Tired of hearing about "Survivors"

Options
grammadebbie
grammadebbie Member Posts: 39

Maybe it's just me but I'm tired of hearing and reading all about cancer "survivors".  I guess I don't feel like I'm a "survivor" anymore....so where do I fit in with all these fundraisers and relays and such?   I participated in my local Realy for Life for many years before my first diagnosis.  Then for a few years I proudly walked in the "Survivors Lap".   Now for the past two years I haven't even gone to the event.  I'm not a "survivor".  I'm a casualty....trying desparately to live a few more years to watch my children grow and spend time with my husband....just like all of you, my Stage 4 sisters.   How do you feel about these things?   Do you ever want to scream at these people "What about me?"   Sorry, thanks for letting me rant. 

«134567

Comments

  • reesie
    reesie Member Posts: 2,078
    edited August 2011

    I was invited to a Relay for Life event by my kids' friend. I was honored but when I went I felt out of place as a "survivor". Problem is my kids didn't know my Stage IV dx yet so that made it even harder (I only told my best friend in the beginning. I would have told my kids if they asked but was glad they didn't so I could tell them after I was doing "better" on treatment).



    I'm still not sure where I stand on this.


    Edited for typos

  • 3beans
    3beans Member Posts: 46
    edited August 2011

    I am so sorry to hear the sadness and frustration in your post. All my life my mom and I partcipated in every fundraiser cancer related. She owned a store and donated more items and organized more functions for local and national organizations, there was no room for her to make a profit. However, she was happy and felt that she was giving back. At 50 (with 2 daughters 17 and 25) was diagnosed with stage 4 lung cancer which took her life after a quick and agonizing 6 months. Such a wonderful woman, what an amazing grandmother she would have been. I miss her painfully everyday (it has been 10 yrs) and although my children have never met her, they talk about her daily as well. I too felt angry that she didnt have the chance to fight the way I have heard so many do. With all the cancer in my family history, At 35 have been faced with 2 years of biopsies and "issues" that leave me feeling like a ticking time bomb. I have been on this site for a couple weeks now trying to make sense of the changes I have recently been feeling in my left breast and hopin that if my appt with the breast specialist in 17 days (yes, I am counting down) goes the way I fear it might, that I might have the chance to fight the good fight. I have 3 children under 8 and have always felt that this disease, no matter where it hits, is cruel and hard to understand. Nothing I say is going to take away the unfair feelings you have, as anyone in your position would feel the same, it is just so unfair. I just hope that you know that there are people who understand and feel that you should be able to vent if that helps in any small way. I wish you comfort and am glad that this site can provide an outlet for you to put your feelings out there and get the support that you need in this very trying time. Much love

  • K-Lo
    K-Lo Member Posts: 2,743
    edited August 2011

    Wow, good point. My hair- (such as it is)-stylist picked up on the chemo hair and she said, "well at least you're a survivor!" And I said, "....yeah." Felt funny!

  • Chickadee
    Chickadee Member Posts: 4,467
    edited August 2011

    I've been wrestling with that "survivor" term from the beginning.  I think it's really for the Stage1, 2, folks who have finished the initial treatment and now hope or expect that it never comes back. 

    The word "survivor" just doesn't fit Stage IV.   Then again, I'm not a casualty until I'm gone. 

    We're fighting the battle daily, so maybe we can call ourselves Warriors.

  • EnglishMajor
    EnglishMajor Member Posts: 2,495
    edited August 2011

    http://www.slate.com/id/2268104/

    I hear you--yes, I do want to scream. OMG, there is one writer who had breast cancer in the Reagan Administration. Now, of course, we know her cancer could still come back, that is certainly a legitimate concern. 

    But then she starts talking about being a survivor and pioneering the survivorship movement and you'd think she was the cancer patient equivalent of Rosa Parks or that she got hit upside the head on Christopher St.back in the day.

    I would say she is just lucky. 

     It's not like our friends who died didn't try hard or didn't take care of themeselves. They did. 

    All cancer sucks, no doubt. I would in no way debate or diminish the very real trauma that all cancer patients, regardless of stage, endure. 

