Has anyone had micro fat grafting?

Options
1101113151668

Comments

  • CrunchyPoodleMama
    CrunchyPoodleMama Member Posts: 1,220
    edited September 2010

    Thank you for the input about that! YAY, I'm excited about this!!

  • NotMyTime2Go
    NotMyTime2Go Member Posts: 34
    edited September 2010

    This is such exciting stuff. I've been hesitant to tell anyone about my plans, like a kid who makes a wish on a birthday cake, you don't want to jinx it by telling anyone. =) But my surgeon has officially made plans to fly to a conference in October and learn this method from Dr. Khouri. So I guess this is my official plan for reconstruction. 

    So can I ask for details from any of you who have done this procedure with expanders in? If I understand correctly, your first surgery is to remove the expanders and do an initial lipo transfer. Correct? Do you use the BRAVA afterwards, but not before? How extensive is the surgery? Is there much down time? And what about the muscle that is over the expanders, does that get put back in place?

    Thanks to anyone who can answer these questions!  And if any of you are in or near Utah - the good news is that there will soon be a new option for this procedure!

  • mormor1
    mormor1 Member Posts: 136
    edited September 2010

    NotMyTime,

    I am so excited for you and your part of the country! 

    You might need to ask Cindy for someone to be in contact with.  This is still new to do the first grafting right after removal of the expanders.  I think I've heard that Dr. K. said it does make the process easier though since the expansion was done, so that is good... I think you use the Brava afterwards but not before...I am not sure though.  Also think downtime is similar tp the procedures I had, which to me was just a few days...some women might say a week or so.

     I probably shouldn't guess at these things....but it isn't always to get answers to these kind of questions, so maybe this is a little stepping stone toward solid facts.  I would recommend you check out Alexandra aaa's web site.  It is a wealth of information and support for women doing this new option.

    Just found out today that we are going to be at the October conference.  Would love it if we get to meet!

    wisconsin randi

  • 1Athena1
    1Athena1 Member Posts: 6,696
    edited September 2010

    This is all incredible. Just the thought of having all that fat that makes us feel so ugly suddenly put to good use!

    One question: does this fat EVER chemically become breast tissue and thus prone to BC recurrence? 

    I had traditional fat grafts because of divots following my reconstruction with implants and it makes me nervous to think I might have planted little seeds that could harvest BC - but maybe I am off? 

  • Luna5
    Luna5 Member Posts: 738
    edited September 2010

    Are you guys saying that those of us who have completed reconstruction with implants could if we wanted to....switch out the implants and let the muscles go back where they belong and put fat in place of the implants?

    What happens if either intentionally or unintentionally you lose weight after the fat is placed?  Do the boobs go away?

    How much fat does it take to make a boob?

  • makingway
    makingway Member Posts: 799
    edited September 2010

    Luna- Yes!!! Isn't it amazing? I want my implant out, and a real boob back so bad....

    Have you read how it's done on the website? It doesn't take much fat. It's done over 2 or 3 procedures.

  • NotMyTime2Go
    NotMyTime2Go Member Posts: 34
    edited September 2010

    I won't even pretend to be an expert, but I have been researching this thing and have come across answers to a couple of the questions above: 1Athena - according to the research they've pretty much ruled out the possibility of this increasing the risk of developing or spreading cancer. This is the link that explains it: www.brava.com/clinical-trial-results-safety.asp

    The most amazing thing to me is that is actually restores normal feeling, and in the studies radiation burns and mastectomy scars begin to heal. That's soooo huge!

    Oh, and Luna - the studies also have a very low absorption rate - meaning hardly any of the fat gets absorbed into the body. I'm not sure about weight gain though, I would think it would get bigger, since it's whatever fat normally absorbs all the twinkies - but that's only a guess? 

  • mormor1
    mormor1 Member Posts: 136
    edited September 2010

    Thanks NotMyTime for finding those articles.  I have seen them also...but didn't know where...

    Luna5  About weight gain or loss...I saw something Dr. Khouri wrote, that it is just like anybody gaining or losing weight.  The breast size tends to fluctuate some with BMI (body mass index).  I believe the estimated rate of retention with the micro fat grafing is 90%.  I have had these new breasts now about 1 1/2 yrs...they aren't going away any more than anyone else's would.  The fat connects into a blood suply mattrix.  It either connects and becomes living tissue or dies soon after the grafting.

