Lying about having breast cancer

Options
2

Comments

  • Sirena_Gorda
    Sirena_Gorda Member Posts: 26
    edited February 2012

    Exbrnxgrl, thank you for expressing my exact thoughts about the bc paranoia comments that were made.


    To clarify, the woman about whom I wrote in my original post is indeed lying to the administration and has not been required to submit proof because she is very proud of not having missed a day of work due to her bc tx. (I didnt miss a day during rads either; not uncommon) This is not rads for metastatic bc. This is rads every day M-F since August 2010. And I am aware that radiation is used for mets because I watched my mom and my best friend, may they both rest in peace, go through it, so I am not completely uneducated about tx protocol. So if you think I am bc paranoid, you are entitled to your opinion.

    And, yes, people who have Munchhausen's can lie effectively enough to fool some doctors about some diseases, although I don't see how they could fool them about bc due to all the CT, PT scans and MRI's. Oh, that's right, I completely forgot! They just tell everyone they have bc but don't really go to the doctor to get biopsies or scans!!

    And I have no intentions of exposing this miscreant or mentally ill person and "ruining her reputation." I'm sure she will accomplish that herself in due time.

  • Sirena_Gorda
    Sirena_Gorda Member Posts: 26
    edited February 2012
    Thanks to all of you who have enlightened me about this not being a unique situation.  I appreciate hearing that other people think this is wrong, and I do understand that some people who do this have a mental illness.  I also believe that some of them are just evil.  
  • mcbird
    mcbird Member Posts: 381
    edited February 2012

    When I came out of remission a few months back my Daughter-in-law suddenly had uterine cancer.  She told me she had to go to the gyn again and they were going to decide what to do about it since her insurance co. wouldn't pay for a hysterectomy.  I offered to go with her to be supportive but she wouldn't let me and wouldn't even let my son go with her.  I asked her last month about it and she said Oh it was just fibroids.  She is an ULTIMATE drama queen and I know she just told me those things for attention and to downplay my tumors coming back.  I wish I was just seeking attention.

  • hrf
    hrf Member Posts: 3,225
    edited February 2012

    If she does start missing work, I hope the administration does require a medical certificate. I wonder if she is using this fake dx to excuse bad performance in the classroom in which case, her students are the ones who are suffering. I have been a school principal and I know that I would be sitting down and having a private (and supportive) discussion with this teacher - telling her that her story doesn't make sense - I'd confront her and tell her that if she is having problems of some sort, that I would want to help her. I'd also involve her union rep because they also can be very helpful when someone has problems. Most school districts have employee assistance programs that are totally confidential. I felt that if one of my staff had a problem, I had to get involved and was as positive as possible. But if someone is that disturbed, I'd worry about the classroom and the students. 

  • Sirena_Gorda
    Sirena_Gorda Member Posts: 26
    edited February 2012

    Mcbird, I cannot imagine having a d-i-l who would do that.  How do you live with it?  What does your son think about that? 

    And to the other ladies who have posted about relatives faking bc:  to me that would be so much worse than dealing with it at work.  You have my sympathy.

  • Sirena_Gorda
    Sirena_Gorda Member Posts: 26
    edited February 2012

    HRF, yes both her students and her colleagues are suffering.  She leaves every day at 2:30.  School is over at 3:30 (She has 2 planning periods at the end of the day since she is a dept. chair.) The admin (a man who is not EVER going to question this) was not aware she was leaving early, but made the comment about having compassion because of radiation.  Since last year (different school) and from August 2011 until now.  Rads every weekday.  Somewhat questionable?

  • exbrnxgrl
    exbrnxgrl Member Posts: 12,424
    edited February 2012

    Gracie1,

    That has not been my experience on bco.

    Caryn

  • Denise2730
    Denise2730 Member Posts: 648
    edited February 2012

    Karma can be a bitch. Shame on anyone claiming to have any type of cancer when they don't.

