 2012

    Michelle I had to google the Tubigrip sleeve...never heard of it.   There is a great resource that can answer some of your questions

    http://www.stepup-speakout.org/

    My understanding is that once you have LE, it is like any other chronic condition...you will always have it however it can be managed.

    Many of the women on this board have 'stubborn' LE and it can be very difficult to make it behave, lymph fluid is SLOW and STUPID and sometimes we get blindsided by a flare (which can throw me into a physical and emotional tailspin)... 

    I have bilateral and truncal LE but my right arm is more pronounce and my fingers tends to swell on that side only...I ALWAYS wear a glove with my sleeve on the right and a gauntlet on my left hand.  Finding a qualified therapist to help you select the correct garments is very important http://www.stepup-speakout.org/Finding_a_Qualified_Lymphedema_Therapist.htm

    There are many variations of sleeves, gloves and gauntlets... http://www.stepup-speakout.org/Lymphedema_garments.htm  

    it is very important that the garments find correctly as a poor fitting sleeve and do more damage then good http://www.stepup-speakout.org/sleeves_gauntlets_for_lymphedema.htm

    Good luck!

  • Momine
    Momine Member Posts: 7,859
    edited June 2012

    You should wear a glove, yes. My lymphedema is mild, and after wearing a sleeve for about 6 months with frequent PT I am now able to go about most activities without the sleeve and I do not go to PT regularly anymore either.

    However, I still need the sleeve for flying, the gym and any other heavy activity.  Also, the lymphedema does act up every so often and then I have to deal with it, rest, fluids, MLD etc. In fact, it has been annoying the last 2-3 days. Nothing dire, but my armpits feel funky.

    So, it is, unfortunately, a chronic problem, but one that can be managed and, in many cases, alleviated greatly. 

  • Moderators
    Moderators Member Posts: 25,912
    edited June 2012

    GuitarHero,

    In addition to the helpful advice you've received here, don't forget to check out the main Breastcancer.org site and our new, extensive Lymphedema section for tons of great info on avoiding, treating, and managing lymphedema.

    Hope this helps!

    --The Mods

  • kira66715
    kira66715 Member Posts: 4,681
    edited June 2012

    guitarhero, some of the PT's use tubigrip, but it's just a stop gap IMO.

    The full treatment toolbox consists of : 1)manual lymphatic drainage--by a therapist and teach you home techniques,2) bandaging if limb volume reduction is needed, for night time swelling, and to have in the tool box to manage flares, 3)official compression garments for daytime use--with hand swelling, that would be a sleeve and glove, and 4) therapeutic exercises.

    It's called complete decongestive therapy, or CDT.

    Far too many therapists take short cuts and don't realize that lymphedema is a clinical diagnosis and there is no standard measurement that defines severity, and the greatest risk for severe lymphedema, is having mild lymphedema.

    I would go back to that therapist, or check out her credentials and go to a qualified therapist (135 hours of training, although that's no guarantee of excellence...)

    http://www.stepup-speakout.org/Finding_a_Qualified_Lymphedema_Therapist.htm

    And insist on complete treatment--which includes addressing night time swelling, learning how to bandage, and formal, official, well fitted compression garments:

    http://www.stepup-speakout.org/treatments_for_lymphedema.htm

    http://www.stepup-speakout.org/proper_fitting_of_lymphedema_garments.htm

    I'd go armed with the official NLN position paper on treatment:

    http://www.lymphnet.org/lymphedemaFAQs/positionPapers.htm

    Far too many LE therapists, think that to justify insurance coverage, you have to have a 2 cm increase in size or a 10% volume increase, and that is not scientifically proven, and any swelling deserves the full evaluation: you may not need to be in bandages to reduce limb volume, but swelling isn't "just swelling", lymph fluid in the tissues causes inflammation and fibrosis and shouldn't be allowed to happen night after night.

    Please let us know how you make out.

    Kira

  • guitarhero25
    guitarhero25 Member Posts: 3
    edited June 2012

    Thanks SO much for your advice! I had a feeling that I wasn't getting the whole picture from my PT, and sure am glad that I found this forum. I'll check out all the information and links you have provided, and keep you posted.