    But you know what? If you are 20 or 25 years from your intial diagnosis, you really did survive! You raised your family! You had a pretty full life! Very few of our Stage IV friends can say that.

    (Small comfort to the "survivor" I am sure.)

    Most of us will die with or from this disease. We are not survivors. (I struggle mightily with the"previvor"idea. What the hell does that make us? Don't get me started.)

    Last year a store in my town actually had BC Awareness Month banner that declared "Treat It and Beat It!" 

     Really?

    And that means what, exactly, to the people who will never beat this disease and face lifelong treatment? 

    I presented with mets which puts me in the minority (about 3 to 6 % of MBC'ers). But about 20% of women who  started at Stage 1, 2 or 3 will find themselves at Stage IV.

    How often do we read angry posts from these early stage women who didn't grasp the real threat of recurrence?

    Embrace the survivor label if you must, but know there are no guarantees. Regardless of what you ate, your attitude or the terrible treatment regimen you endured.

  • Linda11111111
    Linda11111111 Member Posts: 49
    edited August 2011

    I'd like to join the crowd of us who aren't comfortable with the term "survivor." You're only a survivor when you die of something else, at which point you won't be participating in walks for anything. I'd rather be called a statistic. Thank you for posting the topic. Was thinking I was just a grump and overly sensitive when it came to that word.

  • Mazy1959
    Mazy1959 Member Posts: 1,431
    edited August 2011

    gramma, There's a huge billboard I drive by almost everyday that says " Surviving and Thriving with Cancer" and it makes me wanna puke. I'm surviving but not in the way others are and  I am not thriving. Stage 4 is not given much attention at those fundraisers because we are considered terminal. They want ladies who have had stages 0-3 who appear all ok and show how strong they are after winning the battle. Yes I am sick of hearing it. I am happy to be alive of course. But my life has changed and because of stage 4 there are so many things I can no longer do. I do pretty well at accepting my limitations until some know it all decides to say things like " Well u can walk so why cant u work?" I wanna smack em. Hugs, Mazy

  • chainsawz
    chainsawz Member Posts: 3,473
    edited August 2011

    I just can't even think about it because it'll drive me crazy!!!  I started out stage IV like English, but like she mentioned a good percentage of those early stage ""survivors" are gonna join us on this stage IV boat.  That fact just tends to get glossed right over :< 

  • Cynthia1962
    Cynthia1962 Member Posts: 1,424
    edited August 2011

    I agree, Grammadebbie.  I no longer feel like a survivor because, well, I won't be.  I always used to feel weird at "survivor" events, especially ones where they sorted us by how long we'd had cancer, then clapped for us.  Wth?  I just don't understand what the point is.  There's a bc event in my area coming up soon and I want to hear the speaker, but I don't want to be paraded around with the other "survivors".  It's bad enough that they requested photos of survivors for the event and my support group insisted that we take a group photo for it (so much for privacy issues).  They acted as if it was one big party.  I'm just not feeling that way.  I feel like a warrior who will one day be a casualty.  I fight to stay here for my children as long as possible, not to be someone's definition of a "survivor".

  • greytcruise
    greytcruise Member Posts: 105
    edited August 2011

    Thanks for starting this topic.  I have never felt like a "survivor" and I am not thriving, trying to survive the SE's and live a normal life.  I don't like the work "fight" or "battle" either.  I am not fighting anything just trying to live and get rid of a disease, just more time to get back to normallacy than most illnesses.  I wouldn't mind doing the walk, but I do not want attention drawn to myself nor do I want to be remembered for this disease.  This is not what I want to define me.  I like statistic and warrior.

  • jloon
    jloon Member Posts: 30
    edited August 2011
    I feel the same way about the survivor thing...I'm also tired of people telling me to "be Strong" "don't give up!" "I know you can beat this!" I feel like telling them to f-off. Yell but i just smile and say thanks...
  • pupfoster1
    pupfoster1 Member Posts: 1,484
    edited August 2011

    Ditto to those ladies above---

    I had seen this thread on the active topics and had to pipe in. I DO NOT feel lke a survivor.  I just want this s$%t to go away!