  • mcbird
    mcbird Member Posts: 381
    edited February 2012

    Serina, My son isn't surprised at anything she says or does anymore.  We all know that she is mentally ill but there isn't anything we can do about it because she won't go to counseling or admit that she has a problem.  I stay as far away from her as possible.

  • Outfield
    Outfield Member Posts: 1,109
    edited February 2012

    Sirena,

    I think the paranoia comments aren't really relevant.  Whether there's a lot of paranoia on these boards or not, you've brought up an issue that is quite real and is more common than a lot of people realize.

    As I said, I work in medicine.  Not in psychiatry (thank goodness), not in any area where I'd expect to see more than the average amount of Munchhausen's and malingering.  And I have seen a lot.  Right now, there's someone feigning breast cancer.  The next most recent one I can think of, the issue was having had a heart attack and stent placed.  The one before that said he'd had lymphoma.  The list goes on.

    It's simply untrue that people with these issues can't fool doctors.  They fool them ALL THE TIME. In busy ER's where it's too hard to get the outside records and verify that the scar the MD is seeing is from a lumpectomy, for example.  All a person needs to successfully pull this off is either to know a little more than the person they're trying to fool, or be talking to someone who is too busy to get the full story.  And fool one person, and you get yourself a little bit of medical documentation in the form of an ER or clnic note saying you have cancer.  A savvy medical person is going to be able to sort throught that kind of documentation, where there's no proof other than the person saying something (very different from say a path or surgery report) and realize there's nothing concrete.  Someone not as savvy is going to be even more easily fooled when the person brings in their "records."  Then it snowballs.

    It's certainly frustrating to deal with.  It's hard to empathize.  But these people (the ones who aren't just simply scamming for money or drugs) have a serious, serious illness that has the potential to cause them grave harm.   It's not the illness they claim to have, but it's something that can be really, really bad.  I wish you patience and strength in dealing with this.  

  • pj12
    pj12 Member Posts: 25,402
    edited February 2012
    By msnbc.com staff and news servicesRICHMOND, Va. -- A suburban Richmond woman was fined $100 after admitting she faked cancer to raise money.The Richmond Times-Dispatch said that Martha Ann Nicholas pleaded guilty on Monday to two misdemeanor charges of obtaining money by false pretenses. Besides the fine, she was ordered by a judge to not take part in any charitable causes and placed on five years' probation.A 12-month jail sentence was suspended, the newspaper reported.The Mechanicsville woman had claimed at rallies that she was a cancer victim.Advertise | AdChoicesHer attorney, Sam Simpson, said Nicholas has made restitution of $1,700, the total she had collected for herself.Nicholas had been suffering from a psychosomatic condition that made her believe she had a cancer-like illness, Simpson said.Her family said she is receiving counseling and told the Times-Dispatch that they were relieved she was not going to jai
  • Sirena_Gorda
    Sirena_Gorda Member Posts: 26
    edited February 2012

    Thank you, PJ123, for posting this article.  We have had some developments here also.

    Story changed:  Now the story is that she has had rads on Mondays and Tuesdays since August, 2011, but when she was asked about why she was leaving work early, all of a sudden she had only 4 more treatments left and stopped leaving early.  Now we all know, and I am sure you will correct me if I am wrong, that rads are not done 2 days a week for months on end.  And this is for the recurrence of bc from last year when the same type of TX was done, not for mets.  No surgery, no chemo, nothing.  Supposedly the tumor is in a place where chemo cannot reach it, so radiation had to be done.  Location:  behind the left breast toward the arm, so chemo can't reach it?  I thought chemo was systemic?  Anyway, last week a "procedure" was done and a post-op was done 4 days later to remove the stitches. She had a large bandage at the top of her cleavage between the breasts. She says she is not going to have chemo, so it wasn't a port placement.  If the tumor is in the place that has been stated, why would the "incision" for a lumpectomy be between the breasts?  I had a mastectomy with TRAM flap reconstruction, so I don't know much about lumpectomies and recovery time.  Perhaps a sentinel node biopsy?  Help me out, ladies, please.

