When should our daughters get their first mammograms?

2»

Comments

  • 40-years-old-now
    40-years-old-now Member Posts: 309
    edited May 2011

    I think a first base line should be done about 30, unless you have a family memeber that has breast cancer dx before 40, then go with the 10 years earlier that others have said.

    My Father was dx with Breast Cancer in 2007. At that time I got a base line done it came back clear. I have been doing self breast exams (mostly hubby does them) except for the months of Oct -Jan , because of my dad dieing (not from Breast cancer but another type of cancer).

    I did a self exam Feb 11, 2011 and found a lump. I waited for 2 weeks to see if it was just a inflamed glan as I have NO insurance. Then I went to the doctors, they ordered a scan, the 17 of March I have the biopsy done. On March 21, 2011 they confirmed Breast Cancer.

    So do self exams, is what I am telling everyone!

  • angeljoy
    angeljoy Member Posts: 128
    edited May 2011

    Hi everyone,  Just an update:  When my daughter went in for her  baseline mammo, they told her it would be better if they just go straight to an ultrasound instead.  While I know there are also questions as to ultrasound's accuracy in young women, I think it is somewhat better than mammogram.  And there is no radiation exposure.  We also found there is a high-risk clinic at the cancer center in her area, and I'm hoping she'll get evaluated there next summer. I like the idea of experts in breast health making recommendations for her screening, rather than just her gyno. 

    Thanks to everyone for their responses and best wishes to all.

    Angela 

  • Jamie30
    Jamie30 Member Posts: 117
    edited June 2011

    I think mammograms should be done as early as possible.  I went to my Dr. for a physical and mentioned that I felt a little pain in my left breast.  It was only when I would bump something or lean into the washer to remove clothes, I thought it was a pulled muscle or something.  The Dr. felt nothing but sent me for a mammo just to be safe.  Found out that I have multifocal invasice ductal carcinoma.  I firmly believe the guidlines should be changed period. 

  • Annabella58
    Annabella58 Member Posts: 2,466
    edited June 2011

    Hi all:

    My daughter was advised beginning 30.  family history (non genetic) from grandmother on dad's side and me dxd at 46.  No other sibs, no genetics.

    She wants an MRI as two mammos missed mine completely.  I support her in this as young breasts are too dense to show anything well on mammo.

    I don't like the radiation aspect of it, but I am hopeful to be able to get her a thermascan asap they are in use. (Is there radiation with MRI, actually?  don't think so?)

  • DocBabs
    DocBabs Member Posts: 775
    edited August 2011

    One of the first questions I asked my oncologist was when should my daughter have a mammo. She's 35, no kids.She had hers' done 2 weeks ago. She had very dense breasts so an ultrasound was recomended.She hasn't scheduled it yet but hopefully she will before school starts in September, she's a teacher.My personal feeling is that I would want my daughter to have a baseline mammo starting at age 25.Depending on what's found , go from there.

  • vivre
    vivre Member Posts: 2,167
    edited August 2011

    I think young women should never start with mammos because they are not so good at detecting bc in their denser breasts. Thermography is much better for this, safer, no radiation and can detect problems years before a tumor shows up. Getting a themographic baseline early gives a great picture of ones breasts that is easy to compare year by year.

    If I had a daughter, and if I had granddaughters I will recommend they only get mammos as a last resort and get therms early and often if there is anything suspicious.

  • thenewme
    thenewme Member Posts: 1,611
    edited August 2011

    Re: Thermography -  the American Cancer Society has this to say:

    "no study has ever shown that it is an effective screening tool for finding breast cancer early. It should not be used as a substitute for mammograms."

    Source is HERE, and has some good info on other newer and experimental breast imaging methods.

    I was diagnosed at 39, and I was told to have my daughters start being watched 10 years earlier, so they'll  start getting mammos at 29.  I join the rest of you, though, in hoping there's a much better detection modality by then! 

  • Annabella58
    Annabella58 Member Posts: 2,466
    edited August 2011

    most of the OB/GYNs won't do thermo scans yet.  I hope the technology gets us there for our girls soon.

    My daughter is only 22, but wants MRIs.  Not crazy about that and OB/GYN says no to it til she is at least 30.

    What to do?

  • ruthbru
    ruthbru Member Posts: 57,235
    edited August 2011

    I haven't scrolled all the way back to read the whole thread, but I had a baseline at 35 (with no history of BC, but just to have something to compare later ones with). I would think with a strong history of BC, a earlier one would be smart (at 30 maybe?). They cost (around here anyway) about $300. There are also programs that will help people pay if you can't afford it. I would say to everyone to be very vigalant about self-exams too (even though they are not offically recommended anymore), because that is how I found mine.

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited August 2011

    They say to start screening daughters about 10 to 12 years before the age that the mom was diagnosed, or at least by 40.   My mom was diagnosed at almost 58; coincidentally I was diagnosed at age 46. I started screening mammos at age 34, every 2 years; yearly at age 39. I would like to see my daughter start at age 30 if possible.

    Anne 

  • shells43
    shells43 Member Posts: 1,022
    edited August 2011

    Wow, that means my daughter should have her baseline around age 30. I don't think that is too soon either.

  • Paula66
    Paula66 Member Posts: 1,728
    edited August 2011

    My granny lost a breast. cancer took my auntis breast.Cancer to both of my younger sissy breast.  Now mine are gone as well.  My Onc thinks she needs it done soon  even though shes 21, she needs it done  I tested BRCA positive.  I have talks about this often.

  • shells43
    shells43 Member Posts: 1,022
    edited August 2011

    I just came from the OB/GYN today and I asked this very question to her since I have a 19 year old daughter. She said that she does not have a single BC patient (in their 40's or younger) in her practice whose BC was found by a mammogram. They either felt the lump first and then they got confirmation via mammogram/US/biopsy OR felt the lump and the mammo did not see it either before or after finding the lump. She said the most important thing young women can do is a regular self-exam.

Categories