    Take care my sistahs,

    Sharon

  • Leah_S
    Leah_S Member Posts: 8,458
    edited August 2011

    Well, let's see. we're terminal, how 'bout I just say I'm a terminus? Or maybe we should march at those things with signs that say, "I'm not dead yet".

    Cancer doesn't define me so I won't let it label me.

    Leah

  • momoftwo526
    momoftwo526 Member Posts: 151
    edited August 2011

    I have just read this post and agree with so much of what is being said.  I have just completed a BMX and have started recon with TEs.  From the beginning of my diagnosis, since I am Stage I, many people have acted like it is no big deal. Saying things like: "You will be fine", or "You just have to get past this"  I do feel fortunate to have caught it so early, but it is still cancer.  I watched my mother deteriorate rapidly from rolling over in bed and breaking ribs and have seen so many who started as stage I only to have a reacurrance later that comes back with a vengence.  I know that having had breast cancer once puts me at a higher risk for other cancers or for a reoccurance elsewhere.  I definitely do not feel that I can call myself a survivor at this point.  I still have a long road to go and the scars will be with me for the rest of my life as will the constant viligence and monitoring. I don't even know what or if a label should be put on it. I don't want to be defined by my disease.  I am happy to be alive and just want to be able to live my life to the fullest.

    Phyllis

  • eag1954
    eag1954 Member Posts: 334
    edited August 2011

    I to thought it was just me...6 years ago, everyone was happy that I was a survivor.  At stage II i was able to end chemo, all my hair grew back, and I felt "normal."  Well as normal as you can feel when you have cancer.  I watched my stage IV neighbor die from this horrible disease. Funny, but when she was ill, I didnt look at her as a survivor.  I just felt sad.  Wished that there was a cure and helped her in anyway I could...fast forward six years...I don't feel like a survivor.  Noone calls me a survivor anymore and everyone just feels sad...I'm sick of the term and even more sick of pink...I had chemo today and I know for the next three days I'll feel terrible.  Sorry to rant, but when you're stage II stage IV feels like a totally different disease.  Jloon..they tell me , you're going to beat this...you sound good, you look good, blah blah blah...I wish I could see they're crystal ball.

  • Daydreamernh
    Daydreamernh Member Posts: 45
    edited August 2011

    Thank you for starting this thread.  I was at a Making Strides meeting  Monday for the walks in October. They asked everyone who was a survivor to raise their hands, I looked at the committee member  and said I am not a "survivor" anymore, what am I?  She said I am a survivor. I was so uncomfortable with that. I am stage 4 metastatic, I will be on some kind of drug for the rest of my life. These drugs can be debilitating, the side effects are awful sometimes. The treatments themselves interfere with my life, the numerous tests and appointments interfere with my life. I will go from one drug with is SE's to another with its SE's until we run out of drugs and treatment plans. I am terminal!

    The funny thing is there were very few survivors at that meeting and very few care takers according to the hand raising poll they took.

  • ma111
    ma111 Member Posts: 1,376
    edited August 2011

    I asked the cancer society to take my name off the list. I really dod not appriaciate them calling and asking for a donation and reminding me that age 45 to 55, breast cancer is the leading cause of death. I am still paying medical bills and thanked them for the reminder and told them my age and situation. I am in the age range. They need to let the public know that when they have their events, they would donate more money and maybe some vaccine trails would not be canceled because of lack of funding.

    Yet they send celebration of survivior dinner notifactions beside the relay for life for surviors. It makes the public think that you cannot die if you fight. I hate it.

    I also do not take part in the local support group because we are not allowed to talk about dying issues. That came from the professionaly trained moderator. Like hello, we all need to have a living will.

    Englishmajor,

    I also presented with mets and no tumor. It was progression when the ugly inflamatory showed.

  • LivingIt
    LivingIt Member Posts: 710
    edited August 2011

     Seriously, I dont know what to think when some 50 something lady with lots of makeup and a wig grabs my arm and says, "I know what you are going through. Im a survivor too."

    "Yeah?" I want to say "You found your cancer at six months pregnant as a newly wed too?" "You have a three and a ten year old who know you are going to die before they make middle school too?"  "You are going to be on chemo for the rest of your life until you decided to give up and let cancer take you too?"

    But I just smle and walk away.   