  • moogie
    moogie Member Posts: 499
    edited June 2012

    I really recommend learning to wrap before you NEED to wrap. I brought a camera and took notes. If you get a flare in swelling a compression sleeve will not help " move the fluid out", but wrapping by its nature will help this process. It is a tool to try to maintain things if you puff, and it is confidence building because it is something concrete you can do to manage the condition. Also it takes a long while where I live to get a slot for LE PT-----so I can wrap when waiting for a PT session and try to get a hold of things till MLD.

    Keep a set of bandages on hand just in case.

  • guitarhero25
    guitarhero25 Member Posts: 3
    edited June 2012

    Hi everybody,

    I wanted to give you an updated on what I've learned in the last few days. Thanks again for all the links you provided--I learned way more than I learned from my therapist. My therapist is not a PT, she's a Certified Manual Lymph Drainage Therapist (in fairness to her, I remember that she specifically said she is not a PT, she's a CMLDT). I called her yesterday to ask her some follow up questions and here's what she said (I'm sharing this with you because I'm very sure this is not an example of a good and helpful therapist):

    Q: When I wear my Tubigrip sleeve at night, my hand is swollen in the morning. What should I do?

    A: 1. Don't wear the sleeve at night, or 2. Wear the sleeve but buy a weight lifting glove to wear with it. (She specifically told me previously that I should always wear my sleeve at night.)

    Q: Can't I get a compression sleeve with a glove?

    A:  If you want to get a compression sleeve, order one online. Get one with 30-40 compression, class 2, and either Juzo or Jobst brands. As far as gloves, gloves are very expensive and can cost up to $1,000.

    Q: So I can just go online and order a sleeve? Don't you need to measure me? And isn't there an Isotoner support glove I could get (which I saw for $16 on Amazon)?

    A: Sure, if you want me to measure you, I can. (She then gave me guidelines on measuring myself.) And oh yes, you can get an Isotoner but make sure it fits properly.

    She still never talked about wrapping, and didn't in any way encourage me to come back in to continue sessions with her....which I'm not! I'm looking for a different therapist. Meanwhile, I haven't been wearing my Tubigrip at all because it makes my hand swollen and doesn't seem to help with bringing down the swelling anyway. I'm feeling very frustrated because she hasn't been helpful at all and seems so lackadaisical. I guess I was just supposed to be satisfied for the rest of my life with the three Tubigrip sleeves she gave me.

    Wish me luck in finding a new PT!

     Michelle 

  • carol57
    carol57 Member Posts: 3,567
    edited June 2012

    Michelle, can you hear me muttering from afar?  This is a ridiculous example of what is so wrong with LE care access!  Looking for a qualified therapist can feel like going to Vegas...you drop your coin in the slot and if you are very, very lucky, all your fruits line up and you get rewarded with help instead of harm.

    We should not have to find quality therapists by the trial-and-error method.  I am so sorry this has happened to you.  The right therapist will get you in a sleeve/glove or sleeve/gauntlet combination that fits, and he/she will provide the rest of the complete decongestive therapy needed to get that swelling down and keep it down, as Kira described.

    If I sigh any louder, I'll rattle the windows...

    Best of luck in your search for a better therapist.

    Carol

  • kira66715
    kira66715 Member Posts: 4,681
    edited June 2012

    Quitar Hero, with the exception of the Vodder school, which strongly encourages every 2 year recertification, there are no quality controls for lymphedema therapists. The stance of the APTA (American Physical Therapy Assoc.) is that ANY PT can treat lymphedema, and so many "weekend wonder" courses are offered.

    Binney once tried to complain to LANA when she felt the care of a LANA certified therapist was poor, and got the response that they just give the test, and she should complain to the licensure board. And with so many health care providers have knowledge deficits about lymphedema treatment, these therapists operate without supervision. 

    It sounds like she's a massage therapist who was trained in lymphedema. But what training.

    I'm actually taking a training course, which is incredibly intense--from Klose--but I could easily see how someone could take it, and it's done in 10 days, and go out and make mistakes. Ironically, I was treated by a Klose trained, LANA certified PT who was horrid. I just found out she took the Klose course in 2008--not all that long before she saw me and gave me lousy treatment and advice.

    This lack of quality control, makes a difficult situation so much harder.

    So, in response to her answers: Q: When I wear my Tubigrip sleeve at night, my hand is swollen in the morning. What should I do?

    A: 1. Don't wear the sleeve at night, or 2. Wear the sleeve but buy a weight lifting glove to wear with it. (She specifically told me previously that I should always wear my sleeve at night.): If you swell at night, you should be bandaged. The wearing of a sleeve without hand protection can cause hand lymphedema.