    1Athena1  Fat redistribution is a beautiful thing!!  Dr. Khouri is an artist and you feel like you have had body sculpting.  You just have to be patient with the proces...it isn't instant.

  • whippetmom
    whippetmom Member Posts: 6,920
    edited September 2010

    For those of you who are following the BRAVA system developed by Dr. Khouri, there are others out there offering BRAVA and/or their own method of stem-cell derived fat graft transfer to augment the breast.  Just want to put this out there...to be forewarned of some and enlightened as to the availability of another.

    This Arizona plastic surgeon - Todd Malan, M.D. -was trained by a Beverly Hills PS who performed the first fat graft breast augmentation back in 1984. Some articles state that Dr. Malan is board certified, but I have researched this on my own and find no evidence of such certification.

    http://www.innovativecosmeticsurgery.com/doctor-todd-malan/

    A skincare center [no doctors here] in Scottsdale selling the BRAVA system.  How scary is THIS? I am sure there are a bevy of such folk selling the device....I just wonder why Dr. Khouri permits this.  Perhaps it is that the device, in and of itself, is harmless.  I digress.  So here is the link to the aforementioned "skincare" center...

    http://www.perfectskincenter.com/bravo-breast-enhancement.htm

    A PS in Seattle - Scott Sattler, M.D., who IS board certified.  He gets rave reviews on the breast augmentation forums and it might be easier for west coast women to get to Seattle as opposed to Miami.  He does take breast reconstruction patients. I frankly would endorse consulting with him...

    http://www.scottsattlermd.com/ThePlasticSurgeryBlog.aspx

    Of course, Sydney Coleman, M.D. in New York offers the BRAVA system, but his fees are exhorbitant...I believe his fees start around $20K.  Seems a little too slick for me.

    Interesting thread gals!  I am following it with interest!

    Deborah

    EDITED to add this link to a blog of BRAVA users..

    http://home.comcast.net/~drmomentum/bravargh/Advice/advice.html

    and this 2002 news article....

    http://www.bizjournals.com/southflorida/stories/2002/01/14/editorial2.html

    Deborah

  • whippetmom
    whippetmom Member Posts: 6,920
    edited September 2010

    Apparently this is a list of BRAVA approved/trained "specialists" who offer the BRAVA system.  I am surprised to see how many are NOT plastic surgeons...

    http://www.mybrava.com/doctor-list.asp

  • lago
    lago Member Posts: 17,186
    edited September 2010

    Most of those on the list are for brava breast enhancement not breast reconstruction.

  • whippetmom
    whippetmom Member Posts: 6,920
    edited September 2010

    That is what concerns me Lago..... 

  • lago
    lago Member Posts: 17,186
    edited September 2010

    Whippetmom: I'm willing to bet that breast reconstruction is not part of the services they offer in their "practice."

  • alexandra-aaa
    alexandra-aaa Member Posts: 50
    edited September 2010
    I think you're talking about two different things. And I think the confusion stems from the fact that Dr. Khouri invented BRAVA.

    One thing is the physicians/dermatologists/etc., who offer BRAVA for breast enhancement only. It's been sold as such for nearly 10 years. Quite honestly, I don't know what the benefit would be in purchasing the system from anyone other than directly from BRAVA. If you buy it directly, you have access to their coaches who have far more experience and expertise with the device, and its use and idiosyncrasies than any of the physicians (well, except Dr. Khouri!).

    Also, that article and the "Brav-argh" forum are over eight years old. And the forum consists of just a handful of users, who are anonymous and many of which had not even finished the course of wear. They are both regarding BRAVA alone for enhancement, unrelated to fat grafting. (You can see a number of before/afters here though: http://www.bravaresults.com)

    This thread however, had been discussing BRAVA being worn a number of weeks pre-surgically to create a "fertile scaffold", a matrix, to inject tiny micro droplets of fat all throughout that matrix. BRAVA is then worn again for several weeks/months post-op to maintain that new blood supply to support the newly transferred fat. I believe its part in fat transfers, as well as the technique of "micro grafting" has more or less separated this procedure in a huge way from traditional fat transfers.