  • sueopp
    sueopp Member Posts: 1,541
    edited August 2011

    You are so right - I feel the same way.  I did Relay for years and years, and did the "Survivors Lap" with tears streaming down my face.  I do remember how grateful I felt to "survive" - now, whether it's reasonable or not, I feel betrayed.  We need a term different from "Survivor" -  how about we think of ourselves as "Warriers"?  I declare war on cancer!   SUE

  • Fitztwins
    Fitztwins Member Posts: 7,969
    edited August 2011

    I am not mad or frustrated anymore with the term. Sure, it used to irk me. Pink hell October is annoying. I am sure I have SURVIVOR ENVY.

    I just remind myself that all this hoopla, attention, etc...is bringing us closer to better treatments, more research and maybe, just maybe longer lives and HOPE beyond HOPE a CURE.

    It is easy to get angry at the word, term, because many of us were robbed of being a survivor, (I guess I was one for 3 years?). Many of us will be  robbed of being a mother, grandmother, wife, etc...All around, we were dealt a crappy hand.

  • EnglishMajor
    EnglishMajor Member Posts: 2,495
    edited August 2011

    Very well put, Fitz!

    I would stay I still get upset but I have found a positive outlet in volunteering with the Metastatic Breast Cancer Network (www.mbcnetwork.org)

    Mark your calendar: Oct. 13 is National Metatstatic Breast Cancer Awareness Day. 

     Susan Davis helped make this happen on a national level and did so much for people metastatic  breast cancer. She is a true inspiration: 

    http://ihatebreastcancer.wordpress.com/2011/08/20/susan-davis-tireless-mbc-advocate/ 

  • Lowrider54
    Lowrider54 Member Posts: 2,721
    edited August 2011

    I don't feel like a breast cancer survivor - maybe I did a bit after the first go around and was cancer free for over 10 years but now with mets - the only thing I feel like I have 'survived' is the total misconception that my attitude, spunk, sense of humor and will to continue to treat is going to save me.  I don't treat, I die.  I treat, I feel like crap and add on a whole bucket full of stuff to try and feel functional.  I will be alive but it darn sure feels nothing like surviving unless you call surviving nothing more than mere existence. 

  • Heidihill
    Heidihill Member Posts: 5,476
    edited August 2011

    Diabetes isn't something one survives either. So let's have it for...canceric?

  • mks16
    mks16 Member Posts: 415
    edited August 2011

    Hi everyone,

     Sorry to intrude in your forum but Hihopes suggested I share this article with you regarding cliches surrounding cancer. Well written and so true. I lost my beautiful mother to cancer just over a year ago. To say that I am a survivor would be a great disservice to her. I can only hope to have half her strength and courage; the only reason I am here today after my diagnosis is sheer luck.

    I didn't deserve or not deserve it any more than anyone else.

    http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/health/new-health/conditions/cancer/jack-layton-didnt-lose-a-fight-he-died-of-cancer/article2137736/ 

  • IllinoisNancy
    IllinoisNancy Member Posts: 722
    edited August 2011

    Hi,

    It really irritates me when friends and family tell me that I should not have gotten cancer because I look so healthy, take care of myself, eat right, sleep right, etc....  I got cancer because it just happened!! Just like the rest of you.  We didn't do anything wrong!!  I started out Stage I with a 96 percent of not getting it back according to my low oncotypedx score.  Well guess what?  I'm stage IIIb with it in my breast skin which means it could spread at anytime.  I don't really feel like a survivor either.  I am just waiting for Stage IV to arrive.

    Take care,

    Nancy

  • calamtykel
    calamtykel Member Posts: 1,187
    edited August 2011

    I just wanted to say that I am relieved to see such a discussion because even though I am stage 2, I thought something was wrong with me that I just hate that term "survivor" when it comes to cancer.  to me a survivor goes through a difficult thing, such as a wilderness excursion, and survives it and goes home; the situation and circumstances have totally "changed".  Trouble is with cancer, the situation and circumstances have not changed.  We are still inside the same body as we were when we were diagnosed; we are living the same life and the statistics are exactly the same as they were upon diagnosis.   I guess if you want to see it in a broad sense, each day that we are alive, we have survived that day, but then that would make everyone a survivor, cancer or not, just by driving to work and risking an accident, etc.