    Q: Can't I get a compression sleeve with a glove?

    A: If you want to get a compression sleeve, order one online. Get one with 30-40 compression, class 2, and either Juzo or Jobst brands. As far as gloves, gloves are very expensive and can cost up to $1,000.Never get a sleeve without an official fitter measuring you, and they are covered by insurance. And, why is she putting you in a class 2 sleeve, with no hand protection, when you have hand swelling. An off the shelf glove, on line, costs around $150--for a Juzo or a Medi 95, but you need professional measuring, and many women need custom gloves. My custom gloves cost $400 a pair, insurance reimburses in the mid $200 range and I pay 20%. I have a great fitter and the first try required 5 gloves until we got it right--Juzo.

    Q: So I can just go online and order a sleeve? Don't you need to measure me? And isn't there an Isotoner support glove I could get (which I saw for $16 on Amazon)?You can just order a sleeve online, and Jobst comes as small/medium/large, while Juzo and Medi offer multiple sizes. Many women need custom sleeves, and poor fitting compression can trap flud and cause harm.

    A: Sure, if you want me to measure you, I can. (She then gave me guidelines on measuring myself.) And oh yes, you can get an Isotoner but make sure it fits properly.Joe Zuther put on his blog how to measure yourself, but ideally, it should be done by an experienced fitter: http://www.lymphedemablog.com/2011/08/23/measuring-for-compression-arm-sleeves/

    She still never talked about wrapping, and didn't in any way encourage me to come back in to continue sessions with her....which I'm not! I'm looking for a different therapist. Meanwhile, I haven't been wearing my Tubigrip at all because it makes my hand swollen and doesn't seem to help with bringing down the swelling anyway. I'm feeling very frustrated because she hasn't been helpful at all and seems so lackadaisical. I guess I was just supposed to be satisfied for the rest of my life with the three Tubigrip sleeves she gave me.

    She did not get you in perfect control and ready to transition to maintenance phase. She should be reported to whatever board licenses her, as she's potentially harmful. Lymphedema is a chronic disease, and ideally, there should be 6 month check ups for patients in good control, sooner as needed.

    ARGHHHHHH

    Kira

  • Outfield
    Outfield Member Posts: 1,109
    edited June 2012

    Michelle, I've worn tubigrip a lot after orthopedic surgeries and injuries.  It's pretty darn convenient but it is NOTHING like a sleeve that fits well.  

    Insurance coverage of treatment of lymphedema caused by breast cancer treatment is mandated by law.   If your insurance would cover a mastectomy, they have to cover treatment of lymphedema.  I do pay a copay for my sleeves, but nothing has been $1000 out of pocket.  

    I used all the links I could find through Step-Up, Speak-Out and couldn't find a therapist in my dinky city who took my insurance other than the one I was seeing.  I paid out of pocket to see someone for a second opinion, just one visit, and that was helpful.  

    Also, if your hand is swelling with what you are wearing at night, it may actually make sense to stop wearing it while you find a better therapist.  Regular compression sleeves shouldn't be worn at night because without all the movements that we do without thinking about it while awake fluid can get trapped.  I found that out the hard way.  Elevation is something you can do at night that shouldn't make it worse while you wait to be seen.  

    Good luck. 

  • moogie
    moogie Member Posts: 499
    edited June 2012

    Be sure you are not getting rebound swelling from your compression garment. For some of us with sensitivity to compression, a slightly too tight fit will actually CAUSE my hand to swell in reaction. I have this---but was not understanding the " over-compress then over-swell " cycle for a bit. It took me darn near forever, but a custom garment is well worth the trouble if it will help stabilize the swelling. And if you cannot get one---wrapping is not bad once you get the hang of it. For me, it feels better than a garment and it probably treats the arm better because it helps pump the fuid out of the limb. COmpression sleeves just try to keep fluid out--but once it is there you need MLD or a wrapping regime to get it out.

  • bluepearl
    bluepearl Member Posts: 961
    edited December 2015

    What is a wrapping regime?

  • MarieBernice6234
    MarieBernice6234 Member Posts: 202
    edited December 2015

    Hi All,

    I have mild lymphedema in my affected side (right). I have a compression sleeve, and have had cancer rehab therapy. More recently I have noticed an increased swelling in my right hand. It swells up at night, and there is pain in the hand in the morning. I saw my lymphedema specialist yesterday and she gave me a glove for the night time. I have also ordered a gauntlet to wear when I use my sleeve. From what I understand, lymphedema in the hand is hard to get rid of. She thinks that it is weird to have swelling in my hand overnight. Any ideas?