    As far as the specific physicians you mentioned, I have come across Todd Malan's name/website/articles quite a bit in researching this before my procedure. He is a gynecologist. Why ANYONE would trust someone who is not a board certified plastic surgeon to perform such a technique dependent surgery, or any plastic surgery for that fact, is beyond me. Dr. Malan also concerned me because he has pictures of Dr. Khouri's patients on his website, which unless I missed something, implies they are his patients. As for Dr. Coleman, I have read quite a bit about him as well. From what I understand he has quite a bit of fat grafting experience in many areas, but I believe his use of BRAVA is pretty recent. No idea why his prices are through the roof, other than that he is Manhattan. I have no information on the other groups/doctors you list.

    Also, the BRAVA website, where you are finding the list of doctors offering the system, has nothing to do with the surgeons who are trained in using BRAVA in conjunction with fat grafting. While Dr. Khouri did invent BRAVA, his site is http://www.miamibreastcenter.com.

    I hope that helped differentiate the two uses of BRAVA. The overlap can get confusing.
  • alexandra-aaa
    alexandra-aaa Member Posts: 50
    edited September 2010

    (Perhaps the BRAVA site needs to clarify that those providing the system are not necessarily (if at all) surgeons performing the BRAVA enhanced micro fat grafting procedure.)

  • alexandra-aaa
    alexandra-aaa Member Posts: 50
    edited September 2010

    (Perhaps the BRAVA site needs to clarify that those providing the system are not necessarily (if at all) surgeons performing the BRAVA enhanced micro fat grafting procedure.)

  • jseda
    jseda Member Posts: 142
    edited September 2010

    Hi Maria:

    I basically meant that when you add up the costs of all medical expenses not including the cost of the Brava system, the scales tip towards the other medical expenses as being the majority of the overall reconstruction costs, in comparison to the cost of the Brava system. Also, its non-invasive vs having the invasive expanders which have potential risk for complications.

    ie Brava system $900., vs thousands of dollars for liposuction/lipid injections

    Hope this makes better sense.

  • whippetmom
    whippetmom Member Posts: 6,920
    edited September 2010

    BRAVA SATISFACTION SURVEY

    http://alturl.com/f8988

    It is important to know all of the aspects regarding this type of breast expansion process.  There will be positive opinions and there will be negative opinions.  We need to hear from all sides.  This is a serious and potentially expensive option for women who are considering the BRAVA system, rather than implant-based or autologous donor-based procedures for breast reconstruction.  

  • phylu2
    phylu2 Member Posts: 5
    edited September 2010

    Can anyone tell me your experiences with Diep reconstruction after a double mastectomy?  Thanks.

  • makingway
    makingway Member Posts: 799
    edited September 2010

    whippetmom-you are implying that implant and autologous procedures used for breast reconstruction are less 'serious', as well as less expensive, than using a Brava system??? That is not the case. Autologous procedures are extremly invasive!-serious and require long operation and recovery time. They are also very expensive. With implant reconstruction the chest muscle is severed to allow room for the implant-pocket. This is also more invasive than the Brava system and can create problems such as Post Mastectomy Pain Syndrome. The best PS here in Newport Beach quoted me a cost of $28,000.00 for reconstruction using impants. That is 5 times the cost of reconstruction using the Brava system. Of course not all PS are created equal... I spoke with my PS who claimed he would eventually be set up to do the Brava reconstruction surgery. I asked how much it would cost. He quoted me @ $15,000.00-and that's unilaterally. I don't understand how he can justify that cost when Brava's own inventor Dr. Khouri is doing it for 1/3 of the price.

  • hope123108
    hope123108 Member Posts: 58
    edited September 2010

    Hello Ladies,

    Has anybody been to Dr. C Ahn in NYC.  I understand she participates in the reconstruction using the brava and fat grafting.  I went to see Dr. Khouri however i cannot afford the travel and additional expenses.  I am from the Northeast Area and Dr. Ahn is alot closer. Just wondering if anybody knows her credentials? 

    Appreciate all your help and don't know what i would do without these boards.

    Love to you all.....

  • mormor1
    mormor1 Member Posts: 136
    edited September 2010

    Mouse6...did you ever think you would generate so much dialogue on this topic?  Wondering if you are still considering this option?

    Jseda...wondering if you started the process?

