Losing Weight While on Tamoxifin

Options
koshka1
koshka1 Member Posts: 678
edited June 2014 in Working on Your Fitness

Hello...

I am starting this thread because I have heard so much about the weight gain on Tamoxifin...and what I really want to know...is can we lose this weight?

I have been on Tamoxifin for 2 years now ...and have gained about 10 lbs.  I have to confess that my eating habits since the diagnosis have not been stellar.  Usually I have been really fit and active and very diet conscious but since the diagnosis my attitude has been why bother.  I know this is not right, but I think it is partly due to the post traumatic stress and then figuring out how to live after treatment.

Anyway, I am ready to change my eating habits and do some more exercise.

Was wondering if anyone wanted to lose weight on tamoxfin with me????

Hugs...Kosh

«134

Comments

  • lexislove
    lexislove Member Posts: 2,645
    edited March 2010

    Yes...Yes...Yes...

    I started Tamox and Lupron at the same time in July 2008. I did gain weight from treatment but was able to loose 27 lbs in Oct 2008 with a very strict no carb, no dairy 800 cal diet. I went off the diet and gained it back.

    I exercise and watch what I eat. I only eat "good" carbs and avoid all the "bad" sugar and consume between 1200 - 1500 cal a day. This is what was told to me due to my weight and height to loose the extra pounds. Has it worked? Nope. Nothing!

    I asked my onc..he said Tamox doesn't cause weight gain. I thought, well he should know more than me, and just accepted it. But...I have seen to many stories of woman on the boards and their struggle with weight loss and being on Tamox. There HAD to be a connection right?

    Well, for me there is!

    I went off Tamox in the mid of January for 3 weeks for my exchange surgery. I did a little experiment. My last day of Tamox I weighed myself and made a note. I then had surgery and to be honest just laid around and actually indulged in pizza ect...lol. Surgery was a good excuse to have pizza. Laid around more. I din't go to the gym.

    Well....well. the day that I was to start Femara....weighed myself....and....5 lbs gone! In the 4 months of eating right, gym 5-6 x a week nothing. But stopping Tamox? Yes...the weight came off.

    Im actually back on the stupid Tamox, long story, but am having an ooph soon so I will be switching to an AI. Im actually looking forward to this. Sad huh?

    Thats my story, and Im stickin to it.

  • 3monstmama
    3monstmama Member Posts: 1,447
    edited March 2010

    koshka1, 

    I am going to be starting tamoxifen in May or so, post rads.  I have also heard about it causing weight gain BUT this week I also read an article about how now it turns out unless we women of a certain age both decrease our caloric intake AND increase our exercise, we are doomed to weight gain.  Okay on one hand, that makes me feel better about the 15-20 pounds I gained in the last two+ years [I can say its not my fault! Tongue out]--its not that I've been eatting like a pig, its Mother Nature!

    But on the other hand, yargh.  How do I add an hour of exercise =/- to my already hectic rad filled life?  And if tamox makes me gain more weight, I think I will cry........

  • Makratz
    Makratz Member Posts: 12,678
    edited March 2010

    I've been on Tamox for 18 months.  Since DX I have changed what I eat.  I always ate healthfully, but now more so than ever.  Very little meat, maybe 1-2 servings a month.  Fish daily.  Tons of veggies.  I exercise every day (6 days a week) by walking 4-5 miles a day, using the elliptical 3 times a day at 25  minutes each, and doing about 200 sit ups a day along with other squats etc.  I CANNOT LOSE WEIGHT!!  Once I started the tamox, I watched the weight creep on.  It stopped at about 15 pounds or so!  I want my old body back!!

    Lexislove - you give me hope!  I'm so happy to hear that you lost 5 pounds when you stopped the Tamox.  I will be 47 when my 5 years on tamox is over, I would like to lose weight my body starts to naturally gain it from going through menopause.

    Best of luck to you all!

  • lexislove
    lexislove Member Posts: 2,645
    edited March 2010

    Yes. But Im sure the 5 lbs I did loose is back on again....somewhere.

    We are all different, just like our diagnosis's. All I can say is that for ME, Tamox has been a weight nightmare. Im not a vain person by any means, but...come on.

    And then, you see all these studies how heaviness/obeisity(sp?) is linked to BC and/or recurrence. Its an evil cycle. Personally...it gets me down some days.

    Believe me there are days that I feel like saying the hell with it, but Im not giving up yet.

