interview w. Dennis Slamon

Options
BethNY
BethNY Member Posts: 2,710

I've read so many magazine articles about the incredible man who discovered Herceptin-- I really enjoyed this one on the stand up to cancer web site.

http://www.standup2cancer.org/node/194

Comments

  • lisa39
    lisa39 Member Posts: 255
    edited October 2008

    Thanks Beth.  It was a great article.  I'm so grateful to Dr. Slamon, the Revlon Foundation and the Hollywood Entertainment Industry for funding all the trials that led to Herceptin.  I especially loved the line where the reporter says "HER 2 cancer has gone from being one of the most aggressive to one of the most manageable forms of BC" YIPPEE!!!  I'll be happy if we can all stay "well-managed" with no progression or recurrence.

  • Anonymous
    Anonymous Member Posts: 1,376
    edited October 2008

    Actually Slamon didn't discover (nor invent) Herceptin. He just kind of contributed to theories of the her2 oncogene, prodded for development of the antibody, tried to make a name for himself, etc.

    Read the book. It's going to be a truer picture of the whole process than a Lifetime movie. 

  • mimi1030
    mimi1030 Member Posts: 700
    edited October 2008

    What a negative attitude if I must say LJ.  Genentech owned the rights to the Her2 gene and all they had was the Her2 oncogene that caused the cancer, they did not know how it operated and how it functioned, and most of all they did not know how to turn it off...Dr Slamon was the person who found a way to turn it off...to me that is what is important, not who invented what...because realistically speaking no one invents anything in medicine, it is a scientific finding and many people along the course of time contribute to the making of the drugs now used to cure or treat certain disease.,...we are not talking about the inventing the wheel here....we are talking about finding a way to shut down a biological system which one person cannot "make a name for himself, etc.." The point is he was pivotal in the process of creating Herceptin, and saving lives of many people, had it not been for him...millions would not be alive today...to that I give him all rights and all honor for his achievement regardless of whose petrie dish the gene started out in.

    I suggest you read many other books first before disregarding the years he fought for breast cancer paitents.

  • britbaby
    britbaby Member Posts: 95
    edited October 2008

    Being that I am her mother and I am on herceptin I fully agree in what my daughter has said, your remarks were unfounded and from myself and any her2 cancer recipient , I am geatful for Dr Slamon...Yvonne Silva

  • kimbly
    kimbly Member Posts: 398
    edited October 2008

    Good comeback Mimi!!!!  I totally agree with you.

  • Yogi70
    Yogi70 Member Posts: 654
    edited October 2008

    Dr. Dennis Slamon is my undisputed HERO.  I would love to meet him!!

  • mimi1030
    mimi1030 Member Posts: 700
    edited October 2008

    Dr Slamon has an email address at UCLA, I am sure he is bombarded with emails after that great show this weekend.  But I would love to shake his hand and offer a personal thankyou....pity I couldn't do quilting or something, to make something special for him to put in his office to show appreciation for all he has done for us. 

  • britbaby
    britbaby Member Posts: 95
    edited October 2008
    I would love to meet him myself and thank him for my life
  • BethNY
    BethNY Member Posts: 2,710
    edited October 2008

    I thought the post was so negative that's why I didn't even respond.

  • SpunkyGirl
    SpunkyGirl Member Posts: 1,568
    edited October 2008

    You know, after reading so much from various sources over the years, I can see why a few people out there might be skeptical of Slamom's role in the development of Herceptin.  Honestly, I never heard of him before seeing this thread, so I went back and read up on him.  Wow-he's a top-notch Oncologist, and I think he succeeded with Herceptin because he cared.  To me, it's amazing how much someone who cares can do to impact the lives of others.  I love you, Dr. Slamom!

  • Yogi70
    Yogi70 Member Posts: 654
    edited October 2008

    Just think, if not for his perseverance some of us would not have a fighting chance.  It makes me wonder what other miracle drugs have been pushed aside and forgotten because they didn't have a Dr. Slamon.  It's scary to me.

  • cp418
    cp418 Member Posts: 7,079
    edited October 2008

    Yogi70 - Exactly my thoughts!

  • lisa39
    lisa39 Member Posts: 255
    edited October 2008

    I felt the same way as Beth.  And I definitely don't think Dr. Slamon 'tried to make a name for himself' - quite the contrary.  He toiled away in obscurity until the breadth of his ( and his colleagues') research was indisputable.  I'm very grateful.

  • Ivylane
    Ivylane Member Posts: 544
    edited October 2008

    Beth:  Great, great article.  Thanks for bringing in to the forum.  Dr. Slamon has a wonderful, concise way of speaking to the "meat" of the issue in layman's terms.  I was on Herceptin for a year and my Aunt has been on Herceptin for almost 2 years now...so far...so good.

    As far as LJ13's comment, I believe she is incorrect in her statement. Secondly, why the negativity.  We are all trying to stay alive.  Geesh! 

  • britbaby
    britbaby Member Posts: 95
    edited October 2008
    Yes ....blue16..... I agree with you totally, and I notice she hasn't posted since, so maybe her point was annoy us with her negativity input through-out the her2 women, including me. Hope you ladies are all well....Yvonne

Categories