    MarieBernice6234

  • kareenie
    kareenie Member Posts: 339
    edited December 2015

    Compression gloves generally are not recommended to wear at night. She should teach you to wrap. There are also special padded quilted night garments which can help. If you have hand swelling you should wear glove not gauntlet during the day. Kinesiotape on the hand also might help. Sounds like you need a new lymphedema therapist. I will bump some threads addressing the above.

  • MarieBernice6234
    MarieBernice6234 Member Posts: 202
    edited December 2015

    Hi Kareenie -

    The "Compression glove" is actually one that is used for burn patients. It has some element of compression to it, but not so restrictive like the sleeve. I don't think I could wear the glove during the day, because it isn't easy to work with. The gauntlet I could because the fingers are opened andnot closed. Please do bump up the other article, though.


    MarieBernice6234

  • Kicks
    Kicks Member Posts: 4,131
    edited December 2015

    Gloves do not have to cover the entire fingers. My gloves only go to the first joint (not including the joint) and work great. I do have a gauntlet that I use for short times for some activities but it isn't as good for long periods of time. I wear my glove basically all the time I am 'up'. If I am doing 'something' that would get it wet, I either pull it off for a few minutes or pull on a waterproof glove over. When I'm doing 'something' outdoors that I would normally wear my leather work gloves - I just put them over glove. Same with my winter gloves.

    When I get my 2 new gloves/sleeves every 6 months, I rotate the older ones into my boxes (tool boxes in each vehicle/tack boxes/fishing boxes/etc.) so that if I' m out somewhere and need to do something that could get my newest gloves/sleeves dirty/stained from all sorts of things, I just slip into the older ones so the stain doesn't really matter if it doesn't come out in the wash. That keeps the new ones looking nice - not stained up though clean.

    I have to have low compression custom gloves for my hand. Higher level compression makes it puff up like a balloon rapidly (1/2 hr). I do not find my gloves/sleeeves 'restrictive' - don't think about them but they are the right compression level for me and fit me right.

    Day garments (active) and night garments (passive) work on different principles. Day garments are designed to work when being active (day time). Night garments are designed to work when passive (not active/sleeping).

  • zinny
    zinny Member Posts: 281
    edited December 2015

    For all who are dealing with LE, I happened to find a great video on how to do massage/drainage yourself. I had a vaccine on my non-radiated but had lx and node bx side, and my arm got tight and felt like the cording was returning…but i also had a birthday, drank more red wine, ate more salt and exercised less for a few days;) anyhow, it went away, but I did try the massage. Not going to hurt!

    Lymphedema massage video

  • Pricillamylove2211
    Pricillamylove2211 Member Posts: 3
    edited January 2016

    I have a complicated ..Very complicated case and I am extremly scared ...I got diagnosed with Non -Hodgkins Lymphoma in 2011 August. The chemo I went thru and the Cancer BOTH attacked my digestive system so badly they ended up removing ALL of my Large Intestine 100 % , My Gallbladder, My Appendix , my Colon & My Anus. Now after two years of healing it took from that. They found a Lump in my Right axillary Region so took ALL of right axillary Lymphnodes out .....I had severe drainage problems for like 6 weeks , They left the drain in going home and had to change it out a few times and painfully manually drain a few times ( very Painfull but fluids kept building up under skin ) So had to.

    Finally that healed and Ivebeen in Remission since after two years of Rituxan after chemo treatments and after almost dying before big surgury from Renal End Failure so then lived out of hosp by going for hydration treatments twice weekly , But now hydrate myself by drinking 1 & 1/2 gallons of Lemonaide a day. I have to or kidneys will fail again because your large intestine is what gives you fluids from food. But since I dont have one at all and they redirected my small intestine to normal exit I can barely eat anything or Id be in bathroom non stop because list of what I can eat is so small its ridiculous. All other foods will give me diareha .....Im on massive amts of diareha meds daily is all they can do. So Nutrition is almost non existant for me , I am anemic , They have me on energy pills due to malabsorbtion of food.