  • AmyIsStrong
    AmyIsStrong Member Posts: 1,755
    edited March 2010

    I lost 40 lbs the year before dx.  I was in the best shape of many years and loved how I looked/felt.  I am also convinced the smaller boobs allowed me to feel the lump, and therefore may have saved my life!  Anyway, fast forward a year, and I finished surgery/chemo/rads. Started Tamox in October. I felt like I could LITERALLY FEEL the weight gaining every day.  Between Oct and March I gained 20 lbs. Every 6 weeks I see the doctor and get weighed and am another 4-5 lbs more.  He has given me a fairly hard time about it, which only makes me feel worse about it. Still am at the gym regularly. Have not pushed down to super low levels of eating and hardest levels of working out yet - want to wait till my port comes out next month (YAY!) and will work with my personal trainer again. But I harbor a secret fear that the weight will not come off.  I keep telling myself I did it before and can do it again. But I am afraid inside that maybe my best effort will not achieve results and that is HORRIBLY DISCOURAGING. 
    I KNOW that being/staying cancer free is the most important thing. But this is a loss to me and it makes me sad.

    I KNOW the Tamoxifen changed my metabolism or hormones or SOMETHING. The weight came very very quickly & steadily.

    Sorry to say but that's my story.

    Amy

  • ktym
    ktym Member Posts: 2,637
    edited March 2010

    I'm dealing with this too.  Tamox metabolism at a time I'm trying hard but its really hard to exercise due to left over myopathy and neuropathy from the taxotere.  But, I'm trying hard. 

    I've always eaten well and was regularly exercising and actually losing weight before my diagnosis.  So, am I the only one who felt like it was a kick in the teeth to have all the headlines today screaming 1/3 of of breast cancer could be prevented if women would eat less and exercise more?  To have a quote from  Dr. Holmes of Harvard University,  say "people might wrongly think their chances of getting cancer depend more on their genes than their lifestyle. 'The genes have been there for thousands of years, but if cancer rates are changing in a lifetime, that doesn't have much to do with genes,'" she told The Associated Press in a phone interview from Cambridge, Massachusetts.

    Yeah thanks a lot.  A normal weight, regular exercise, and all the brocolli in the world didn't keep me from getting breast cancer, and now that I'm feeling like crap and trying my darndest despite the body and weight changes treatment have brought on, I get the added benefit of having everyone thinking appetite sloth and laziness led to this wonderful existence. 

     (I don't think its against  BCO rules to put in that quote. We're not supposed to use names without consent, but since she gave consent this to the Associated Press and had to be happy to be quoted on CNN, USA today, Comcast news to name the few I've seen it on today, and I'm sure there are others, I would think it would be tacit permission to have that quote discussed and disseminated)

    http://www.comcast.net/articles/news-health/20100325/EU.MED.Avoiding.Breast.Cancer/

  • lexislove
    lexislove Member Posts: 2,645
    edited March 2010

    I can see pointing a finger at a smoker for developing lung cancer, but pointing a finger at a woman for developing BC...is wrong.

    when I read articles like the one mentioned above, it pees me off. Not because I don't like what the article is saying, but it makes me feel like  its my fault!

     My fault?...30 yrs old, no family history. Ive always had a little extra something going on...but I was never classified as obese. I come from a European/Mediteranean background, eating is in my blood...lol.

    This is off topic, but I just read an article today on Gestational Breast Cancer. Gestational! Meaning, a woman who develops BC while being pregnant or up to 12 months post baby. hmmmm....I was always had a gut feeling that my pregnancy and hormones played a role in developing ER+ BC at 30!

  • Makratz
    Makratz Member Posts: 12,678
    edited March 2010

    Lexislove, I am not vain either.  The tamox is just a weight nightmare for me.  I chose to take it though, to hopefully keep me healthier.  I always weighed about 115 and I am 5'3.  Now I am 135!!!  I'm still 5'3 Wink

    And Lexislove, it is NOT your fault!!! 
    XOXO

  • Beverly11
    Beverly11 Member Posts: 443
    edited March 2010

    This is the perfect forum for me today.  I am eating healthier than ever & more conscious about calories.  I have gained at least 5 pounds since starting tamoxifen in July.  If this keeps up I will be really really down.  I am keeping a food journal as I thought maybe I was eating more than I realized as I can be prone to being a grazer.  It is tough after all we have been through.  I am walking around hungry all the time.  Going to bed hungry, waking up hungry and gaining weight!!!  Frustrating when you feel like you are doing all the right things and getting the opposite results. 

