Anyone do Neoadjuvant AND Adjuvant chemo?

Options
NannaBaby
NannaBaby Member Posts: 510

I have locally advanced BC.  Originally 6cm in contact with chest wall but no muscular invasion.  Did neoadjuvant chemo and had good response.  It shrunk to 4cm multifocal with a central lesion of 2cm.  Had mastectomy and next is Rads.  I am thinking of insisting adjuvant chemo.  I am worried because the deep margin close to the chest wall was only 0.5mm! I want more chemo.  Is that doable? Good idea??

 Thanks :)

Comments

  • Kathleen26
    Kathleen26 Member Posts: 210
    edited January 2011

    I had a situation somewhat similar to yours, but had a large mass in the axillary area, plus the PET scan showed positive nodes in the subclavical and pectoral area.   I had a pretty good, but not complete response to neo-adjuvant chemo, followed by surgery and rads.   Now I am on Arimidex. 

    I asked my onc whether I should have more chemo to ensure that cancer in the nodes that could not be radiated/removed was knocked out.  He said no, so I would also be very interested in hearing whether someone else got adjuvant chemo as well as neo-adjuvant without any finding of new disease.

  • Gitane
    Gitane Member Posts: 1,885
    edited January 2011

    I had both neo and adj. at my oncologist's suggestion.  I know it is done, but it depends on the agents being used and the oncologist's assessment of the benefit/risk involved.  Chemo is carcinogenic in itself, so you have to use it judiciously.

  • NancyD
    NancyD Member Posts: 3,562
    edited January 2011

    My treatment was identical to Sherri's, but my tumor was smaller and I had fewer involved nodes. However, I did have at least one encapsulated node, which means they had broken open and the cancer was growing on the outside. I have a gnawing suspicion that that node was the one they core biopsied. I think that created a hole that allowed the cancer cells to spill out. My surgery was five months after the biopsy.

  • Kodapants
    Kodapants Member Posts: 139
    edited January 2011

    I also had Neoadjuvant with AC&T dd x 8. I had partial response. Then I had surgery with Bilateral Mastectomy.  I still had cancer in the breast,  nodes where positive prior to neo but negative after. I did more chemo with Methotrexate, Navilbine and Xeloda.  Then rads.  I hope this helps.

    God bless

    Koda

  • bonsi77
    bonsi77 Member Posts: 7
    edited January 2011

    My Mom is in a similar situation. She was DX in July Stage 2B/3A- Triple Negative. Her tumor was 4.5cm and she had lymph nodes measuring 2.5cm. She did neo-adjuvent AC x4, T X 4 DD. It did not out a lot of the cancer, the tumor was all gone but some residual cancer remained in 3 of her lymph nodes as per her path report after her BMX. She is now going to get some additional chemo due to her high risk of recurrence since the lymph nodes had residual cancer. Her Onc recommended either gem/carbo or Ixempra with possible carbo. Due to heavy duty side effects of Ixempra we are leaning towards the gem/carbo and that will probably be what she does and she will prob start next wee. Her BMX was Dec. 10th. 

     If you didn't have node involvement you may not want to do more chemo as yes it is toxic and will reck some havoc on the body again. If my mom didn't have residual in the nodes we wouldn't have pushed for add'l chemo and she could have just gotten radiation. But given her stage and triple negative status, her risk is high for recurrence and the nodes still having some cancer is a chance that we rather not take. It seems as though there isn't much out there on studies of women getting adjuvent chemo after neo-adjuvent fails to produce a complete response. Some Onc's definitely do it but more of on a case by case basis rather than as a protocol. There should be more studies to see if it does make a difference especially in women who are triple negative and can't get any additional hormone therapy after chemo etc.  

  • NannaBaby
    NannaBaby Member Posts: 510
    edited January 2011

    In Canada, chemo regimes are more spaced.  My last chemo was Nov. 10 and my left mastectomy was Dec.14.  My 25 rads (tomo radiation) start at the end of this month.  I am not the one pushing more chemo.  It was brought up by my oncologists :(  I think it's due to the enlarged intercostal lymph node that was seen on my first MRI.  They're considering it to be involved because it's an unusual lymph node to be affected. 

    The fact that my "case" was discussed at a meeting with a bunch of breast specialists is making me nervous!  (My radiation oncologist phoned me at home right after the meeting at 6pm! Informing me that the majority agreed to treat it as a malignant node)

    Please tell me I'm freaking out for nothing Yell Ativan doesn't seem to be working for me anymore... any other suggestions? 

    I've started meditating :) Should I try a different chill pill?

     Thanks :)

  • SusieMTN
    SusieMTN Member Posts: 795
    edited January 2011

    NannaBaby - Could the meeting be just a standard procedure.  They are done that way at certain hospitals, it is a normal course of action.  Ask you Oncologist about it, so much can scare us and I know for myself I read too much into things.     