  • J-Bug
    J-Bug Member Posts: 626
    edited February 2012

    Chemo is systemic - it reaches all. Sentinal node biopsy would leave her with an incision going into the armpit. I thought that most doctors didn't use stitches in these things now anyway. Every procedure that I have had lately has involved glue. Even my daughter's open heart surgery in 1998 used glue. All of my son's stitches, hyperactive child that he is, involved glue. 

    I think that this is interesting and sad and it makes me angry, but I usually come to the conclusion that if I am not going to do anything about it, I would have to distance myself from it. I am sure you are still processing this mess of a situation though. It's like you are watching a car wreck about to happen, you know it's going to happen, but you have to look anyway. 

  • Beesie
    Beesie Member Posts: 12,240
    edited February 2012

    The tumor is in a place where chemo can't reach it?  Sorry, but I actually laughed out loud when I read that. 

    If someone told me that, or if I heard it from another person about someone else's breast cancer diagnosis/treatment, I think I would say "That's the stupidest thing that I've ever heard" and then turn and walk away.  

  • CoolBreeze
    CoolBreeze Member Posts: 4,668
    edited February 2012

    It sounds like she's lying or trying to get attention.

    I work in school administration, so I would urge you (or anybody) not to send any anonymous notes about her or call the press, what a terrible idea.  I have never seen an anonymous note read by anybody in authority.  They go right into the shredder.  If you have an issue you want addressed, you have to be willling to speak up to have it taken seriously.  And, the press isn't going to care about this, first, and second, the school district will rally around the teacher and things will just get stirred up where they shouldn't be. No changes will happen, saying you are sick when you are not isn't illegal.

    I would assume that this is a high school since she's got two prep periods at the end of the day.  She wouldn't be the first one I've seen abuse that time; most just say they are doing their planning at home. I have teachers with 6th period prep who have never heard the final bell ring.

    As for Department Chairs, they usually meet once a month, right?  Maybe she hasn't missed as much as you thought?   Are you in the department she is leading?  Have you noticed a lack of focus about where you are to go instructionally?

    Since I work in a high school, for me to take time off for surgeries, chemos, etc, I had to provide a doctor's note. This was only after I used up my sick leave and vacation leave.  I did go out on FMLA.  It's possible this teacher arranged with the principal to be gone an hour a day for radiation.  And, the principal may not know that radiation doesn't take that long, and since it's her prep, she's told him she'll make up the work.  Then he probably wouldn't look further.  From his persective, the work is being done, no children are being left alone and she has medical needs.

    My advice to you would be just to ignore this woman.  It would not be unreasonable to sit down with the principal and express your doubts.  Several others may have done it already and he can keep an eye on her or request that she stay on campus until the end of the day from now on.

    And, I would also ask why this upsets you so very much?  Honestly, I don't care what teacher leaves when as long as classes are covered and if somebody wants to tell people lies about breast cancer, it has nothing to do with me. I'm struggling to survive here and I can't worry about what other people do.  

    Do you feel like she's getting attention that you should have gotten?  Other than that, I can't imagine why this upsets you so much.  I can understand when coworkers get attention you haven't gotten but upsetting you to the point of the stress shown in your notes is not good for you either.  I would learn to let it go.  It's important for your own health to lean when there are things you can;t control - to let them go.

  • Sirena_Gorda
    Sirena_Gorda Member Posts: 26
    edited March 2012

    Wow, CoolBreeze.  I was not aware that this was a site where people were supposed to make personal attacks. Perhaps I am wrong.

    I will address your questions.  Why does this bother me so much? Did you ever hear the words "professional ethics" or "morality" in the classes you took to become an administrator, or did you miss those classes?  People who lie about having cancer and many other things do not belong around kids because they have a serious mental illness and need to get help and should not be in a classroom setting until they get treatment.  Furthermore, in this case, this woman has the ability to destroy the career of any teacher to whom she takes a dislike by telling lies about them to the administration.