    And just got dioagnosed with Lymphedema....Now from what I read so far nutrition is a big part of treatment ....Well that wont / cant work for me because I can only eat such a small list of items as it is

    Im so scared because then the surgery ussually they go to from what Ive read is moving Lymphnodes from one area to another to replace blockages or blocked ones ....Well since Non Hodgkins Lymphoma is Cancer of The Lymphatic system and Cancer is thruout my entire system ......What are my chances then or options for treating the Lymphedema ????????????

  • Pricillamylove2211
    Pricillamylove2211 Member Posts: 3
    edited January 2016

    I have swelling at night as well ....Just got diagnosed , So need to find a Dr any around my area ?That are good with all my NHL and all other i suffer from ...I dont know how in the heck there going to treat me at all and im in sooooo much pain

  • Binney4
    Binney4 Member Posts: 8,609
    edited January 2016

    Pricilla, welcome to the discussion boards here at BreastCancer.org. I'm so sorry for the reasons that brought you here, but glad you found us.

    Lymphedema is a scary diagnosis for most of us--it's chronic, and it's hard to get good information about it, and sometimes even to find a well-qualified lymphedema therapist to treat it.

    I'm not sure where you heard that diet was a significant part of lymphedema treatment. It helps some of us if we avoid salt or alcohol, but aside from that there's little about diet that can affect lymphedema (except weight gain, but that doesn't sound like a problem you're having).

    The surgery you mention--moving lymphnodes from one site to another, or connecting lymph vessels to blood vessels for more effective draining--is still very much in the experimental stage and is certainly not standard lymphedema treatment, so please don't worry about the need for further surgery.

    Briefly, standard lymphedema treatment involves Manual Lymph Drainage, which is a kind of very gentle massage that helps to stimulate the lymph vessels (which are close to the skin) to move lymph more efficiently. Some special exercises help with that as well. And adding compression to the arm or other swollen area to help reduce swelling and maintain the arm in good condition. That compression at first is usually a special kind of layered bandage, applied by the lymphedema therapist. Later, when the swelling is reduced, you will be fitted for thin compression garments to use as needed (some of us need them all the time, others just for exercise or travel.

    All of that will be worked out with the help of a well-trained lymphedema therapist. Here's how to find one near you--any member of you medical team can write you a referral:

    http://www.stepup-speakout.org/Finding_a_Qualified...

    I hope some of that helps to calm your concerns at least a little. With gentle treatment and time to learn the "ropes" of managing this new challenge, you'll soon be on top of this. Please ask away if you have other questions, and do keep us posted on your progress.

    Gentle hugs,
    Binney


  • Pricillamylove2211
    Pricillamylove2211 Member Posts: 3
    edited January 2016

    Thank you for reaching out to me yupp thought maybe my NHL spread to Bone Cancer with symptoms Im having but no its lymphedema and I have every single symptom on the board .......I dont even know where to begin and know so little about it. And am scared , Do you live around illinois and do you have one to suggest ...A specialist

  • Binney4
    Binney4 Member Posts: 8,609
    edited January 2016

    Mary, I don't know anyone in Illinois, but hopefully some of our Illinois gals will be along soon with suggestions. The link above can help you find someone well-qualified. I'm glad it's "only" lymphedema and not the other things you were fearing! Lymphedema is as steep learning curve, but it really is doable. Hang in there! We're here for you,
    Binney

  • glennie19
    glennie19 Member Posts: 6,398
    edited January 2016

    Pricilla, I don't live in IL either, but wanted to send you a big ((hug)) and second Binney's suggestion of checking out that link for help in finding a qualified LE therapist. Hopefully your cancer center or oncologist will be able to refer you to a therapist near you too. Keep us posted.

  • ChiSandy
    ChiSandy Member Posts: 12,133
    edited January 2016

    Mary, the LE doc I’m seeing tomorrow, Dr. Kaplan at NorthShore Evanston Hospital, is supposedly the best in the Chi. area (acc. to Chicago Magazine’s Top Doctors article). Evanston isn’t exactly a stone’s throw from Plainfield, but it is doable. His office (Dept. of Physical and Rehab Medicine) is at 1000 Central St. Ste. 880. Phone is 847-570-2000. He also has offices at Glenbrook and Highland Park, which might be an easier trip along the Stevenson, Kennedy & Edens so you needn’t go through the city.

  • glennie19
    glennie19 Member Posts: 6,398
    edited January 2016

    Sandy, please report in after your appt. I would love to hear what the Doctor tells you. Thanks !

Categories