    I just had neoadjuvant for a 11 cm mass, 6 months of Chemo, weekly Taxol and Herceptin for 12 weeks and 12 weeks of every three weeks of (5 FU, epirubicin, Cytoxin) FEC. Almost a complete response, a few cancer cells left and 2 positive nodes.  Clean margins -when I had my MRM.  Originally I was told I would have more Chemo after surgery but had such a great response that I was told I didn't need to do more.  

  • pupfoster1
    pupfoster1 Member Posts: 1,484
    edited January 2011

    Nana,

    First I am so sorry you are going through this at such a young age!  Is there a family history of it?  I guess that's irrelevant once you are dx, here you are, and we all truly understand what you are going through.  Glad you found us.

    I actually freaked out when my General Surgeon (NOT a cancer doc) suggested chemo to shrink the tumor (he did this right after telling me the biopsy was positive).  First I didn't even know at the time they did this, and secondly he was saying the primary tumor looked to be "about" 3cm.  Although that did sound large to me at the time, I had NO idea that it would end up being 6.5cm at the time of surgery!!!!  Believe me, if I had to do it all over again I would have had the chemo first!  Oh well, can't second guess every decision we make right?

    I agree with Sherri Nana.  Sounds like a "tumor board" meeting where a bunch of onc's get together and review different cases.  The more eyes, the more knowledge, right????

    Keep us posted on how you are doing.

    (((HUGS))),

    Sharon

  • Annaanne
    Annaanne Member Posts: 190
    edited January 2011

    To add to this discussion: I had neo chemo in '05, 3 months of A/C, then 3 mos of Taxotere/herceptin.  I did not have a good response (I still had stage 3a disease at surgery.) So,  I consulted a couple of oncs about whether to do more chemo after surgery.  The consensus was (at that time) that there was no research to support the benefit of additional chemo.  I continued with rads and 9 months more of herceptin, but no more chemo.  

    I've done really well, by the way.  No recurrence.  Highly her pos, hormone neg, very aggressive path.

    Annaanne 

  • AnacortesGirl
    AnacortesGirl Member Posts: 1,758
    edited January 2011

    I had no response to neoadjuvant so we tried carboplatin even though we had clean margins after surgery (2 mm).  My marrow could only handle 5 of the 12 weekly doses.  But I feel good that I was able to get 5 more.

    Just this week I downloaded the NCCN's 2010 Guidelines for Breast Cancer Patients.  They used to only create the guideline document for the oncs.  The guideline for locally advanced still doesn't say outright that adjuvant chemo should be given if the tumor doesn't shrink.  Just "individualized treatment".  I know that this isn't quite your situation but it just goes to show that the minute you have anything different (such as your intercostal lymph node) then it generates discussions with the docs.  That's a good thing!

    My feeling is go for it.  Your docs are looking out for you and trying to kill any cancer cells that might have escaped.  It sure would be great if we had a test that would tell us if they are all gone or not after we finish the standard treatment.

    If anyone is interested here's the link to the guidelines:

    http://www.nccn.com/patient-guidelines.html

  • NannaBaby
    NannaBaby Member Posts: 510
    edited January 2011

    Saw med onc. today. And they recommend more chemo because the tumour was still a significant size at surgery and I'm triple negative.  I think it will either be Gemzar with Cisplatin or Carbolplatin combo or Ixempra with Carboplatin.  Something like that.  I need to finish rads first and do some more scans before we decide on a regime.  I am bumbed out, but happy at the same time that I am getting aggressive treatment.  Better to it right and kill off cancer the first time! Right?!

  • Kathleen26
    Kathleen26 Member Posts: 210
    edited January 2011

    Glad to hear it.  It sounds like an aggressive approach, but you want to do whatever you can now to knock it out if you can.

  • Gitane
    Gitane Member Posts: 1,885
    edited January 2011

    NannaBaby,    I know it is hard to hear that you need more chemo.  I can remember being told that, too.  As crumby as it is to face more treatment, you know your doctors are doing everything they can to see that you are healthy.  You are right, we want to do it right the first time.

  • NannaBaby
    NannaBaby Member Posts: 510
    edited January 2011

    Thank you ladies for the support :)  I will keep my chin up and continue on doing my thing!  I had a great time at Zumba last night :) Happy to be getting back in shape!

    Gitane Your cat is cute! I have one that looks like him! Cute big eyes:)

  • Gitane
    Gitane Member Posts: 1,885
    edited January 2011

    Thanks, NannaBaby.  His name is Smokey and he's my companion.  I rescued him while I was in treatment.  Good to hear you have the energy to get in shape.  Hugs!