    No, lying is not illegal, but it is stealing when you are required to report any missed work time (in this system, even 10 minutes must be reported) to the central absence reporting system so that it is deducted from sick leave.  When one does not do this, it is considered stealing from the school system and taxpayers, and the last time I heard, stealing is illegal. Perhaps you missed that class also?

    If you had read my previous posts before attacking, you would have seen that I stated that I have no intention of exposing this woman either by calling the press or by sending an anonymous letter.  Guess you didn't do your homework.

    Oh, and yes, I am jealous of all the attention this woman is getting.  How did you know?  I didn't get any attention at all when I was going through treatment and was told I would lose my job if I took 2 weeks off at the end of the year for a mastectomy.  I just went to work and lied and told people that I was fine and that I had the flu for months so that no one would notice and I wouldn't stand out as a cancer victim.

    By the way, are you still on FMLA?  Just curious since you have made over 2,500 posts on this board.  If you're not, it doesn't seem that you can be getting much work done in the administrative office.

    And finally, I was under the impression that all of us on this board were struggling to survive.

  • Chickadee
    Chickadee Member Posts: 4,467
    edited March 2012

    . Personally I'd be pissed, not stressed. But I also would have nailed her when she tried to get away with telling that whopper about how chemo couldn't reach the cancer. OMG!



    When you work diligently and follow the rules people like this woman piss you off. Lame ass administrators only contribute to allowing mediocre employees like this keep on picking up the same check you do.

  • Sirena_Gorda
    Sirena_Gorda Member Posts: 26
    edited March 2012
    Chickadee, she's not at my school, but one close by where several of my good friends work.  And I am pissed because of what she can do to them, and has attempted to do to someone in the department.
  • TonLee
    TonLee Member Posts: 2,626
    edited March 2012

    Omaz,

    Buwhahahaha...love your last line!

  • MizMarie
    MizMarie Member Posts: 332
    edited March 2012

    People are just strange...  There is a local pizza chain that is well-known for its generous fundraising policy.  A few months ago, they hosted a fundraiser night for a man who claimed to have pancreatic cancer and needed funds for treatment.  Close to $2000 were raised and donated to the man's "medical fund" by the pizza chain.  Somehow the restaurant manager became suspicious of the man's story, and his tale began to unravel.  It turns out that he got at least $5000 from various fundraising scams - many of his victims were fellow church members.  He was charged with theft by deception, and is scheduled to go on trial in March.  His wife claims to have not known he was faking cancer, saying she never went with him to his appointments.  When a local TV news station interviewed him and asked him straight up if he has cancer, his answer was "I don't really know how to respond to that".  Um, how about Yes or No?

  • waawaa
    waawaa Member Posts: 10
    edited March 2012

    Sirena I think you are right to be indignant about this. It may be fraud and can be hurting the other staff and students and using resources unfairly. Some people may think they are administrators of these discussions but they are not.

  • 1Athena1
    1Athena1 Member Posts: 6,696
    edited March 2012

    Sirena Gorda:

    I can understand how you would feel outraged about this. It is only human. But forgive me if I m dense and ask a few questions (if you addressed them before I apologize):

    --How do you know this woman is lying? Lack of symptoms from treatment is often nota reliable indicator. Some people do not suffer redness or fatigue from radiation. Do you have evidence? If so I agree it shouldn't be allowed to pass.

    --I agree with you on the moral issue, and if you have proof that she is lying she needs to know how hurtful it is to use an illness that some of us really do have/have had.

    --I agree that an anonymous note is a bad idea (it is illegal in some countries). But I understand the urge to send one. IMO your feelings, if you are right about this woman, are valid. Going to the press is taking this out of its appropriate cxontext  and you will probably be ignored.

