The Anti-Cancer Book

Options
mocame
mocame Member Posts: 669

Has anyone read the Anti-Cancer: A New Way of Life book? The author is David Servan-Schreiber. I think it just came out. I saw it in Walmart today and wondered if it was any good.

Comments

  • cp418
    cp418 Member Posts: 7,079
    edited October 2008

    I just looked it up on amazon.com for the reviews.  It looks interesting but is not specific to breast cancer if you are looking for supplement or dietary guidance regarding hormone status.

    http://www.amazon.com/Anticancer-New-Life-David-Servan-Schreiber/dp/0670020346/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1223598977&sr=1-1

  • greenfrog
    greenfrog Member Posts: 269
    edited October 2008

    I read this recently and really enjoyed it (if you CAN enjoy a cancer book!). I found it much more thoughtful and less hysterical than some of the diet/cancer books out there.

    He is an interesting man and an elegant author - a scientist - which means he supports a lot of his claims with some pretty solid research.

     As the previous poster said it is not specific to breast cancer and in all honesty he is saying nothing particulalry new about a healthy diet and the immune system - but it makes interesting reading none the less.

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited September 2009

    OMG what a beautiful, well-written book by a 2 time brain cancer survivor!

  • LittleFlower
    LittleFlower Member Posts: 405
    edited October 2009

    I've just started this book.  So far i find it very interesting.  I agree with previous posters that the book is well written.  It's an easy and interesting read so far.  It's inspiring to read someone's personal journey... I would recommend it because i look forward to reading it every night.

    LittleFlower

  • Mouser
    Mouser Member Posts: 245
    edited October 2009

    I've browsed through it, and it is a good read. The thing that bothers me about it is his emphasis on positive attitudes -- it comes awfully close to saying: if you have a recurrence or get worse, it's because you weren't fighting hard enough mentally, so your immune system let you down. Very close to blaming the victim (us!) for the disease.

    I don't think he means it that way, but his case histories sound like that. I think it's because he's a psychologist, and looks at mental processes ... surgeons cut, oncologists give drugs, psychologists look for thought processes. But it bothers me enough that i would not recommend the book to others.

    I also think he over-estimates the effects of diet, both positive nad negative, for most people. The data just aren't there! (But then, i'm a biologist, and biologists want statistical significance, right?) And certainly his diet advice won't do any harm -- which i'm afraid his emphasis on positive thinking might. 

  • NOTaStatistic
    NOTaStatistic Member Posts: 7
    edited December 2009

    The book is excellent!!!

  • Dee2810
    Dee2810 Member Posts: 97
    edited January 2010

    Great book!!

    Dee(0: 

  • Merilee
    Merilee Member Posts: 3,047
    edited January 2010

    Yup it's a good one

  • cheza
    cheza Member Posts: 3
    edited January 2010

    Hello everyone, i am reading for the second time a book called "foods that fight cancer" by professor Richard Beliveau and Dr Denis Gingras, i first read it a couple of years ago and keep going back to it. I just love the way they explain the chemical compounds that make up the food and what they do in our bodies. Its not just about breast cancer but its very imformative and easy to read and understand. 

     Cheza 

  • kittycat
    kittycat Member Posts: 2,144
    edited April 2010

    My husband bought the anti cancer book when his dad and my sister were dx with BC in 2008.  It's a great book.  I didn't read it front to back, but found myself going back to certain sections. I would recommend it to anyone.  The focus is on staying healthy.  :)

  • NatureGrrl
    NatureGrrl Member Posts: 1,367
    edited April 2010

    I agree, I highly recommend this book, mostly because he isn't into fads or miracle cures and uses solid research to support what he's writing about.  He tackles "healthy" on a variety of levels and there are lots of good suggestions.

    If you're looking for a good book specifically for breast cancer, try "A Dietician's Cancer Story."  Again, she backs up her writing with citations to the scientific literature (and not just anecdotal stories) and offers what she has determined works best for her, but also encourages people to find their own path.

    I was swamped with cancer books when I was first diagnosed but these are the two that I refer back to over and over.

  • badger
    badger Member Posts: 34,614
    edited April 2010

    I am reading Anticancer and really like it so far.  Couple of things stand out for me:

    1. Everyone has cancer cells in their bodies but not everyone gets cancer.  The "terrain" of your body is important in helping stay healthy.  Look at your body the way a gardener looks at soil.  There are weed seeds in the soil but not every one sprouts, takes root, and spreads like a weed.

    2. Sugar reduces the effectiveness of chemotherapy.  Two samples of breast cancer tissue were used, one got sugar one got no sugar.  Then chemo was introduced to the mix and it did a better job of killing the less sugary cells.  I am going thru too much with chemo to have its effectiveness reduced so have cut waaay back on sugar and white flour.

    I don't have a lot of cancer in my family but we do have a few diabetics.  My brother has read the glycemic index book, changed his eating habits, and improved his diabetes situation.  Like the old saying, it may not help but it couldn't hurt.

  • NatureGrrl
    NatureGrrl Member Posts: 1,367
    edited April 2010

    groundhog, you hit it exactly:  it may not help but it couldn't hurt.

    There's certainly no magic bullet that will guarantee a cure of (or prevention of) cancer, but there are a lot of things we can do that will reduce the risk... so why not do them?  If it gives me an edge, I'm happy!

    Of course, I'm also not going to live a life where I deprive myself of every joy, but I'm happy to do things with moderation.  

    As Don Kardong once said, "Without ice cream, there would be darkness and chaos."  Laughing

  • Rabbit_fan
    Rabbit_fan Member Posts: 166
    edited June 2010

    I'm a devoted fan of Anti-cancer and Foods to Fight cancer - can't give them high enough praise.  I also can't wait to check out A Dietician's Cancer Story.

    Regarding depriving yourself of joy - I see that a lot on BCO in reference to old habits.  My intent isn't to knock those people, but I want to share my experience with it. 

    After cancer, I've found new things that bring me joy.  Eating food that I feel is healthy for my body and maybe even cancer-fighting really brings me joy now.  After my huge salad for dinner I feel happy.  I just cooked chickpeas from scratch for the first time instead of using canned (cans have BPA) - and I really felt good about it.  I don't skip working out for months on end anymore, and when I get off the treadmill I'm really satisfied with myself. 

    In the beginning I would sometimes feel sad that I can't eat candy or potato chips or pizza or have coke zero or wine anymore.  But at the same time I knew that those things never made me happy.  I wasn't happy when I ate all that junk that kept me fat - I would usually feel regret as soon as I finished a package of candy, or the one-too-many piece of pizza.  I never have that feeling anymore, and I love it!

    There is life without junk food, and it's great!  I honestly feel like it was an addiction that didn't make me happy, and now I'm finally free.

    (End of self-therapy session Smile)

  • mumito
    mumito Member Posts: 4,562
    edited August 2010

    Read  both of the books that Rabbitfan was talking about. Learned alot. The recipies are good in the Foods to fight cancer book.If I had to pick one it would be that one. Use it all the time. I must of read at least 5 books on the subject.

  • perky
    perky Member Posts: 241
    edited August 2010

    Loved this book!  The Susan Love Breast Book was very valuable to me while going through the diagnosis and treatment gauntlet and this book has helped me figure out what to do once the dust has settled a bit.  I highlly reccomend it!

  • SusieMTN
    SusieMTN Member Posts: 795
    edited August 2010

    I agree with PERKY Dr. Susan Love's Breast Book got me thru treatment.  I would also Highly recommend it. 

Categories