Second opinion in the states

Options
Sheff
Sheff Member Posts: 36

Hello,

As a Canadian I appreciate our public system but rightly or wrongly you often hear about the "better" treatment you can get in the states but obvioulsy at a cost.

Has anyone gone to the states to seek treatment or to get a second opinion (this is what I am really considering).  Where is the best place to go? I hear a lot about places like MD Anderson, and Dana Farber in Boston, I know these centres are all excellent but is there one that is really better than another for BC?

Thanks,

Sheff

Comments

  • konakat
    konakat Member Posts: 6,085
    edited January 2010

    Sheff -- I don't really think it would be money well spent.  I lived in Boston for 3.5 years and never step foot in Dana Farber.  The local hospital (I was in a suburb of Boston, 15 minutes from DF) was giving me the same treatment that I would have received at DF.  All the hospitals follow the same standards and protocols.  My thoughts on this have been validated by others in the medical field that are not affiliated with DF or the hospital I went to -- no bias. 

    Having returned to Canada I am getting the exact same treatment.  However, if you have a rare condition or are looking for clinical trials not available in Canada, certainly you'd have more options at an teaching hospital.  Otherwise, I don't see the value.

  • crazy4carrots
    crazy4carrots Member Posts: 5,324
    edited January 2010

    Sheff:  I can almost guarantee** that if you live in the Toronto area, and were to go to DF in Boston or SK in New York, your oncologist would ask you why on earth you didn't choose PMH!  It is widely considered (and has been for a long time) in the top 5 of North American cancer treatment and research centres.  And Sunnybrook is quickly ascending to that level as well (if not already there!).

    ** I have anectdotal evidence -- not just saying it!!

    But as Elizabeth says, if you have a rare condition or are looking for specific clinical trials, it's wise to look around and see what's available.  PMH and Sunnybrook certainly participate in international clinical trials, so it's unlikely you would have to go out-of-country.

    Good luck to you!

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited January 2010

    I'll second that. We're at PMH and our onc told us he can hook us up to the American trials in no time if needed. But he also said that in some cases people do go south for the trials.

  • Babyface
    Babyface Member Posts: 91
    edited January 2010

    Hi Sheff

    When I did my treatment in 2004 I did get a 2nd opinion in the states and as a result of that opinion it did in fact change my treatment protocol here in Ontario. With regard to MD Anderson, unless things have changed(and they may well have) back then they would not give 2nd opinions unless you were prepared to have your treatment completed there. Sloan Kettering, Dana Farber, John's Hopkins and the Mayo Clinic are all places you could consider and all have programs for Canadians and International visitors. If you do have a particular type of BC, most have oncologists who specialize in the various subtypes so you may wish to ask about that as well. Finally many of the larger U.S centers also have programs set up for remote 2nd opinions so that for a much more reasonable cost you can send your records to the onc. along with your suggested treatment protocol to get a 2nd opinion. Princess Margaret is also a good place for a 2nd opinion if you can in fact get in in a reasonable time period . A friend who had consulted recently in Hamilton had her gp contact PM to get a 2nd and because she was already in the Hamilton/Niagara network she was told it would take 6-8 weeks for an onc app't. Rather than wait (which would have delayed the commencement of her chemo) she went to Johns Hopkins for an opinion. Her treatment protocol for chemo is the same but they made a definite different suggestion with regard to her rads to follow her chemo(boost in addition to regular rads). She feels alot better having had the 2nd opinion even though much didnt change.

  • Sierra
    Sierra Member Posts: 1,638
    edited January 2010

    I second what is being

    said

    re: PMH

    and Sunybrook

    Did my TX at PMH

    they are excellent!!

    Sierra :)

    best to you with this

Categories