    --There may be something constructive that you can do. Do you have evidence (going beyond heresay) that she is using that lie to get excused from work? That may violate some employment policy or ethics rule. I am a stranger to this area, but if there is a union or an employee assistance program, can you get advice on how to proceed?

    Your feelings are valid. Hell yes, you deserve more attention. How dare this woman use others' suffering to get attention. That is damaging to others. One option: have you tried just telling her to her face that she is lying and you DO have BC so you know what it's like? She may at least shut up in the future. I always believe old fashioned methods of inquiry work best. Don't keep this in. Do something about it that is constructive. Maybe this IS about your feelings and asserting yourself - but that's OK!! It's ok to advocate for yourself. That is part of dealing with serious illness. Otherwise these feelings can torture you. You have enough to deal with from the diagnosis. Hang in there.

  • apple
    apple Member Posts: 7,799
    edited March 2012

    she's an idiot.. i'd write her a little letter.. tell her to knock it off and let her know how it really is and how her idiocy is really getting you down.  anonymously

    i think that would help you at least to put her thinking into perspective

  • Kadia
    Kadia Member Posts: 314
    edited March 2012

    I would have a really difficult time working with someone like this, whether she is lying completely or just handling it in an incompetent/arrogant way.

    Assuming she is lying, though, about the cancer--that is also an illness (as others have pointed out). It bothers me to see so much hatred being placed here on someone who is clearly ill, even if it is not the illness she is claiming. Anger and frustration I get, but I guess I would have expected to see a little bit more compassion--even amidst the intense frustration--for someone who is clearly suffering from a serious illness. 

    It seems to me unfair when psychiatric illnesses--and people living with them--are stigmatized in a way that people with non-psychiatric illnesses are not. (To be clear, I don't think all posts here are doing that.) A serious illness is a serious illness, and it makes me sad to see anyone struggling with one.

    Edited to add: From what I know about Munchausen's, a letter expressing frustration or anger is not likely to make a difference in this person's behavior, although it may be helpful for people dealing with the fallout from it to express their experience. Munchausen's is very difficult to treat. 

  • CoolBreeze
    CoolBreeze Member Posts: 4,668
    edited March 2012

    Wait a minute - what personal attack did I make?   I'm completely confused.

    I am no longer on FMLA, that ended last week.  I have so many posts on this board because I have been dealing with cancer for three years. I am Stage IV, with mets to the liver. I had half my liver removed to try and cure it back in October and have been off work since then. I was going back in December but I got a colon infection called c-diff and went septic, and spent some time in the hospital. I have been home recovering from septic shock and organ shut down since then. I just started back to work half time last week. I found out today that apparently the cancer is growing in my liver again so who knows how long that will last?.

    I don't post at work, ever.  

    Based on my experience, I was trying to HELP you, and give you advice on how to handle it with the administration. In reading your first post again, I see you even said this is a teacher at a different school, and yet you are saying you feel rage over it to the point of it consuming you.

     Rage is not helpful to your body as you recover from cancer, and if something a teacher is doing at another school is consuming you, as you said, than it will cause stress hormones to kick in and that isn't good for you physically.  I was pointing out that this is a situation you can't control and maybe letting it go is good for your health.  I really fail to see how anything I said is a personal attack.  I didn't call you a name, for goodness sake.   

    And, frankly, you have no idea what the administration there is or isn't doing about it.  Personnel matters are confidential and they may very well be working to do something and you don't know about it.  Your union is very powerful and it is extremely difficult to discipline a teacher as you well know - there are lots of things that must be done and documented for a long period of time.  They might be doing that and trust me, they aren't going to do that and let the school population know about it.  Even the teachers don't know many of the things I know at my school.

    I didn't disagree with the fact that she is likely to be faking illness, I only was advising you that you can't do anything about it and it's not even at your school, so try to let it go.  It doesn't touch you or your life. Hell, 90% of Hollywood actors are unethical - do you feel rage to the point of it consuming you over them?  