    I watched a news clipping this week which stated that most breast cancer could be prevented with proper diet and exercise.  Well, I have always been a health nut (as people refer to me as) and a very avid exerciser.  My 2 older sisters are quite overweight, smokers and not very healthy eaters.  

    A lot of us have gone into menopause which is affecting our metabolism too.  I am a cardio nut and going to make a point of adding more weight bearing exercises.  Jillian Michaels has just put out a book about metabolism.  I haven't looked at it yet.  Maybe we could all post our tips.

    Off to the gym.

    Take Care,

    Bev

  • koshka1
    koshka1 Member Posts: 678
    edited March 2010

    Hi Bev,

    I saw that news clipping too and it actually angered me.

    The reason being...i have been an aerobics instructor for almost 20 years prior to diagnosis, was very lean, always ate the most organic healthy food as possible, and always use natural products.

    Ummm..I still got breast cancer.

    I taught a spin class today and have started weights.  I have stopped buying bread and sweets.

    Tomorrow I am gonna go for a run..and try burn this off my body.

    However, still having a glass of wine....lol

    Hugs  to all ...we can do this together :)

  • nowords
    nowords Member Posts: 423
    edited March 2010

    I have been on Tamoxifen since July 09. I lost 12- 13 pounds towards the end of rads in August and September of 09 because I was just too nauseated to eat much at all. I had neo adj. chemo and ate more than I am eating now and did not gain any or lose any during chemo (was not on tamoxifen then). Once I resumed eating 1000 to 1200 calories a day the pounds came back. I am holding steady at my diagnosis weight but am eating very little carbs, not much salt or sugar or alcohol and I do 30 minutes on the eliptical machine and 15 minutes of weights and toning 5 to 6 days a week.... and the scale does not move. I have foggy brain from the Tamox I think and I stopped taking it for 4 days to do my taxes and then went back on it...I lost 3 pounds and my abdomen flattened some, and within 2 days of taking the tamox again the weight was back.

    I too have been pissed at some of the info coming out lately....genes ARE being altered in a generation and mutated by toxins in the environment...I think it is bigger than weight issues and diet and pregnancy and breast feeding and etc. etc. If it was just about weight and eating poorly there would be many more cases...just my theory...I think causes of the cancer and effectiveness of treatment are very very DNA individually genetic specific and that is why people with the same diagnosis and pathology stats often have different success levels of treatment...again just my thoughts...I am married to a statistician but am leary ( of medical studies and statisitics ) because I am skeptical of motives of some of them and concerned about the control groups variations on so many of these studies. So much of this "weight causes breast cancer" info seems to be punctuated with the estrogen issue ... what about the negative cancers? What about people who did have healthy lifestyles and got it anyway....? I have more questions than my oncologist ever has time to answer!

  • ktym
    ktym Member Posts: 2,637
    edited March 2010

    nowords:  I agree with you, to say the only thing effecting our genes over the last few decades is our weight and exercise is simplistic thinking. 

     2005:

    http://jnci.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/content/abstract/97/3/219

    2007:

    http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/abstract/298/18/2149

    The above cited abstracts are a good lesson.  Don't know how many of you were following closely medical headlines a few years back when everyone was hopping on the bandwagon of how many lymph nodes you resected mattered in rectal cancer.  More lymph nodes resected=better outcome.  They were actually getting ready to make it a quality indicator for surgeons and hospitals.  Well, a couple of investigators really dug into the problem instead of sticking with simplistic thinking, and 2 years later you get the article debunking that theory.  Turns out they think the biology of the disease is different and you'll have less lymph nodes if you have worse disease.  The disease resulted in the number of lymph nodes, not the surgeon or pathologist taking out more or less effecting the disease. They're still working on it.  But, it points out the very important lesson regarding the difference between correlation and causation.  I remain very concerned that if the people quoted this past week are sure they know the answer emphasis in research and money for research may shift and lead us down the wrong path for some time to come.

  • jrgolomb
    jrgolomb Member Posts: 1,236
    edited March 2010

    Well, I have to say I have not cut out chocolate or wine---maybe cut down on it all, but haven't stopped.  I have been on tamoxifen since August and have sort of hit a plateau and just can't seem to lose the roll around my tummy.  A dear friend of mine suggested I eat almonds to help with the tummy roll. I haven't heard /read or thought about almonds being bad to eat for me a pr er+ person  and I enjoy them, so there I go!