     Deborah...appreciate the article on skin care ideas...good stuff.  The 2002 article shouldn't even be shown anymore...that is very outdated.  I think I heard the big breakthrough was the use of skin prep to avoid skin breakdown...any of course this isn't the approach used by Dr. Khouri anymore (though sounds like maybe other MD's are trying to promote this approach).  Love the verse!

    hope...I think someone else posted that Dr. Ahn was also very expensive....sorry, but maybe I'm wrong. 

     whippetmom...I think you have a good point.  I know I have probably mostly expressed the positives, but there are important considerations in deciding which option is best for each woman.

    There are out of pocket expenses...for the Brava and for travel especially.  If you try to cut costs be sure it really is a cost savings though.  I ended up with insurance problems in Milwaukee (each state is different and some do not have coding that will allow this to be considered breast reconstruction.  As soon as they see liposuction...they think it is cosmetic).  Would have been cheaper for us to travel to Miami each time.

     You need someone who can take pictures....and you can't ask just anyone to take pictures of your breasts...at least I wouldn't:D  My husband was very helpful in helping when there were "leaks" in the Brava system.  There may be very competant women out there though that don't need that help.

    You need to be able to wear the domes for 10 hours a night (or day) consistantly.  They aren't something that works very well on the soccer field or running other errands (unless you are much less self conscious than most of us).  I did wear them out in public in Miami because I didn't know anyone...and my sense of adventure was stronger than my embarrassment.  I did work full time with doing this process though.  My curfew was just 8 pm.

     You need to be willing to wait awhile for answers at times if you go with Dr. Khouri (unless things change).  He is so busy and so is his staff.  When you are on his radar immediately pre or post op, you get incredible attention ...simple questions can be hard to get answers to.  Check Alexandra's forum though...that is fabulous for connecting with others who have done this and you will get lots of support and answers to nitty gritty questions. 

    This is an amazing option for some women, but it isn't for everyone.  It is good to know what you are getting into....even though if I did know all of what it would involve, I probably wouldn't have done it, and I'm so glad I did go through with it!!

    with care,

    wisconsin randi

  • PinkChic07
    PinkChic07 Member Posts: 71
    edited September 2010

    I just had fat grafts to help with divot areas above my implants and also to fill in an indentation across the implant.  They have so far worked wonders.  My PS lipo'd from my thighs & then injected into the breast area.  I'm happy to get the info from Miami Breast Ctr concerning the necrotic issue, that being one of my concerns.  I am very happy with my results.  The lipo was somewhat painful, more soreness I guess, but well worth it, both in the thigh area & the breast. 

  • CrunchyPoodleMama
    CrunchyPoodleMama Member Posts: 1,220
    edited September 2010

    Well, I called Dr. Khouri's surgeon training program coordinator and found out that there's a doctor in Atlanta who has gone through his training... Dr. Namnoum. BUT, the coordinator said "We don't recommend him because he hasn't continued ongoing training with Dr. Khouri."

    I decided to call Dr. Namnoum's office anyway and see if he's performed this procedure (frankly, I wouldn't mind being a guinea pig if it meant being able to have the surgery here instead of having to fly to Miami). His website doesn't even MENTION the procedure or have any patient photos (just of other types of reconstruction), so that makes me a little nervous, but his nurse insisted he's done it, so I set up a consultation for next week.

  • makingway
    makingway Member Posts: 799
    edited September 2010
    crunchy-I'd go with the 'expert'.
  • CrunchyPoodleMama
    CrunchyPoodleMama Member Posts: 1,220
    edited September 2010

    makingway, I'm not going to be able to have Dr. Khouri do my surgery, unfortunately. It's a long story but it just isn't a possibility. My only hope is that the other plastic surgeon I've met with will be willing to go through training with Dr. Khouri... I've emailed him explaining what it is and urging him to do it, but I haven't heard back.

    I'm so depressed about this because I can't even TRY to have a baby until this is all done, and I will be 40 in March...... Frown

  • NotMyTime2Go
    NotMyTime2Go Member Posts: 34
    edited September 2010

    Crunchy - I'm so sorry you have to deal with cancer and fertility issues at the same time. I can only offer my sympathy in that area.