    Oh, and by the way, I am the principal's secretary, not an actual administrator.  Just privy to everything that happens personnel-wise and thought I could help you see things from that end.  I know exactly how schools handle problem teachers, including how and why they surplus teachers and it isn't because they take two weeks off for health reasons.  They are secretive when there is an issue with a teacher, they have to quietly document and follow union rules, they don't read anonymous complaints and basically, they try to do what is best for the school and the school community while following all the rules that are in place.

    I'm sorry you felt that I was attacking you but I wasn't at all, just trying to get you to see it's something you can't fix and let it go so you aren't consumed with rage anymore. 

    Again, I wish you good luck.  I don't think adding stress over things you cannot control is helpful to you but it is your life.   

  • Meggy
    Meggy Member Posts: 530
    edited March 2012

    Oh this really pisses me off.  I would absolutely expose this woman but do it anonmyously so you don't suffer in some fight with a lunatic.  I like the idea of tipping of the press. 

    I once heard of a case of a woman who pretended to have BC and had a fund raiser thrown for her for reconstruction.  Then she took the money and went to a plastic surgeon for an ordinary boob job....who had attended her fake fund raiser.  He tipped off the authorities and she was charged with fraud. 

  • 1Athena1
    1Athena1 Member Posts: 6,696
    edited March 2012

    Ok, let's clear up some misconceptions:

    Mental illness does not excuse lying, and lying to get attention is not by itself a mental illness. We are all responsible for behaving properly. More so if we are public employees teaching children. Sorry, but that's how it is.

    Most importantly, let's not make assumptions about this woman's psychiatric profile. There is such thing as bad character. People, both mentally ill and not mentally ill, do bad things all of the time. BAD BEHAVIOR IS NOT BY ITSELF A SIGN OF MENTAL ILLNESS. Conversely, mental illness does not mean a person manifests bad behavior. Plenty of pleasant, benign people are desperaely mentally ill.

    Also, lying is not a form of psychosis. Lying is deliberate deception. Psychosis involves nothing deliberate and nothing deceptive. Let's be careful about how we throw around medical diagnoses/opinions not based on facts.

    I apologize if this sounds cold, but some here are running away with assumptions and misconceptions.

    --Maybe I'm just pissed because I am watching a television program about lions who attack humans, and I am uncomfortable about the misconceptions that people watching the program could have about lions (NOT natural maneaters!) Tongue out Off to lick my own wounds.:-)

  • binga
    binga Member Posts: 140
    edited March 2012

    There was actually a lady here in my area who faked cancer and used it for monetary gain. Lots of her co-workers donated their accumulated sick time to her so she would continue to be paid. She had everyone fooled so evidently it can be done depending on the circumstances. I was always amazed at how her employer didn't know.

  • Kadia
    Kadia Member Posts: 314
    edited March 2012

    Athena--It's true we don't know if this woman has a psychiatric diagnosis, but there are indications that she may, so we don't know that she doesn't either. If anyone is curious about the criteria for a Munchausen's diagnosis (aka factitious disorder--aka, a disorder whose hallmark is lying about illness), here is the DSM criteria:

    1)The patient intentionally produces or feigns physical or psychological signs or symptoms.

    2)The motivation for the behavior is to assume the sick role.

    3) External incentives for the behavior are absent.

    Edited at an attempt at clarity! 

  • 1Athena1
    1Athena1 Member Posts: 6,696
    edited March 2012

    Kadia:

    My chief concern is first whether we have convincing evidence that the woman is lying about breast cancer. That is what first has to be established. Lack of treatment or symptoms of treatment is not sufficient evidence. Once we know one way or the other, then the second priority is to see what our OP can do about it for the interests of our OP. If that this woman is lying and gaining advantage, then she should be held accountable regardless. If there is mental illness discovered she would be advised to seek treatment, but IMO that is way beyond the scope of the issue here.

Categories