  • NannaBaby
    NannaBaby Member Posts: 510
    edited January 2011

    I changed my profile pic to my Rascal :) He cuddles with me everyday :)

  • Gitane
    Gitane Member Posts: 1,885
    edited January 2011

    What a beautiful cat your Rascal is.  I can almost hear him purr.

  • JoJo2341
    JoJo2341 Member Posts: 9
    edited January 2011

    I did TCH chemo starting last May and had Lumpectomy in Oct. and finished 42 rads. Met with my MO and was told my cancer markers were normal and that he would like me to go for a 2nd opinion. I went to that appointment and it was recommended that I do 4 cycles of Adriamyicin chemo 2 weeks apart. She told me that it would decrease my chances of a recurrence by 30 %. I will stop my weekly Herceptin while I do these 4 cycles then restart Herceptin after to finish out my year which will be in May. She also said I need to do 5 yrs of Aremidex as I am ER+. I know this is what I need to do and am set up to start next Fri. How do you get in the right mind set for chemo again? The first time ignorance helped and you just seemed to float thru it. Any help you all can give will be appreciated

  • negirly
    negirly Member Posts: 318
    edited January 2011

    I did Taxol/Herceptin for 12 weeks then had my mastectomy and 4 AC (herceptin for a year) after the surgery.  For me it was recommended to get some Herceptin prior to my surgery bc my tumor was large. 

    So I had Neo and adjuvant but no more in total than if I did it all before or after

    Karyn

  • NannaBaby
    NannaBaby Member Posts: 510
    edited January 2011
    JoJo I don't know about getting into the right mindset for more chemo! So far, it's not going good.  I am freaking out!  I'll be sure to enjoy hot baths and good food before it starts! So much for the weight loss plan!
  • JoJo2341
    JoJo2341 Member Posts: 9
    edited January 2011

    Nanna I know what you mean by freaking out! My family and close friends are freaking out also and that is not helping. God I hate BC!  I have spent the day telling myself this is what I need to do and trying to get into the right frame of mind. Will be glad to go to work tomarrow and not think about it till I have my first cycle on fri.

  • NannaBaby
    NannaBaby Member Posts: 510
    edited January 2011

    I got mail.  The plan is Vinorelbine and Cisplatin.  I don't know how many yet, but I will start late March...

  • Suze35
    Suze35 Member Posts: 1,045
    edited January 2011

    I'm keeping an eye on this thread just in case...

    I asked my doctor Monday about the chances of having to do adjuvant, and she said it was very unlikely due to my good response to chemo.  When I asked what would we do if I still had residual disease in my nodes, she said she would take it to tumor board...

    I hope you guys do well!  I can only imagine trying to get back into the mindset...I think I'd just focus on my kids as much as I could.

  • Lynn18
    Lynn18 Member Posts: 416
    edited January 2011

    Suze35:  My dr told me the same thing, that if there were residual disease in my nodes, we would talk about more chemo.  My nodes were all clear so, even though there was a small amount of residual disease in the breast, she didn't think I needed any more chemo.

    Nannybaby:  I have heard of many people who do chemo both neo and adjuvant.  I think it's a good idea to hit this triple negative with everything you can.  Can I ask if you had positive nodes before you started?  I did have at least one that was biopsied.

  • Suze35
    Suze35 Member Posts: 1,045
    edited January 2011

    Lynn - that's good to hear your doctor feels the same way. For some reason, residual in the nodes bothers me more than in the breast, even though with TN it doesn't seem to care.

  • NannaBaby
    NannaBaby Member Posts: 510
    edited January 2011

    Yes, I had enlarged lymph nodes show up on my MRI scans prior to surgery.  Chemo cleared all the nodes... BS says multiple nodes were positive because they all matted together from the chemo killing them.

  • NannaBaby
    NannaBaby Member Posts: 510
    edited January 2011

    Check out this study...  those who achieved pCR in their aux. lymph nodes at surgery (after neoadjuvant chemo) had great outcomes :)

    http://www.jco.ascopubs.org/content/23/36/9304.full

  • Latte
    Latte Member Posts: 1,072
    edited January 2011

    nannababy, thanks for that article. my onc told me that my stats are better because i had a pCR with neoadj chemo, but i didn't believe her - now i do :-)

  • anna4969
    anna4969 Member Posts: 86
    edited January 2011

    Nannababy,

    Thank you for that article!!! I am so pleased to read that.  After neoadjuvant and then mastectomy, all my lymph nodes were now clear and about 8-9 were involved to begin with but there was a tiny bit of residual left in the breast tissue.  I was concerned of course, but all my doctors were ecstatic.  Now, I know why.  Thank you.

    Take care all.

Categories