    BUT as one who has decided to offer myself up as a guinea pig, let me say that at first I was kind of appalled at the idea. But there were two things that swayed me, one is that my surgeon has a fantastic reputation for being conservative, moral, and an "artist" when it comes to reconstruction. He doesn't do any cosmetic procedures, only reconstruction, which is somehow appealing to me. The second was that he has been trained in, and regularly uses, fat grafting. The difference being that he uses it in small amounts as enhancement or correction to other methods of reconstruction. The BRAVA reconstruction method is based on the same principals, except with a way to use larger amounts of tissue and to keep the body from absorbing the new tissue.

    So it's not like my surgeon is trying something entirely new, just a new way to do something he's already learned. Plus he's using a needle instead of a scalpel. There's always potential for complications, but this procedure seems to have less potential than others.

    I spoke to a woman who is a breast cancer patient and an operating room nurse. She said she frequently sees doctors with open books in the operating room. Yikes. But she also knows my surgeon and said he wouldn't ever try anything he isn't confident in. So...I guess you can just call me piggie...but since flying to Florida is out of the question, I'm good with this alternative.

  • whippetmom
    whippetmom Member Posts: 6,920
    edited September 2010

    CrunchyPoodleMama: Dr. James Namnoum IS an expert and a renowned plastic surgeon.  He is on my preferred plastic surgeon referral list.  His name is included in medical treatises along with the names of the most sought-after plastic surgeons in the U.S.  He is the Chief of Plastic Surgery of a prestigious hospital in Atlanta.  He contributes regularly to the American Journal of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery.  He is highly respected in the field.

    http://www.atlplastic.com/DrJamesNamnoumblog/2010/02/25/dr-namnoum-and-one-of-his-breast-reconstruction-patients-features-on-fox-5-atlanta-to-discuss-fat-transfer/

    http://www.miinews.com/pdf/eag_featured/spring_2010/AutoFat_FTR_EAG0310v5-032210.pdf

    He has been doing fat graft transfer for breast reconstruction for years....

    http://www.northside.com/about_us/PreferredHospital.aspx

    I hope it works out for you!

    Deborah

  • makingway
    makingway Member Posts: 799
    edited September 2010

    crunchy-I'm sorry you can't have Dr. Khouri do the surgery and also that you have to wait a while longer before trying to have a baby. I know how much you want this. There are two reasons why I suggested going with the expert. One is that he is the expert on this procedure-he invented it. And because I want you to be happy with the results. My PS was going to get his office setup to do the Brava system. He attended Dr. Khouri's workshop. He has yet to set it up though-it's been over a year. When I asked him how much it would cost, he wanted to charge me 3 times the price of Dr. Khouri! Also, I found out my PS had only preformed 2 reconstruction surgeries in his practice. I found this out after the fact. I realized he didn't know what he was doing when he put an oversize tissue expander in my small chest.

    Ask Dr. Namnoum for before and after photos. That way you can get an idea of what he considers a 'good result'. Will you have a coach to help you with the process? The surgery, while not a walk in the park, does look simpler than other more invasive procedures.Keep us updated

  • CrunchyPoodleMama
    CrunchyPoodleMama Member Posts: 1,220
    edited September 2010

    THANK YOU, NotMyTime, whippetmom, and makingway!

    Deborah, that is great to know that he is so well-respected... thanks for those links, too - I had watched a couple of his videos but had missed the news feature that was linked from the blog entry you posted:

    http://www.myfoxatlanta.com/dpp/news/fox-5-special%3A-fabulous-fat-022410

    Interesting that he didn't acknowledge Dr. Khouri in this story as the one who developed this technique (in fact, it said "Davies met Dr. James Namnoum, an Atlanta plastic surgeon with the breakthrough idea to use Davies' own fat cells" - mmkay!). Also, it said that this woman did micro-fat-grafting with an implant. I need to confirm that he's done this with patients who had micro-fat-grafting only, no implant. (In fact, during the anchor banter at the end, the anchor asked the reporter if Dr. Namnoum thought this could someday replace implants, and the reporter said he "THOUGHT" it could, but there isn't enough data yet to say for sure. Say WHAT??)

    Hm, after rereading the transcript of the news story, it says the woman wore the Brava 4-6 hours a day. Maybe that's why she needed an implant - she didn't wear it enough! LOL

    Would it be psycho-stalky of me to contact this woman and ask her a few questions about her experience with Dr. Namnoum??

    makingway, what does Dr. Khouri charge (just so I'll know whether Dr. N. is charging 3x his cost too!)? (Sorry, this was probably said somewhere in this thread)

Categories