    Anyway, just like Koshka I taught exercise classes to people, was in pretty great shape, cut out fats , rarely ate chocolate, and drank moderate levels of alcohol and yuppers....got C!

  • Beverly11
    Beverly11 Member Posts: 443
    edited March 2010

    If anything it seems like more fit and healthy women are getting bc.  I was the one at the office riding my bike to work!   My coworkers were baffled that I, the healthiest one in the office gets bc.  Cancer doesn't care.  I have just started taking coenzyme Q10 yesterday.  It claims to help with bc as well as metabolism.  Apple cider vinegar claims to help our metabolism also.  We need to use every trick we can.  I keep an exercise log which includes my weight.  Yeah, I am obsessed.  I am going to check out Jillian Michael's book.  Hoping to pick up some more tips.

    koshka1 - I still enjoy a glass of red wine too.  I read that wine from Chili has more antioxidants in it.  nowords - I feel for you and your exercise and diet efforts.  It just is not fair.

    Happy Exercising Ladies.

  • Beverly11
    Beverly11 Member Posts: 443
    edited March 2010

    Kosh - I would like to lose weight with you.  I have about 7 pounds I need to drop.

     Bev

  • Marion
    Marion Member Posts: 207
    edited March 2010

    Hello everyone!

    I want to lose the weight too, I had been skinny forever until BC came along ...  

    I gained about 10 pounds during chemo. I have lost some but still have 6 to lose. I have been on tamoxifen for 3 months now. I was very healthy before getting BC. Just like Beverly11, my coworkers were baffled when they found out I had it. BC does not discriminate!

    I find it hard to go and work out during the work week. I am a teacher, kids take all my energy and when I get home I am so exhausted that I cannot motivate myself. I have thought about having a picture of a fit girl on my fridge just to motivate myself ... hopefully, with the weather getting warmer I'll be better at working out, even if it is just walking outside.

  • 3monstmama
    3monstmama Member Posts: 1,447
    edited March 2010

    Well I HATE working out.  Always have.  Doing "stuff" is fine but a gym has never worked for me.  So in December, I bought my first bicycle since I was about 11.  I have three monsters and they love to ride bicycles and unicycles and I figured they would encourage me and it would be a good family thing to do.  And so far, its working pretty darned well.  With the time change and leaving an hour early to accommodate Zapping, I have been able to fit in rides at the end of my day.  No weight loss yet but the exercise feels good.

    Oh and like so many others, I am not overweight, I almost never eat fast food, I eat almost all organic etc.

    I fall  in the camp of those who thinks its a combination of genetics and our rapidly decaying toxic environment.

  • Marion
    Marion Member Posts: 207
    edited March 2010

    Does anyone have a personal trainer? I thought about it but htey are SO expensive! US $ 60 for 30 mns, plus a 150 enrollment fee!!!

  • Beverly11
    Beverly11 Member Posts: 443
    edited March 2010

    I don't but my husband does motivate me a lot.  Personal trainers do seem to be getting a lot more popular.

  • Marion
    Marion Member Posts: 207
    edited March 2010

    So, I went to the gym today and I signed up for a personal trainer... I bargained a bit so that it was cheaper. It is going to cost me $37.50 for a session instead of $60. Still very expensive if you ask me but I want to lose the weight so bad, I'll do anything. I'll meet my personal trainer once a week and the rest of the week I'll work out by myself or take a class.

    I actually had a "preview" session today and after 15 mns I felt nauseous. Same thing happened over the weekend. I went for a bike ride and felt nauseous after a while. Can tamoxifen make us feel nauseous? It seems to happen to me everytime I do something strenuous. Has anyone experienced that?

  • lexislove
    lexislove Member Posts: 2,645
    edited March 2010

    On a positive note about being on the plus side of the scale...the more you weigh the more calories you burn doing cardio...lol. Surprised

    I used an online cardio calculator...put in my stats and according to it, 1/2 hour on a elliptical/ski machine with a heart rate of such and such...  burned 400 calories. Still haven't made my way on it yet. ha!

    Im getting there...

  • ktym
    ktym Member Posts: 2,637
    edited March 2010

    lexislove, thanks for the laugh today.  That is funny, I'll remember that when I'm doing my cardio today

  • Beverly11
    Beverly11 Member Posts: 443
    edited March 2010

    Marion - Congrats on the personal trainer.  You are tempting me.  They do make you accountable and push that extra little bit.  (or lot)  I have not been nauseous but I do get dizzy spells.