    I hate pink ribbon stuff - I hate the whole "breast cancer awareness".  What is the point of awareness?  Awareness of what? That it happens every day to people like you and me? That they have WOEFULLY failed kick the butt of this disease despite the millions pouring in with research?  And those who do have new ideas about it, whether holistic, or even allopathic, are silenced while they continue to whack us with awful drugs, etc?  

    I don't know.  I detest the whole pink ribbon survivor thing.  The walks and relays bother me because I really just wonder if they are a money making thing.  We all know that cancer itself is.  But maybe I'm just bitter about being organized into a "group" because of something that "happened" to me.    --it happened; I live with fear every day - just leave me alone and don't slap a pink ribbon t-shirt on me and say "Congratulations - you survived!"   I hate when people I meet ask me if I'm cured. I want to say "Don't you understand, you're never out of the woods with BC?  You never "KNOW" what's going on??"  Maybe THAT should be part of the whole BC "AWARENESS" campaign.  

  • NewReality
    NewReality Member Posts: 249
    edited August 2011

    An even stranger term is "metavivor!" What the heck does that mean, anyway? Does it mean we have survived mets? Realistically, how many of us survive mets? I find that term even more condescending.

  • mamanmidwife
    mamanmidwife Member Posts: 689
    edited August 2011

    this topic came at the right time - i work in a hospital, and yest i was coming in @ 8am my ID on just going to the elevators. Two nurses from some floor come running behind me wanting me to buy a pink id holder "for breast cancer awareness".

     i kept moving and said no. they insisted it's for Breast cancer! i said well then i have donated enough - i've given a breast to the cause.

     you'd think that would stop them.... no "oh so then you are a survivor, you should really get the holder"

     i don't know what happened to me because usually i'm a nice, reasonable person, but i turned around and spoke loudly "well, i can't be a survivor because the cancer has taken up residence in my liver and bones, therefore it will probably outlast me! the breast cancer is what's surviving, please leave me alone, and by the way i went to my yearly mammos they were all normal until it wasn't" finally silence, i was fumng that they got to me , but it happens.

    then i got on FB and reminded all my friends to donate to research not awareness

  • Frapp
    Frapp Member Posts: 1,987
    edited August 2011

    I went to a breast cancer walk last year put on by the american cancer society and they were giving out beautiful white sashes with Survivor in pink for people battling this insideous disease.  I just could not bring myself to wear one.  I am not a survivor and never will be.  I am a constant fighter.  I wake up everyday fighting.  I fight my emotions, my cancer and my side effects.  I went to the person in charge and told her how I felt. She happened to be the regional manager and brought it to the attention of her superior who is looking into changing or adding another ribbon.  This year, this same person had their relay for life and had added a "fighter" ribbon.  I was so honored and humbled.  I couldn't believe that my little voice made a change.  I'm sure if you all started to write the American Cancer Society, that they will make a nationwide change.  Let's do something about it!!!

  • GrandHillMom
    GrandHillMom Member Posts: 179
    edited August 2011

    This is a great topic.  I have never thought of myself as a survivor.  I was diagnosed at IIIB with angiolymphatic involvement, etc. that were bad for prognosis. Yes, I had yearly mammograms and breast exams. My breasts were so dense that a 7 centimer tumor couldn't be felt or seen on the mammogram and the first clue was a fully encampsulated lymph node outside my breast.   I had my first child at age 25, breast fed two children, and did or didn't do most all the things that supposedly lower your risk.    I did every possible thing to beat this monster, had very good response, but never, ever, thought I had "survived", which to me means the danger is over.   The danger was never over, and the mets showed up almost exactly four years from the day of the first diagnosis.  I can't stand people who do not really know about metastatic breast cancer who say "You'll beat it!" or "They are finding new cures!"  I sometimes ignore them (like my brother, who says he can only deal with my illness by believing this) but sometimes I treat them to the truth.  I have already told my husband he is not to say something like I lost a brave fight against breast cancer in my obit--I want it to say (assuming I'm not hit by a truck or die from some other reason) that I died from metastatic breast cancer.   People need to know. 

Categories