    Bev

  • jrgolomb
    jrgolomb Member Posts: 1,236
    edited April 2010

    Beverly11---so, how much apple vinegar? 

  • Marion
    Marion Member Posts: 207
    edited April 2010

    I had my first training session today with my personal trainer. He's called Luke and he's cute, I think it might give me extra motivation to go ! :)

    He pushed me to see what I could/could not do. I was so weak, it was kind of pathetic... Well, it can only get better from here ... 

    I have also started weighting myself every morning. Is anyone doing that too?

  • Beverly11
    Beverly11 Member Posts: 443
    edited April 2010

    I take a 500 mg capsule of apple cider vinegar.  No guarantees that it will work but we'll see.

     Yeah, I am weighing myself pretty much every morning.  I made a request for no Easter treats from hubby.  Kale only please.  No temptations.  

    I was hoping to reach my goal by April 30th (my birthday)  I will have to be extra extra careful about what I eat and workout extra hard if I have a chance of achieving it.  

    Bev

  • lafemmejenn
    lafemmejenn Member Posts: 5
    edited April 2010

    I've put on approximately 25 pounds since being on tamoxifen (since September 2008).  My oncologist just this past week informed me that although weight gain is associated with taking the drug, 25 pounds is extreme.  I also am healing from third reconstructive surgery, and it may be that chronic back spasms associated with most recent surgery have aggravated these circumstances.  My online research has led me to stories of others who have similarly gained, but I have never heard it being referred to as "extreme."  (I am aware that any weight gain increases percentage of recurrence and have already had earlier discussions with oncologist when prescribed anti-nausea steroids and chemo drugs that caused weight gain earlier in treatment.) 

     Any feedback would be appreciated.

  • Maddy5
    Maddy5 Member Posts: 1
    edited April 2010

    Just thought I'd give the longterm view. I am 48 and have been on Tamoxifen for just over 4 years. Over the course of chemo and radiation for Stage 3 BC I only gained about 5 pounds since I lost during radiation what I gained from being sedentary during 6 months of treatment. I was thin my entire life before BC without extreme dieting and just avoiding fast food and keeping active- Size 8 mostly. Since being on Tamoxifen have gained about 25 pounds. Tried a personal trainer for 6 months after a year in. Although I felt great didn't really lose much weight. For the past few weeks have been eating raw veggies only for lunch and have dropped a few pounds. Bottom Line: I CAN'T WAIT to get off this stuff- only 9 more months! It has been a CONSTANT struggle to keep from exploding. I am in a Size 12-14 now and feel like my middle has fat rolls that will never go away. It's mortifying. My oncologist said that once I stop taking the Tamox I may stop gaining weight, but won't be much easier to take it off than it is now. I'm hoping he's wrong. I mean the Tamox bottle said it may make you lose weight when I first starting taking it. On WHAT PLANET?! Anyway, if I remember in 9 months I'll let you know how getting off of the Tamoxifen is. Just keep thinking I'd rather be slightly plump and alive than back doing chemo or surgery or not around for my sons. Hang in there everyone. Life is good even if you're slightly more plump!

  • marilee
    marilee Member Posts: 245
    edited April 2010

    I have been on Tamox for 18 months and have gained between 5 and 7 pounds.  I walk everyday and try to work out at the gym at least 3 times a week.  Lately, I've been really bad about getting to the gym, for various reasons.  I am also menopausal and at every 6 month followup, have my hormone levels tested to see if I'm ready to switch to an AI. I eat well, little to no red meat (except when my husband grills a steak -- too delicious to pass up!). 

    While I tolerate Tamox fairly well, those last few pounds make me feel bloaty and were just enough to push me right into the next size, which is very discouraging. I am really hoping I can switch to an AI soon because the other possible side effects of Tamox are more frightening to me.

    Does anyone know if weight gain is an issue for AI's? 

  • ascatt
    ascatt Member Posts: 2
    edited April 2010

    My experience is a little different from many others...

    I'm 48, and  have been on Tamoxifin for nearly two years, and did not put on any weight from it.  I did gain 15 lbs during chemo, though, probably from steroids, which came off practically by themselves.    But I was already carrying around some extra pounds before I was diagnosed.  I started Weight Watchers on September 28th and lost 25 pounds before Christmas.  I didn't find that Tamox hindered my progress at all.  I've kept the weight off with sensible eating and regular workouts-cardio 3-4 times a week, weights 3X a week, for 1 hour.

    I weigh myself daily to make sure I stay on track.

Categories